Woman (54) with terminal cervical cancer settles case over smear tests
A 54-year-old woman who has terminal cervical cancer has settled a
High Court
action against the HSE and a US laboratory over the alleged misinterpretation of smear tests.
The action related to five smear tests taken between 2011 and 2018.
Her senior counsel, Patrick Treacy, instructed by Cian O'Carroll solicitors, told the court on Wednesday that the case had been resolved after mediation this week.
The settlement against the HSE and the US laboratory Quest Diagnostics Incorporated, with an address in New Jersey, is without an admission of liability.
READ MORE
In the proceedings it was claimed that as a result of alleged delay, the woman lost the opportunity of cure, her life expectancy has been severely impaired and her enjoyment of life has been catastrophically damaged.
It was claimed her cancer had been allegedly allowed to develop and spread unidentified, unmonitored and untreated until she was ultimately diagnosed following her attendance at a hospital emergency department in late 2024.
It was claimed that the woman had a smear test under the
CervicalCheck
screening programme in February 2011 and the report showed a lesion, and a procedure was arranged with a follow smear arranged for six months later.
She had another smear test in December 2011 which came back as negative, and also in June 2012, which was also negative.
At the end of December 2013, it was claimed the woman had another smear test and cells of uncertain significance were detected, and a referral was made to a colposcopy clinic.
A further smear test in October 2014 came back as negative, and the woman also had a smear test in August 2018, which was returned as negative.
She became unwell on holiday last year and on her return home she was referred for review, where an MRI scan showed a cervical tumour, and she began chemotherapy.
It was claimed that had any of the five smear tests been correctly reported, there would have been a different approach to her care and she would have been advised to undergo a hysterectomy.
It was contended that on the balance of probabilities, her high grade pre-cancer would have been cured and it would not have developed into advanced cancer lesion requiring intensive palliative chemotherapy.
All of the claims were denied.
Noting the settlement, Mr Justice Paul Coffey said he was delighted to hear the case had been resolved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
19 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
HSE apologises for two-year delay in North Kerry children's mental health review
The HSE has apologised for the fact that a review of 300 children in mental health services in North Kerry has taken two years and is still not complete. The report is only at draft stage, minister of state for mental health Mary Butler told the Oireachtas Health Committee on Wednesday morning. She also said that 'red flags' identified in children's care have already led to individual open disclosure meetings between families and the HSE. After the committee, a spokeswoman for HSE Southwest said: 'We sincerely regret that this review process has taken longer than we initially hoped, and we apologise to the young people involved and their families.' She said it is not yet possible to give a definitive completion date. 'It is important to point out that all individual young people and families have already been told what the review team found in relation to their care,' she said. 'The information was provided in person at individual open disclosure meetings detailing the full clinical details available in relation to the cases involved where necessary.' The final report will contain recommendations from Dr Colette Halpin and her expert team, as well as relevant clinical information. The look-back review was set up after the shocking findings from the Maskey Report on CAMHS in South Kerry, which included evidence of 'significant harm' caused to 46 children among the 240 whose care was deemed substandard.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Tusla to hire security to restrain children during violent episodes, despite concerns
Tusla , the child and family agency, is to hire security guards to restrain children during violent episodes, despite repeatedly raising concerns about the practice in the past. The agency expects to spend about €1 millon on hiring security personnel for 'close protection' duties. These personnel will work with Tusla staff to respond to physical violence and help transport children in State care. The security officers will be permitted to physically restrain children during violent episodes, but only as a last resort and under the supervision of Tusla staff. They will not be permitted to engage in 'behaviour management' of young people 'unless there is an immediate physical threat to the safety of staff members or themselves', according to official documents. READ MORE It is understood they will mainly be assigned to Tusla's special care units, which are used to detain children who pose a risk of violence to themselves or others. They may also be assigned to other residential care units and off-site locations. The agency operates three special care units - Ballydowd and Crannóg Nua in Dublin and Coovagh House in Limerick – but just 14 of 26 beds in the facilities are operational due to staffing shortfalls. [ Replace secure special care units with one 'centre of excellence', Tusla told Opens in new window ] The challenging and sometimes violent nature of work in these units has been blamed for significant staff turnover. Since 2021, 174 staff have left these units while 168 have been hired. Staff