SNP ‘should rewrite school guidelines on single-sex lavatories'
SNP ministers must review guidance to Scottish schools telling them to allow trans pupils to use the lavatories 'they feel most comfortable with', the solicitor for parents who have won a legal test case has said.
Judge Lady Ross KC issued a court order on Thursday making clear that state schools north of the border must provide single-sex lavatories for pupils, following a case brought by parents against Scottish Borders Council (SBC).
Rosie Walker, the parents' solicitor, told The Telegraph the SNP Government would now be 'well advised' to rewrite 2021 guidance that claimed there was 'no law in Scotland' that only biological males could use boys' lavatories and vice-versa.
The document also encouraged the provision of 'gender-neutral facilities' and argued that 'where possible' trans pupils should use 'the facilities they feel most comfortable with'.
Ms Walker said she suspected there would be schools across the country that were breaking regulations passed in 1967, which said that separate facilities, including urinals for boys, must be provided.
Although this has yet to be tested in court, she said that schools would also likely be breaking the law if they provided gender-neutral facilities in addition to separate toilets for boys and girls.
This is because the 1967 regulations state that half of a school's toilets must be provided exclusively for the use of each of the two genders, she said.
Her warning came after her clients, Sean Stratford and Leigh Hurley, took legal action against SBC over the new Earlston Primary School only providing gender-neutral facilities.
Their concerns were dismissed by headteacher Kevin Wilson and the council, which claimed it did not have to consult with parents about lavatory policy.
The council this week conceded the case and Lady Ross announced her intention to issue a declarator - a court order - in a hearing on Wednesday morning.
The order, published on Thursday, said that state schools had to 'provide separate sanitary accommodation for boys and girls' in line with Regulation 15 of the School Premises (General Requirements and Standards) (Scotland) Regulations 1967.
It followed last week's Supreme Court ruling that trans women are not women, after a long-running legal battle between feminist group For Women Scotland (FWS) and the Scottish Government.
Ms Wilson, who also worked on the Supreme Court case, said: 'A lot of local authorities have been relying on the Scottish Government guidance issued in 2021.
'That guidance requires being updated in line with the Cass Review (of gender identity services for children) and the FWS case.'
Trina Budge, a director of FWS, said: 'At this point there is so much wrong with the Scottish Government's trans guidance for schools that it should be binned and started again from scratch.
'It is clearly unlawful regarding toilets, but also on changing rooms, sports and overnight accommodation on trips. Disgracefully, it was never updated after the Cass review and still promotes, against best medical advice, social transition for children confused about gender and suggests children who do not use preferred pronouns should be punished.'
Asked about the case after First Minister's Questions at Holyrood, John Swinney said: 'Obviously, there's detail in the decision of the Court of Session yesterday that the government will consider.
'It's obviously an action that involves Scottish Borders Council. It's not an action that involves the government, but it's important that all regulatory issues are properly followed by all public bodies, and the government will look at the judgement and come to its conclusions on that.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Russell Findlay distances himself from Kemi Badenoch defector comments
Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay has distanced himself from comments by the national party's leader who claimed defections were a 'good thing'. Kemi Badenoch faced journalists in Edinburgh on Friday after her first address to the Scottish Tory conference since taking over the job. Her first appearance came amid a stream of defections from the Tories, mainly to Reform UK, with one MSP – Jamie Greene – moving to the Liberal Democrats. While Mr Findlay has generally been conciliatory when elected members announce plans to move, Ms Badenoch said the departures were a 'good thing' because those who left 'don't believe in conservatism'. Speaking to the PA news agency on Saturday, after his own inaugural address to the Scottish party conference, Mr Findlay said: 'I'm always disappointed when I see anyone choosing to the leave the party for whatever reason. 'The reasons are varied and I can't get inside the minds of everyone who might choose to do so.' Asked if he agreed with the 'good riddance' attitude of Ms Badenoch, he said: 'I would never say that about anyone that chooses to go elsewhere. 'It's more of a disappointment than anything else.' The UK party leader also told journalists she did not understand how someone could vote for the Scottish Government's blocked gender reform proposals in 2022 and call themselves a conservative, in a direct attack on Mr Greene. But two of the party's MSPs, frontbencher Dr Sandesh Gulhane and former leader Jackson Carlaw, voted for the legislation. Asked if he believed the pair were conservatives, Mr Findlay said: 'Of course they are conservatives and they have realised that they got that vote wrong.' The Scottish Tory leader also hit out at Mr Greene, who has accused him of 'undoing Ruth Davidson's broad-church conservativism in favour of right-wing propaganda' on the same day Mr Findlay sat down with the former leader.
