Official apathy delays cancer, renal treatment for Bhopal Gas survivors
More than a year after the death of her husband, she says, "I am fed up. I don't know how many more times I will have to make rounds of the gas welfare commissioner office to get the money. When my husband was diagnosed with cancer, we thought the ex-gratia given to cancer and renal failure patients among the gas victims would help us in his treatment, but he died in just three months. I have two daughters aged 18 and 14 years. This money means a lot to me.
I even hired a lawyer in an attempt to get the money early, and the welfare commissioner is said to have decided the case in our favour, but the order has not been uploaded on the office's website for two months, thereby making our agonising wait even longer," said Usha while talking to TOI.
Usha is not the only survivor of a gas victim who died of cancer or renal failure and is waiting for the disbursement of ex-gratia, which should ideally have been given to her when her husband was diagnosed with cancer.
There are gas victims and their survivors who are facing an inordinate delay in receiving the amount of ex-gratia assistance of Rs 2 lakh offered to cancer and renal failure patients among gas victims.
Azad, whose father Geeta Prasad died of cancer on May 23, 2023, is also among the people waiting for the payment of the ex-gratia amount so that he could make partial repayment of Rs 3.5 lakh, which he borrowed during the treatment of his father.
"I applied for ex-gratia after the death of my father, but if it comes my way early, it would help me pay back some of the amount I borrowed for the treatment of my father," he told TOI.
In 2010, when the group of ministers on Bhopal in the Union govt announced several measures to ameliorate the condition of the victims, an ex-gratia assistance of Rs 2 lakh to cancer and renal failure patients among gas victims was also one of the measures.
After a person or his family members apply for the ex-gratia, the matter goes to the welfare commissioner for arbitration, who is a serving judge of the Madhya Pradesh high court.
Once he is satisfied that the person for whom the ex-gratia is being sought is a gas victim and also suffers from cancer or renal failure, he passes the order for payment of ex-gratia to the patient or his family. This process takes 12 to 18 months, and there is so much paperwork involved.
Majority of persons applying for the assistance have to hire a lawyer to 'fight' their case, like Usha Ahuja has done.
What is adding further to their woes is the fact that orders of the welfare commissioner are not being uploaded since May 5 on the website of the office due to a lack of logistic support, including staff with technical know-how to do it, thereby further delaying the payments to sufferers for whom every day is important.
The co-convener of the Bhopal Group for Action & Information (BGAI), an NGO working among survivors of Bhopal gas victims, has written a letter to the secretary of the ministry of chemical & fertilisers, which handles the issues related to the
Bhopal gas tragedy
and its victims, drawing his attention towards the delay in payment of ex-gratia to gas victims suffering from cancer and renal failure.
She has not only raised the issue of no new orders of payment being uploaded on the website of the welfare commissioner office since May 5, 2025, but further said that the average time taken for adjudicating individual cancer and renal failure cases is 12 to 18 months. "This is an unconscionable delay, especially considering the severity of illness involved in far too many cases. The claimant passes away even before the order is issued," she said.
Registrar in the welfare commissioner office, Renuka Kanchal, was not available for comments. Director of gas relief, Swatantra Kumar Singh, said, "I am not aware of it. It is not connected to me, so it won't be apt for me to make a comment."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Spurt in evictions: Assam eyes to reclaim encroached forest land
Guwahati: Assam is carrying out large-scale eviction drives in its forest lands for several interrelated reasons, driven by ecological, legal, and social imperatives with the objective of reclaiming vast tracts of encroached land. According to the Union environment ministry's report to the National Green Tribunal (NGT), the state's total forest area under encroachment was 3,620.9 square kilometers (3,62,090 ha) as of March 2024, making it the second highest among all Indian states and Union Territories, after Madhya Pradesh. The eviction drives in forest lands are primarily motivated by the need to reduce human-wildlife conflict, comply with judicial orders, restore ecological balance, reclaim land for public use, and enforce land laws. These efforts are complex and often controversial, reflecting the intersection of conservation priorities, legal mandates, and social dynamics. The biggest impact of the unabetted encroachment of forest lands for decades in the state has been on wildlife habitats, resulting into high incidence of human-animal conflict, particularly with elephant. Assam, particularly districts like Goalpara, has some of the highest rates of human-elephant conflict in India where encroachment into forest areas disrupts elephant corridors and habitats, leading to frequent and sometimes fatal encounters between humans and wildlife. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like [화제] 150cm엄마,170아빠 이거먹고 우리아이는 180cm됐습니다! 3개월만에8cm성장 더 알아보기 Undo The eviction drives also aim to reclaim forest land to restore ecological integrity, protect biodiversity, and ensure the survival of endangered species by reviving degraded habitats. The Gauhati high court has explicitly directed the Assam govt to clear encroachments from protected forest areas. These orders often follow petitions highlighting the impact of encroachment on wildlife and forest conservation. The NGT has also mandated updated reporting and action on forest encroachment, further compelling the state to act. In some cases, land cleared of encroachment is earmarked for public infrastructure projects, such as power plants, which the government argues are for regional development and public welfare. According to data given by forest minister Chandra Mohan Patowary in assembly last March, of the total forest land under encroachment, over 83,000 ha are encroached by neighbouring states, over 2,50,000 ha by people of the state, and over 1,000 ha by tea gardens. Chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma recently said over 25,000 ha (more than 10,000 ha) of encroached land has been cleared in last four years. Since the BJP govt came to power in Assam in 2016, eviction drives targeting forest land, govt land, and religious places have increased dramatically compared to previous administrations. The govt cites restoration of ecological balance, curbing human-elephant conflict, and removal of illegal immigrants as primary reasons. Many eviction drives have been conducted under direct court orders or PILs, especially after a 2015 Gauhati HC directive to clear encroachments from Kaziranga National Park. The drives have been criticized for disproportionately targeting minority (especially Bangladesh-origin Muslim) communities, and for lack of rehabilitation and short notice periods.
