Review launched over reports of delayed response to faulty knee replacement part
BBC's File on 4 reported patients were left immobile and addicted to painkillers due to issues with the joint replacement.
Some medics have said they first started noticing issues with a part of a knee replacement made by American medical device company Zimmer Biomet around eight years ago.
A product recall was not issued until December 2022.
A standard total knee replacement has four parts – a femoral component, tibial tray, patellar component and a polyethylene insert.
Concerns were raised about the tibial part – also known as 'NexGen Stemmed Option Tibial Component' – as experts found the implant was linked to higher revision rates compared to other models.
A recall was led by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) in December 2022 after analysis of National Joint Registry data.
Leading knee surgeon Professor Leela Biant said action was not taken quickly enough after problems arose.
She told File on 4 that concerns were raised by herself and colleagues around eight years ago – five years before the product recall.
'The issue is their initial reluctance to acknowledge a problem and to not really engage with a process to evaluate these patients until they got to a situation where they had to,' she told the programme.
In June 2022, a study was published in the journal Bone & Joint Open which suggested 'there is a fundamental issue with this NexGen implant design'.
Patients have told the BBC about the impact on their lives.
Debbie Booker, a manager for a company running retirement homes on the south coast, had a knee replacement operation at a local NHS hospital in 2016.
Mrs Booker, from Southampton, described how it initially felt like the operation was a success but a year later she was suddenly 'in agony'.
As a result of the pain she said she had to take powerful pain killers.
'I was on fentanyl and morphine. I was actually addicted to morphine and it took me a long time to actually come off the morphine because I was addicted,' she said.
Medics found the implant had slipped out of place and she needed revision surgery.
Another patient, known only as Diana, described how within three years of her left knee replacement surgery she went from being an active retiree to being sofa-bound.
'Every time I stood up I was standing on a broken leg and it was agony,' she told the programme.
It also impacted surgeons who used the implant during their operations.
One described how they became a surgical 'outlier', with higher revision rates than expected, after using the implant.
File on 4 reported the implant had been used on 10,000 patients.
Local NHS teams are responsible for reviewing and, where clinically necessary, replacing affected implants.
A spokesperson for NHS England said: 'The safety of patients is the absolute priority for the NHS.
'Where issues are identified with any medical device, local NHS teams work swiftly to assess patients and provide replacement treatment where clinically necessary, in accordance with recommendations from the MHRA and device manufacturers.
'NHS England is currently reviewing the case involving Zimmer Biomet NexGen knee implants.'
Zimmer Biomet has been approached for comment.
The company told File on 4 in a statement: 'Zimmer Biomet is committed to the highest standards of patient safety, quality, and transparency.
'When new data becomes available, we act appropriately, responsibly, and in accordance with applicable regulatory requirements.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
9 minutes ago
- BBC News
Gloucestershire charity opens café to support cancer patients
Volunteers who have been affected by cancer are giving back by running a new community café and support café has been opened by Gloucester charity Charlie's, which provides free holistic therapies to cancer patients. "I would live in such a dark place without it, they're like my second family," said Pete White who has multiple myeloma and prostate cancer and will volunteer at the café.It is hoped the venue, in Barnwood, will give people living with cancer an opportunity to meet others going through similar experiences. Mr White has been volunteering with the charity since 2017 and says Charlie's has been fantastic in providing him with support. He now looks forward to helping others at the café, who are also struggling with the impact of cancer."We all support one another, if someone has some bad news, there's always someone to give them a hug," he said. Charlie's was founded by Jo Sutherland after she was diagnosed with breast cancer 20 years ago. She said the café was "going to be phenomenal" and the volunteers would "understand where you're coming from". "It's not just a café providing food. We want it to be a real community café." Ness Holbrook is the family and youth worker for Charlie's and works with young people that have been impacted by cancer. She holds sessions at schools and colleges, but now hopes to bring young people to the café.She said: "People will be able to come along, find out a bit more about us and then maybe come to the therapy centre and access support. "It will just be that nice space, but also somewhere for us to meet with other organisations and other people in the community." Paul Mount, whose sister died from breast cancer 23 years ago, got involved with the charity in 2018 by offering a room, and later a warehouse, for the charity to run monthly meetings. He has now donated the room which is being used for the café. "When Jo came to me looking for support I thought this is perfect because I wanted something to get involved in and to try and help," he hope the café will help them generate an income for the charity so it can keep providing support to those who need it.
