Crushed to death, fingers lost: the machines hurting workers
Photo:
Supplied
A timber worker is having to relearn how to play the guitar and trumpet - and how to write - after losing two fingers in a machine without a guard.
His passion, music, is now bittersweet, he says.
A 37-year-old man is dead; seven months into a packing job, asphyxiated after he fell onto a fast-moving conveyor belt.
The belt lacked a guard.
Graham McKean of the Maritime Union counselled the man's workmates at the factory just days later.
"They were distraught," he said.
"It was horrific, I just, the feeling in the air, the hair on the back of my neck, the chill that ran down my spine.
"Simply because the proper guard had not been put in place."
Then there is
Ethyn McTier
, dead at 23, crushed in an unguarded conveyor belt.
Ethyn McTier was crushed by an unguarded conveyor belt.
Photo:
Supplied
These are
cases
brought to public attention in recent months, where machinery safety failings were only penalised or fixed after the fact.
An engineer who gives expert evidence in courts and to inquests after workers are killed or hurt is angry.
"Expert witness work mostly makes me angry," Dr Joe Bain said.
"Because time after time, after time, we wind up writing reports that highlight that somebody's been seriously injured, if not killed, by a known problem, where there is an existing solution ... that simply hasn't been applied."
In eight years giving such testimony, he has yet to come across a tragedy that could not have been averted.
It's mostly not malice, he said, but businesses not knowing what "good looks like".
But could it be that now a solution to New Zealand's poor and dangerous record with machinery is in sight?
The government thinks so.
Workplace Safety Minister Brooke van Velden has launched a quickfire consultation with factories aiming to simplify rules around keeping machines safe - to make what "good" looks like clear.
"The Health and Safety in Employment 1995 Regulations for machine guarding are out-of-date, incomplete and very prescriptive, requiring very specific protection for woodworking and abrasive grinding machinery," she said in a statement on Thursday.
"The review will consult on simplifying these out-of-date rules" and guidance, she said.
Make that a "major" rewrite, said the Employers and Manufacturers Association.
The EMA joined with ACC last year to come up with a harm reduction plan. "No funding was provided for the implementation of this plan," said ACC, which instead has been seeking companies with good ideas about what to do.
ACC, like Worksafe, faces financial strictures limiting or cutting its programmes.
That could be financially wrong-footed, when manufacturing injuries are costing ACC $165 million a year and mounting.
Business Canterbury's Leeann Watson senses a breakthrough after years of frustration - she and the EMA are among those puzzling over why work on machine safety started then stopped - buoyed by van Velden fronting 100 of her members last year, an unusual move by a minister she believes.
"There is no business that I know of that is not wanting to keep their people safe," Watson said.
"They just want good clarity and good consistency."
Workplace Safety Minister Brooke van Velden is consulting with factories aiming to simplify rules around keeping machines safe.
Photo:
RNZ / REECE BAKER
Yet the 1995 regulations to be simplified say very little about machine guards; by contrast, the guidance and existing standards amount to over 1000 pages.
Yet it leaves out "the useful bit", Bain said.
What is that?
Simple European standards, complete with pictures, called Type Cs, that show how to keep most of the most commonly used machines safe - "all the work has been done".
Bain (who declared to RNZ his involvement with the Labour Party) told van Velden about Type Cs at her roadshow on overall work safety reform in Napier last year.
"I've told her.
"Anybody who knows me is sick of hearing me talk about Type C standards" - he wrote about them in Safeguard magazine in January - "Pretty much, they nod their heads and go, 'Yeah, that makes sense'.
"Whether it's come through as clearly from other contributors to the roadshows, I don't know."
As it turns out, not so much. An initial summary of roadshow submissions alluded to it.
But a summary out on Wednesday of all the submissions - including written ones covering over a thousand people - left it out. This later summary only mentions machinery and guards once.
It is, in fact, seven pages shorter than the 46-page summary that covers only the roadshow.
Mike Cosman is nervous at what the minister is saying.
"Yesterday it was scaffolding. Today it's guarding and the messaging seems to be the same, which is lowering standards, which means making it cheaper."
The consultant, a veteran of previous government workplace safety reviews, helped submit to the roadshow on behalf of a thousand members of the Institute of Safety Management.
"The approach that we take is already risk based. It's all based on the concept of doing what's reasonably practicable in the circumstances.
"And anything that undermines that fundamental approach, which has been around now for 50 years, I think is dangerous."
At the same time, he acknowledged the way the rules should be implemented needed to be clearer.
The Maritime Union's Graham McKean voiced similar worries.
Bain was clear on the problem and the solution.
"Generally speaking, that's not as a result of malice," he said of harm to workers, "it's as a result of businesses not having enough information made available to them. Not having a clear idea of what good looks like."
Import Type Cs tomorrow and give them to businesses for free, was his message to the government.
There is no sign of that happening.
