Car finance lender quits market after commissions scandal sparks industry upheaval
A watershed Court of Appeal ruling last October declared that lenders could not hand car dealers commissions without a customer's informed consent.
Until 2021, most vehicle purchases involved the use of discretionary commission arrangements, which enabled dealerships and brokers to set the interest rate on a buyer's finance agreement.
This incentivised brokers to charge consumers higher rates, regardless of other factors, such as the loan's value, length of agreement, or a customer's credit score.
The Court of Appeal's decision has left the vehicle finance industry worried it might be hit with a huge compensation bill.
Ratings agency suggests the sector could end up paying £30billion, while one senior Financial Conduct Authority lawyer estimates it could surpass the £50billion banks paid to settle PPI claims.
Following an appeal against the October court decision, the Supreme Court is set to bring a final judgement on the matter sometime this month.
Secure Trust told investors on Wednesday its commercial banking firm is halting all lending within the motor finance segment and allowing the existing portfolio to run off.
It claimed the move 'reflects the historical financial performance and medium-term outlook' of the vehicle finance division, which incurred a £21.8million loss before tax and exceptional items last year.
STB believes the pivot would have increased its adjusted pre-tax profits in 2024 from £39.1million to £56.6million and its return on average equity by 800 basis points.
The Solihull-based company hopes to eliminate over £25million of operating costs by 2030 from running down its motor finance loan book.
Over the same timeframe, 284 positions will be at risk of redundancy, including 78 this year alone.
The lender intends to redirect capital to more 'higher-returning' businesses, including retail finance, commercial finance, and real estate finance.
David McCreadie, chief executive of STB, said the 'pivot will allow the group to prioritise these established specialist businesses and achieves further simplification of the group, combined with the removal of a significant level of costs.
'These measures will have a material positive impact on ROAE for the group and will position the group to being capital accretive.'
'We will be consulting with impacted colleagues to explain why this pivot in our strategy will drive the future sustainable success of the group.'
Secure Trust Bank shares were 6.8 per cent up at 852p on Wednesday morning and have climbed by around 140 per cent since the year started.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 minutes ago
- The Independent
Tuesday's briefing: Grealish set for Everton loan and Palace lose Europe appeal
Jack Grealish appears to be heading to Everton while Crystal Palace are to play in the Europa Conference League after losing their appeal against demotion from the Europa League. Meanwhile Italy goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma is potentially set to depart Paris St Germain this summer. City give green light to Grealish loan Everton have agreed a season-long loan deal with Manchester City for out-of-favour England international Jack Grealish. The PA news agency understands the 29-year-old was due to undergo a medical with the Merseyside club on Monday. Grealish, signed by City in a then British record £100million deal four years ago, will hope the move can rejuvenate his career in a World Cup season. He made just seven Premier League starts after falling down the pecking order at the Etihad Stadium last season and was left out of the squad for the Club World Cup in the summer. Palace fail in CAS appeal Crystal Palace have lost their appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport against their demotion from the Europa League to the Conference League. The FA Cup winners were relegated to the continent's third-tier competition by European governing body UEFA after it determined that American businessman John Textor had 'decisive influence' at both Palace and Lyon after March 1. Nottingham Forest – who travel to Selhurst Park on August 24 – are expected to take the Europa League place. A CAS statement read: 'The panel found that John Textor, founder of Eagle Football Holdings, had shares in CPFC and OL (Olympique Lyon) and was a board member with decisive influence over both clubs at the time of UEFA's assessment date.' Old Trafford protest on hold A Manchester United supporters' group has postponed a demonstration against the club's ownership planned for the day of their opening game of the Premier League season. The 1958 group had organised a protest march to Old Trafford on August 17, ahead of United's clash with Arsenal, with banners referring to minority owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe . Previous demonstrations have focused on unpopular majority shareholders the Glazers but frustration has now spread to Ratcliffe, who has made series of controversial changes since acquiring a 28.94 per cent stake in United and taking charge of operations last year. However, after conducting a survey, the group has acknowledged opinion is split and the time is not right for a protest. A statement read: 'It's clear there is no unified view on the direction of the club under Ratcliffe. We believe it would be irresponsible to risk creating a situation that could result in any 'red on red' conflict inside or outside the stadium.' Clubs on Donnarumma alert Gianluigi Donnarumma is open to a move away from Paris St Germain this summer but will not be pushed out by the French club, the PA news agency understands. The Italy goalkeeper has been left out of PSG's squad for Wednesday's UEFA Super Cup match against Tottenham, and it is understood he will now leave Paris this summer if the right move opens up. Manchester United have been linked with the 26-year-old, who is out of contract next summer, but it is understood there has been no contact. The European champions completed the signing of Lucas Chevalier from Lille over the weekend. What's on today? Rangers take a 3-0 lead into the second leg of their Champions League third qualifying round tie against Viktoria Plzen in the Czech city. The first round of the Carabao Cup also gets under way, featuring clubs from the EFL.
