
Joe Canning: Long winter for Cork as they come to terms with being outfoxed by Tipp when victory was in sight
Cork
dressing room at half-time last Sunday. They had just scored 1-16 against a sweeper. Without being anywhere near their free-flowing best, they were six points up in the
All-Ireland hurling final
.
Maybe the goal before half-time helped create a false narrative and you could argue that Cork didn't deserve to be so far ahead, but if you're the Cork management in that scenario, you're not thinking about changing anything significant. Just like
Tipperary
in the other dressing room, you're sticking to your guns.
That looks like a mistake on Cork's part now. At half-time last Sunday, though, nobody was screaming that Cork needed to do something radical.
Ten years ago, I played on a Galway team that was three points ahead against Kilkenny at half-time in an
All-Ireland
final and had played well enough to be further clear. By that stage Galway hadn't won an All-Ireland in 27 years. We thought our time had come. In the first half, we had played well enough to win.
READ MORE
In the second half, Kilkenny blew us away. They just took over. The scoring wasn't nearly as dramatic as last Sunday, but we only scored 1-4 in the second half. The goal came in stoppage time, when Kilkenny were seven points clear.
Did we tighten up? Probably. Looking back, it felt like everyone was almost waiting for someone else to step up. If the Cork players are honest with themselves, they'll probably admit to the same thing.
Cork's Ciaran Joyce is tackled by Tipperary captain Ronan Maher. Photograph: Bryan Keane/Inpho
But when you strip that away, Cork lost the tactical battle hands-down. It wasn't just that Cork didn't manage Tipp's seventh defender, but they didn't seem to know what to do with the spare man at the back Tipp had given them.
In the first half, Rob Downey was being run ragged across the field chasing puckouts. The Tipp half forwards were making lateral runs that were designed to create chaos. Cork played into that trap. Against the Tipp puckout they should have stayed zonal.
The Cork defenders who were picking up Tipp's five forwards were under much more pressure than they should have been. Tipp were attracting Cork's half backs out the field and dragging Cork players into their attacking half, where Tipp already had numbers. All of that was creating space at the other end.
In the middle of the last decade a lot of teams were playing with sweepers, even Cork. I remember we played them in an All-Ireland quarter-final in Thurles when Brian Murphy was their spare man.
Cork manager Pat Ryan looks away after Eoin Downey is sent off. Photograph: Bryan Keane/Inpho
You often heard people say that you must mark the sweeper, even if that meant sacrificing somebody. I didn't try to mark Murphy that day, but I positioned myself behind him and made sure he knew I was there. In that way I occupied him more than he wanted to be occupied.
Cork didn't try to dictate anything with Tipp's seventh defender. He set up exactly as Tipp planned and Cork didn't do anything to disrupt it.
[
All-Ireland number four is Noel McGrath's sweetest yet, but he may already be plotting the drive for five
Opens in new window
]
Tipp had clearly worked out Cork's puckouts. Not just the long ones aimed at Brian Hayes and a cluster of players around the D, that everyone is expecting, but the kind of puckouts that worked against Dublin and other teams during the year.
Finding Tim O'Mahony in a pocket of space had really worked at various times during the season. They tried it twice early in the game, straight after Tipp had a free inside the Cork 45. This was obviously a trigger, but both times Tipp snuffed it out. While the Cork half-backs were scrambling around trying to deal with Tipp puckouts, the Tipp backs were basically comfortable on Cork's restarts.
Cork's Shane Barrett tries to prevent Willie Connors of Tipperary breaking free from the pack. Photograph: Ryan Byrne/Inpho
Tipp's first goal was a huge turning point. It was a mistake by Patrick Collins and there have been too many of those over the last couple of years. In the avalanche of scores that came later, Cork's response to the goal has been forgotten.
Shane Barrett scored a great point directly from the puck-out and Tipp didn't score for the next four minutes. Their bounce from the goal wasn't immediate. In those four minutes, Séamus Harnedy came on as a sub and missed a great chance to draw Cork level.
None of that was important at the end, but momentum is a volatile thing. Harnedy could have carried the ball another 20 yards to make sure of the score and everyone would have said that Cork had responded well to the goal. Four minutes after that, Eoin Downey was sent off and the game was effectively over.
Tipp took a chance by going with an extra defender. Nobody had ever won an All-Ireland with a sweeper before. If Patrick Horgan had scored that free after half-time to put Cork seven points up, it wouldn't have taken much more for Tipp to start questioning their approach. Cork needed to push Tipp to that brink.
Tipperary's goalkeeper Rhys Shelly watches as a Cork shot hits the upright. Photograph: Laszlo Geczo/Inpho
In the event, they couldn't. Cork have had the most potent attack all year, but on Sunday four of their six forwards were shut down. Only Barrett and Diarmuid Healy emerged with credit.
