logo
‘Political theatre': key takeaways from US universities' House antisemitism hearing

‘Political theatre': key takeaways from US universities' House antisemitism hearing

The Guardian16-07-2025
Lawmakers questioned the leaders of the University of California at Berkeley, Georgetown University and the City University of New York in the final antisemitism hearing the House of Representatives has held since the 7 October attacks and ensuing war in Gaza broke out in 2023.
Georgetown University's interim president Robert Groves, Cuny's chancellor Félix V Matos Rodríguez and UC Berkeley's chancellor Rich Lyons faced scrutiny from Republican representatives – who questioned the universities' hiring practices, faculty unions, Middle East study centers, foreign funding and DEI initiatives.
Congress's preceding antisemitism hearings featured tense exchanges between Republican lawmakers such as representative Elise Stefanik, and precipitated the resignations of the presidents of the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard and Columbia.
While denouncing antisemitism, Democratic lawmakers spoke out against the focus of the hearing, calling it 'political theatre' and criticizing the Trump administration's gutting of the government agencies that enforce civil rights protections.
'I'd be remiss if I did not point out that this is our ninth hearing on antisemitism in 18 months,' said ranking member Bobby Scott, a Democrat from Virginia. 'I'll also note that since this committee's first antisemitism hearing in December 2023 we have not held a single hearing addressing racism, xenophobia, sexism, Islamophobia or other challenges affecting other student groups on American college campuses.'
In their opening statements, each of the university leaders present at Tuesday's hearings began their remarks by condemning antisemitism, and in many cases listing actions their campuses had undertaken to prevent future antisemitism.
Georgetown was one of the first campuses to condemn the 7 October attacks, Groves said, adding: that 'Antisemitism is incompatible with living our mission; the same applies to Islamophobia and racism.'
'Berkeley unequivocally condemns antisemitism,' Lyons echoed. He added: 'I am the first to say we have more work to do. Berkeley, like our nation, has not been immune to the disturbing rise in antisemitism.'
Matos Rodríguez shared a similar remark: 'Our university has not been immune, but let me be clear: antisemitism has no place at Cuny.' He added that the university now has a zero-tolerance policy toward encampments, like those students established at City College and Brooklyn College in 2024.
Democratic lawmakers and witnesses noted that the Trump administration's decision to shutter federal agencies tasked with enforcing civil rights protections will not protect Jewish students on college campuses.
'Antisemitism in America and on campuses is real' but 'this administration's approach is contradictory and counterproductive,' said Matt Nosanchuck, a former deputy assistant secretary for the education department's office for civil rights under the Obama administration. He urged that 'Congress must fulfill its core responsibilites' to give agencies appropriate resources, not conduct political theatre.
In his opening remarks, Scott criticized his fellow committee members for saying 'nothing about the firings attacking the office of civil rights' or the supreme court decision allowing the Trump administration to dismantle the Department of Education. The Trump administration closed seven of the office of civil rights' 12 regional offices in March.
'If the majority wanted to fight antisemitism and protect Jewish students, they should condemn antisemitism in their own party and at the highest level of government,' said Democratic representative Suzanne Bonamici of Oregon. 'They have failed to do so. Multiple White House officials have ties to antisemitic extremists.'
To begin the hearing, Walberg said that the committee would 'be examining several factors that incite antisemitism on college campuses' including faculty unions and faculty membership in the group Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine.
He later questioned Matos-Rodríguez about a Hunter College faculty job posting looking for candidates who could 'take a critical lense' to issues such as 'settler colonialsm, genocide, human rights, apartheid' and others. Matos-Rodríguez called the listing 'entirely inappropriate' and said he ordered it revised immediately upon learning about it.
Representative Virginia Foxx, a Republican from North Carolina, focused her questioning on questions around faculty hiring and union practices. She questioned Matos-Rodríguez on the fact that the president of Cuny's faculty union supports the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement. She also questioned Lyons on Columbia's hiring practices, which she said had allowed antisemitic faculty to join the staff.
'We use academic standards to hire faculty. We don't use ideological conditions to hire faculty,' Lyons said.
'I'm concerned by what I see happening here. Because instead of solving a problem, we're watching some try to use antisemitism as a reason to go after higher education,' said representative Alma Adams, a Democrat from North Carolina.
'Let's not forget as we sit here today, the Department of Education is withholding more than $6bn in congressionally mandated funding from our K-12 schools,' she added.
During her questioning Bonamici also questioned whether the antisemitism hearings were motivated by 'plans to defund colleges and universities'.
Following an exchange between representative Elise Stefanik of New York and Cuny chancellor Matos Rodríguez, California representative Mark DeSaulnier yielded his time so Matos Rodríguez could 'respond to that outrageous attack by my colleague'.
Stefanik had denounced the university for having on its staff an attorney also leading the legal defense fund for Mahmoud Khalil, who she called 'chief pro-Hamas agitator that led to the anti-semitic encampments at Columbia'.
Earlier in the hearing, California representative Mark Takano called the committee's hearing 'a kangaroo court'.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

