Legal bid against Herald and Age in Lattouf case fails
On February 3, during Antoinette Lattouf's unlawful termination suit against the ABC, Justice Darryl Rangiah made a 10-year suppression order over the 'names, identities, contact details and addresses of persons who made complaints' about Lattouf's employment by the ABC.
The order was made 'on the ground that it is necessary to protect the safety of persons'.
Rangiah said at the time that he was satisfied there was 'a substantial risk' the individuals 'will face, at least, vilification and harassment if their identities and contact details were available to the public'.
Lawyers acting for people whose identities are said to be protected by the suppression order in the Lattouf case allege Herald editor Bevan Shields and The Age editor Patrick Elligett, as well as two in-house lawyers, two reporters and the publishing companies, breached the order.
The four articles at the centre of the dispute were published last year, before the suppression order was made.
Rangiah noted in a decision on Friday that '[the] articles remained available online even after the order was made' but were amended in March this year 'to remove the names of the relevant persons without any admission that the publishers were obliged to do so'.
At a preliminary hearing in April, Sue Chrysanthou, SC, acting for the group, said: 'Only one order is sought, and that is a referral under … the Federal Court Rules to the principal registrar to consider whether proceedings should be instituted for the punishment of contempt'.
But Tom Blackburn, SC, acting for the mastheads, said the registrar would have no 'independent discretion' and would have to commence contempt proceedings if Rangiah made the order.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
33 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
Pro-Palestine March for Humanity could shut down the Sydney Harbour Bridge to send 'powerful' message to the world
Pro-Palestinian protestors are set to march across the Sydney Harbour Bridge on August 3 to send a ''powerful'' message to the world amid the ongoing humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip. The Palestine Action Group Sydney said in a statement on Sunday that it has informed NSW Police of its intention to hold a 'March for Humanity' across the Sydney Harbour Bridge on Sunday to "save Gaza". "We call on everyone, every individual and every organisation, who cannot bear to do nothing in the face of this atrocity, to join with us," the statement reads. "As Australia's most iconic symbol, a mass march across the Harbour Bridge will send a powerful message to the world, to Gaza, to Israel, and to our own Government, that we are determined to stand up for humanity." The statement drew comparisons to the 2023 WorldPride March event, which closed the Harbour Bridge so 50,000 people - including Prime Minister Anthony Albanese - could march across. Palestine Action Group Sydney said the bridge "can certainly be closed to stop a genocide". "That same year (2023) saw the bridge closed for several hours to shoot a scene for a Ryan Gosling film. It can certainly be closed to stop a genocide," it wrote. The group further called on the NSW Government to facilitate the March for Humanity. The protest due to take place this coming weekend could set the stage for confrontations with police. Major traffic disruptions may also be on the cards if roads are closed for protestors to march across the bridge. The Palestine Action Group Sydney said it lodged a Form 1 notifying NSW Police of its intentions. While NSW protestors do not require formal approval from police to hold a legal rally after the filing of a Form 1, police can oppose it through the court system. The group said protesters planned on meeting at Lang Park, near Wynyard station, at 1pm before marching to the bridge. "We appeal to organisations and high profile individuals to please sign on and endorse this March for Humanity," the statement continues. "Let's do this! "Save Gaza! Free Palestine!"