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Tories will 'wield claymore' on spending, says Findlay
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay has pledged to save £650m from the Scottish budget if elected at next year's Holyrood election. Findlay said he would achieve this by introducing a Taxpayer Saving Act to "cut red tape and get a grip on spending" alongside a Scottish Agency of Value and Efficiency (Save) to "wield a claymore" on waste. Findlay told the party's conference in Edinburgh he would put "streamlining" the Scottish government at the heart of his plans if elected next year. He urged voters to back the Scottish Conservatives over Reform UK, adding a vote for Nigel Farage's party would only result in "another five years of SNP government". In his keynote speech to members, Findlay accused John Swinney's government of "wasting untold sums of public money". He said the party would shut down government quangos, reduce the number of ministers and advisors and cut the size of the civil service to levels last seen 10 years ago in order to "deliver better value". Badenoch calls for end to oil and gas windfall tax Why Reform was the other big winner in the Hamilton by-election Money regained from the Taxpayer Saving Act would be used to reduce taxes, he told the conference at Murrayfield Stadium. Save, which would be run by business leaders, would be tasked with cutting government "waste," while an Accountability and Transparency Index would be introduced as a way of "shining a light" on organisations which receive public funding. He also said a £20,000 pay rise for ministers would be reversed. Findlay told party members: "There will be no more jobs for the SNP boys. "Putting a stop to wasteful spending is top of our agenda. "We need to urgently streamline bloated government." He added: "Improving services means treating people's money with respect." Findlay also revealed plans to scrap the SNP's 2045 net zero target and replaced the Just Transition Fund with an Affordable Transition Fund aimed at supporting oil and gas workers. On Friday, the UK Conservative leader, Kemi Badenoch, used her speech at the conference to call for an end to the windfall tax in the North Sea. Findlay said residents would be given new powers to oppose "mega-pylons" and would end the current presumption against new nuclear energy in Scotland. The Conservative leader claimed pupils in schools were being "written off" and that "woke ideas" were being pushed on children "at the expense of vital knowledge". Findlay said his party offered a "common sense vision" for Scotland. But he said those considering abandoning the party in favour of Reform would only help the SNP hang on to power. Aberdeenshire councillor Lauren Knight became the latest Conservative councillor to defect to Reform on Friday, stating she felt "let down" by the party. Reform also finished ahead of the Conservatives in the recent Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, which saw the Tory vote fall by 11.5%. Findlay described Farage's spending plans as "fantastical" and said only his party could "shake up Scottish politics". He said: "Reform pretend they can do it, but all they'll achieve is another five years of SNP government. "As we saw at the General Election, and as every poll shows, Reform increases the chance of the SNP winning." He added: "Maybe it's because Nigel Farage says he's not worried about the SNP getting another five-year term. "Well we are worried about the SNP, Nigel, because we live here. "But we can't spend our time focusing on Reform because it's what we do that matters most."