South Park creator SMIRKS while apologizing to Donald Trump over episode that linked president to Jeffrey Epstein and Satan
South Park creator SMIRKS while apologizing to Donald Trump over episode that linked president to Jeffrey Epstein and Satan

Daily Mail​

time12 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

South Park creator SMIRKS while apologizing to Donald Trump over episode that linked president to Jeffrey Epstein and Satan

South Park co-creator Trey Parker smirked as he apologized over an episode that showed President Donald Trump in bed with Satan as they discussed the Jeffrey Epstein files. 'We're terribly sorry,' Parker said with a grin as he appeared alongside show co-creator Matt Stone at a Comedy Central panel on Thursday in San Diego. Parker made the comment after he was asked whether he anticipated the reaction to the episode, which aired on Tuesday and resulted in a damning statement by the White House. The premiere episode took aim at Paramount and its recent $16 million settlement with Trump just hours after Parker and Stone signed a five-year $1.5 billion deal with the company. 'Three days ago I didn't know if anyone's going to like this,' Parker added of the reaction to the episode, saying they were changing details on it until the last minute. When moderator Josh Horowitz joked that he had a 'subpoena with him,' Parker replied: 'It's fine, we're ready.' Later in the panel, Parker said they did get a note from their producers on Tuesday night's episode. 'If we put eyes on the penis, we won't blur it,' Parker said. 'That was a whole conversation with grown-up people for four f***ing days.' The show creators shared that they were currently working on their next episode and it was 'super stressful.' But Parker joked that upcoming episodes would include 'no politics.' 'We're not doing any of that (stuff),' he said. It comes after the White House released a scathing statement after the episode's release. 'This show hasn't been relevant for over 20 years and is hanging on by a thread with uninspired ideas in a desperate attempt for attention,' White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers said in the statement. 'President Trump has delivered on more promises in just six months than any other president in our country's history – and no fourth-rate show can derail President Trump's hot streak.' The installment touched upon the controversial cancellation of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, which critics baselessly allege was axed by the network to appease Trump despite it losing $40 million each year. One particularly controversial moment in Wednesday's episode saw Trump trying to romance Satan in bed before they discuss the Epstein list. #SouthPark creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone say 'we're very sorry' when asked about last night's episode. #SDCC #SouthParkSeason27 #Paramount — Karra Small (@karrasmallmedia) July 25, 2025 The creators also appeared to take aim at Paramount and its $16 million settlement of Trump's 60 Minutes lawsuit. In the episode, Trump sues the town of South Park when its residents challenge the presence of Jesus Christ – the actual person – in its elementary school. Jesus tells them they ought to settle. South Park returned for the first time in two years Wednesday, just one day after Parker and Stone brokered a $1.5 billion deal with Paramount. The deal confirms 50 new episodes, which will air on Comedy Central and stream exclusively on Paramount Plus over five years. It also makes Paramount+ the home to the entire catalogue of South Park. The agreement concludes protracted negotiations between Paramount and the show's creators - who previously sued incoming Paramount President Jeff Shell - accusing him of interference with rival negotiations involving Warner Bros Discovery and Netflix. Talks were further complicated by the Skydance leadership, which is in the process of acquiring Paramount, reportedly objecting to earlier proposed terms valued at $3billion over ten years.

