Was Pope Francis really that progressive?
ADVERTISEMENT
Committed to the poor, migrants, and the environment, Pope Francis devoted his pontificate to the most disadvantaged. But was he really that progressive?
The Argentine pontiff, who died on Easter Monday at the age of 88, dedicated his first visit to the Italian island of Lampedusa on 8 July 2013. On that occasion, he paid tribute to the migrants who had died in the Mediterranean and denounced "the globalisation of indifference" to their fate.
"He was a man of peace, a man for human dignity, and he always spoke out when people were mistreated and when migrants were scapegoated and demonised by forces that are no less present in this parliament", Evin Incir, a Swedish Social Democrat MEP (S&D), told Euronews.
Nicknamed the "Pope of the Poor," Francis had multiplied his actions in favour of people in need, inviting homeless people to dine at the Vatican and instituting a World Day of the Poor.
Very interested in economic issues, the head of the Church also denounced the "excesses of globalisation", finance that "tramples people underfoot," and "the new idolatry of money."
Ecology was at the heart of his pontificate, to which he dedicated his encyclical letter Laudato Si', published in 2015.
Pope Francis hugs Jeannette Zurita, an inmate representative at the San Joaquin women's prison, as he visits the prison in Santiago, Chile, Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2018. T(AP Photo/
Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.
Human rights
In the field of minority rights and women's rights, the situation has not changed much.
While the head of the Church has opened the blessing of marriage to homosexual couples, the door to religious marriage remains closed to them.
Related
Pope Francis urges parents not to condemn gay children
Women's sexual and reproductive rights have been largely absent from his pontificate.
During a visit to Belgium, the Pope described abortion doctors as "hired killers" and compared abortion to homicide.
"He failed to see that restrictions on women's sexual and reproductive rights will not put an end to abortions. It will only make abortions dangerous and not accessible to all women," said Lina Gálvez, Spanish MEP (S&D).
"So he was a man who fought against a lot of inequalities, but it seems that these gender inequalities and this gap in women's rights were not in his mind," she adds.
Although he put forward women in the Vatican, they are still excluded from the priesthood. MEP Lina Gálvez does not hesitate to speak of a "missed opportunity."
The question remains: was he unable, or unwilling, to reform the Church in depth?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
2 hours ago
- LeMonde
World leaders urged to step up for overexploited oceans
World leaders arrived in the French Riviera on Sunday, June 8, ahead of a high-level summit on ocean conservation, as nations face pressure to adopt tougher stances on overfishing, pollution and marine protection. The United Nations has sounded the alarm over an oceans "emergency" and leaders gathering in Nice will be called upon to commit money and stronger protections for the seas. The UN Ocean Conference, starting Monday, is seeking to turn a corner as nations feud over deep-sea mining, plastic litter and exploitative fishing, against a backdrop of wider geopolitical tensions. "We have a duty to mobilize, because the science is clear and the facts are there," said French President Emmanuel Macron in Monaco on Sunday, where he attended a pre-conference event on ocean finance. Some 60 heads of state and government are expected in Nice, including Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and his Argentine counterpart Javier Milei. "The planet can no longer tolerate broken promises," said Lula on Sunday. "Either we act, or the planet is in danger." 'No excuses' Later Sunday, Macron was to arrive in Nice from Monaco and tour the conference venue, made to look like the cavernous belly of a whale. In the evening, he was to host leaders for a dinner of Mediterranean fish. France has deployed 5,000 police to Nice for the five-day summit where scientists, business leaders and environmental activists were also to attend in big numbers. A strong turnout was expected from Pacific Island nations, whose delegations will urge financial aid to combat rising seas, marine trash and the plunder of fish stocks. The United States under President Donald Trump − whose recent push to fast-track seabed mining in international waters sparked global outrage − was not expected to send a delegation. Conservationists have warned that the summit, which will not produce a legally binding agreement, risks being a talkfest unless leaders come up with concrete proposals to restore marine health. On Saturday, Macron said France would restrict bottom trawling − a destructive fishing method that indiscriminately scrapes the ocean floor − in some of its marine protected areas. Britain also said it would announce plans looking to extend a ban on bottom trawling to more than half of protected English seas. Environmental groups said such steps were good but do not go far enough. Pay up Nations will also face calls to cough up the missing finances to protect 30% of the world's oceans by 2030, a target that had been agreed upon by nearly 200 countries in 2022. So far, only around 8% of oceans are designated marine conservation zones and even less are considered truly protected. Greenpeace says at this rate, it could take another 82 years to reach the 30% goal. Another summit priority will be inching towards the numbers required to ratify a global treaty on harmful fishing subsidies, and another on protecting the high seas beyond national control. France is also spearheading a push in Nice to build support for a moratorium on deep-sea mining ahead of a closely-watched meeting of the International Seabed Authority in July.
