Gaza crisis demands a return to political reality
At a time when Palestinians in Gaza are being killed at aid distribution points or bombed from the air, the idea that forcibly displacing them and cornering them could lead to an improvement in their lives is a disturbing one. This plan is just the latest in a series of mendacious and unrealistic proposals for Gaza that waste time and diplomatic energy that could be better spent producing genuine solutions.
In fact, a similarly incongruous proposal came from Mr Katz in January last year. Presented to 27 EU foreign ministers during a meeting in Brussels to discuss the war, Mr Katz showed the European representatives videos of an artificial island to be built off the Gazan coast. The EU's High Commissioner for Foreign Affairs, Josep Borrell, later told a news briefing that 'the minister could have made better use of his time and focus on the security of his country, bearing in mind the high number of deaths in Gaza'.
The stakes for Palestine, the Middle East and the Israeli public are much too high for further timewasting or disruptive proposals that are clearly unworkable and unacceptable. In Gaza itself, amid the suffering of the Palestinian civilians there, some 50 Israeli hostages are still being held after being kidnapped during the brutal Hamas -led attacks of October 7, 2023.
The idea that the military responsible for tens of thousands of civilian deaths can be trusted to guard any kind of humanitarian operation is unworkable
Sadly, however, more speculative contributions are coming to light; experts have been alarmed by reports that an American official, quoted anonymously in US news outlet The Hill, said that the Middle East's borders are 'illusory', dismissing the sovereignty of a number of nation states.
It is time to come back to political reality. The overwhelming majority of the international community agree on the need to end the war in Gaza, to get humanitarian aid to its suffering inhabitants, to stop the creeping Israeli annexation of the West Bank and to move from merely 'managing' the Palestinian-Israeli conflict to bringing it to a negotiated end. The possibility of peace in the region – that includes all the countries of the Middle East – cannot be met without a path to Palestinian statehood, with peace and security for Palestinians and Israelis.
Reconvening the high-level UN conference on the two-state solution that was postponed by the Iran-Israel war would be a good place to start. No-one should object to good-faith proposals or fresh thinking about how to resolve this conflict's many related aspects, such as reaching a ceasefire, releasing Palestinians held in Israeli detention, rebuilding Gaza and encouraging consensus among Palestinian factions so they can eventually deliver good governance for their people. But proposals such as an Israeli-run 'humanitarian city' amid the ashes of Gaza do not offer real solutions nor serve regional peace.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
27 minutes ago
- Zawya
Egypt: Madbouly follows up on financial allocations for petroleum supply to power stations
Arab Finance: Prime Minister Mostafa Madbouly followed up on the procedures for securing the financial allocations required for the petroleum products needed to operate power plants, according to a statement. This came during his meeting with Minister of Finance Ahmed Kouchouk, Minister of Electricity and Renewable Energy Mahmoud Esmat, and Minister of Petroleum and Mineral Resources Karim Badawi. Madbouly discussed joint efforts to repay government agencies' debts to electricity companies. He stressed the government's need to secure sufficient funding to meet the demands for petroleum products, thereby ensuring the continuity of electricity services across various sectors amidst global challenges and their regional repercussions. On his part, the Cabinet's spokesperson Mohamed Elhomosany said the meeting discussed efforts to allocate funding to secure the necessary fuel to secure the electricity supply and ensure the stability of the national grid to meet demand. They also reviewed the status of debt repayments owed to the Ministry of Electricity's companies for electricity consumption by several ministries and government agencies. They discussed the mechanisms for repaying these debts and possible settlements in this regard. This would contribute to resolving these financial entanglements, with the aim of improving the level of services provided across key sectors and enhancing their financial capabilities to achieve further operational goals with greater efficiency and capacity. Meanwhile, Kouchouk confirmed that the required funding would be provided, under agreements reached with the relevant ministries. The finance minister added that the ministry is working to increase investments in the energy sector, aligned with the state's vision to support the competitiveness of the Egyptian economy. He also affirmed that there is full coordination with the electricity and petroleum ministries to ensure the sustainability of energy sources for all sectors and individuals. © 2020-2023 Arab Finance For Information Technology. All Rights Reserved. Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Crew rescued from Red Sea ship attacked by Houthis arrive in Saudi Arabia