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Donald Trump says Gaza is a 'mess' as Israel denies starvation crisis
US President Donald Trump has labelled Gaza "a mess" and says Israel would have to "make a decision" about its next steps in the strip, hours after aid restrictions were eased. Speaking at his golf course in Scotland, the president suggested Hamas had changed its stance on negotiations to release the 50 Israeli hostages the group still held captive, in exchange for a ceasefire in the war-ravaged strip. "They had a routine discussion the other day and all of a sudden [Hamas] hardened up," he said. "They don't want to give them back, and so Israel's going to have to make a decision." Mr Trump said the situation in Gaza had deteriorated dramatically. More than 100 humanitarian agencies had warned the strip was facing mass starvation, as Israeli restrictions on aid fuelled shortages of food and other supplies. Israel denied its actions had caused a starvation crisis, instead blaming Hamas for creating the situation. Palestinian health authorities said 133 people had died from starvation in the last week, with 87 of them children. "You know, when I see the children and when I see, especially over the last couple of weeks, and people are stealing the food, they're stealing the money, they're stealing the money for the food, they're stealing weapons, they're stealing everything," Mr Trump said. "It's a mess. That whole place is a mess." He suggested it was a mistake by then Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon to withdraw from Gaza, although he could not name which Israeli leader had been responsible for the move. "The Gaza Strip, you know, was given many years ago so that they could have peace — that didn't work out too well," he said. "When Israel gave that up, whoever was the prime minister at the time, who I know who it was — but it was not exactly a very clever thing to do, because that was given so that they finally have peace. "And it's actually made the situation worse." Ceasefire and hostage negotiations between Israel and Hamas have collapsed, with the White House's special envoy for the Middle East Steve Witkoff saying the militant group displayed a "lack of desire to reach" a deal. "There is no point in continuing negotiations under blockade, extermination and starvation of our children, women and people in the Gaza Strip," Hamas chief Khalil al-Hayya said on Sunday night. "The immediate and dignified entry of food and medications to our people is the real and serious expression of the viability of continuing negotiations." Despite the stalemate, Israel has bowed to international pressure over the humanitarian crisis which has developed in Gaza. The Netanyahu Government ordered a partial easing of the aid restrictions in the strip, with the changes coming into force on Sunday local time. Pallets of aid were dropped across Gaza by the Israeli, Jordanian and United Arab Emirates air forces, while the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said it had established "secure corridors" for the United Nations and other agencies to distribute aid. There are reports that as many as 11 Palestinians were injured as the pallets fell on their tents. Even with more supplies entering Gaza, it remains a dangerous situation for Palestinians trying to secure supplies. The ABC found Alaa Abu Muteer, 47, lying on a thin mattress in the Al-Shifa hospital in a corridor full of injured Palestinians. "Currently, I am unemployed. I went to bring food for my children. I reached the location, and saw there Israeli tanks that began opening fire on the people, and I was shot in my back," he said. "I have [10] children. They are all hungry, and I am also hungry. "I am looking for a mouthful of bread. I now need treatment for the wounds that I have." The IDF told the ABC it was not aware of any shootings in the area. Marwari Al-Barari, 39, said she feared the aid situation in Gaza had fuelled a dangerous culture. "This has taught our children to use knives, things like that," she said. "I saw a 10-year-old boy carrying a knife. Where is he going to? He said he is going to the aid distribution." She said the airdrops were the wrong approach. "I fully reject it, because I was in the south and it happened in front of my eyes. The people were living next to me, and the parachutes came down," she said. "There was a boy, 12 years old, that was killed on the spot from a parachute. "Also, these parachutes cause the barbarism and killing and bullying and stabbing and so forth. I reject it in full." Israel has accused humanitarian organisations of refusing to pick up supplies which have been dropped on the Gaza side of the border fence. In response, Israel has been accused of making it too difficult and too dangerous to collect the supplies. "We have hundreds of trucks that are waiting on the Gazan side of the Kerem Shalom crossing," Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said. "We've just announced that formally — here are safe corridors. "And the UN has no excuses left. No excuses left, stop lying. Stop finding excuses, do what you have to do, and stop accusing Israel deliberately of this egregious falsehood." The prime minister again denied there was a starvation crisis in Gaza, despite changing his government's policy in the strip and the international consensus on the situation. "Israel is presented as though we are applying a campaign of starvation in Gaza — what a bold-faced lie," Mr Netanyahu said. "There is no policy of starvation in Gaza, and there is no starvation in Gaza. "Hamas rob, steals this humanitarian aid and then accuses Israel of not supplying it." Aid agencies have repeatedly denied that there is any evidence of Hamas stealing food and other items. The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Volker Türk, urged the international community to continue pressuring Israel to allow more aid in. "When we think it can't get worse, it gets worse," he said. "Children are starving and dying in front of our eyes. "Gaza is a dystopian landscape of deadly attacks and total destruction."
