Government could ban ‘barely legal' pornography after Bonnie Blue documentary
It comes after Channel 4 broadcast a documentary about the porn star, called: '1000 Men and Me: The Bonnie Blue Story', which followed her for six months.
The show attracted significant criticism, with the children's commissioner for England, Dame Rachel de Souza, accusing the show of 'glamorising and normalising' extreme pornography.
The documentary shows Tia Billinger – who uses the stage name Bonnie Blue – preparing to film a scene with a group of models dressed in school uniform, who acknowledge that they have been picked for the scene because they look young.
'This content is pushing at the boundaries. We will be trying to address the 'barely legal' aspect legislatively', Baroness Bertin told The Guardian.
She said she plans to raise amendments to the Crime and Policing Bill once Parliament returns from its summer recess to make it illegal for online platforms to host content that could encourage child sexual abuse. This would include content filmed by adults dressed up as children.
Bonnie Blue became famous after initially filming sexual content with young male students, who she dubbed 'barely legal'. She later gained notoriety after filming stunts, including one which saw her have sex with more than 1,000 men in a 24-hour period.
Under rules that came into effect on July 25 as part of the Online Safety Act, online platforms including social media sites and search engines must take steps to prevent children from accessing harmful content such as pornography or material that encourages suicide.
The act also gave Ofcom the responsibility to monitor whether sites are protecting viewers from illegal material including child sexual abuse or extreme content such as portrayals of rape, bestiality and necrophilia.
But currently, adults role-playing as children in pornography is not prohibited online.
The Channel 4 documentary, which showed pixellated clips of Bonnie Blue having sex with more than 1,000 men, faced condemnation for failing to challenge her enough, with advertisers pulling support for the programme.
Card payment business Visa, juice maker Cawston Press and vodka brand Smirnoff all had ads which appeared online during the show, but they later told Channel 4 that they no longer wanted their products promoted during the programme as it did not align with their advertising guidelines or values.
Dame Rachel said: 'For years we have been fighting to protect our children from the kind of degrading, violent sex that exists freely on their social media feeds. This documentary risks taking us a step back by glamorising, even normalising, the things young people tell me are frightening, confusing and damaging to their relationships.'
Baroness Bertin added: 'Channel 4 showed a surprising lack of judgment in showing such explicit sex scenes. More widely the glamorisation and normalisation of content creators like Bonnie Blue does undoubtedly have an effect. In my opinion, this is a direction of travel that is not particularly helpful for society nor is it prudish to call it out as such.'
A Channel 4 spokesperson said: 'The film looks at how Bonnie Blue has gained worldwide attention and earned millions of pounds in the last year, exploring changing attitudes to sex, success, porn and feminism in an ever-evolving online world.
'Director Victoria Silver puts a number of challenges to Bonnie throughout the documentary on the example she sets and how she is perceived, and the film clearly lays bare the tactics and strategies she uses, with the audience purposefully left to form their own opinions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
-copy.jpeg%3Ftrim%3D0%2C0%2C0%2C0%26width%3D1200%26height%3D800%26crop%3D1200%3A800&w=3840&q=100)
The Independent
5 minutes ago
- The Independent
Tributes paid to dad who died during Oasis gig in Wembley
Lee Claydon, a father from Bournemouth, tragically died after falling from an upper tier balcony during an Oasis concert at Wembley Stadium on Saturday night. Described as a 'loving family man' and 'role model' to his son, his brother Aaron Claydon paid tribute, stating the family is devastated by the unexpected loss. A GoFundMe page has been established by his brother to provide financial and emotional support to Lee's partner, Amanda, and their family. The Metropolitan Police are investigating the incident and have appealed for witnesses or anyone with mobile phone footage to assist their inquiry. Both Wembley Stadium officials and the Gallagher brothers expressed their shock and sadness following the concert-goer's death.