The Guardian
34 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘Demon' rabbits growing hornlike warts in Colorado are no danger, scientists say
A group of rabbits in Colorado with grotesque, hornlike growths may seem straight out of a low-budget horror film, but scientists say there is no reason to be spooked – the furry creatures merely have a relatively common virus. The cottontails recently spotted in Fort Collins are infected with the mostly harmless Shope papillomavirus, which causes wart-like growths that protrude from their faces like metastasizing horns. Viral photos have inspired a fluffle of unflattering nicknames, including 'Frankenstein bunnies', 'demon rabbits' and 'zombie rabbits'. But their affliction is nothing new, with the virus inspiring ancient folklore and fueling scientific research nearly 100 years ago. The virus probably influenced the centuries-old jackalope myth in North America, which told of a rabbit with antlers or horns, among other animal variations. The disease in rabbits also contributed to scientists' knowledge about the connection between viruses and cancer, such as the human papillomavirus that causes cervical cancer. The virus in rabbits was named after Dr Richard E Shope, a professor at the Rockefeller University who discovered the disease in cottontails in the 1930s. News about the rabbit sightings in Fort Collins, 65 miles (105km) north of Denver, started getting attention after residents started spotting them around town and posting pictures. Kara Van Hoose, a spokesperson for Colorado parks and wildlife, told the Associated Press on Wednesday that the agency had been getting calls about the rabbits seen in Fort Collins. But she said that it was not uncommon to see infected rabbits, especially in the summer, when the fleas and ticks that spread the virus are most active. The virus can spread from rabbit to rabbit but not to other species, including humans and pets, she said. The growths resemble warts but can look like horns if they grow longer, Van Hoose said. The growths do not harm rabbits unless they grow on their eyes or mouths and interfere with eating. Rabbits' immune systems are able to fight the virus and, once they do, the growths disappear, she said.
BBC News
37 minutes ago
- BBC News
Parents withdraw SEND children from school over safety fears
A group of families from West Sussex said their children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) are not safe at said a lack of appropriate support has led to dangerous situations, forcing some parents to withdraw their Gover said her autistic daughter Emily, 10, was hurting herself in the playground due to insufficient supervision, adding: "I'm being left with no choice but to keep my child at home for her safety."West Sussex County Council said it had seen "a dramatic increase in the number of children needing SEND support" and must "prioritise those with the highest level of need." Emily attends a specialist school due to her autism, Crohn's disease and complex emotional needs. Her Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP) entitles her to specific support, including occupational therapy, small class sizes and sensory Gover said these provisions are rarely in place, and the stress of the unsuitable environment is triggering painful Crohn's flare-ups."Until something can be put in place to make it safe, I have no choice but to keep her at home," she said. Ellis, 8, has autism and ADHD and was enrolled in a mainstream school. He has not attended since November 2024, after his parents withdrew him due to what they described as a "dangerous environment.""We were seeing a rise in incidents. Either him hurting himself or hurting other children," said his mother, Rachel EHCP entitles him to one-on-one support, but Ms Hardy said he stopped receiving this. She said she has repeatedly contacted the council for help and to find an alternative placement, to no avail. A West Sussex County Council spokesperson said the number of children with EHCPs had risen from 3,400 in 2015 to more than 10,000 in 2025."Our dedicated staff are working hard to prioritise those with the highest level of need and, despite the continued growth in demand, we are making improvements to the speed that EHCP applications are processed and completed."However, changes to the SEND system at a national level are urgently required if we are to see a sustainable future for support services."We want to see a system that works with families and ensures all children receive the support they need to achieve their full potential, no matter where they live or what their level of need is."
