EXCLUSIVE: £2m St Andrews University donor disputes principal's funding claim
The Wolfson Foundation – which ultimately awarded the green technology grant – says the funding was never at risk, contradicting what Dame Sally Mapstone told an independent investigation.
Dame Mapstone told Morag Ross KC, now known as Lady Ross, that the seven-figure donation was in 'serious jeopardy' due to remarks made by rector Stella Maris.
The independent report following the row said the charity was 'very concerned about information relating to the university and the statement made by Ms Maris'.
It states that Dame Mapstone and other university chiefs had to 'work very hard to repair damage done' to the university's relationship with The Wolfson Foundation.
But the charity – which has close links to Israel – strongly disputed this version of events when approached by The Courier.
A spokesperson said: 'Funding was not in jeopardy because of comments made by the university's rector.
'The Wolfson Foundation's grant was made following a rigorous peer review process.
'Our funding is a matter of public record, as are the conditions of all the funding that we award.'
The charity's name was redacted when the top judge's independent investigation was published by the university on July 29, 2024.
A university press release on January 31, 2024 announced the Wolfson Foundation's £2m donation to help develop green hydrogen technologies.
The charity was established in 1958 by Sir Isaac Wolfson, a Scottish businessman and philanthropist.
The Wolfson Foundation, while best known for supporting science, education, and the arts across the UK, has historic ties to the Jewish community and also backs projects in Israel through related family trusts.
It gave £2m to St Andrews University's medical school in 2008 to open a new biophotonics laboratory.
The report by Lady Ross found Ms Maris was 'in breach of her obligations' as a member of the university court and charity trustee.
It said she exercised 'poor judgement' and her social media posts on the conflict in Gaza were 'ill-judged'.
Ms Maris was stripped of her senior powers and removed from the university court after the report was made public.
Earlier this month, Ms Maris won her appeal against the decision, allowing her to rejoin the university court.
The rector previously told The Courier she had been subjected to a 'smear campaign'.
St Andrews University declined to comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
26 minutes ago
- ITV News
Sturgeon's memoirs: The book that has got everyone in Scottish politics talking
A little more than a decade ago, I watched Nicola Sturgeon headline a venue usually reserved for rock bands. Working for The Courier newspaper at the time, I saw the then soon-to-be first minister provoke rapturous applause from a sold out Caird Hall in Dundee. Like a gig, there was merchandise. T-shirts made to look like vintage Scotland football tops with ' Sturgeon 15' on the back. Yet this was all just part of the warm up for her being the star attraction for a sold-out show in Glasgow's vast Hydro arena. She seemed untouchable. Even many of her opponents admired her. So why is she now one of the most divisive politicians in the country? The answer to that is in part answered by the content – and the reaction to it – that has been serialised in her upcoming memoirs. The book is called Frankly. Given the top-down, secretive approach Sturgeon's critics say she took to government, that alone has drawn some mirth amongst Holyrood mischief makers. Remember the furore about her deleting all of her WhatsApp messages from during the pandemic? In 2019, I revealed in The Times, to much consternation from her allies, that Sturgeon had been using an SNP email address for government business. At the time concerns were raised that officials might have been using private emails and social media accounts to avoid scrutiny and circumvent freedom of information requests. Official documents had to be dragged from the Scottish government like blood from a stone when a Holyrood committee was investigating the unlawful handling of sexual misconduct allegations against her predecessor Alex Salmond. Salmond, who died last year, was cleared in court of any criminal activity and claimed there was a conspiracy orchestrated against him by Sturgeon and people close to her. In extracts of the book released in the Sunday Times, Sturgeon calls this 'a fabrication, the invention of a man who wasn't prepared to reflect honestly on his own conduct'. She also floated the theory that Salmond himself leaked the allegations to the Daily Record so he could play the victim card. Unsurprisingly, this latest twist in the falling out of two of the UK's biggest politicians of the last 20 years has both reignited Scottish politics' very own Greek tragedy onto the front page of the papers and enraged Salmond's allies. It also appears to be, charitably, a stretch. As a declaration of interest, I wrote a book about the Salmond/Sturgeon fallout with David Clegg, who broke that story in the Daily Record. His account of how he received the document outlining the complaint against Salmond – it was delivered anonymously to the newspaper's office – is set out in Break-Up and on quite a few occasions we have speculated between ourselves about who might have sent it. We have our suspicions but the truth is that only the sender and anyone they told will know for sure who was behind the leak. It sums up a lot of the criticism of Sturgeon, particularly in recent years: great at garnering headlines, especially when it involves undermining an opponent, not very much of substance beyond that. Nicola Sturgeon: My arrest was 'horrific' and part of me 'closed down' Nicola Sturgeon opens up about sexuality and 'mental torture' of arrest in book Her allies would of course dispute that assessment. They would correctly be able to point to a series of election wins that surpass her peers; they would highlight policies like the Scottish child payment, which is widely seen as helping the poorest kids in society; they would say that just having a strong, impressive female leader with some of the best communications skills in politics is important to show women they can break the glass-ceiling. This may be true but plenty of promises lay broken. The attainment gap between the richest and poorest pupils has barely budged despite Sturgeon's promises; NHS waiting lists including those in the Borders and Dumfries and Galloway continue to be too long by ministers own admission; for independence supporters there has been no move on the constitutional question; rural Scotland has felt like an afterthought to an Edinburgh-based government that has often felt increasingly central belt focused; and a new culture war has opened over people's gender. In her interview with ITV, Sturgeon admitted to some blame for the latter but still floundered when asked about Isla Bryson, the rapist who self-identified as female and was transferred to a women's prison. It is possible that the most revealing piece of information to have emerged from all the book extracts and interviews so far is Sturgeon saying he has "always loved London' as she teased the potential for a move to the city that has often been shorthand for everything the SNP sees wrong with the United Kingdom. Perhaps Frankly will prove to be insightful and revealing. Right now it looks like one final defence of the years that followed Nicola Sturgeon's glory days. Years that Scotland has largely moved on from.