Telegraph
6 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Withholding facts about suspects risks endangering the British public
How much does the public need to know about the background of suspected criminals? On Sunday, the shadow home secretary Chris Philp called on the Government to ensure that the immigration status and nationality of all offenders was published 'for each crime and as quarterly totals'. Otherwise, he said, 'we risk a repeat of the rape gang scandal where horrendous crimes were covered up because of the identity of the perpetrators'. Philp's reference to 'each crime' suggests he was referring to convicted offenders. But what happened with the grooming gangs was a scandal because allegations were not prosecuted or even investigated. The Conservative MP was responding to concerns that Warwickshire Police had not revealed the background of two men accused of involvement in the alleged rape of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. In contrast to the earlier cases, those defendants were promptly charged. It's reported that the accused are asylum seekers from Afghanistan. But Warwickshire police, following national guidelines, have not confirmed that. On Monday, Nigel Farage accused the police of a 'cover-up' after officers reportedly advised local councillors not to disclose that the suspects were asylum seekers for fear of 'inflaming community tensions'. The Reform UK leader argued that police forces should release the name, address and immigration status of people after they were charged with a crime. Not to be outdone, the Home Secretary said on Tuesday that police guidance needed to be changed. Asked if she thought the immigration status and ethnicity of suspects should be disclosed, Yvette Cooper told the BBC: 'We do want to see more transparency in cases. We think local people do need to have more information.' She had asked the Law Commission to speed up its review of the restrictions on prejudicing criminal trials. In March, the Government's independent law reform advisers responded with a brief consultation paper, focusing on an aspect of its current inquiry into contempt of court liability. Final recommendations are expected in the autumn. After Axel Rudakubana murdered three young girls at a dance class in Southport in July 2024, Merseyside police disclosed that he had been born in Cardiff. But confirmation that the suspect was a British national did little to ease the growing but false belief that the massacre at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class was the work of an asylum-seeker. Reporters told the Law Commission that the widespread public disorder that followed was an indirect result of contempt laws. By constraining the information that public authorities could disclose, the law helped create an information vacuum into which misinformation, disinformation and counter-narratives could spread unchecked. That, said the Law Commission, raised the question of whether there should be contempt of court liability for those who risk prejudicing a criminal trial by releasing information in the interests of public safety or national security. Changing the law would provide a defence for the police. But it might also make it harder for the defendant to receive a fair trial. For example, publishing information about a defendant's past misconduct – even, for example, that the accused had entered the UK illegally – might in some cases be prejudicial. In practice, though, juries are expected to ignore whatever they may remember from the time of arrest. If a retrial is ordered in a notorious case, the second jury may be told that a previous jury had failed to agree. And if extremely prejudicial material has been published, the Law Commission suggested that a defendant could be tried by judge alone. It should be possible for incontrovertible facts about suspects – such as nationality – to be published at the time of an arrest without, as the law puts it, a 'substantial risk that the course of justice… will be seriously impeded or prejudiced'. As the Home Secretary recalled, Scotland Yard had announced in May that several individuals arrested under the National Security Act were Iranian nationals. Their immigration status was disclosed by the Crown Prosecution Service when three of them were charged, Cooper added. But good reasons must be shown for publishing anything about a suspect that is not necessary to avoid confusion with someone of a similar name. Some people are arrested but not charged while others are charged but not convicted. And there is a risk that merely reporting an individual's immigration status or nationality may be positively misleading. More important in assessing the threat to the public in terrorist cases is the suspect's religion – though this is not something a defendant can be required to disclose. As so often, there is a balance to be struck. If the police have to announce every suspect's nationality, immigration status, ethnicity and religion, cases will take longer to process and prejudice will be more likely. Far from deterring public disorder, it may provoke it.
Daily Mail
6 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Formula 1's George Russell shares a steamy smooch with his bikini-clad girlfriend Carmen Montero Mundt on romantic Italian yacht trip
shared a steamy smooch with his bikini-clad girlfriend Carmen Montero Mundt on a romantic yacht trip in Sardinia, Italy on Monday. The Mercedes Formula One driver jetted off on a relaxing Italian getaway before he returns for the Dutch Grand Prix after a three week summer break. The loved-up couple looked completely smitten as they larked around during watersports. George and Carmen packed on the PDA later in the day after a fun-filled day in the sun. The shirtless hunk showcased her ripped physique in navy swimshorts, while Carmen flashed her abs in a skimpy yellow bikini. The 27-year-old first came across fashion influencer Carmen, when the Spaniard had been set to meet a friend of his for a date in 2020. 'My mate couldn't make it, so I thought I'll swing along to see how it goes,' Russell told The Sun. 'She told me she's from the south of Spain and she wouldn't ever expect someone to know the small place she's from. 'I knew exactly where she was from, so it was quite coincidental.' The pair quickly bonded, with George having spent a significant amount of time in the city of Jerez in southern Spain where Carmen hails from during his karting days. However, while Carmen has now become one of George's biggest supporters, faithfully following his globe trotting exploits, she was not initially aware of his profession. He continued: 'I'm so fortunate with Carmen because we met before the craziness of F1. We met organically and it wasn't a set up. 'She didn't know who I was, she didn't know F1 and wasn't even bothered by any of that. She is a very down-to-earth individual and we share values. 'She's such a hard worker, wants to achieve so much and she really recognises what it takes in my position to be at this level. Having her on this journey means an awful lot to me because even though we are living our dream it can be a lonely lifestyle. The shirtless hunk showcased her ripped physique in navy swimshorts, while Carmen flashed her abs in a skimpy yellow bikini George and Carmen showed off their impressive skills There had been some nagging doubts about his future with the constructor but George is set for a bumper payday, more than doubling his current £12m-a-year package The pair put on a tactile display 'Having somebody to help you disconnect from that actually brings performance as well.' When the pair celebrated five years together in February, Carmen detailed her pride in her partner in a post on social media. She wrote: 'Five years with the most wonderful person I could ever ask for. Forever proud of who you are and what you do.' The British Formula One star is closing in on a new Mercedes deal worth an eye-watering £30m-a-year. There had been some nagging doubts about his future with the constructor but George is set for a bumper payday, more than doubling his current £12m-a-year package. As Mail Sport's Jonathan McEvoy exclusively revealed this week, negotiations have accelerated over the last few weeks and a source close to the talks confirmed: 'All the main points have been agreed.' George's incoming raise will remain well short of Max Verstappen and Ferrari's Lewis Hamilton - each on about £60m a year. While he does not yet have the achievements or global fanbase to garner such earnings, his win in Canada and domination over team-mate Kimi Antonelli this season point to his consistent form. His net worth is currently estimated to be in the region of £15m, though clearly that is set to increase substantially in the next few years.