"There are many standards referenced across the health and safety at work regulations; it is not standard practice for government to pay for accessing these," van Velden told RNZ.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Deceased Wellington diver named as Chiu Minh Looc
Chiu Minh Looc is described as a hard-working and loving family man, with a great sense of humour. Photo: Facebook/Chu Minh Looc The diver who died at Lower Hutt's Lowry Bay this week has been identified to RNZ as 46-year-old Wellington real estate agent Chiu Minh Looc, also known as Jack. Friend Jack Gordon told RNZ he was an avid scuba diver, who had done a lot of training. He said they often went diving together and were meant to go later this week. "I'm the one who got him in the water for the first time ever," Gordon said. "He was a really determined guy and really passionate about diving. "He just loved supplying his family with seafood. Seafood is so hard to come by and expensive." Gordon described Looc as a hard-working and loving family man, with a great sense of humour. He said Looc was known in the Wellington community for posting on social media about his seafood creations. "He was smiling every time you see him. He had a really big heart and always wanted to take you to a big buffet. "He loved his food and his hot pot, and posting about his food." Ray White Johnsonville sales manager Philip Reeve told RNZ Looc was one of their real estate agents. "I heard through one of my colleagues that the person who was reported missing was Jack," he said. "I've dived myself in the past and I know it's very easy to get into difficulty, but it [Looc's death] was completely unexpected. "Talking to his family, they said going back to his car afterwards, his lunch was sitting there waiting for him, when he came back from his dive, which he never came back from." Reeve said Looc left behind a wife, two children and two brothers, who were in a great deal of shock. "He was just a fun guy to have around the office. He worked primarily with the Chinese community, being Chinese himself. "He was very generous with his time, and always willing to share his knowledge and experience." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Teen boy housed in Tauranga motel by Oranga Tamariki for more than a year
By Hannah Bartlett, Open Justice reporter of The teenager spent his time gaming and visiting his girlfriend during almost a year of living in a motel without going to school. File photo. Photo: Andrey Popov When a Youth Court judge asked a 15-year-old boy how long he had been living in a motel, with round-the-clock minders, he was taken aback by the answer. "Nearly a year," the teen replied. "A year?" the judge exclaimed. During that year, Oranga Tamariki sent *Cody on a state-funded trip to a Pacific island, with his now-estranged mother, to see if he could connect with family. The boy told the court this had "not gone well", and after the trip last August, it was back to the motel. Cody was in Youth Court in Tauranga, facing relatively low-level charges, and Judge Paul Geoghegan asked him how he spent his days, and what education he was receiving while living in the Tauranga motel. "None," he replied, describing waking up late, eating, gaming, and seeing his girlfriend. He also had an Oranga Tamariki-appointed mentor he would meet with on occasion. Cody was supervised by Oranga Tamariki-contracted APEX minders, who, in pairs, were on 48-hour shifts at the motel. It's understood there were a limited number of carers on rotation. Youth Court judge Christina Cook commented at a later hearing that the "cost to the taxpayer must be horrendous", and remarked that it was "not a way to live". One of the reported constants the teen appreciated was a weekly meeting with a psychologist from Auckland. However, an Oranga Tamariki social worker told Judge Geoghegan, at the hearing in March, that a "leadership-led" decision was made to stop that. Judge Geoghegan issued a minute, in which he said the teen was "simply treading water" and "there may be psychological needs which are not being met". Judge Geoghegan was surprised a teen boy had been living in a motel without any education for almost a year. Photo: Andrew Warner / NZME After being granted permission to report on proceedings by three separate Youth Court judges, NZME sent questions to Oranga Tamariki about Cody, primarily focused on why he was at the motel for so long, what led the organisation to place him there, and how much it cost to keep him there. Oranga Tamariki was also asked about what provisions were made for his food and education, and how much the trip to the Pacific Islands cost. However, Oranga Tamariki declined to provide responses saying: "The leave that has been granted to [NZME] does not authorise Oranga Tamariki to provide you with information about the young person and matters addressed in the Youth Court". Tamariki and whānau services national commissioner for the North, Alison Cronin, provided a general statement that said typically young people only spent one night in a motel, and most children and young people stay for three nights or less. She said "occasionally" young people may need to stay longer. "These young people may have high and complex needs which can make it difficult to find appropriate placements for them," she said. "Some may have behaviours which are extremely challenging to safely manage, and which pose a risk to themselves or others in a group setting." She said sometimes they might stay longer because of proximity to whānau, continuation of education, or access to support services while a longer-term placement is found. Data released by Oranga Tamariki under the Official Information Act said that as at 1 July 2025, 18 tamariki and rangatahi in the care of Oranga Tamariki were staying in motels. Oranga Tamariki had more than 4100 young people in its care at that time. Oranga Tamariki didn't keep specific data on the number of children sent overseas, while in its care. "Information on tamariki and rangatahi travelling overseas