How many of the Tipp forwards were shut down? None. Darragh McCarthy had his best game of the year, John McGrath had an incredible second half, Jake Morris, Jason Forde and Andrew Ormond all contributed with the sliotar and without it. Tipp won the All-Ireland with five forwards.
There will be a lot of soul-searching in Cork over the coming months and a lot of blame shared around. That's just the nature of the beast. After the 2015 All-Ireland, Anthony Cunningham was forced out as the Galway manager. That's not going to happen in Cork. If Pat Ryan wants to stay, I'd be certain that the players and the county board wouldn't have any objection.
No matter how close they got to the summit, Cork are back at the bottom of the mountain again.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Sexton eyes strong start to upset favourite Mallon
Every time Kelly Mallon stands on a bowling road, she is the favourite. This has been earned through an unparalleled career in which she leads both the All-Ireland and Queen of the Roads roll of honour. Next Sunday's All-Ireland senior final is no exception. She will be expected to see off the challenge of Munster champion, Hannah Sexton, especially as the final will be played over the Keady-Tassagh road in Armagh. Some factors offer a case that Sexton can cause an upset. Sexton had to come through a much more exacting Munster campaign. Her form has been on a steady upward trajectory and she was sublime in the Munster final. She will also be totally unburdened by expectation. Unlike most Munster contestants she comes into the final with absolutely nothing to lose and more than a decent chance to upset the odds. Mallon is bidding for her 12th senior All-Ireland while Sexton is looking for her first. In the 2023 final Mallon stormed home against Geraldine Daly-Curtain in Eglish. After missing out in 2024, she is back with a renewed appetite for success this year. It's a cliché, but Sexton will absolutely have to start strongly to cause an upset. Any hesitancy in the early exchanges and she will have the task of trying to reel in the greatest woman bowler of all time. Munster intermediate champion, Páidín Stokes, is also in search of his first All-Ireland. He faces Tyrone's Gene McVeigh. Stokes may lack experience at this level, but he is not deficient in talent. He turned around the Munster final against Timmy McDonagh through sheer dent of consistent excellence. Keady-Tassagh is made for his assertive bowling. McVeigh, is arguably the highest ranked Tyrone player of all-time. He was part of a most unusual combination of Tyrone v Kerry in an All-Ireland bowling All-Ireland at Eglish in 2023. As frequently happens on the football field, Denis O'Sullivan had the last word for the Kingdom in that junior A final. McVeigh should be a tougher and more calculating competitor as a result of that loss. Eoghan McVeigh, Gene's cousin, will wear the red-hand shirt too against Shane Crowley in the u18 final. Crowley's bowling in the Munster final confirmed his status as a potential senior champion. He has explosive power, which he will be able to flaunt at Keady. If Crowley is in the zone, it is hard to see McVeigh staying with him. The girls u18 is far less clear. This pits two very hot prospects in opposition. Emma Hurley emerged from an incredibly competitive Munster cauldron, beating a highly rated Darcy O'Brien in the final. Ellie-May Carr, daughter of former world champion Eddie, beat last year's Ulster champion Lilly O'Rourke. She will also be playing over her home club road too. Laura Sexton or Jessica Hughes will become the first ever winner of a women's Junior final. Ulster's Hughes comes with strong credentials, which she will need. Sexton was astonishing in her Munster final win over Darcy O'Brien. Her bowling was impeccable and her focus and resolve were exemplary. The men's junior A final is an intriguing contest between Conor McGuigan and Patrick Stokes. Stokes is oozing talent and his bowls carry huge velocity, but neither is a guarantee of success. McGuigan has made a career of pulling off unlikely wins. The most audacious being his three bowls of odds win over David Murphy in the 2011 senior All-Ireland, over the same road as next Saturday's final. Eoghan Kelly's form in Munster will make him favourite against Emmet O'Rourke in the Boys U14 final. All-Ireland Programme, Keady-Tassagh, Co. Armagh: Saturday August 2 11am, Boy U18: Shane Crowley (Munster) v Eoghan McVeigh (Ulster). Back, Girls U18: Emma Hurley (Munster) v Ellie-May Carr (Ulster). 2pm, Junior A men: Patrick Stokes (Munster) v Conor McGuigan (Ulster). Back, Boys U14: Eoghan Kelly (Munster) v Emmet O'Rourke (Ulster) Sunday August 3 11am, Senior Ladies: Hannah Sexton (Munster) v Kelly Mallon (Ulster). Back, Junior Ladies: Laura Sexton (Munster) v Jessica Hughes (Ulster). 3pm, Intermediate Men: Páidín Stokes (Munster) v Gene McVeigh (Ulster).


Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Sam Monaghan eager for return to Ireland jersey
It's fair to say that it's been a tough 13 months for Sam Monaghan. The Meath woman suffered an ACL injury while playing for her English club side Gloucester Hartpury. Nowadays ACL injuries are much more treatable that what they used to be, but it's still a lengthy recovery period which can take up to the best part of a year to be fully back. However like busses, it's never just one that arrives and for Monaghan that meant that her rehabilitation was set back by further calf and hamstring injuries which has seen her miss the whole of the 2024/25 season at any level. Sam Monaghan and Linda Djougang before the Women's Six Nations match between Ireland and Italy. Pic: Harry Murphy/Sportsfile So exactly 13 months and nine days after suffering that ACL injury, Sam Monaghan is back in an Ireland jersey for their World Cup warm-up match against Scotland and the lock will captain the side in Cork to boost. 'It was really emotional seeing my name on the team sheet again.' Monaghan said about finally returning to action. 'Not only for me, but for my family, teammates, everyone that's been on the journey with me, physio's, S&Cs.' Sam Monaghan. Pic: INPHO/Ben Brady It's easy to get carried away with yourself after such a long time on the sideline but Monaghan is trying to temper emotions leading into Saturday. 'I'm taking it day by day. I won't be getting too ahead of myself, but my goal is to just get back out on the pitch and hopefully put in a performance I can be proud of on Saturday and get back into it again. It's been a long road and it's been tough, I'm really excited, trying not to get too excited until Saturday.' After such a tumultuous year on the sidelines it'll be hard for the crowd to watch Monaghan on Saturday and not think about the injuries. But the Ireland captain is confident she won't carry that weight onto the pitch and will be fully present. Sam Monaghan of Ireland during the Women's Six Nations match between Ireland and Wales. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile 'When you're between them four white lines, that's all you think about in that moment is what's going on in that game, the people around you, the crowd and the atmosphere. 'I'm really concentrating on just the performance. You kind of leave everything behind on the whitewash that's happened. I'm really looking forwards to it. I don't think I'll be thinking of what's happened in that last year at all.' There's a sense of making up for lost time with Monaghan. She's missed an extremely successful and historic WXV campaign and a Six Nations campaign which showed that this Ireland side had taken further strides in their overall developments, even if the results didn't necessarily go their way. She's eager to hit the ground running and put in a good performances for all the people that put their faith in her during her recovery. Sam Monaghan is tackled by Varonica Madia of Italy. Pic: Roberto Bregani/Sportsfile. 'You build up a hunger. It's kind of like you've been starving for the last 13 months and you finally get your opportunity. So yeah, I'm sure I'll really savour every moment and just want to do the best I can for the squad around me. They've really looked after me the last year so I'll be extremely excited to get back out on the pitch with them. ' The lock also pointed out that Saturday isn't all about her. There's at three players lining up to make their Test debut, Béibhinn Parsons is also returning after suffering a two leg breaks in the past year and Monaghan's second row partner Eimear Corri-Fallon also makes a return to the squad following injury, something Monaghan is happy to share the return with. Eimear Corri Fallon. Pic: INPHO/Ben Brady 'Me and Eimear have played together before in Dubai and Six Nations. So, we have that second row connection. Unfortunately, both of us had a bit of a rough year, so we're kind of on the same journey at the minute, it's nice to come back out on the pitch together.' A lot of players have come into this camp to cover for the injury losses but Monaghan is confident in the squad and while ultimately the match against Scotland is a glorified friendly ahead of the World Cup, the Ireland captain still wants to put on a show for the fans. 'I've no doubt everyone that has the opportunity to wear that jersey on Saturday able to give it their all and we'll put in a good performance.' Beibhinn Parsons. Pic: INPHO/Laszlo Geczo It could be the last chance for many to put up their hand for a spot in Scott Bemand's World Cup squad with only this Saturday and next week against Canada the only games left before the squad announcement on August 11 before they go out for their opener against Japan less than two weeks' later on August 24. For Monaghan though just getting back out there is a huge achievement, especially after such rotten spell of luck. Hopefully she can show why she's been Ireland captain and show what Ireland have missed over the past year.


Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Paul Rouse: Nenagh's Maloney a pioneering figure in Tipp GAA
Tipperary's victory in the All-Ireland senior hurling final was obviously a stunning one in that it marked such a dramatic turnaround in fortunes for a team that had suffered such a dismal 2024. There is no doubt that 'tradition' played a huge role in facilitating what happened. Sometimes it is true that tradition can be a burden, the past weighing down the present. This is exclusive subscriber content. Already a subscriber? Sign in Take us with you this summer. Annual €130€65 Best value Monthly €12€6 / month