Review of The City and Its Uncertain Walls
Haruki Murakami's The City And Its Uncertain Walls is at one level a gentle love story whilst also holding deep philosophic undertones. The Buddhist idea of the shadow representing repressed emotions, negative aspects of the self and the illusory nature of experiences runs through the narrative. The wall symbolises something which is there and yet not there. It is perhaps this complexity which made the author rework the story over a period of more than 40 years.
The book is divided into three parts. The first part intersperses the narration between the past and an ambiguous present. The second part deals with strange and surreal encounters in a real world. The third part seems to suggest that the real and unreal are only in the mind. It is faith and belief which sustain both.
When the reclusive, nameless protagonist, a 16-year-old boy, meets an equally introverted 15-year-old girl, both find they can converse freely with each other. They talk endlessly about her dreams, write long letters, and at 17, the boy is hopelessly in love. The girl confesses that she is not real but a stand-in, a wandering shadow. Her real self lives in a city with high walls.
She describes this mysterious place at great length and tells him that the only way to get there is by wishing for it from the heart. She works there in a library and if he ever comes there, he could get a position where she would always be by his side but she would not remember him or them. Some months later, she vanishes, leaving him devastated and not able to have a meaningful relationship with any other woman.
Of memory and consciousness
When he is 45, he suddenly finds himself at the gates of the strange city. Leaving his shadow behind, he enters and becomes the dream reader. The girl, still a teenager, is his assistant but does not remember him. The quintessential Murakami element emerges when the shadow starts putting emotional pressure on him to leave the town. Assuming a psychic consciousness, it convinces him that the wall is nothing but fear, the city an imagination and the whole thing an illusion.
Back in the real world, reunited with the shadow, a dream leads him to a small mountain town, unknown yet familiar. The patron of a library mentors him and takes him through strange experiences making him wonder if memory and consciousness can exist without a body. This section is the longest and tends to get dense.
The third part takes us to a socially dysfunctional teenager who is nameless and has an eidetic memory. His power to concentrate and absorb go beyond the normal.
Overhearing the protagonist's description of the walled city, he wishes to go there perhaps because no social skills are necessary there. This character is similar to the boy in Murakami's The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle, but is more a philosophical concept than a social misfit. He symbolises the incompleteness felt at times by everybody.
Dose of magical realism
The protagonist is dragged back to the city as he feels a strong sense of responsibility for the boy. Their merging together makes both of them complete. The relationship makes both of them realise and come to terms with their incompleteness. The boy who is perhaps autistic develops empathy while the protagonist becomes capable of unconditional compassion. Their separation marks a kind of realisation and liberation for both.
Unlike other Murakami narratives, the dreams here are not used to bring out repression in the form of erotica. The women the protagonist feels an affinity for are all nameless and the physical aspect is completely taken out of the relationship. Love is pure and unadulterated.
In this exercise in magical realism, it is only the literary skill of a Murakami that can hold the attention of the reader through a complex narrative, sometimes beyond the realm of not one but more than one reality. The abstract nature of the book does not in any way take away from the gentle and poignant handling of relationships. The book is a fascinating read.
The reviewer has been a psephologist and a publisher who now focuses on her writing.
