Entire city council sacked
Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley took drastic action after four councillors quit the council based in Perth's western suburbs on Monday leaving it without a quorum to make decisions.
Councillors Fergus Bennett, Noel Youngman, Ben Hodson and Hengameh Amiry all pulled the pin following years of dysfunction at the council. Nedlands Mayor Fiona Argyle welcomed the resignation of the four councillors which she described as a 'fantastic day' during a trainwreck interview on ABC Perth. Supplied Credit: Supplied
Mr Bennett had served on the council for 23 years, telling 6PR all his efforts to get positive outcomes for the community had fallen on deaf ears.
'So I thought it was … time to leave the building,' he said.
The veteran councillor claimed notices were often skipped in council meetings and the mayor would often rule against a person talking and when they arced up they would be accused of being misogynistic.
'It's light entertainment,' he said.
The former councillor said the only way to force the mayor to leave was if there was no longer a quorum and the minister was forced to step in.
Nedlands Mayor Fiona Argyle told ABC Perth she welcomed the resignation of the four councillors which she described as a 'fantastic day' during a trainwreck interview.
'I am the most popularly elected mayor since the 70s,' she said.
'I am a globalised girl with almost three university degrees that can speak two languages, if they want to put that on me that's their business.' City of Nedlands Mayor Fiona Argyle opposed a Perth Children's Hospice and parkland on Class A Reserve next to Swanbourne Beach. Supplied Credit: Supplied
Mayor Argyle had been at loggerheads with the state government over plans for a children's hospice and park on council land located next to Swanbourne Beach, in Perth's western suburbs.
The council blocked a development application from the Perth Children's Hospital Foundation's to turn a Class A Reserve into an oasis for terminally ill children and the community.
Planning and Lands Minister John Cary stepped in and took excise of the land to allow the Perth Children's Hospital Foundation to create a park for patients, families and the community.
'No one on this planet is against dying children,' Mayor Argyle said.
'No one hates dying children. Everyone loves dying children.
'It had a Whadjuk Noongar trail on it for 40,000 years and it was the only beach access, so should that go into private hands?' Minister for Local Government Hannah Beazley sacked the entire City of Nedlands Council after four councillors quit leaving the council without a quorum to make decisions. Supplied Credit: Supplied
After the four councillors resigned Minister Beazley said she would bring an end to the saga of dysfunction and disunity that plagued the City of Nedlands and appoint three commissioners as quickly as possible.
'I'm currently working with the department through that process, having conversations with people who may be appropriate commissioners and provide the skill sets, intelligence and backgrounds that I will need to take to the city of Nedlands to sort out the core governance that have been plaguing that city for some time,' she said.
The minister said there was nothing stopping the sacked councillors from running for council again during the October elections, but encouraged them to reflect on their behaviour and the decisions they had made.
'I've had concerns about the City of Nedlands Netherlands for quite some time, so the department has had them under investigation,' said.
'That investigation is due to wrap up soon and will be a useful resource for the commissioners coming in as a source of information.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
6 days ago
- ABC News
Move to exempt miners from paying rates on miscellaneous licenses 'concerning'
The WA Local Government Association (WALGA) says it is "gravely concerned" about the state government's move to exempt mining companies from paying rates on miscellaneous licenses. Local Government and Acting Mines and Petroleum Minister Hannah Beazley announced a "swift" amendment to the Local Government Act after the Supreme Court granted a Midwest shire the right to rate one mining company. In July, the Shire of Mount Magnet, about 570 kilometres north-east of Perth, won a Supreme Court appeal which allowed it to levy rates on land covered by vanadium miner Atlantic's "miscellaneous licences". Miscellaneous licenses are typically levied on land with mining infrastructure such as access roads and accommodation sites. Atlantic will appeal the decision, with backing from the Association of Mining and Exploration Companies (AMEC) and the WA Chamber of Minerals and Energy. The ruling opened the door for other local governments to scrutinise miscellaneous license holders, a move which the mining sector said could cost it $55 million a year. Ms Beazley said the government would amend the Act "to uphold the status quo". "The state government, local governments and mining companies have for decades understood that land under miscellaneous licences was not rateable," she said. Association of Mining and Exploration Companies (AMEC) chief executive Warren Pearce said miscellaneous licences had always been considered exempt from rates under the Local Government Act. "That's been the understanding for the last 50 years," Mr Pearce said. WALGA president Karen Chapel said the government's decision threatened the judicial process. "It's an extraordinary step for the state government to introduce legislation to undermine a Supreme