Can Trump take control of Washington D.C. to fight the city's crime?
U.S. President Donald Trump has repeatedly threatened to put Washington, D.C., under full federal control to reduce crime, even as city officials stressed crime is already falling.
While Trump does have some authority over the capital city's police force and National Guard soldiers, a full federal takeover would likely be blocked in court. Here is why.
What does the constitution say about control of D.C.?
The U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1787, provided for the creation of a federal capital district to serve as the permanent seat of the government.
The Constitution made clear that Congress has complete legislative authority over the district. But Congress has historically delegated at least some of the day-to-day work of municipal government to other entities.
How is D.C. governed?
A federal law passed by Congress in 1973, known as the Home Rule Act, allowed city residents to elect a mayor and council, who have some autonomy to pass their own laws.
Congress still has budgetary oversight over D.C., however, and can overturn local legislation. Congress did that most recently in 2023, voting to overturn changes to Washington's laws that lowered penalties for some crimes.
Who controls D.C. law enforcement?
The Democratic mayor of Washington, Muriel Bowser, has authority over the city's Metropolitan Police Department. But the Home Rule Act allows the president to take control of the MPD for federal purposes during emergencies if 'special conditions of an emergency nature exist.'
A presidential takeover is limited to 30 days, unless Congress votes to extend it through a joint resolution.
Trump invoked this part of the Home Rule Act on Monday, saying in an executive order that there is a 'crime emergency' in the city that necessitates federal management of the police department.
Bowser has pushed back on Trump's claims of unchecked violence, saying the city is 'not experiencing a crime spike' and highlighting that violent crime hit its lowest level in more than three decades last year.
Violent crime, including murders, spiked in 2023, turning Washington into one of the nation's deadliest cities, according to city police data.
However, violent crime dropped 35 per cent in 2024, according to federal data, and it has fallen an additional 26 per cent in the first seven months of 2025.
Trump also has broad control over the D.C. National Guard's 2,700 soldiers and airmen. They report directly to the president, unlike counterparts in other states and territories.
Trump said on Monday he was deploying 800 National Guard troops to Washington.
So, can Trump 'federalize' D.C.?
It is highly unlikely.
To exert full federal control of D.C., Trump would need Congress to repeal the Home Rule Act.
Such a repeal would require 60 votes in the U.S. Senate, where Trump's Republican Party has a 53-47 advantage. Democrats have been supportive of home rule for D.C. and are not expected to cross party lines to endorse Trump's vision.
But there are ways Trump can exert more influence over the district without fully taking it over.
Trump in recent months has directed federal law enforcement agencies such as the FBI to increase the police presence in Washington.
Trump has broad authority to reallocate FBI personnel, and in recent months, FBI agents around the country have been given temporary assignments to help with immigration enforcement.
Trump also signed an executive order in March to make D.C. 'safe and beautiful,' establishing a task force to increase police presence in public areas, maximize immigration enforcement, and expedite concealed carry licenses.
Can Trump evict D.C.'s homeless population?
Trump has said homeless people must move out of Washington, without offering specifics of a plan to accomplish this.
'I'm going to make our Capital safer and more beautiful than it ever was before,' Trump said on Truth Social. 'The Homeless have to move out, IMMEDIATELY. We will give you places to stay, but FAR from the Capital.'
The federal government owns much of Washington's parkland, so the Trump administration has legal authority to clear homeless encampments in those areas, like President Joe Biden did while in office. But the federal government cannot force people to move out of the city because they lack shelter, legal experts said.