Yahoo
21 hours ago
- Yahoo
Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay aims to get party ‘back on the pitch'
Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay has insisted his party can 'get back on the pitch' as he set Conservatives the target of increasing their number of seats at Holyrood in next May's election. Mr Findlay said some wanted to 'write off' the Tories, but he believed they could win seats from the SNP in the 2026 vote, holding out the potential of even ousting First Minister John Swinney from his Perthshire constituency. While polls have pointed to Nigel Farage's Reform party – which has no seats at Holyrood at present – overtaking the Tories, Mr Findlay made clear he was 'not prepared to accept doom and gloom'. He promised his party would offer voters a 'a common-sense vision for Scotland's future'. He set out plans to save £650 million by 'cutting red tape, getting a grip on spending and harnessing business expertise', with the cash to be used to cut taxes for Scots. He also vowed the Tories would 'scrap' Scotland's 'unaffordable and unachievable' target of reaching net zero by 2045. Mr Findlay added he would boost doctor numbers by setting a target to have more Scottish medical students, and tackle classroom violence and improve education with a 'firmer approach' to school discipline. In his first major conference speech since becoming Scottish Tory leader last year, Mr Findlay said: 'We will aim to take on and defeat the SNP in more constituencies. 'Not just hold on to what we have but win more.' 🗣️ @RussellFindlay1: "We will aim to take on and defeat the SNP in more constituencies. "Not just hold onto what we have but win more."#SCC25 — Scottish Conservatives (@ScotTories) June 14, 2025 He added: 'Pundits want to write off our party. 'But I'm an optimist. I'm not prepared to accept doom and gloom. 'Where we are today is not necessarily where we will be tomorrow. 'By working hard, sticking to our values, and holding our nerve, we can and will turn things around.' The Tories returned 31 MSPs at Holyrood in the last Scottish elections in 2021, and Mr Findlay said the target of winning more is 'optimistic' but 'also realistic if you speak to people'. He even set his sights on winning the Perthshire North seat of Mr Swinney, saying that while the SNP 'will do everything to protect' its leader there, seats like that 'can be in play for us'. Speaking at the Scottish Conservative conference in Edinburgh, Mr Findlay said: 'Wouldn't that be some prize? Swinney paying the price for his abysmal record.' He claimed that Mr Swinney was 'an Amstrad politician in the Apple age', adding the First Minister would 'impoverish Scotland in pursuit of his perverse lifelong desire to destroy the UK'. Mr Findlay said: 'People like him are why voters have lost trust in politics.' Next May's election should be a 'referendum on the SNP's record', Mr Findlay said, adding there is a 'binary choice between the change that Scotland so urgently needs or more of the same from John Swinney'. The Scottish Conservative leader told his party: 'I guarantee that we will stand on a manifesto with funded tax cuts.' 🗣️ @RussellFindlay1: "Let's make the Holyrood election a referendum on the SNP's record. "A binary choice between the change that Scotland so urgently needs or more of the same from John Swinney."#SCC25 — Scottish Conservatives (@ScotTories) June 14, 2025 His pledge to save £650 million would be achieved with a Taxpayer Savings Act, and he said the Tories would also 'shut down quangos that don't deliver value' and reverse the £20,000 a year pay rise for Scottish ministers delivered by Mr Swinney'. Civil service jobs would be reduced to the level of 10 years ago and there would be 'much stricter rules on pay rises' for public sector workers. In a move similar to US President Donald Trump's creation of the Department of Government Efficiency (Doge), Mr Findlay promised to bring in a Scottish Agency of Value and Efficiency (Save) to be run by business leaders 'tasked with wielding a claymore on waste'. On energy, the Scottish Tory leader said the party would 'scrap the SNP's 2045 net zero target', insisting it is 'unaffordable and unachievable'. He told party supporters: 'Instead of spending this money on SNP eco projects, we would use it to protect oil and gas workers' livelihoods.' 🗣️ @RussellFindlay1: "Today I can announce that we would introduce a Taxpayer Savings Act to get the books in order and deliver better value. "This proposal would save £650 million by cutting red tape, getting a grip on spending, and harnessing business expertise."#SCC25 — Scottish Conservatives (@ScotTories) June 14, 2025 He said the Tories would 'would take £100 off every household energy bill in Scotland from the proceeds of leasing our waters to wind farms', and would give residents new legal powers to oppose 'mega-pylons'. On education, he also promised 'less bureaucracy' and said teachers should be free to 'instil discipline… because violence in schools has reached truly horrific levels'. 'We must now take a firmer approach. Exclusions are not cruel, but sometimes necessary.' To tackle problems in the NHS he said 'the way to deliver more doctors is simple common sense', claiming what is needed is 'more Scottish students training to join Scotland's NHS'. Arguing Scottish medical students are more likely to work in Scotland after finishing their training than their overseas counterparts, Mr Findlay said the Tories would set a new target for the number of Scottish medical students at Scottish universities.