Glasgow Times
26 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
George Galloway to stand for Holyrood 2026 election
The former Labour MP, who now leads the Workers Party, told The Herald his party will contest Glasgow's Southside following Nicola Sturgeon's announcement that she is stepping down in May. Yvonne Ridley, a former member of Alex Salmond's Alba Party and journalist, will also contest the Glasgow Pollok seat for Galloway's party following former first minister Humza Yousaf's plans to step down next year. Galloway said he will top the Workers Party list for next year's Holyrood election and that his party are going to 'put everything' into winning Glasgow's Southside. 'We're going all out for it and we've got a lot of support,' he said. Asked if he was confident of winning, Galloway said: 'I wouldn't say confident.' He added: 'We're hopeful that we can win in it. We're going to put everything into trying to do so.' Galloway said momentum for the Workers Party was growing in Glasgow and that he has had people ask if they can stand in seats in Inverness and Edinburgh. 'But these seats in Glasgow are our current and number one target,' he said, adding: 'We're strong there.' (Image: PA) According to The Herald, his Holyrood campaign will strongly focus on the crisis in Gaza, and the end to Israel's genocidal campaign. The veteran politician has also said he would back a second referendum on Scottish independence. In June, Galloway came out in support of a Scottish independence referendum despite having been opposed to Scotland having the right to self-determination for his entire political life. In 2021, he pledged to 'tackle the scourge of separatism' when All for Unity launched their Scottish Parliament election manifesto. But in June, Galloway made the surprise announcement that he had changed his view as he said in a social media post: 'We support the right of the Scots to self-determination. Eleven years after they last did so, we believe the time for another referendum is close. 'Given the collapsing authority of the British state the pitiful prime minister Starmer the moral decline of British society the result cannot easily be predicted. Britain has become a cesspit.' Galloway founded the Workers Party of Britain in 2019 and has served as an MP across five different constituencies, including Glasgow Hillhead between 1987 and 1997 and Glasgow Kelvin from 1997 to 2005.
The National
37 minutes ago
- The National
Call for probe into radioactive leak in Scottish loch and ‘cover-up'
The Scottish Greens have said it was a 'stark failure on the part of the UK Government', adding that it could have 'serious consequences'. A joint investigation from The Guardian and The Ferret – also reported by the BBC – found that the material was released into Loch Long in Argyll and Bute. It comes after a six-year battle to access documents which involved Scotland's information commissioner. READ MORE: Three new cancer drugs approved for use for NHS Scotland The investigation revealed that files compiled by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Sepa) – the environment watchdog – stated the Royal Navy failed to properly maintain a network of 1500 pipes at the Coulport armaments depot. Coulport holds the Royal Navy's supply of nuclear warheads for its fleet of Trident submarines, which are based at HMNB Clyde at Faslane, near Helensburgh. Sepa said the issues at Coulport, which date back to a pipe burst in 2010, were caused by "shortfalls in maintenance". One incident listed in the files, which took place in August 2019, resulted in the release of "unnecessary radioactive waste" in the form of low levels of tritium, which is used in nuclear warheads. The environment watchdog insisted that its assessments found the risk to the environment from effluent discharges was "of no regulatory concern". Meanwhile, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) said there had been "no unsafe releases of radioactive material" into the environment. The files were released after a ruling by Scottish information commissioner David Hamilton, who oversees the country's freedom of information laws. According to The Guardian and The Ferret, the UK Government allegedly insisted the files had to be kept secret for national security reasons. However, in June Hamilton ruled that most of the files had to be released as their disclosure did not threaten national security but "reputations". Now, the Scottish Greens have called for an investigation to be launched. (Image: PA) "It is scandalous, but given the long list of previous incidents at Faslane and Coulport, its sadly no surprise,' MSP for West Scotland Ross Greer (above) said. "The Ministry of Defence has long played fast and loose with these weapons of mass slaughter, throwing billions at private contractors whilst failing to even maintain its own facilities.' He added: "These revelations will have been particularly chilling for my constituents who live near the site. To reassure them, UK Ministers must now investigate and explain why it happened and the steps they are taking to ensure it never does again. We need full transparency and accountability, not more secrecy. 'Nuclear weapons are a moral obscenity. They have no place in Scotland. These incidents underline the direct risk to the local communities who host them. "It's time to disarm our waters and get these dangerous weapons of mass slaughter out of Scotland." READ MORE: Historic English fuel firm opening new Scottish head office in Grangemouth Commenting on the issue, ALBA depute leader Neale Hanvey added: 'This is a disgraceful cover-up by the UK Government. Radioactive leaks into Scottish waters were kept secret to protect Westminster's nuclear obsession—not our communities. 'The UK government and MoD have form when it come to this. When I challenged them on radiation leaks in 2023 their response raised more questions than it answered. 'Scotland is treated as a dumping ground for weapons we don't want and dangers we didn't vote for. Independence is the only way we rid ourselves of nuclear weapons and end this toxic disregard for our nation's safety.' A MoD spokesperson previously said: "We place the upmost importance on our responsibilities for handling radioactive substances safely and securely. "There have been no unsafe releases of radioactive material into the environment at any stage. "We frequently engage with regulators who report there is no significant impact on the environment or public health and are supportive of an open reporting culture."