The City and Its Uncertain Walls Haruki Murakami, trs Philip Gabriel Harvill Secker ₹1,399
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
11 hours ago
- Mint
Kamal Haasan's ‘Thug Life': Brutal money lessons hidden in the blood and betrayal
Let's face facts. Mani Ratnam's vision on film is stunning. Sreekar Prasad's editing is seamless and incomparable. And Kamal Haasan might be happy to incite controversy with the film, but he's still got those acting chops. Alas, AR Rahman is the only one who does not seem to fit - the background music is so odd it is annoying at times, and the songs are forgettable (despite Sanya Malhotra's pointless song appearance). The film opens where Rangaraya Sakthivel is telling us how he has survived many encounters with death. The black and white telling of his backstory and a young Kamal Haasan is unmissable. Here is where betrayal begins. Here is also where Sakthivel saves a little kid, who in turn saves the gangster. The boy Amar grows up to be Sakthivel's shadow and is given the responsibility of managing the business when Sakthivel goes to jail. This annoys his older brother Mannikkam (the brilliant Nasser) but not for long. Amar and Manikkam join hands with the Sakthivel's rival Sadanand who wants to look like he's cleaned up because he's going into politics. Too convoluted? Stay with me! Sakthivel comes out of jail and goes straight to Indrani (Trisha Krishnan, still gorgeous), his mistress. His wife Jeeva (Abhirami, wow!) is understandably upset but Sakthivel has a way with the ladies… Alas, when he tries to get to Kailas to fulfill a vow Jeeva has made, Amar and Manikkam take this opportunity to shoot him and push him off a cliff. Of course he is saved by Buddhist monks who teach him martial arts skills. But by the time Sakthivel comes back home, those who have betrayed him are thriving and those who loved him (Jeeva and Indrani) have lost the plot (don't ask!). After Sakthivel takes his revenge on each of the five who betrayed him, plus a whole bunch of goons who are there only to lose limbs and die violently, we see him still alive… What money lessons can this 165 minute long telling of a gangster's never say die attitude teach you, intrepid investors? Rival Sadanand (Mahesh Manjrekar who simply zombie-walks through this role) tries to kill Sakthivel, he fails. Sadanand's nephew (Ali Fazal, totally wasted in this role) sends a couple of SUVs to kill Sakthivel, but they fail. Saktivel's brother Manikkam, his son Amar, His associates (the one and only Joju George), shoot him and push him off a snowy cliff, he survives. You marvel at Ravi K. Chandran's awesome cinematography, but begin to see Warren Buffett's investment tips. Warren Buffett's ability to survive in the market is legendary, as are the men who made this movie. Kamal Haasan's soliloquy about he's like the yakuza doesn't wash with the audience, because we have watched international shows about gang wars, and nothing that comes before or after in the movie refer to anything Japanese… Educate yourself about everything into which your hard earned money is going. Even if investing in a company that manufactures diamonds seems shiny, if you know nothing about how that business works, you should turn to what you understand. Through thick and thin, Sakthivel remembers the promise he made to his adopted son - that he will find his missing sister. But by the time we see this promise being fulfilled, and the lovely Aishwarya Lakshmi displays her acting chops, we have been exhausted by the interminable story. But you must take inspiration from Warren Buffett whose investing philosophy of 'long term view' has increased his wealth from a hundred million dollars to over 166 billion! Sakthivel hands over the reins of his business to his adopted son instead of his older brother Manikkam. His reasoning is logical, 'You've just lost a daughter and are mourning. Amar is capable of handling the day to day operations because I will still wield power even from jail.' If your money manager knows what you want, is able to invest in stocks you understand thoroughly, then your chances at being successful are a given. Your goals should be your manager's goals, and only then will you be happy and rich. Sakthivel knows this principle. Just because his rival Sadanand is getting into politics which promises lots of money, he tells Amar to stay away from it all. We should not join hands with Sadanand even if he promises you 'his territories' which will bring us more money, We need to expand business in ways we understand. In your investment life too, don't go chasing after stocks everyone is buying simply because they look like the current 'in thing' in which to invest. Hold on to your blue chip stocks that have been giving you credible returns. Nobody is saying shiny objects always turn out to be junk, but if you follow the crowd, your returns may not be as many as you might expect or perhaps not be what they promised in the shiny, expensive brochure… This film could have been epic, but it seems like a long-winded tale told by grandpas who tend to lose the thread and veer off into 'season two' vibes. Although some elderly men can inspire us like Warren Buffett does, Mani Ratnam and Kamal Haasan who wrote this story think like old men who haven't learned that a young girl who has become pregnant inadvertently does not have to kill herself because she has no options left in the world. Such a missed opportunity to have a vengeful woman included in this gangster saga! Manisha Lakhe is a poet, film critic, traveller, founder of Caferati — an online writer's forum, hosts Mumbai's oldest open mic, and teaches advertising, films and communication. She can be reached on Twitter at @manishalakhe.
