Police officer lists four problems with restaurant applying for drinks licence
An Indian restaurant owner faced objections from police and licensing officers for the second time in a matter of months after re-applying for a drinks licence for his business.
Rafiqul Islam, 47, wants to serve alcohol from 10am to 11pm at Cardamom, in St James's Street, Brighton. He has not been legally able to do so since his licence lapsed.
He previously applied for a licence until midnight every day but was turned down after a Brighton and Hove City Council licensing panel hearing in February.
Mr Islam has since brought in a former colleague and more experienced licence holder, Szabolcs Veres, to work as the designated premises supervisor (DPS) with responsibility for alcohol sales.
But at a licensing panel hearing before three councillors, Sussex Police licensing officer Mark Thorogood listed several issues with the premises since Mr Islam took over.
These included
The licence lapsing in October 2023
Alcohol was listed on the menu and a beer pump was still connected in November 2023 even though the premises no longer had a licence
Trading outside permitted hours and with no functioning closed-circuit television (CCTV) in December 2023
The battery-operated CCTV was not working in December 2024
The panel was told that the incident log had not been signed off and staff had not received the training that they needed, the licence was found to have lapsed and Mr Islam was given a final warning.
Conservative councillor Ivan Lyons asked what measures would give the police confidence to support Mr Islam's premises having a licence. Mr Thorogood said that there were none.
He said: 'We have raised our concerns around a history of non-compliance and a new proposed DPS.
'We have spent a long time already trying to assist Mr Islam in adhering to the previous premises licences he has held but with no success.'
Mr Thorogood said that the business was small and 'not challenging' but the various issues, including trading without a licence, meant that the force had lost confidence in Mr Islam.
Council licensing officer Donna Lynsdale also said that she had no confidence in Mr Islam's ability to comply with any licence conditions.
Ms Lynsdale said that she visited the business in February to ensure that no alcohol was on sale after the previous licence application was turned down.
Although no alcoholic drinks were on display, they were still included in the menus on the counter.
She said that Mr Islam called her for help with his new licence application and asked her to recommend someone who could help.
Ms Lynsdale said: 'Mr Islam stated he believed the reason the last application was refused was because the committee did not like his legal representative.
'This clarifies that Mr Islam is not taking any responsibility for the previous issue – the breaches – or the poor running of the premises.
'Despite providing Mr islam with all the documents and assistance to comply with the previous premises licence, he continued to breach the conditions.'
Mr Islam's solicitor, Nicholas Perkins, said that the business was small, with space for only 20 to 28 customers at a time, so it was not a 'challenging' restaurant.
But it was in the centre of Brighton where there were restrictions on new alcohol licences because of the 'saturation' of licensed premises and the associated risks of crime and nuisance.
Mr Perkins said that the site had been a restaurant for many years and would not be adding to the volume of similar businesses in the area.
Without the licence, Mr Perkins said, his client would be 'financially ruined'.
He said: 'You (the panel) should look at this whole situation afresh. Mr Islam has candidly admitted his failings but that does not mean he should not be given a further opportunity.
'The proposal before you is new, different and you could have confidence in it on the basis that Mr Veres is prepared to be the DPS.
'He's prepared to take the risk. He has the confidence that going forward these premises will operate correctly.'
Labour councillor Paul Nann asked if conditions could include the number of hours that Mr Veres spent at the premises but he was told that this would not be possible.