The Herald Scotland
26 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Barrhead Travel launches European cities river cruise
The eight-day journey will set sail on August 25 next year, cruising through the heart of European destinations including Budapest, Bratislava, Vienna and Munich. Barrhead Travel said: 'The exclusive sailing with APT's premium brand, Travelmarvel, comes in response to unprecedented demand, with the agency reporting a 31% increase in river cruise bookings year to date, following a 38% surge in 2024. Read more 'The charter marks a significant milestone for UK-based travel retailers, showcasing Barrhead Travel's confidence in the river cruise sector and its dedication to delivering tailored, high-quality travel experiences.' It added: 'Holidaymakers will enjoy a premium onboard experience aboard one of Travelmarvel's contemporary river ships, renowned for their relaxed atmosphere, exceptional service, and curated itineraries.' Nicki Tempest-Mitchell, managing director of Barrhead Travel, said: 'Chartering a cruise ship is a significant step for the agency and a clear signal of our intent to lead the way in the UK river cruise market. 'We're seeing record-breaking interest in river cruising as holidaymakers look for more immersive experiences that combine comfort, culture, and convenience. This exclusive charter allows us to bring something truly special to our customers and our team of specialists have worked hard to curate a stunning itinerary at our favourite ports of call.' Barrhead Travel, which is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year, was sold to US-based Travel Leaders Group in 2018, and was by that time one of the UK's biggest travel agents. Travel Leaders Group is part of Internova Travel Group, which has its head office in New York.
Times
33 minutes ago
- Times
‘Try before you buy': the new property trend loved by the super-rich
'Madame,' Marcel Proust wrote to his noisy upstairs neighbour in the summer of 1915, 'I had ordered these flowers for you and I am in despair that they are coming on a day when… I feel so ill that I would like to ask you for silence… causing them to lose all their fragrance… and bristle with nasty thorns.' For many of us the ills of close-quartered London living are just as prosaic as they were for the French writer over a century ago, delicately navigating the upstairs harpist's playing and her dentist husband's drill, as he flattered them into a peace that would let him finish In Search of Lost Time, his masterpiece. However, a new trend might hold the answer, for the uber-wealthy at least. Prime and super-prime real estate agents — broadly defined as those selling properties over £5 million and £10 million respectively — are seeing a rise in high and ultra-high-net-worth individuals negotiating the right to 'try before you buy' — renting a luxury home before taking the purchasing plunge. Francesca Fox, the director of lettings at Sotheby's International Realty, says the trend started last year but has accelerated 'like wildfire' in 2025, driven mainly by international clients looking to relocate to London but increasingly concerned by high property purchase costs in the UK, potential changes to the non-dom rules, international wars and the whims of their own governments' attitudes to taxation and business. With such slings and arrows, it makes sense to keep their roots shallow, for now. It's not just Sotheby's that has spotted this trend — Knight Frank agrees it's on the rise. Tom Smith, the head of super-prime lettings, says that in the last fifteen months four properties have sold to their former tenants, with two more looking to buy having tried the approach. That might not sound like much, but this is a very small, niche market. Tom says that about 10 to 15 per cent of his clients are having these conversations now, whereas, 15 months ago, it 'just wasn't happening'. The deals can be structured in a few ways — a simple gentleman's agreement, a right of first refusal where a keen renter can buy if the owner decides to sell, or a purchase right built into a tenancy agreement, often with an agreed price or terms, but sometimes with the final price