Euronews
9 hours ago
- Euronews
Italian labour reform and citizenship referendum under way
On Sunday 8 and Monday 9 June, citizens are called to the polls to vote on five abrogative or repeal referenda - they are so called because they decide whether to retain or repeal a law or decree that is part of the legislature and already implemented. They coincide with local elections in several Italian regions and municipalities. The referenda, proposed by trade unions and civic organisations, touch on issues that have generated political debate in recent years, in particular the labour market reform, mainly of the 2016 Jobs Act, and migrant reception and integration policies. The first four issues are related to the job topic and concern increasing protection of workers, small enterprises and their obligations towards employees, short-term contracts, and the responsibility of clients towards sub-contracting parties and employees' safety. The fifth question concerns the period of time necessary to be eligible for Italian citizenship, proposing to reduce it from 10 to 5 years. Government parties opposed the referenda, with some politicians urging citizens not to go to the polls. Analysts say the vote is a test for Giorgia Meloni's executive. For the referenda to be valid, a quorum must be reached: at least 50% plus one of all eligible voters must participate. According to the advocacy group International Democracy Community, the referenda can be characterised as a citizens' initiative: "The referendum questions were proposed through a bottom-up approach, and did not come from Parliament. Members of the Europa+ party launched the initiative on the citizenship question, whilst the Italian General Confederation of Labour (CGIL) has been the initiator of the Jobs Act ones, with support from the Democratic Party, the Five Star Movement, and the Green & Left Alliance." Voting is taking place from 07:00 to 23:00 on Sunday and from 07:00 to 15:00 on Monday. At 12 noon, with almost all sections verified, turnout stood at just over 7%, raising concerns about a successful outcome. In 2011, the last time the quorum was reached in a referendum, 11.6% had voted by that time. Russia's Defence Ministry said on Sunday that its forces had reached the western edge of the Donetsk region, one of the four provinces Russia illegally annexed in 2022, and that troops were 'developing the offensive' in the neighbouring Dnipropetrovsk region. This would be the first time Russian troops had pushed into the region in the more than three-year-old war. Ukraine has denied the claim. Russia's advance would mark a significant setback for Ukraine's already stretched forces as peace talks remain stalled and Russian troops have made incremental gains elsewhere. Putin's forces also appear to be within a few kilometres of the city of Sumy, three years after Ukraine forced them out of the northern region. One person was killed and another seriously wounded in Russian aerial strikes on the eastern Ukrainian Kharkiv region. These strikes came after Russian attacks targeted the regional capital on Saturday. Regional police in Kharkiv said on Sunday that the death toll from Saturday's attacks had increased to six people. More than two dozen others were wounded. Russia fired a total of 49 exploding drones and decoys and three missiles overnight, Ukraine's air force said Sunday. Forty drones were shot down or electronically jammed. Russia's defence ministry said that its forces shot down 61 Ukrainian drones overnight, including near the capital. Five people were wounded Sunday in a Ukrainian drone attack on a parking lot in Russia's Belgorod region, according to regional Governor Vyacheslav Gladkov. Two people were wounded when a Ukrainian drone attack sparked a fire at a chemical plant in the Tula region, local authorities said. Russian authorities said early Sunday that Vnukovo and Domodedovo airports, two international airports serving Moscow, temporarily suspended flights because of a Ukrainian drone attack. Later in the day, Domodedovo halted flights temporarily for a second time, along with Zhukovsky airport.
France 24
9 hours ago
- France 24
World leaders gather for summit, urged to act to avert oceans 'emergency'
World leaders arrive in the French Riviera on Sunday ahead of a high-level summit on ocean conservation, as nations face pressure to adopt tougher stances on overfishing, pollution and marine protection. The United Nations has sounded the alarm over an oceans"emergency" and leaders gathering in Nice will be called to commit money and stronger protections for the seas. The UN Ocean Conference, starting Monday, seeks to turn a corner as nations feud over deep-sea mining, plastic litter and exploitative fishing, against a backdrop of wider geopolitical tensions. "We have a duty to mobilise, because the science is clear and the facts are there," said French President Emmanuel Macron in Monaco on Sunday, where he attended a pre-conference event on ocean finance. Some 60 heads of state and government are expected in Nice, including Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and his Argentine counterpart Javier Milei. "The planet can no longer tolerate broken promises," said Lula on Sunday. "Either we act, or the planet is in danger." 'No excuses' Later Sunday, Macron was to arrive in Nice from Monaco and tour the conference venue, made to look like the cavernous belly of a whale. In the evening, he was to host leaders for a dinner of Mediterranean fish. France has deployed 5,000 police to Nice for the five-day summit where scientists, business leaders and environmental activists were also to attend in big numbers. A strong turnout was expected from Pacific Island nations, whose delegations will urge financial aid to combat the rising seas, marine trash and plunder of fish stocks. The United States under President Donald Trump -- whose recent push to fast-track seabed mining in international waters sparked global outrage -- was not expected to send a delegation. Conservationists have warned the summit -- which will not produce a legally binding agreement -- risks being a talkfest unless leaders come up with concrete proposals to restore marine health. On Saturday, Macron said France would restrict bottom trawling -- a destructive fishing method that indiscriminately scrapes the ocean floor -- in some of its marine protected areas. Britain also said it would announce plans looking to extend a ban on bottom trawling to more than half of protected English seas. Environmental groups said such steps were good but do not go far enough. Pay up Nations will also face calls to cough up the missing finance to protect 30 percent of the world's oceans by 2030, a target agreed by nearly 200 countries in 2022. "We've created this sort of myth that governments don't have money for ocean conservation," Brian O'Donnell, director of Campaign for Nature, told reporters. "There is money. There is not political will," he said. So far, only around eight percent of oceans are designated marine conservation zones and even less are considered truly protected. Greenpeace says at this rate, it could take another 82 years to reach the 30 percent goal. In a boost this week, Samoa declared 30 percent of its national waters under protection with the creation of nine new marine parks. Conservationists hope others at the summit follow suit. "All eyes should be on the many Pacific leaders attending.... Their ambition and dedication to ocean protection can serve as inspiration to all countries," said Kevin Chand from the nonprofit group Pristine Seas. Another summit priority will be inching towards the numbers required to ratify a global treaty on harmful fishing subsidies, and another on protecting the high seas beyond national control. France is also spearheading a push in Nice to build support for a moratorium on deep-sea mining ahead of a closely-watched meeting of the International Seabed Authority in July.