absenteeism is also a major issue in the units, reaching as high as 25 per cent in recent years, according to a recently published external review. The review stated close protection personnel were brought into the special case units to manage 'violence, harassment and aggression'. However, 'following concerns this practice was ended', the report states. In March of last year, the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) conducted an unannounced inspection of Coovagh House after a tip-off about 'concerning incidents of physical restraint' and the use of close protection personnel. Security staff had been hired by the unit the previous year to protect staff following several violent incidents involving a child, one of which resulted in serious injury. Hiqa found that the management of serious incidents using close protection personnel was not in line with policy. The use of close protection officers continued until February 2024, despite the unit not having all the required documentation on file, Hiqa said. Close protection officers were also employed in a Tusla residential unit in 2023 following a violent incident. Their use was discussed at a Tusla board meeting in November 2023, during which the chief executive Kate Duggan raised concerns. 'The CEO advised that the use of close protection security may not be seen as in line with the agency's purpose and function by Hiqa,' the minutes of the meeting state. [ Tusla referrals set to breach 100,000 mark for first time Opens in new window ] The hiring of close protection officers is part of a wider €8 million contract to provide security at Tusla sites, including patrolling the grounds and monitoring CCTV. In a statement, Tusla said that violence, harassment and aggression present an 'ongoing challenge'. 'However, it is important to point out that these incidents arise in the context of children and young people who have experienced significant trauma in their lives,' it said. 'Since 2023, in circumstances of particularly difficult periods of violence and aggression towards staff, close protection personnel have been employed as an additional safety measure to protect social care staff and support them in the course of their work.' Such staff are given the necessary training for their work and are only used for short periods of time until the situation stabilises, Tusla said.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Greystones bungalow offers sea air and sumptuous views
Address : San Salvador, Ennis Lane, Windgates, Greystones, Co Wicklow Price : €1,075,000 Agent : DNG View this property on In the 18th century, doctors prescribed seashore visits for patients with respiratory problems. They knew that salty air had benefits but it wasn't until years later that science understood this was from iodine, magnesium and other ions, such as potassium and calcium, that encourage respiratory health. Conditions such as asthma, sinusitis and allergies have all been proven to improve from living by the sea, as sea air is heavier so it tends to clear out the nasal cavities, as anyone who's taken to dunking their head under the seawater can attest. That's before you take in the aesthetic values of sunsets, sunrises and even stormy nights as tempests bellow while you're safely inside by a roaring fire. San Salvador, a detached bungalow on Ennis Lane in Greystones , has just been launched to market by DNG, seeking €1.075 million. Its maritime setting on 0.64 of an acre, with uninterrupted views of the sea, is a rare offering along the Dublin and Wicklow coastlines. According to its current owner, who moved here in 1975, previous owners (who built the house) wanted a unique name for their home as the house back then 'was in the middle of nowhere ... They had been a very charitable family and had spent time in El Salvador, so decided to call their home after its capital city,' the owner says. When the current residents moved in 50 years ago, they decided to retain the name. READ MORE Entrance The house is elevated to maximise views Sea views from inside Family room Livingroom Location over the sea It is in need of a refresh, but offers a gem of an opportunity for those who love the sea. As the property includes a 152sq m (1,636sq ft) four-bedroom house, with a further 29sq m (312sq ft) in a garage and outbuildings, there is huge potential to develop a dream maritime home. In its current layout it has three reception rooms, a kitchen and three bathrooms. The property lies in rolling greenbelt farmland so is protected from future development. According to selling agent DNG, 'The views you enjoy today are the views you'll enjoy tomorrow and for years to come,' making it an attractive option. Its elevated position catches the full drama of the coastline, and its owner says her friends come to stay for the full moons that light up Greystones, providing wonderful reflections over the sea. Though it may seem like its miles from anywhere, Lidl and Tesco are within a five-minute drive. Greystones centre will take less than 10 minutes to reach. You can step out the front door, and be at the Cove, where locals swim from 5am onwards, in about a 20-minute walk. And if sailing, boating or fishing are your thing, the town's marina lies at your disposal. Though you might never want to leave, it is 350m to the Dublin Bus stop on Windgates Road, and 3.3km to the Dart station in Greystones. This is a unique offering in an extraordinary setting, and as it's in Greystones, which has become the poster child for quality of life living near the capital, it will be sure to draw interest. San Salvador has a Ber rating of E1 and is on the market through DNG, seeking €1.075 million.
