No O'Driscoll or O'Connell – my Lions team from last four tours

Telegraph

2 days ago

Selecting a British and Irish Lions Test 23 from the three tours I've been involved with – and this most recent 2025 tour – proved far more difficult than I anticipated.
I found myself questioning: If the Lions had won the third Test comfortably on Saturday, would more players from this tour have made my squad? The honest answer is: Probably.
When picking from the 2025 squad, we can only judge based on the matches we've seen. But there's so much more to a tour than just what happens on match day. We don't see how players have trained, their availability, their professionalism in preparation and recovery, or their attitude on and off the field. That's where Andy Farrell, as head coach, has had the advantage—he's witnessed all of this first-hand. No doubt, some of his selections were based on that deeper insight.
My Lions Test 23: 2013–2025
1. Ellis Genge
I haven't always been Ellis's biggest fan, but he was outstanding on this tour. His ball carrying, particularly in the first Test, had a huge impact. His leadership and physicality made him a key figure.
2. Dan Sheehan
An exceptional talent who's redefined the hooker role in international rugby. His try-scoring, mobility, and consistent set-piece work – especially line-out throwing – are elite. For me, a genuine contender for player of the series.
3. Tadhg Furlong
He has dominated the No 3 jersey for the Lions over the last three tours. A powerhouse in the scrum and surprisingly agile around the field. An easy pick.
4. Maro Itoje
A world-class line-out operator with relentless work-rate. His leadership and experience made him a potential captain. Always rises to the occasion.
5. Alun Wyn Jones
Brought immense physicality and leadership. His drive and refusal to give in made him indispensable. People will ask, 'How could Paul O'Connell be left out?' A fair question. Geoff Parling was also excellent in 2013, but Alun Wyn edges it for me.
Incredible.
This speech sums up Alun Wyn Jones. pic.twitter.com/fhQbEFL2dI
— British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) May 19, 2023
6. Tadhg Beirne
This was one of the toughest calls due to the depth in back-row options. Beirne earns the shirt thanks to some incredible performances and being named Man of the Series by Stan Sport. He's matured brilliantly and delivered in big moments.
7. Sam Warburton (captain)
Led from the front and had a superb relationship with referees. One of the most complete opensides of the modern era – professional, intelligent, and a master at the breakdown. A natural leader.
8. Taulupe Faletau
Arguably the most naturally gifted footballer across all squads. Despite strong competition from Jack Conan and the unfortunate unavailability of Caelan Doris, Faletau's instincts, ball skills, and knack for big moments earn him the nod.
When Taulupe Faletau stopped a dead-certain try 😅 pic.twitter.com/kdtyVM9Z5D
— British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) February 26, 2024
9. Jamison Gibson-Park
A very tight call. Gibson-Park has emerged as one of the best 9s in world rugby. His kicking, calmness under pressure and ability to make smart decisions stood out. Mike Phillips, Conor Murray, and Ben Youngs were all strong contenders.
10. Johnny Sexton
Not an easy pick, but Sexton's performances in 2013 and 2017 secured his place. Despite a slow start in 2017, his competitive edge and game management proved decisive. Finn Russell and Owen Farrell were close behind.
11. George North
At his peak in 2013, he was almost unstoppable – big, fast, and powerful. A lethal finisher with the versatility to carry hard and break the gain line.
This just never gets old... #OnThisDay in 2013 we beat Australia in the first test with this gem of a finish from @George_North!! #Classic pic.twitter.com/K6C8XbOdjG
— British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) June 22, 2019
12. Jamie Roberts
Not the most skilful distributor, but a defensive rock and relentless front-foot player. His combination with Jonathan Davies was crucial in 2017, and that familiarity matters.
13. Jonathan Davies
Outstanding in 2013; he was named Man of the Series for a reason. Strong in both attack and defence, with a valuable left-foot kicking option.
14. Tommy Bowe
A consistent performer. Fast, strong, and excellent under the high ball. A reliable defender and communicator who contributed hugely to the back-three unit.
15. Leigh Halfpenny
One of the most professional players the game has seen. Impeccable preparation, positional understanding and an elite goal-kicker. A key figure in the Lions' success.
Leigh Halfpenny on the counterattack: LETHAL ⚡️ pic.twitter.com/4peLfzAZDn
— British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) September 22, 2024
Replacements
16. Jamie George
A dependable hooker and ideal replacement for Sheehan. Strong set-piece presence, composed under pressure, and bags of experience.
17. Mako Vunipola
A tough decision between Mako, Andrew Porter, and Alex Corbisiero. Mako's rugby intelligence and powerful carrying earn him the spot. A great complement to Genge.
18. Adam Jones
Invaluable in the scrum, a true anchor. Often underrated for his skill level, but was a cornerstone in the 2013 pack.
19. Courtney Lawes
Offers impact off the bench with his carrying, footwork, and versatility across the second and back rows. A reliable line-out option as well.
Powerful ball carries ✅
Hammering the breakdown ✅
Smashing into tackles ✅
It was an all-action display from @Courtney_Lawes at the wekeend 😤💪 #LionsRugby #CastleLionsSeries #BoksvLions pic.twitter.com/QBRbBGzqf9
— British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) July 26, 2021
20. Tom Curry
Like a fine wine, he's improved with time. A dynamic and tough back-rower who can cover all three positions. Brings energy and aggression off the bench.
21. Mike Phillips
A fierce competitor. Big, physical, and combative. Almost like an extra loose forward. His presence off the bench could change the momentum of a close game.
22. Owen Farrell
A fierce competitor with big-match temperament. Can cover both 10 and 12, and his goal-kicking is top class. Just edges out Finn Russell due to his versatility and experience.
A kick to level the series and a kick we'll never forget.
Happy Birthday, @owen_faz pic.twitter.com/3RDgII8rds
— British & Irish Lions (@lionsofficial) September 24, 2019
23. Elliot Daly
Selected for his versatility. Can cover centre, wing, or full-back. A long-range kicking threat as well, with proven match-winning ability.