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
VMC bans meat shops during Shrawan, violators to face FIR
1 2 Varanasi: The Varanasi Municipal Corporation has decided to shut down all meat, fish and chicken shops within its jurisdiction during the sacred Shrawan month. To enforce this order, the corporation will conduct regular checks, and any shop found violating the directive will face an FIR against the owner. Corporator Hanuman Prasad suggested a total ban on meat, chicken and fish shops in the municipal area during Shrawan and Mayor Ashok Kumar Tiwari passed the order. Animal welfare officer Santosh Pal confirmed that the order will be strictly enforced and FIRs will be filed under the Animal Cruelty Act against the violators. At the executive meeting, chaired by the mayor, deputy chairman Narsingh Das proposed necessary action for cleaning prominent ghats and preventing sewer overflow in the paved neighbourhoods during Shrawan, ensuring no inconvenience to pilgrims. The mayor instructed the general engineering, waterworks, lighting and health departments to coordinate and form a QRT to resolve complaints within 40 minutes. Additionally, instructions were given to place dustbins near important temples and regularly clean them. Member Sushil Gupta proposed a ban on the use of plastic bags around temples, with the mayor instructing that a special campaign be conducted to distribute cloth bags in these areas. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Esta nueva alarma con cámara es casi regalada en Rufino (ver precio) Verisure Más información Undo Earlier, the meeting began with the deputy chairman proposing the confirmation of the previous meeting's minutes, which was approved by all the members. Subsequently, discussions were held on govt orders received, during which joint municipal commissioner Krishna Chandra discussed the tree plantation programme for the year 2025-26. Additional municipal commissioner Vinod Kumar Gupta presented a proposal for the National Clean Air Programme and the operation of ABC Dog Care, which was introduced by the animal welfare officer. After discussions, it was decided that the ABC centre would be operated by a contracted organisation for six months, after which the municipal corporation would take over the following training. Chandra proposed the creation of a Miyawaki Forest Park on 2.5 hectares of vacant municipal land near Sarang Pond at a cost of Rs 2.94 crore, which was approved by the committee with instructions for prompt action. Regarding the auction of 33 trees obstructing the Unity Mall construction in IDH Kajjakpura, Chandra presented a proposal. The mayor instructed that the teak and jamun trees be auctioned at a fair price, while the remaining ones should be cut and stored for use as firewood in winter. A proposal for faecal sludge management was presented by the general manager of waterworks, which was unanimously approved with instructions for further action. In response to a question about well restoration, the chief engineer in-charge reported that 500 wells have been identified for restoration, with work underway on 31 wells. The mayor instructed that funds be allocated to expedite the restoration work. Member Rajesh Yadav Challu inquired about the number of projects completed under the councillor quota for 2023-24. The mayor instructed that if contractors do not participate in tenders, work should be carried out at fixed rates. The general manager of waterworks reported progress on the sewer and water line installation project in 18 old wards. The Detailed Project Report (DPR) has been approved by the govt, and work is expected to commence within three months after fund allocation. Once funds are allocated, the project will move forward, aiming to improve the city's infrastructure and services.
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
Union culture min directs ASI to refill Deeg excavation trenches after TOI report
Jaipur: Union minister for culture, Gajendra Singh Shekhawat , has directed the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), Jaipur Circle to immediately begin refilling the exposed excavation trenches at the archaeological site in Bahaj village, Deeg district, to prevent further monsoon-related damage. Shekhawat's directions follows TOI's July 10 report titled "Bureaucratic Limbo: Monsoon Threatens Deeg Archaeological Site", which highlighted the absence of protective measures at the site, where over 4,500 artefacts—dating back to the Paleolithic, Copper, and Iron Ages—were uncovered during a significant excavation. The site suffered its first spell of damage on June 22, when rainwater filled trenches up to two metres deep, putting the area in acute danger and raising concerns over the preservation of unearthed artefacts. Responding to TOI, Shekhawat acknowledged the archaeological significance of the site and confirmed that preventive measures are now underway. He said, the ASI's Jaipur Circle briefed the Director General, ASI, and that the backfilling of trenches is already in progress, with completion expected in two to four days. "Some trenches were intentionally left open for collecting soil and charcoal samples for scientific analysis. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Why seniors are rushing to get this Internet box – here's why! Techno Mag Learn More Undo All trenches are now being systematically refilled," he told TOI. Shekhawat also noted the challenges of long-term preservation. He said, "The site at Bahaj is archaeologically important but lies amid residential houses in the village. Therefore, permanent protection and preservation are not feasible without the rehabilitation or relocation of the settlement." He added that the antiquarian material recovered can be properly showcased either at the Deeg Palace or in a future museum, once the excavation report is completed. The ASI was excavating the site for nearly a year, with work concluding only recently. However, the area has not been notified as a protected site under ASI, leaving it exposed to weather, encroachment, and human interference. When the matter was referred to the Rajasthan Department of Archaeology and Museums, the response was equally non-committal, as the site is not listed under state-protected monuments either.
