40-year legal battle over Jalandhar green belts ends in defeat for industrialists
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed a 40-year-old appeal by a group of industrialists challenging the State of Punjab's decision to revise the layout plan of the Jalandhar Industrial Area. The ruling, delivered by Justice Deepak Gupta, upholds the state's authority to alter the original 1951 plan—which included a 120-foot-wide road and green belts—despite objections from plaintiffs who claimed the changes infringed on their rights and harmed the environment.
The dispute goes back to 1980, when Joginder Singh and other industrialists filed a lawsuit seeking a permanent injunction to prevent the state from diverting the road and green belts for other uses, such as allotting land to a school, a rubber factory, and government departments like the police and post office. They argued they had used these areas—flanked by 80- to 85-foot green belts—for over 20 years, asserting easementary rights, and contended that the state's 1979 revision, which reduced the road width to 80 feet and eliminated the green belts, violated their interests and public health.
The industrialists claimed the original plan, prepared by the state's Industries Department, promised these amenities, and said they had built factories and homes with doors and windows facing the green belts. They further alleged the revision lacked proper government approval and public notice, calling it arbitrary and a breach of constitutional rights under Articles 14, 21, and 51(A)(g), which ensure equality, life, and environmental protection.
However, the state and other defendants—including Devi Sahai Sanatan Dharam Girls High School and Hind Rubber Factory—defended the revision as a necessary policy decision to meet evolving needs, such as accommodating essential services. They argued the plaintiffs had no legal right to the green belts, as their sale deeds contained no such promises, and said the suit—filed without challenging the revised plan—was legally flawed.
Justice Gupta's 23-page judgment, pronounced on Tuesday, rejected the plaintiffs' claims. He emphasized that no enforceable right had been established, noting: 'A perusal of the Conveyance Deed dated 08.11.1955 (Ex. DW5/1) executed by the Director of Industries, Punjab, reveals no covenant granting or assuring the plaintiff any right over the greenbelt or the 120-foot-wide road.' He further ruled the suit for injunction was not maintainable without a declaration challenging the 1979 revision, stating: 'It is a settled proposition that no relief can be granted beyond the pleadings and prayer clause.'
The court also dismissed the claim of easementary rights, observing that under the Indian Easements Act, 1882, 30 years of uninterrupted use of government land is required—not the 20 years claimed by the plaintiffs. Justice Gupta underscored the state's policy discretion, saying: 'Amendment of layout plans in larger public interest, to accommodate essential services like Police Stations, District Industries Centres, and Post Offices, constitutes a policy decision,' and found no evidence of arbitrariness.
The judge also pointed to the plaintiffs' unauthorised use of the green belts—opening doors and windows without approval—as a reason to deny equitable relief, remarking: 'Equitable relief is not available to parties who approach the Court with unclean hands.' He cited the 54-year delay and third-party rights accrued over time, concluding: 'Belated challenges are impermissible, particularly when third-party rights have accrued.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Delhi Court Acquits Former Secretary HC Gupta In Coal Scam Case
New Delhi: A Delhi court on Friday acquitted former coal secretary HC Gupta, ex-joint secretary (coal) KS Kropha and then director KC Samaria in a coal scam case related to irregularities in the allocation of Mahugarhi Coal Block in Jharkhand. Today marks Gupta's second acquittal in coal block related cases whereas he has been convicted in five other cases and his appeals are currently pending in Delhi High Court. The CBI has also challenged his acquittal in the first case. There were total 19 cases filed by the CBI against Gupta, of which 12 are pending before trial courts. Special Judge Sanjay Bansal while pronouncing the verdict on Friday convicted JAS Infrastructure Capital Ltd and its then director Manoj Kumar Jayaswal for cheating and criminal conspiracy in securing coal block's allocation. The judge would hear arguments on sentencing on July 8. A total of 29 corruption cases filed by the CBI are currently pending before two special courts set up to try cases arising out of coal scam whereas 27 cases have been disposed of so far. On January 16, the Enforcement Directorate informed the top court that 45 complaints (ED's equivalent to a chargesheet), including supplementary ones, were pending under the PMLA. The top court in 2014 quashed 214 coal blocks allocated by the Centre between 1993 and 2010 after taking note of two PILs and had ordered a trial by a special CBI Judge. It later increased the number of the courts to two to try the scam-related cases. The CBI was represented by special public prosecutor R S Cheema, additional legal advisor Sanjay Kumar and public prosecutors A P Singh and N P Srivastava in the case. The CBI lodged the case on the reference of Central Vigilance Commission against officials of Ministry of Coal for alleged corruption in the matter of allocation of coal blocks to the private companies during period 2006-09. It was alleged in the FIR that JAS Infrastructure Capital Pvt Ltd and its Director Jayaswal had misrepresented/concealed facts in the application form in order to qualify and obtain wrongful gains/undue benefits in allocation of Mahuagarhi coal block. The CBI spokesperson in a statement on Friday said, "This is the 19th conviction in coal block allocation cases investigated by CBI. Initially, the CBI had filed final report (closure) in the case on November 20, 2014." The special court had previously taken cognisance and framed charges against JAS Infrastructure Capital Pvt Ltd, Manoj Kumar Jayaswal, H C Gupta, K S Kropha and K C Samaria. "The allegations in the case were that the accused private persons, namely the promoters of JAS Infrastructure Capital Pvt. Ltd, had made false and misleading claims regarding the financial net worth of the company," the CBI said. They further misrepresented the appraisal and syndication of debt by financial institutions, with a view to securing the wrongful allocation of a coal block, the CBI spokesperson said. The company, it was alleged, "deliberately concealed" material facts concerning the previous allocation of coal blocks to other group or associate companies in the application and feedback forms. "The company had also dishonestly projected the net worth of unrelated third-party companies- Inertia Iron & Steel Industries Pvt. Ltd. and IL&FS- as its own, both in its application and during the presentation made before the Screening Committee for the allocation of Mahugarhi Coal Block," the statement said. The CBI examined 18 prosecution witnesses in support of its case.