Ten crew members rescued after Yemen's Houthi rebels sank a Greek-owned ship last week have arrived in Saudi Arabia, Reuters quoted maritime security sources as saying. Private security companies said earlier that the search for the remaining crew had been called off, with at least four people presumed dead and 11 unaccounted for. The announcement came as satellite imagery revealed long, trailing oil slicks at the sites where the bulk carrier Eternity C sank and where the Magic Seas was also struck by the Iran-backed Houthis, AP reported. Both ships were attacked by the rebels more than a week ago. The group has escalated assaults on maritime traffic in response to Israel's war on Gaza. The Houthi campaign has severely disrupted shipping in the Red Sea, a global trade route through which about $1 trillion in goods passes each year. Private security firms Ambrey and Diaplous Group led the search for the missing Eternity C crew. The vessel was carrying a three-man security team but did not ask for an escort from the US navy or the EU naval mission in the region. The vessel was attacked on July 7 and endured hours of Houthi assaults involving small arms fire and bomb-laden drones before sinking. The attack came a day after the Magic Seas was struck. Both ships were Greek-owned, Liberian-flagged bulk carriers. Ten crew members were rescued from the Eternity C – eight Filipinos, one Greek citizen and one Indian security guard – the EU's Operation Aspides said. The Houthis claimed they took some of the crew hostage, but have provided no evidence. The US embassy in Yemen said it believed the rebels kidnapped some of the crew. 'The decision to end the search has been taken by the vessel's Owner reluctantly but it believes that, in all the circumstances, the priority must now be to get the 10 souls safely recovered alive ashore and to provide them with the urgent medical support they need at this difficult time,' the security companies said in a statement. 'The thoughts of all those involved in the rescue operation are with the families of those who remain missing.' The Houthis also claimed responsibility for the assault on the Magic Seas. All crew from the vessel were rescued before it sank.
Zawya
2 hours ago
- Zawya
Asphalt coating for unpaved roads in Bahrain proposed
Bahrain - A new proposal to provide temporary or full asphalt coating for unpaved roads has been unanimously approved by the Muharraq Municipal Council. The urgent proposal was spearheaded by councillor Dalal Al Meghawi, who believes it would provide a much-needed relief to residents of newly urbanised neighbourhoods that have yet to receive essential infrastructure. She said home owners in several areas have been reporting hardships commuting to and from their homes, especially during adverse weather conditions. Ms Al Meghawi 'Their daily commutes often involve navigating uneven, dusty or muddy terrain, leading to higher vehicle maintenance costs,' Ms Al Meghawi said. 'This is a matter of basic quality of life. 'Families shouldn't have to risk damage to their vehicles or deal with unbearable road conditions just because they live in new or underdeveloped areas. 'Paving – even temporarily – can make a world of difference.' Ms Al Meghawi added that the initiative was not only about easing daily transport but also preventing unnecessary financial burdens on citizens. 'Residents are spending hundreds of dinars a year on vehicle repairs caused by potholes, gravel and dust,' she claimed. 'These are avoidable expenses if the government steps in to provide even interim road surfacing solutions.' She further noted that this issue affected a cross-section of Bahraini families, including those who were recently allotted housing in government projects. 'We've made a commitment to decent housing, but without roads, these homes are incomplete,' she said. The proposal is now being reviewed by Bahrain's other municipal bodies – the Southern and Northern Municipal Councils and the Capital Trustees Board. Support from these authorities would allow for the formulation of a co-ordinated national approach to the issue. According to Muharraq Municipal Council chairman Saleh Tarradah, the lack of roads in many of Bahrain's newly developed housing zones has generated widespread discontent. 'We continue to receive complaints from residents who are living in areas that were handed over for housing but lack even the most basic road infrastructure,' he said. Mr Tarradah 'This is not acceptable in a modern, urban environment. We're not even talking about luxury here – we're talking about accessibility, safety and dignity. 'We hope other councils will support the proposal and that the relevant ministries will treat it as a national priority.' Mr Tarradah said co-ordination with the Works, Housing and Urban Planning, and Municipalities Affairs and Agriculture Ministries would be key to securing funding for the project. 'The problem is clear, the solution is straightforward, and now we have momentum. Let's not wait until another rainy season turns our neighbourhoods into mud traps,' said Mr Tarradah. 'The proposal's forward momentum now rests on the endorsement of the other municipal bodies and the responsiveness of the executive agencies. 'If adopted nationally, it could bring long-awaited relief to thousands of families across Bahrain's developing districts.'