Trump tears into his 'crazy' haters as he bets big on risky move amid new Epstein revelations
Trump tears into his 'crazy' haters as he bets big on risky move amid new Epstein revelations

Daily Mail​

time12 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Trump tears into his 'crazy' haters as he bets big on risky move amid new Epstein revelations

Donald Trump is still trying to blame the Jeffrey Epstein files outrage on 'crazy Democrats ' as his base demands answers amid claims of a 'cover-up.' Convinced that his haters are trying to distract from his 'great' first six months back in office, Trump is hoping that his direction to unseal grand jury testimony will be his saving grace among MAGA loyalists who are growing impatient. During his 2024 campaign, Trump vowed transparency on the Epstein files and claimed his administration would release troves of government secrets, including in the child sex trafficking case. Trump dubbed the entire ordeal a 'con job' and 'scam' as he again tore into the continuation of the saga in a Thursday night Truth Social post. It comes as yet another piece of evidence emerged that may shine additional light on Trump's relationship with Epstein. The New York Times reported that the president called Epstein 'the greatest' in a newly unearthed message he wrote for the disgraced billionaire on a copy of his 1997 book 'Trump: The Art of the Comeback.' The report comes as Trump is grappling with the fallout from a story by the Wall Street Journal claiming that the president signed a birthday note with a drawing of an outline of a naked woman to Epstein in 2003. Epstein's longtime girlfriend and British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell wrote an introductory letter to a leather-bound book of birthday notes, which the Times also published. Trump has fiercely denied ever drawing the picture and sued the Journal for $10 billion for libel claims. Shortly after the WSJ article was published, Trump shot back in a post to Truth Social saying: 'The supposed letter they printed by President Trump to Epstein was a FAKE.' The report claimed that Trump wrote in his birthday note to Epstein: 'May every day be another wonderful secret.' Trump's communications director has a standard statement he appears to be sending to all media who ask about Trump's connection to the Epstein debacle, and dismissing the reports as more 'fake news.' 'The fact is that the President kicked him out of his club for being a creep,' Cheung said in the statement sent to multiple outlets, including the Daily Mail. 'This is nothing more than a continuation of the fake news stories concocted by the Democrats and the liberal media, just like the Obama Russiagate scandal, which President Trump was right about,' he concludes. Trump is now all-in on his direction for the Justice Department to request courts unseal grand jury testimony. 'As things are revealed and, I hope will take place quickly, you will see that it is yet another Democrat con job,' Trump said on Truth Social in relation to the Epstein files. 'Hopefully, the Grand Jury Files will put an end to this hoax,' the president wrote on Truth Social shortly after the NYT piece was published. 'Everyone should see what is there, but people who are innocent should not be hurt.' Trump last week instructed Attorney General Pam Bondi to request the grand jury testimony on the Epstein case amid mounting pressure from his base to release more information. However, his plan is already hitting a snag. The Southern District of Florida this week denied the request for the highly-sensitive materials to be made available. And the Southern District of New York asked Trump's DOJ to respond to a request for more information on why they are seeking the additional court documents. It's very difficult to get grand jury testimony unsealed as it's one of the more highly-protected and secretive pieces of court materials. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche flew to Florida on Wednesday and met with Maxwell on Thursday to find out what more she knows and can reveal about Epstein. It's no secret that Trump associated with Epstein in the 1980s and 1990s. They ran in similar circles in New York City and Palm Beach and were oftentimes pictured at the same events. CNN unearthed images this month that showed Epstein attended Trump's second wedding to Marla Maples on December 20, 1993 at The Plaza Hotel in New York.

Fed says its "grateful" for Trump's encouragement to complete renovation
Fed says its "grateful" for Trump's encouragement to complete renovation

Reuters

time12 minutes ago

  • Reuters

Fed says its "grateful" for Trump's encouragement to complete renovation

July 25 (Reuters) - The Federal Reserve said on Friday that it was "grateful" for President Donald Trump's encouragement to complete its renovation project and that it "looked forward" to seeing the project through to completion. "We remain committed to continuing to be careful stewards of these resources as we see the project through to completion," it said in a statement, a day after Trump made a rare visit to the U.S. central bank, where he criticized the renovation project of its two historical buildings at headquarters.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store