Reporting by Jan Wolfe; Editing by Noeleen Walder and Rod Nickel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
White House hopes monthly U.S. jobs report to continue despite claim by labour statistics nominee
Donald Trump's selection as next commissioner of the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) threatens to bring a new level of politicization to what for decades has been a nonpartisan agency issuing reports on the nation's economic health, according to Democrats and some economists. While many former Labour Department officials say it's unlikely that as commissioner of the department's Bureau of Labour Statistics, E.J. Antoni will be able to distort or alter the economic data, he could change the way it is presented. Antoni was nominated by Trump after the BLS released a jobs report on Aug. 1 that showed that hiring had weakened in July and was much lower in May and June than the agency had previously reported. Even as the rest of the report contained positive data points for the Trump White House, the president asserted, without evidence, that data had been "rigged" for political reasons and fired the then-BLS chair, Erika McEntarfer, who had been put in the position with bipartisan Senate support. McEntarfer's firing was criticized even by some Republican Congress members, including senators Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming and Thom Tillis of North Carolina. Antoni has been a vocal critic of the government's jobs data in frequent appearances on podcasts and cable TV. He has publicly said that the Labour Department should stop publishing the monthly jobs reports until its data collection processes improve, and rely on quarterly data based on actual employment filings with state unemployment offices. WATCH l Concerns that firing will have a chilling effect on data collection: Trump fires U.S. Bureau of Labour Statistics head after weak jobs report 11 days ago Revisions common, understood by Wall Street The monthly employment reports are probably the closest-watched economic data on Wall Street, and can frequently cause swings in stock prices. When asked at Tuesday's White House briefing whether the jobs report would continue to be released, press secretary Karoline Leavitt said the administration hoped it would be. "I believe that is the plan and that's the hope," Leavitt said. Leavitt also defended Antoni's nomination, calling him an "economic expert" who has testified before Congress, adding that "the president trusts him to lead this important department." Yet Antoni wrongly claimed in the last year of Joe Biden's presidency that the economy had been in recession since 2022; called on the entire Federal Reserve board to be fired for not earning a profit on its Treasury securities holdings; and posted a chart on social media that conflated timelines to suggest inflation under Biden was headed to 15 per cent. His argument that the U.S. was in a recession rested on a vastly exaggerated measure of housing inflation, based on newly purchased home prices, to artificially make the nation's gross domestic product appear smaller than it was. "This is actually maybe the worst Antoni content I've seen yet," Alan Cole of the centre-right Tax Foundation said on social media on Tuesday, referring to his recession claim. Many economists share, to some degree, Antoni's concerns that the government's jobs data has flaws and is threatened by trends such as declining response rates to its surveys. The drop has made the jobs figures more volatile, though not necessarily less accurate over time. "The stock market moves clearly based on these job numbers, and so people with skin in the game think it's telling them something about the future of their investments," said Brian Albrecht, chief economist at the International Center for Law and Economics. "Could it be improved? Absolutely." Katharine Abraham, an economist at the University of Maryland who was BLS commissioner under president Bill Clinton, said updating the jobs report's methods would require at least some initial investment. The government could use more modern data sources, she said, such as figures from payroll processing companies, and fill in gaps with surveys. UBS economist Alan Detmeister estimates that BLS is now collecting about 18 per cent fewer price quotes for the inflation report than it did earlier this year. He thinks the report will produce more volatile results, though averaged out over time, still reliable. Ex-commissioner doubts data can be changed William Beach, who was appointed BLS commissioner by Trump in his first term and also served under Biden, said he is confident that BLS procedures are strong enough to prevent political meddling. He said that when he served as commissioner, he didn't see the figures himself until two days before publication. "The commissioner does not affect the numbers," Beach said. "They don't collect the data. They don't massage the data." Regarding the odds of rigging the numbers, Beach said, "I wouldn't put it at complete zero, but I'd put it pretty close to zero." WATCH l Will Trump wait for Fed chair Powell's term to end before acting?: Why Trump wants to get rid of Fed Chair Jerome Powell | About That 26 days ago U.S. President Donald Trump has been increasingly critical of Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell. Andrew Chang explains why Trump is so upset with the man he nominated in 2017, and explores the way in which the president could attempt to remove Powell. Images provided by Getty Images, The Canadian Press and Reuters. Before launching his political career, Trump frequently accused Barack Obama's administration of juking the stats to produce more favourable economic reports, without providing evidence. As president, Trump has frequently assailed the Federal Reserve chair he nominated back in his first term, Jerome Powell. Antoni requires Senate confirmation. Sen. Patty Murray, a senior Democrat, called on Sen. Bill Cassidy, the Republican chair of the Senate health, education, labor and pensions committee, to hold a confirmation hearing for Antoni as soon as possible. It took about six months after McEntarfer was nominated in July 2023 for her to be approved. She was confirmed in an 86-8 vote, meaning she had support from dozens of Republicans.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