Hindustan Times
4 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
75 Delhi govt schools to get PM Shri tag, smart upgrades
The Delhi government will relaunch 75 of its schools as CM-Shri schools with state-of-the-art infrastructure and experiential learning models, chief minister Rekha Gupta said on Friday. The initiative aims to transform the quality of education in government schools by blending modern technology with improved facilities. The CM, addressing a meeting with school principals and education department officials in Shalimar Bagh, said the revamped schools will feature thousands of smart classrooms, 100 language labs, and 125 digital libraries by the end of the year. The city government currently runs 1,060 schools, and the 75 CM-Shri campuses will be chosen from among these, based on their readiness for infrastructure and technological upgrades. 'Every child in Delhi deserves quality education. Our aim isn't merely to build schools, but to create an education system that plays a vital role in nation-building. These 75 CM-Shri Schools are a step towards delivering learning that surpasses even private institutions,' Gupta said. The criteria for selecting the 75 schools are still being finalised, but will likely hinge on the existing infrastructure, an official said. The CM also directed that basic amenities like clean toilets, drinking water, proper lighting, and comfortable seating be upgraded across its 1,060 schools on a need basis. She instructed the PWD's horticulture wing to green campuses with landscaping initiatives. Each CM-Shri school will also be equipped with smart boards, science and computer labs, and other digital tools. Emphasising the importance of teacher quality, Gupta announced regular training programmes and exposure to modern teaching methods. The CM further directed officials to provide targeted support for meritorious, underperforming, and differently abled students, ensuring inclusive education. She also announced laptops for 1,200 students who excelled in Class 10 and 12 board exams, and said the government is actively seeking CSR partnerships to bolster the initiative. Meanwhile, the Directorate of Education (DoE) has opened applications for transfers to CM-Shri schools for the 2025-26 session. Post Graduate Teachers (PGTs), Trained Graduate Teachers (TGTs), Primary Teachers (PRTs), and other staff with at least five years remaining before retirement can apply by June 9 via email. Interviews will be held on June 11 (TGTs) and June 12 (PGTs and others). An official said the National Education Policy (NEP) will be implemented across CM-Shri schools, alongside the integration of AI tools and language labs. Gupta, meanwhile, took aim at the former Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government, calling its education model 'artificial.' 'Despite the heavy propaganda, the ground reality was dismal. Even their most celebrated school buildings were poorly built — one constructed in 2018 deteriorated within two years. This exposes their so-called model as nothing more than a facade,' she said, adding that legal action would be initiated for irregularities in classroom construction flagged in the CAG report.
Hindustan Times
5 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Delhi Assembly's 1st 100 days: Paperless push, Savarkar portrait, solar project
From unveiling the portrait of Hindutva ideologue Vinayak Damodar Savarkar to launching a solar energy project and moving towards a paperless legislature, the eighth Delhi Assembly marked its first 100 days with a flurry of symbolic and infrastructure initiatives, according to a 100-day report card released on Friday. Speaker Vijender Gupta, along with Union minister Harsh Malhotra, released the report card and the 32-page document, covering the period from February 24 to June 4, outlines legislative developments, green energy projects, and efforts to modernize the Assembly's infrastructure. 'This report is not just a summary of legislative work — it reflects an evolving, citizen-centric approach to governance,' Gupta said at the event. 'We've achieved key milestones, including the roll-out of the National e-Vidhan Application (NeVA) for a paperless legislature, and the laying of the foundation stone for a 500kW solar power plant, underscoring the assembly's dedication to clean energy and green governance.' 'We have also started the modernisation of the assembly library into a cutting-edge digital knowledge hub and the introduction of a comprehensive heritage conservation plan aimed at preserving the Assembly's architectural and historical legacy…collectively, these efforts, symbolise the assembly's holistic approach to progress, inclusivity, and participatory legislation,' Gupta said. The eighth Delhi assembly was constituted on February 24 following the elections in which the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) secured 48 out of 70 seats, while the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) won 22. Speaker Vijender Gupta said several people-centric initiatives had been launched in the first 100 days, including the introduction of a 'Best MLA Award' to recognise legislative performance, orientation programmes for newly elected members, and cultural events marking occasions such as the Hindu New Year and Mahavir Jayanti. Among the key infrastructure efforts is the solarisation of the Assembly building. The foundation stone for a 500 kW solar power plant was laid in the second week of May, with the aim of bringing the Assembly's estimated ₹2 crore annual electricity bill down to zero. The project, expected to be completed by the end of July, will see 3,250 square metres of rooftop space — including the Speaker's Chamber, parts of the Assembly Hall, and the gallery roofs — covered with solar panels to generate sufficient power for the entire complex.