The panel – which also included Labour councillor Julie Cattel – retired to make its decision which should be made public within five working days.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
44 minutes ago
- Yahoo
London must ‘market its successes better' to avoid another Wise
Britain must emulate the success of Nasdaq and get better at trumpeting its business success stories if it wants to attract more companies to list in London, one of the UK's top fintech venture capital investors has said. Speaking to City AM the day that payments darling Wise revealed plans to ditch its primary listing for New York, Anthemis founder Amy Nauiokas said the London Stock Exchange (LSE) should try emulate the support promotion the US's tech-heavy bourse gives its new constituents. 'It's not brain surgery,' said Nauiokas, whose firm has been an early-stage backer of fintech success stories like Etoro, Zoopla and Tide. 'They [the LSE] need to promise UK entrepreneurs that there's a path here, and that they'll support them, build an ecosystem around them, and give the perks that the Nasdaq gives them.' London capital markets have been locked in a multi-year struggle to attract and retain some of its brightest companies. Since the start of 2024 alone, cherished listed firms like Darktrace, TUI and most DS Smith have all delisted or been taken private from the capital's stock market. And promising UK-headquartered scale-ups like Arm have opted to list in New York over London, with other darlings like Revolut and Klarna looking likely to follow suit. Departed firms have tended to cite London's stubbornly low valuations and lower liquidity relative to its US rivals, but Nauiokas argued that the lengths to which New York goes to promote and celebrate its new additions was just as important a factor. Commenting on the Nasdaq's custom of advertising its fresh listings in New York's Time Square, she said: 'Half the reason why people go there is so they get to see their their picture on 45th Street.' Her comments ring true with the rationale for ditching London given by Wise, which floated in the UK to great fanfare in 2021. Billionaire cofounder Kristo Kaarmannder said a US listing would help raise Wise's profile in the country as it joins the many London-based fintech giants looking to expand their services in the world's largest market. 'We believe the addition of a primary US listing would help us accelerate our mission and bring substantial strategic and capital market benefits to Wise and our owners,' he said in the firm's statement announcing its planned departure. Nauiokas, whose firm invests in start-ups in both the US and UK with offices in both New York and London, said she understood the Wise board's decision, adding that were she a secondary capital and pre-IPO dealmaker, she 'would probably say the best option right now was either a dual listing or a US-based IPO'. But despite the downbeat rhetoric surrounding the London Stock Exchange, she added that the ongoing political turmoil in America was something on which London – and Europe as a whole – should be poised to capitalise. 'It strikes me that all the opportunity is here [in London],' she said. 'This is a moment. A moment for investors to find great entrepreneurs and make money, but also a moment for regulatory navel gazing – government navel gazing – private partnership navel gazing – to say we could do something here. Let's do something.' Family offices and institutional money are increasingly looking to reduce the weighting of US assets in their portfolio in response to the capricious and unpredictable policy directives from the White House, Nauiokas said. Many ultra-rich families have re-weighted their portfolios from an '80/20 North America to Europe to now 50/50'. 'I'm super excited about the UK specifically. But it needs to take this moment of market geopolitical dislocation,' she said, adding: 'The LSE can do a much better job of reshaping its proposition, and the government needs to get rid of stamp duty on shares.' Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Murder charge after woman found dead in flat
A man has been charged with murder after a 47-year-old woman was found dead in a flat. Police were called to the property on Ashe Place, in Normanton, Derby, at about 11:30 BST on Thursday and arrested a man. On Sunday, Derbyshire Police said Thomas Turner, 63, had been charged with murder. Mr Turner, of no fixed address, was to appear at Southern Derbyshire Magistrates' Court on Monday, the force said. Officers have yet to name the woman who died. Follow BBC Derby on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@ or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210. Derbyshire Police
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Fraudster on the run after absconding from prison
Police are searching for a convict who has absconded from an open prison in Derbyshire. Derbyshire Police said Paul Haughey left HMP Sudbury, near Ashbourne, between 11:00 BST and midday on Sunday. The force described the 40-year-old, who was serving a nine-month sentence for fraud and theft offences, as white, about 5ft 9in (1.75m) tall, of medium build, with grey hair. He was last seen wearing grey tracksuit bottoms, a dark grey lightweight bomber jacket and black trainers, officers said. Anyone who sees the prisoner is urged to call the police. Follow BBC Derby on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@ or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210. Derbyshire Police HMP Sudbury