for any purpose, including to connect with whānau, is not recorded in fields that can be extracted from our case management system as structured data," it said. "This information would be stored in the narrative case notes for the tamaiti or rangatahi in question... Oranga Tamariki would need to review individual case notes for all tamariki and rangatahi, which would require substantial manual collation." Cody, who turned 15 in February, was charged with wilful damage, speaking threateningly, threatening to kill, and unlawfully interfering with a motor vehicle. Judge Geoghegan felt the charges were to a "considerable degree", because of the boy's "frustration" with his current circumstances. The judge couldn't move ahead with the Youth Court charges without a plan for more appropriate housing and education, and without a psychological report, which had been cancelled. "The reasons for that are unclear given the quite dire situation which I believe exists in [Cody's] particular circumstances," the judge said. It's understood Cody had a long history with Oranga Tamariki's Care and Protection arm, and Oranga Tamariki's typical care arrangements had been tried without success. The judge acknowledged the teen's mother had "washed her hands of him", his father's whereabouts were unknown, and efforts to connect the teen to whānau in New Zealand had fallen on "barren ground". Youth advocate, lawyer Peter Attwood. Photo: NZME The teen's lawyer, Peter Attwood, told the court the teen's charges weren't serious enough for him to be remanded in a youth justice residence, and he, the social workers, and police all agreed the National High Needs Hub needed to find a place for him. "The hub" is a centralised Oranga Tamariki unit, that receives referrals to care and protection residences with specific wrap-around supports. But no one could tell the judge why "the hub" hadn't accepted the referrals and found a placement. Cody was first referred there in mid-December last year, and nothing had been progressed. At a crossover court appearance a month later, where both Care and Protection and Youth Justice social workers were in attendance, little had changed. At that hearing, Judge Christina Cook reiterated Judge Geoghegan's concern, noting the teen was still living in a motel, albeit absconding in breach of his bail conditions to spend time with his transient girlfriend. The teen's youth justice social worker said this worried her. "I don't know where he is, who he is with, and if he's safe", she said. "We [social workers] stay awake at night worrying about the likes of [Cody] and if he's okay." Judge Cook was particularly concerned about the abrupt end to Cody's meetings with the psychologist, and was baffled by the delay in response from "the hub". "Which is immensely frustrating and it is easy for me to say that, but I am not the one who has to live day-to-day in a motel supported by carers." Despite the less-than-ideal circumstances of being housed at a motel, Judge Cook was told the teen's key social worker on the ground had done an "incredible amount of work". NZME attempted to speak with that social worker, who arguably understood the nuances and challenges of Cody's situation better than anybody, but she said she'd been told by Oranga Tamariki management not to speak to NZME about the case. Judge Cook spoke directly to the teen, acknowledging he'd been at the motel for "a hell of a long time", but it was "nothing to do with the people in this room, it's somewhere up the chain". Both Judge Cook and Judge Geoghegan directed minutes to Oranga Tamariki, raising their concerns about Cody's circumstances. At an appearance on 26 May, it was advised that a placement had been found, supported by an iwi provider. He would be the sole occupant of a home, with specialist support and carers. NZME was granted provisional permission to report on Cody's circumstances, but only once the teen had been advised of the new arrangement, and safely relocated to the new residence. The teen was transferred in late June, and questions were then put to Oranga Tamariki on 30 June, but a media adviser indicated they needed more time. In the meantime, Cody's matter was called in the Tauranga District Court for the final time. At a hearing on 7 July, his offences were discharged under section 282 of the Oranga Tamariki Act, meaning he will not have a criminal record. His lawyer, the police, social workers and the judge all agreed the teen needed a fresh start in his new residence, out of Tauranga. Judge Louis Bidois. Photo: RNZ / Anusha Bradley There had been concerns he would refuse to leave Tauranga, but the transfer had gone smoothly and Attwood told the court he was "finally" getting the therapeutic intervention he needed. Attwood said there was little need for punitive action, as his core needs had always been care and protection, with youth justice "has been used as an arm to crank" that side of things. Judge Louis Bidois agreed with a social worker that to transfer the charges to a different location would just be another "weight on his shoulders". NZME understands that his new placement hasn't been without incident, but his iwi are sticking by him. It's also understood his particular care arrangement falls under a relatively new care provider. * The teen's identity is subject to statutory suppression, as is the case in all Youth Court proceedings. A pseudonym has been used. * This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .
RNZ News
18 hours ago
- RNZ News
Emergency services responding to incident in Massey, West Auckland
(File photo) Photo: RNZ/Marika Khabazi Emergency services are scrambling to 'an evolving situation' in the West Auckland suburb of Massey. RNZ understands police and ambulance crews are responding. Do you know more? Email iwitness@ The police Eagle helicopter was seen circling the area. St John Ambulance said the incident was "an evolving situation" and referred RNZ to the police. RNZ has sought comment from police. More to come ... Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
