Former priest accused of assault says church group leadership was ‘on consensus'
Brain denies one count of rape and 36 counts of indecent assault between 1981 and 1995 against 13 women.
Prosecutors say NOS became a cult where Brain abused his position to sexually assault a 'staggering number' of women followers, exerting control over their lives and ostracising them from friends and family.
On Monday, Brain told jurors at Inner London Crown Court that he had a leading role in a group in the Yorkshire city from the early 1980s, which would later 'dissolve into' the NOS.
Giving evidence in a navy suit, the defendant said the earlier group had been likened to a 'kibbutz' with 12 members who would focus on helping the poor and disadvantaged.
Defence lawyer Iain Simkin KC asked Brain if he attempted to indoctrinate those in the group.
Brain replied: 'No, of course not.'
The defendant also denied trying to coerce others.
Mr Simkin asked: 'Did you try to start a cult?'
Brain said he did not, adding that those involved were 'completely anti-cult'.
The NOS began in 1986, and the defendant said it had a 'team structure' but that he led the congregation.
He told of leading the design of the worship, choosing the music, songs and lighting.
Brain said he 'rarely' stood at the front of worships and instead played more of a 'producer' role.
He told jurors: 'Yes I was a leader but there were other leaders as well.'
Mr Simkin asked Brain if he was a 'controlling maniac' who ran a cult for his own ends.
The defendant said he was not, adding that members were 'completely against a charismatic bloke leading the front of their service'.
Mr Simkin asked the defendant if he made members 'obey' or if he turned them into 'robots' for his 'sexual desires', which he denied.
Asked if members could work, the defendant said: 'Yes of course. Some of them had normal jobs.'
Mr Simkin asked Brain about his leadership style, to which the defendant said: 'I think most of the time I worked on consensus, at the time that's what I thought was most considerate, making sure you take everybody with you.'
But he admitted being 'Yorkshire and straight' and 'direct by today's standards'.
Brain said that his role was 'totally consuming' and 'creatively intensive'.
Mr Simkin also asked Brain if he dressed people down in public, humiliated them or wanted to control, which the defendant denied.
He denied having an extravagant lifestyle, saying he lived in a two-bedroom terraced house and drove a third-hand Ford Escort before switching it for a Toyota.
Mr Simkin asked Brain if he 'fleeced' others to pay for his lifestyle, and the defendant replied: 'No.'
The trial continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
7 days ago
- Daily Mail
Brain surgeon who 'raped woman' and posed for series of selfies with an arsenal of weapons including knives in a Snapchat post with the message 'Who wants to play?' is struck off
A brain surgeon who assaulted a woman and posed for selfies with weapons including knives in a Snapchat post saying, 'Who wants to play?', has been struck off. Dr Sayed Talibi, 38, of the town of Tamworth, Staffordshire, used to work for the University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire (UHCW) NHS Trust. But an array of horrifying charges against the British-born doctor have now been proven, at a General Medical Council (GMC) tribunal misconduct hearing. He accumulated a range of incriminating videos, pictures and documents on his electronic devices from 2007 to 2018. These included graphic footage of beheadings, including of the Taliban killing civilians and Pakistani soldiers, and an image of a waterboarding device. His selfies with weapons included variously a large number of knives and an axe, with others showing him holding or pointing firearms, including rifles, semi-automatics and handguns. His sinisterly captioned Snapchat post pictured three knives, a meat cleaver and a small sword. The neurosurgeon also threatened to waterboard and brandished a knife at the woman he is said to have raped, attacking her and being threatening and abusive to her. He denied raping the woman three times - but the tribunal found they once had sex without her consent and without him 'having reasonable belief' she was consenting. Some images on his devices were thought to have have been taken 'in a foreign location'. But one photo showing semi-automatic firearms, pistols and magazines laid out on a garden patio is believed to have been taken in the UK. Other images on his devices showed heavy armoured vehicles and weaponry, an aerial shot of RAF Lakenheath and army bases in Italy, Greece, Turkey and the UK. A charge he posed with a Russian rocket launcher was dropped. The practitioner was accused of bringing the profession into disrepute. When questioned by Simon Jackson KC, Talibi admitted he had been 'foolish' to pose for the selfies with weapons - but thought 'it was cool' at the time. He denied being 'obsessed' with guns and expressing 'anti-Western attitudes' and said many photos showed 'BB' or 'toy' guns. Talibi said his interests in guns and weaponry stemmed from his time as an army cadet at university and his ongoing interest in 'West Asian geopolitics'. The neurosurgeon said he saw himself as a 'British patriot' and abhorred 'terrorism in any form'. But Mr Jackson said the doctor's incriminating images showed he had 'anti-Western sentiments'. Talibi replied: 'I'm sure everyone is allowed to disagree with politics but I don't disagree with being a law-abiding citizen in the West. They're two different things.' But on top of this, he also created an online dating profile showing a picture of him participating in live brain surgery. The graphic image, on the profile describing him as a '28-year-old brain surgeon', displayed the exposed brain of a patient. Talibi also made racist and discriminatory comments, including saying he 'hated' non-Muslims, who he described with the derogatory term 'kuffar'. He also said he 'hated' Afghans and Afghan culture. The doctor also stole milk powder from an Asda supermarket, defrauded EDF Energy over a £770 energy bill and recorded a court appearance for driving offences. University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire (UHCW) NHS Trust has been approached for comment.