Court decision," she said. Ms Chapel said mining could have adverse impacts on communities, and local governments "have to pick up the tab". She said local governments were not consulted before the reform was publicly announced. "This move by the state government continues to show us that they are putting industry above local governments." Ms Beazley said WALGA was advised of the intent to reform before it was announced, and said it was not a matter of prioritising one sector over another. "Charging rates on land held under miscellaneous licences was never intended to be a source of income for local governments," she said. Shire of Mount Magnet President Jim McGorman said the Supreme Court ruling was an unbiased understanding of the Local Government Act. "They're independent of everything from the state government, basically, so they gave us the genuine interpretation of what the act says," Cr McGorman said. He said while mining companies felt they were treated as "cash cows", they could not operate without the region's resources and infrastructure. He said the sector paid royalties to the state government, but that money was not often redistributed back to the mining regions that earned it. Mr Pearce said mining companies already paid rates to shires under exploration, mining or prospecting licenses. "[The reform] is about making sure they're not being double dipped, essentially, or doubly rated over the same ground," he said. He said the mining sector was not responsible for bolstering financially strained councils. "Is having 110 local governments for a population that might cover 500,000 people actually a good way to do things," he said.
ABC News
02-08-2025
- ABC News
Minister Hannah Beazley is looking forward to the government having more oversight of the state's 137 local governments.
Minister Hannah Beazley is looking forward to the government having more oversight of the state's 137 local governments.
ABC News
02-08-2025
- ABC News
WA local government minister hails beefed-up laws as biggest reform in sector for 25 years
If keeping up to date with what your local council is doing isn't that high on your to-do list, you're probably not alone. The often mundane cogs of local government turn without much scrutiny, because the vast majority function as they should. But if the recent string of council dramas across Perth has taught us anything, it's that we need to look a lot closer. The state government is watching, and is unapologetic about plans to beef up its powers to intervene. But tinkering with other branches of democracy can put governments on dangerous ground. Who can forget former Liberal premier Colin Barnett being forced to wave the white flag after attempting to slash the number of Perth councils in half back in 2015, not long before he left office for good. It's a lesson Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley is likely to be keeping front of mind. There's no hiding how ticked off Ms Beazley has been with Nedlands council. What started off as a spot fire of dysfunction turned into raging flames of controversy. "It's been incredibly frustrating," she told Stateline. While she describes it as an outlier, there are clear recent examples of dysfunction gripping other councils. As recently as April, a commissioner had to be brought in to run the Shire of Derby/West Kimberley after five council members resigned. In Port Hedland, councillors have been walking out the door amid allegations of "extreme views" — including one councillor who made national headlines praising Russia's elections as the most "transparent" in the world and congratulating Vladimir Putin. And who can forget the "soap opera" saga of the City of Perth? That culminated in the sacking of the entire council back in 2018 amid backbiting and a Corruption and Crime Commission finding that former lord mayor Lisa Scaffidi "signally failed in her duties … by not disclosing gifts and contributions to travel" she received while in her role. Ms Beazley said she would have preferred to act sooner on Nedlands, but the Local Government Act proscribes clear limits on the minister's power. But she is hopeful law changes passed late last year, which she describes as the "biggest reform to the sector in 25 years", will ensure earlier intervention is possible. Among many things, they will see the establishment of a new local government inspector to oversee WA's 137 local governments. The inspector will have broad powers to investigate allegations of bad behaviour, reminiscent of those wielded by the state's corruption watchdog or those tasked with independently investigating the state's prison sector. The new inspector will be able to demand someone appear and give evidence, produce documents and information, and enter local government property without a warrant. But when it comes to broader reform, Ms Beazley is not planning on taking a leaf out of the Liberal playbook under Colin Barnett. "I'm not going to go down the route of forcibly merging local governments, as what happened in the previous government," Ms Beazley said. However, she said she would be open to "boundary adjustments" in the case of councils facing financial viability issues. The premier is also on the record saying while he thinks there are too many local governments in WA, the "system that we have is what it is" and it's not his policy to try to slash that number. Perhaps the best way to ensure the viability of this often unloved branch of democracy is for us to all pay more attention, and not just when local councils hit the headlines for all the wrong reasons.