At least 123 Palestinians killed as Israeli army pounds Gaza City ahead of planned takeover
Social Sharing Israel's military pounded Gaza City on Wednesday prior to a planned takeover, with another 123 people killed in the last day, according to the Gaza health ministry, while militant group Hamas held further talks with Egyptian mediators. The 24-hour death toll was the worst in a week and added to the massive fatalities from the nearly two-year war that has shattered the enclave, which houses more than two million Palestinians. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reiterated an idea — also enthusiastically floated by U.S. President Donald Trump — that Palestinians should simply leave. "They're not being pushed out, they'll be allowed to exit," he told Israeli television channel i24NEWS. "All those who are concerned for the Palestinians and say they want to help the Palestinians should open their gates and stop lecturing us." Arabs and many world leaders are aghast at the idea of displacing the Gaza population, which Palestinians say would be like another "Nakba," or catastrophe, when hundreds of thousands fled or were forced out during the 1948 war. WATCH | Former hostage negotiator calls Netanyahu 'biggest liar' in Israel: Benjamin Netanyahu the 'biggest liar' in Israel: former hostage negotiator 3 days ago In a press conference with international journalists, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has defended his plan to take over Gaza City, claiming it's the fastest way to end Israel's military offensive in the Palestinian territory. But former hostage negotiator Gershon Baskin says Netanyahu would be the 'only winner' in that plan. Israel's planned recapture of Gaza City — which it took in the early days of the war before withdrawing — is probably weeks away, officials say. That means a ceasefire is still possible, though talks have been floundering and conflict still rages. Israeli planes and tanks bombed eastern areas of Gaza City heavily, residents said, with many homes destroyed in the Zeitoun and Shejaia neighbourhoods overnight. Al-Ahli hospital said 12 people were killed in an airstrike on a home in Zeitoun. Tanks also destroyed several houses in the east of Khan Younis in south Gaza, while in the centre, Israeli gunfire killed nine aid-seekers in two separate incidents, Palestinian medics said. Israel's military did not comment. Eight more people, including three children, have died of starvation and malnutrition in Gaza in the past 24 hours, the territory's health ministry said. That took the total to 235, including 106 children, since the war began. Hamas chief negotiator Khalil Al-Hayya's meetings with Egyptian officials in Cairo on Wednesday were to focus on stopping the war, delivering aid and "ending the suffering of our people in Gaza," Hamas official Taher al-Nono said in a statement. Truce talks resume after international outcry Egyptian security sources said the talks would also discuss the possibility of a comprehensive ceasefire that would see Hamas relinquish governance in Gaza and concede its weapons. A Hamas official told Reuters the group was open to all ideas if Israel ends the war and pulls out. However, "laying down arms before the occupation is dismissed is impossible," the official, who asked not to be named, told Reuters. Netanyahu's plan to expand military control over Gaza, which Israeli sources said could be launched in October, has heightened global outcry over the widespread devastation, displacement and hunger in the enclave. About half of Gaza's residents live in the Gaza City area. Foreign ministers of 24 countries, including Canada, Britain Australia, France and Japan, said this week the humanitarian crisis in Gaza had reached "unimaginable levels" and urged Israel to allow unrestricted aid. Israel denies responsibility for hunger, accusing Hamas of stealing aid. It says it has taken steps to increase deliveries, including daily combat pauses in some areas and protected routes for aid convoys. Aid remains far from sufficient: UN and Palestinians The Israeli military on Wednesday said that nearly 320 trucks entered Gaza through the Kerem Shalom and Zikim crossings and that a further nearly 320 trucks were collected and distributed by the UN and international organizations in the past 24 hours, along with three tankers of fuel and 97 pallets of air-dropped aid. The United Nations and Palestinians say aid entering Gaza remains far from sufficient. The war began on Oct. 7, 2023, when Hamas-led militants stormed into southern Israel, killing 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages, according to Israeli figures. Israel's offensive against Hamas in Gaza since then has killed more than 61,000 Palestinians, according to local health officials. WATCH | Norway's wealth fund to divest from more Israeli companies over Gaza war: Norway's wealth fund to divest from more Israeli companies over war in Gaza 23 hours ago Norway's $2-trillion wealth fund said Tuesday it expects to divest from more Israeli companies over the situation in Gaza and the West Bank. A review of investments began last week following media reports that the fund had built a stake of just over two per cent in an Israeli jet engine group that provides services to Israel's armed forces. Arab states and much of the international community want postwar Gaza to be governed by the Palestinian Authority, which exercises limited governance in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. The authority's foreign minister, Varsen Aghabekian Shahin, told reporters it was ready to assume full responsibility in Gaza. Hamas would have no role and be required to hand over arms, she added, calling for an international peacekeeping force and withdrawal by Israel.
Toronto Star
2 hours ago
- Toronto Star
At least 25 killed by Israeli gunfire as Netanyahu says he will ‘allow' Palestinians to leave
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks at the opening ceremony of the Knesset Museum in the old building of the Israeli parliament, in Jerusalem, Monday, Aug.11, 2025. AP Photo/Ohad Zwigenberg, Pool flag wire: true flag sponsored: false article_type: : sWebsitePrimaryPublication : publications/toronto_star bHasMigratedAvatar : false :