BBC News
05-08-2025
- BBC News
Sheffield priest Chris Brain says sex acts were 'consensual'
A former priest accused of sexually assaulting 13 women while he was the head of a church group has said consent was the "grounding of everything".Chris Brain, 68, denies one count of rape and 36 charges of indecent assault, relating to his time with the Nine O'Clock Service (NOS), an influential evangelical church movement in Sheffield in the 1980s and allege he used his position to abuse a "staggering number" of female members, exerting control over their lives and ostracising evidence at Inner London Crown Court, Mr Brain, from Wilmslow, Cheshire, said he had sex with one of the complainants, but said it "just went too far" but insisted it had been consensual. He said the Sheffield-based evangelical movement was a "free, open, really caring, very fun environment" and denied claims he had abused one victim, Mr Brain admitted there had been "petting at a regular basis" but that she had "absolutely" consented to having her breasts touched under her agreed the relationship had gone further but that it was by Iain Simkin KC, defending, if he cared whether the woman he had slept with consented, he replied: "Of course I did".He also told jurors there was "consent at a very serious, deep level" with another woman after they agreed to have a more sexual Brain insisted consent was "absolutely the grounding of everything we were doing". 'Intimacy and trust' NOS, which began in 1986, was initially celebrated by Church of England leaders for its nightclub-style services which incorporated live music and multimedia and attracted hundreds of young people to its Brain said the environment in the NOS was less like a church house and "much more like a group of musicians living together".The defendant said he had built up "intimacy and trust" with church members over a long period of time, but said he was not the "kind of guy to try it on"."It's not part of my character or my belief system."Mr Simkin told the court Mr Brain admitted to having relations with members of his congregation in a BBC documentary in November defendant said he was "in a state of complete overwhelmed trauma" at the time of the admission and had "needed to be really open and accountable for what I had done".He said he had resigned from his priesthood in the same month "because the hassle at the time (and) the press intrusion had pretty much devastated my life".Mr Brain rejected testimonies from people who said he had tried to control people's clothing, weight and relationships."The intensity of what we did tended to draw people in," he Tim Clark KC, cross-examining, put it to Mr Brain that he spoke "psychobabble" to get his own sexual gratification."No," the defendant defendant told jurors he felt he had used his position of trust "to the best effect I could at the time" and denied abusing any trust placed in trial reporting by PA Media. Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North
The Independent
05-08-2025
- The Independent
‘I was the most radical ordained vicar there was': Church of England ‘cult' leader defends ‘sensual' contact with followers
A former priest accused of leading an evangelical cult in the Church of England has defended having 'sensual' contact with followers, telling the jury: 'I was the most radical ordained vicar there was.' Christopher Brain, who led the rave-style Nine O-Clock Service (NOS) in Sheffield in the 80s and 90s, allegedly surrounded himself with women who wore lingerie or revealing clothes as part of his 'homebase team' who kept his house 'spotlessly clean'. Jurors at Inner London Crown Court previously heard the women – sometimes referred to as 'the Lycra Lovelies' or 'the Lycra Nuns' – were on a rota to help maintain the home of then-Reverend Brain. The 68-year-old denies one count of rape and 36 counts of indecent assault relating to 13 women in the church movement between 1981 and 1995. He accepts that he engaged in sexual activity with some of the complainants, but insists that it was consensual. Giving evidence for a second day, he defended the liaisons with members of his congregation when he was married with a young child. He claimed he and his former wife 'were in a pretty much open relationship' and considering splitting up, adding: 'I wasn't a traditional vicar, I was someone on a journey of radical research and experimentation.' The former clergyman, who was fast-tracked for ordination in 1991 after the movement attracted hundreds of younger congregants to the Church of England, previously told the court said he received 'sensual' back massages from women to relieve tension headaches. He claims he resigned from NOS to carry on his work in San Francisco in 1993, two years before the Sheffield church collapsed surrounded by controversy in 1995. Challenged over his contact with congregants on Tuesday, he replied: 'In a traditional setting I don't know. But if you are in a polyamorous community at the front edge of culture in San Francisco and at the heart of the rave movement, then obviously I thought it was OK.' He told the jury he and one complainant – who alleges he raped her at his home in Sheffield in 1983 or 1984 – engaged in 'petting' on a regular basis. He said he and his then-wife were 'pretty open', but if liaisons progressed to full sex it would be cheating. He admitted to having sex with the woman after it 'went too far', but said it was 'absolutely' consensual. 'We were in the bedroom and it just went too far,' he said. 'We started having sex and shortly after that started we stopped.' He said another woman, who accuses him of multiple counts of sexual assault, was 'totally happy with it'. 'It was a club environment' he added. 'It wasn't like a church house it was like a group of musicians living together.' He insisted sexual aggression is 'not my style' and contested his portrayal as some kind of 'lairy' guy. He alleged the liaisons came after trust had been built up over a long period of time. He added: 'I am not the type of guy to try it on, I never have been. It's not part of my character or my belief system.' He said an accusation he simulated a rape scene with one woman 'absolutely didn't happen' and denied a number of other charges, including an allegation he placed a woman's hand on his genitals. Questioned by his lawyer Iain Simkins KC over his appearance in a 1995 BBC documentary on NOS called Everyman, in which he admitted he was 'involved in improper sexual conduct with a number of women', he told the jury he 'over accepted responsibility' in the programme. 'I think it shows I pretty much over accepted responsibility,' he said. 'I massively accepted the responsibility for the bulk of it. Almost single handedly being blamed for everything that seemed to have gone wrong.' He insisted NOS was never a cult and denied he never engaged in a 'sexual healing practise' with female followers, adding: 'The sexual healing trope that is laid all over this case didn't exist.' He described the criminal charges as a 'witch hunt' and said the breakdown of NOS 'basically destroyed my life' in the 90s. The prosecution allege NOS became a 'closed and controlled' group which he used to 'sexually assault a staggering number of women from his congregation'. The eight-week trial continues.