set once the tenant 'triggers' their option. As can be imagined when you're spending many millions, things are pretty bespoke — despite the growth in popularity, there's lots of flexibility in how these agreements are structured. Fox estimates that 80 to 90 per cent of the homes on her books were originally listed as sale only, but now she is offering them to rent. Tenants tend to test-drive their homes for no more than 24 months before deciding to buy, usually after 6 to 12 months. The majority of homes are rented furnished — if people are uncertain about long-term plans they don't want to invest in blinds, bookends and artworks. Although Fox says several super-prime homes have recently sold with the furniture included too, and those sellers have themselves gone on to rent fully furnished homes while they decide whether to buy a new place or relocate. Flexibility is the name of the game in today's market. • Read more expert advice on property, interiors and home improvement Psychologically this desire to try before we buy makes sense. We put far more effort into assessing risk — and therein avoiding loss — than we do into trying to gain something, says the consumer psychologist Dr Helen Watts. The type of person we are matters too. 'Some people are very high on what's called an external locus of control. And this means that if something goes wrong they find it much easier to say, well, it wasn't really my fault, it's to do with the environment,' she explains. 'But others have a high internal locus of control, where they feel that everything that goes wrong or right is to do with themselves.' It's these people, Watts thinks, who feel the pain of a loss more personally and are thus more likely to give a product — or a £20 million townhouse — a renting whirl first. And what of the properties themselves? Buyers are usually looking for six to eight bedrooms, Fox says. A lot of properties have pools, cinemas and private gardens. The wellness craze is driving an interest in spa facilities too — cold water pool plunges, saunas and, increasingly, hammam spas. The latest must-have is a private driveway because of the high rates of car theft, though some are mitigating that risk by simply hiring chauffeurs. One property on offer from Sotheby's is an eight-bed, nine-bath, 8,825 sq ft home on Sheldon Avenue in Highgate, north London. If a triple-height reception hall with a sweeping staircase and two galleried landings is your thing, it's available to rent on a short let basis for £25,000 a week. There's also a two-storey orangery and a pool. Another property currently looking for a tenant — and hopefully one who will ultimately buy — is 1 Hanover Terrace. With 6,730 sq ft of living space it's a touch larger than the average London home's 850 sq ft. Plus, there are six bedrooms and nine bathrooms, a cinema, gym, sauna, double garage and a separate mews house for staff — or all the friends who'll try to come and stay with you when you're living in Regent's Park. Its owner — the Addison Lee founder, Sir John Griffin — moved in in 2013. 'Living there is very peaceful. The view of the lake is mesmerising.' And has he had any problems with noisy neighbours? 'None whatsoever. If anyone misbehaves, I am sure that Damian Hirst [a neighbour] could place them in a tank.' Approaching his eighties and in search of a quieter life in the countryside, Griffin listed the mansion for sale at £29 million in 2022. It failed to sell and can now be rented for £75,000 a month. To top it off it was designed by John Nash in 1811, who also has Buckingham Palace on his CV. There are some potential downsides to all this flexibility. 'From a psychological point of view it can be very draining,' says Watts, highlighting how easily we now return everything from a cashmere jumper to a floor lamp — many of Ikea's items now have a full 365-day returns policy. 'We are in this perpetual state of questioning 'do I still want to own this?' and that can be quite wearing for consumers.' And what might have become of Proust if he had rented first, ditched his apartment at the first pluck of a harp string and spent more time writing. In Search of Lost Time, Volume Two perhaps?
