Stab victim ‘gave grief' to murder-accused's friend over £20 debt, trial told
Jurors were told that Charles Hartle, 18, wearing a balaclava, grinned when he 'thrust' the knife into Noah Smedley's chest after a drug deal in Ilkeston, Derbyshire, on the evening of December 28 last year.
Hartle, also known as Charlie, was 17 at the time of the alleged attack.
The defendant, of Station Road, Stanley, Derbyshire, pleaded guilty to possessing a bladed article in a public place but denies murder.
Marcus Coleman, a friend of Hartle's who was 'feet away' from the attack, went with two other friends and the defendant to buy cannabis from Mr Smedley that evening.
Mr Coleman, who was 17 at the time but is now 18, denied that there was animosity between him and Mr Smedley because of an incident months earlier.
Peter Joyce KC, defending Hartle, cross-examined Mr Coleman, who gave evidence from behind a screen at Derby Crown Court on Thursday, and said: 'Noah had been causing you… some grief about a £20 debt of cannabis a little while before.'
The witness replied: 'It was a separate incident that happened months prior, it had nothing to do with this incident.'
Mr Joyce said: 'I suggest it was on this night you saw Charlie for the first time in four months, that's when you told him about the problem with Noah.
'You told him that Noah was giving you grief. Noah had really annoyed you, irritated you, hacked you off.'
Mr Coleman said it was 'not really a problem'.
Mr Joyce said: 'There was no need at all for four of you to go and meet Noah was there? Unless there was a second purpose that required all four of you to go, namely to give him a bit of a slapping.
'For the next four hours the three of you are together at your home aren't you? The three of you instead spent between nine o'clock and one o'clock… doing a number of things. One, smoking weed. Two, talking about what had happened and, I suggest, agreeing your stories.'
Mr Coleman replied: 'No sir.'
Mr Joyce asked: 'Did you decide you would not say the three of you had a grudge against Noah?'
The witness said no.
Mr Coleman said: 'We weren't really talking about anything sir, we were shocked. We were trying to distract ourselves with the cannabis and I think I was on my PS5 at the time, trying to distract myself from the situation.'
When asked why he left the scene with his friends after Hartle ran away instead of helping Mr Smedley, Mr Coleman said he was 'scared' and added: 'I still regret it to this day.'
Mr Joyce said: 'You ran away from Noah in the opposite direction and you took a roundabout route to get away so you would not be seen.
'I'm going to suggest that the reason for all of that was that all four of you – you three and Charlie – had agreed earlier that Noah was to be given a bit of a slapping.'
Mr Coleman replied: 'No, not true sir.'
The trial continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Man falls to his death at Oasis' Wembley Stadium gig
Oasis have released a statement after a man fell to his death at their Wembley gig.
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Dog shot dead by police in North Yorkshire town
A WOMAN has been arrested after a dog was shot dead by police in a North Yorkshire town. The county's police say an Alsatian-type dog had to be put down by a police firearms officer in Bedale after it bit a man and a police officer on their legs. Recommended reading: Man detained after incident on North Yorkshire cliff top Woman and three men arrested at North Yorkshire home Road rage incident on major York road Officers were called to the scene at 10.50pm on Friday (August 1) by the man, who is in his 60s, following the initial biting incident. He had been walking home from the pub in the Market Place when he was attacked by the dog near the bowling club. Officers located the dog near the fire station at around 11.30pm and repeated attempts were made to bring it under control, during which a police officer was bitten. The dog managed to get away and it was tracked down to Queen Anne's Drive, off Firby Road, at 1.30am on Saturday. With a vet due to take 25 minutes to arrive at the scene, a decision was made for a firearms officer to put the dog down due to serious public safety concerns. The owner of the dog, a 64-year-old local woman, has been arrested for having a dog dangerously out of control which has caused injury to a person. The injured man and police officer attended hospital for treatment to the bite wounds and receive tetanus jabs. Witnesses to the incident or anyone with information are asked to call North Yorkshire Police on 101 quoting reference NYP-01082025-0637.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Hammersmith bridge illegal fireworks spark 80 emergency calls amid fear for homes
An unauthorised fireworks display on Hammersmith bridge almost resulted in nearby buildings catching fire, it can be revealed. More than 80 emergency calls were received by the London Fire Brigade at around 9.45pm on Sunday when a flare set fire to a hedge on the south side of the river. The blaze is believed to have broken out in the fields belonging to St Paul's School. One resident said the firework could have easily hit a person or burned down a row of houses. It is thought football fans had gathered on the bridge, which has been closed to vehicles since 2019, to let off a 'huge amount' of fireworks, according to residents. A row of hedges caught fire, with the flames reaching 3m in height – caused by a suspected stray firework or flare. Fire brigade sources said it was extremely fortunate that no buildings became involved in this incident. Six fire engines were initially dispatched to the scene, due to the volume of calls and suggestions from some callers that buildings may be involved. Following an assessment of the situation from firefighters on scene, the response was scaled down to three fire engines and about 15 firefighters. A London Fire Brigade spokesperson said: "We were called at 21:48 yesterday (August 3) to reports of a fire near Lonsdale Road, SW13. 'Firefighters attended and discovered a hedge fully alight. The fire was safely extinguished by crews by around 22:30. The fire is believed to have been caused by a stray firework or flare." A spokesperson for Hammersmith Bridge SOS, which campaigns to restore public transport over the bridge, said: 'This was terrifying, orchestrated behaviour, its flares and fireworks raining down. 'If they had landed just slightly differently they could've set fire easily to a row of wooden houses or killed someone. 'It shows once again how vulnerable Hammersmith bridge has become now Hammersmith's Labour council, Richmond council, TfL and the Department for Transport all have washed their hands of it and try to pass responsibility from one to the other – no one is monitoring the bridge effectively and crime is becoming rife.' Hammersmith and Fulham council, which owns Hammersmith bridge, said it was aware of the incident. Almost exactly a year ago, Algerian football fans held an illegal firework display on the Millennium Bridge and Blackfriars bridge in central London to celebrate the anniversary of the country's national football team. It is not known at this stage whether the same fans were responsible for the incident on Hammersmith bridge. In March, The Standard revealed that a number of ideas about the future of the bridge were discussed at a meeting of the 'taskforce' designed to get the council, TfL and the Government working together. In April, the bridge's main carriageway reopened to pedestrians and cyclists after a £2.9m upgrade. There is no date for it to reopen to cars and buses. The Metropolitan Police, St Paul's school and Richmond council have been contacted by The Standard.