The Hindu
2 days ago
- The Hindu
Dhruvi Acharya's landmark solo exhibition at Hampi Art Labs
The Journey is Home, a significant solo exhibition by acclaimed contemporary artist Dhruvi Acharya, which began on June 1, at Hampi Art Labs in Toranagallu, Ballari district, will be on display till September 30th, 2025. The JSW Foundation, the social development arm of the $24 billion JSW Group and host of the exhibition, stated that The Journey is Home, curated by noted art critic Girish Shahane, features an expansive collection of Dhruvi Acharya's works, ranging from her early creations to more recent pieces. It delves into a deeply personal exploration of identity, motherhood, environmental awareness, grief, and the complexities of urban life. Dhruvi Acharya's art, rooted in autobiography, often connects with larger, universal subjects. The exhibition's title is inspired by a poem by the Japanese author and Zen practitioner Matsuo Basho, reflecting Dhruvi Acharya's early interest in Buddhist philosophy. Her work is known to explore the psychological and emotional musings of a woman. The exhibition also features key works from the JSW collection. Sangita Jindal, chairperson of the JSW Foundation, expressed her enthusiasm for the show. 'I see hope and resilience in Dhruvi Acharya's layered works, which often reflect the psychological and emotional musings of a woman. I am delighted that Hampi Art Labs is hosting a solo show by Dhruvi, an artist I have long admired.' Describing the exhibition as a mid-career survey, Dhruvi Acharya said, 'The show includes work from various stages of my journey, including those commissioned or acquired by Sangita Jindal over the last 25 years. These pieces reflect my investigations into memory, love, loss, motherhood, the status of women in society, and the deteriorating environment. I am grateful to Hampi Art Labs and JSW Foundation for providing a space where these stories can breathe and resonate.' Located near the UNESCO World Heritage Site of Hampi, Hampi Art Labs spans nine acres and serves as a cultural retreat offering studio spaces, galleries, artist residencies, and educational programmes. Rooted in the region's rich artistic and architectural heritage, the centre is a vital cultural initiative of the JSW Foundation. The Journey is Home is open to the public from 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., from Monday to Friday, offering visitors a unique opportunity to engage with one of India's most thoughtful and introspective contemporary artists in an inspiring setting.
India.com
5 days ago
- India.com
From ‘Norwegian Wood' to ‘Men Without Women': 7 Best Works Of Haruki Murakami Everyone Must Read Once
photoDetails english 2909478 Haruki Murakami's literary world is a mesmerizing blend of the surreal and the deeply human, where everyday lives intersect with mystery, memory, and metaphysical questions. He was born in 1949 and his works have been translates into more than 50 languages and his most popular works are Norwegian Wood, The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle, Kafka on the Shore and more. Scroll down to read more about his works. Updated:Jun 01, 2025, 03:33 PM IST Who is Haruki Murakami? 1 / 8 Haruki Murakami is a Japanese writer born in 1949 is one of the most celebrated literary voices of times. His works have been translated into more than 50 languages. His characters often feel alienated from society, drifting through love, loss, and parallel realities. With his global fan base and numerous literary awards, Murakami continues to captivate readers with stories that are as strange as they are emotionally resonant. Norwegian Wood 2 / 8 Published in 1987, this is one of the most popular books, this heartbreaking novel explores the themes of love and grief, the book is set in the 1960s in Tokyo. It remains one of his most accessible and emotionally raw novels, showcasing his ability to explore human fragility without leaning on the surreal. Kafka on the Shore 3 / 8 This amazing read was published in 2002, 'Kafka on the Shore' is a perfect blend of fantasy, metaphysics, and philosophy. The book is full of riddles, double meanings, and classical references, this novel invites interpretation and rereading, and is often named among his most inventive and iconic works. 1Q84 4 / 8 The book was first published in three volumes 2009-10, this book explores the themes of love, destiny, and alternate realities are explored in depth. The book follows the story of an assassin and a math teacher as they become entangled in a mysterious parallel world. Men Without Women 5 / 8 This is a collection of short stories which was published in 2014 and each story explores the emotional solitude of men who have lost or been left by women, touching on loneliness, heartbreak, and the quiet ache of everyday life. Dance Dance Dance 6 / 8 This is Murakami's sixth novel and was first published in 1988, this book centres around the life of an unnamed narrator who is drifting through a Tokyo filled with lost connections, odd jobs, and supernatural encounters. After Dark 7 / 8 This amazing novel was published in 2004 and it explores the themes of alienation in the urban world. It revolves around the stories of insomniacs, runaways, and a girl who sleeps in suspended animation, the novel feels like a dream you wake from feeling haunted. The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle 8 / 8 The novel was first published in 1994-95, it is one of Murakami's most powerful novels. The book follows an unassuming man whose search for his missing wife leads him into a surreal underworld of war stories, psychic experiences, and deep personal reckonings.