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Dan Tehan challenges Anthony Albanese's assertion Israel is breaching international law
The Coalition is demanding Prime Minister Anthony Albanese "produce the facts", challenging his assertion that Israel has "clearly" breached international law by blocking aid into Gaza. Speaking on ABC Radio National, Coalition frontbencher Dan Tehan said the prime minister had made a heavy accusation. "That allegation should not be made lightly," Mr Tehan said. "Obviously, Israel are trying to provide humanitarian relief into Gaza, Hamas keeps on trying to disrupt those efforts. Now what the prime minister has said takes this whole situation to a new level." Yesterday, Mr Albanese said it was "quite clearly" a breach of international law to stop food from being delivered, a decision he said Israel made in March. Israel imposed a total blockade on humanitarian aid in March that ran for several months, as it tried to pressure Hamas to release Israeli hostages. That blockade was partially eased as Israel instead developed its own private aid delivery model, bypassing established UN channels. But last week more than 100 international humanitarian organisations, including Médecins Sans Frontières, Oxfam and Save the Children jointly warned Gaza was on the brink of "mass starvation", with not enough aid getting to Palestinians. Israel has consistently rejected allegations it has fuelled a hunger crisis in Gaza, instead blaming Hamas and claiming the listed terror group has weaponised humanitarian aid to supply its fighters. Under intense global pressure, Israel announced overnight it would pause fighting in some densely populated areas to allow more aid drops. Mr Tehan said Israel had been trying to provide relief in a way that Hamas could not capitalise on. "They have been attempting to do that for months because they know and understand [that] while Hamas is in control in Gaza, it will not lead to the humanitarian situation we all want to see, which is aid flowing there and ultimately the people of Gaza being able to determine who governs them in a free and fair way," Mr Tehan said. "The problem all along has been an internationally listed terrorist organisation, Hamas. If Hamas removed themselves from this process, we would not be in the situation we are in today." Mr Tehan said he wanted to see humanitarian aid flowing into Gaza, but until Hamas was removed, "unfortunately" the use of aid would be weaponised and that was not in anyone's interest. "If Hamas had not acted like they did on October 7 [2023], we wouldn't have this situation. They stand condemned and, in my view, they are the sole responsible actor here for the situation we find ourselves in," Mr Tehan said. Yesterday, Mr Albanese stopped short of saying whether Australia would take further action to pressure Israel to end what he said were breaches of international law. The prime minister confirmed Australia would not follow France to immediately recognise a Palestinian state, with Foreign Minister Penny Wong telling the ABC that there were still several hurdles to a two-state solution. The senator said Hamas must be de-militarised and Israeli hostages released before discussions to recognise Palestine could be progressed. Former foreign minister and Labor luminary Bob Carr told ABC Radio National it was clear from the prime minister's comments that recognition from Australia was "a matter of time". But he said the prime minister should not wait for the United Kingdom to move before acting. "I think that is very unfortunate if we see ourselves as a strong, creative middle power," Mr Carr said. "It would strengthen the impression of Australia as a country that can do things big and important ... I just think Australians are ready for our country to show a flash of independence, strength and maturity by moving with the French, and not huddling and waiting for the sanction that Britain would give us when Downing Street finally gets around to it." Twenty-eight nations, including Australia, last week demanded an immediate end to the war in Gaza and for Israel to lift aid restrictions. Shadow Foreign Minister Michaelia Cash said last week the Coalition had "strong concerns" about the worsening humanitarian situation in Gaza, but was disappointed that the prime minister had failed to place blame on Hamas for the delays in aid reaching Gaza. "Hamas could end the suffering of the people of Gaza by freeing the remaining Israeli hostages and laying down their weapons," Senator Cash said.
