Court asks woman to pay ₹8.3 lakh for bumping into a stranger while walking; social media reacts
A court in Qingdao, China, has ordered a woman named Wang to pay 70,000 yuan ( ₹ 8.3 lakh) as compensation to a 59-year-old woman named Liu. But, the reason has baffled many.
Liu was walking in her residential area in May 2023 when she stopped suddenly to answer a phone call and turned around. Wang, who was walking behind her and not paying attention, walked into Liu.
The collision caused Liu to fall and suffer bone fractures. Later, she was diagnosed with Grade 10 disability.
In China, disability is graded on a scale of 1 to 10, with Grade 1 being the most severe and Grade 10 being the least. Grade 10 disability in China typically involves partial damage or deformity to an organ. However, it does not involve functional deficiencies. It requires no medical care, as per the China Labour Bulletin.
According to the court, Wang was careless and should have watched where she was going.
Liu initially asked Wang to pay 188,000 yuan (about ₹ 22 lakh) as compensation for medical costs and injury after the accident. While Liu blamed Wang, Wang said Liu had suddenly stopped.
The judge watched CCTV footage and said both were partly responsible. He blamed Liu for stopping in the middle of the road and Wang for not paying attention. After negotiations, Wang agreed to pay 70,000 yuan in instalments.
The case has gone viral on Chinese social media, with many questioning why the person walking behind was blamed. The case has caused public debate as the judge blamed Wang for 'not keeping a safe distance while walking behind Liu'. In China, such road laws only apply to vehicles.
'The judge should be more cautious when speaking publicly about the case; otherwise, it might have a negative social impact,' the South China Morning Post quoted an online user as saying.
Another commented, 'It would be a different case if the person in front not only stopped but also walked back, but judging from the video footage, the person behind should be responsible for the accident.'
'I do believe people should keep a greater distance from one another while walking or queuing when there is enough space,' remarked another user.
Some users recalled a 2006 case where a man named Peng Yu helped an elderly woman who had fallen. She later sued him, blaming him for her fall.
The judge ruled against Peng, saying no one would help a stranger 'by common sense'. That decision still affects people in China today. Many still fear helping others due to possible false claims.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
'They forced me to transfer money': Film producer Shyam Dey alleges abduction and extortion by actors Puja Banerjee and Kunal Verma
Bengali film producer Shyam Sunder Dey, a familiar name in the industry with over 60 films to his credit, has alleged that he was abducted, confined and extorted in Goa by actor Puja Banerjee , her husband Kunal Verma, and their associate Piyush Kothari. The incident came to light through a social media post made by Shyam's wife, Malabika Dey, who attached copies of FIRs, payment slips, and WhatsApp screenshots. The post accused the trio of coercing Shyam into transferring money and attempting to force property handovers, all while threatening him with false drug charges. FIR Lodged against Puja Banerjee, Kunal Verma and Piyush Kothari 'They intercepted my car in Goa' Shyam recounted that he had travelled to Goa with his family for a holiday. 'My family stayed with me for about five days. They returned home for my child's education purpose, and I decided to stay on to attend to some business matters,' he said. While driving a rented car— Shyam alleged that a black Jaguar intercepted his vehicle on the main road. 'It came out of nowhere and forced me to a halt. Two men got down, approached me, and insisted I step out, all of it I assume will be there in CCTV. At first, I refused. But then I noticed Puja Banerjee — who has been like a sister to me — was present. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo Seeing her, I let my guard down, thinking this must be a misunderstanding,' Shyam shared. According to him, he was first taken to a friend's house and then shifted to a villa. 'They made me sit in their car and took me to Amber Villa. Initially, I was kept on the first floor, but because it was too close to the road and they feared attention, I was shifted upstairs.' Copy of complaint to Goa Police dated 03/6/2025 'They made me sign papers' 'I stayed at the villa from the 1st to the 4th of June. I wasn't allowed to leave. Every day I tried to reason with Puja and Kunal — I reminded them we were like family, pleaded with them to stop. But all I faced were threats,' Shyam said. He also alleged that he was beaten — not just by Kunal but also by other unknown men — while Puja watched. 'I told her, your husband is beating me, fine. But other men are thrashing me in front of you, and you're silent? How can this be right?' Shyam claimed his phones were taken — two seized outright, and one kept temporarily with him under the pretext that it would help him arrange funds. With that device, he secretly shared his live location with his wife. 'One of the phones stayed with Puja, even when she was shooting in Bombay. Police later recovered one handset from Kunal, but the other remained with her until it was returned.' Gratitude email to SP North Goa with a cc to DGP Goa Police thanking them for recovering Shyam. Shyam tried to make them understand because they were close Throughout his ordeal, Shyam said he kept appealing to Puja and Kunal's better judgment. 'I told them repeatedly what they were doing was sheer madness. But they simply said, 'Don't teach us what's legal or illegal.' I didn't want to go to the police straight away — I knew the consequences. Their careers could be ruined, and they had been close to me for years. But when they began pressing me to sign property papers, I realised this had gone too far. ' Fearing for his life, Shyam secretly filmed a video from the villa's bathroom, and his wife promptly alerted the police. The Goa Police acted swiftly, rescuing him on June 4. As of now, no official statement has been issued by Puja Banerjee, Kunal Verma or Piyush Kothari. Malabika Dey said they will pursue the matter legally and hopes the industry stands by them during what she calls a 'betrayal of trust and friendship.' Email to SP North Goa requesting him to rescue Shyam with location details. FIR filed , police probe on After Shyam Sunder Dey was rescued from a Goa villa on June 4, an FIR was lodged by Goa Police against actors Puja Banerjee, Kunal Verma, and their associate Piyush Kothari, under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). The charges include: Sections 126(2), 137(2), 140(2), 308(2), 115(2), 351(3), 61(2), and 3(5) — relating to abduction, wrongful confinement, extortion, criminal intimidation, and threats involving criminal conspiracy. According to a detailed post by Shyam's wife Malabika Dey, Shyam was allegedly abducted and taken to Amber Villa, and held there for four days, during which he was assaulted, filmed under duress, and threatened with false implication in a narcotics case if he didn't pay ₹64 lakh. Under pressure, he transferred ₹23 lakh, including payments to Puja's assistant in Kolkata and RTGS transactions to Puja and Kunal's accounts. Malabika's post calls the incident not just a crime, but a deep betrayal: 'This has caused irreparable emotional and psychological harm. We're pursuing justice and urge others to be cautious about the company they keep.' "Lowest phase of our lives": Puja Banerjee, Kunal Verma share their side We have reached out to Puja Banerjee for her response but she didn't comment on the topic. Days before the FIR was filed against her and husband Kunal Verma, the couple uploaded a video on their YouTube channel, titled 'LOWEST PHASE OF OUR LIVES .. NEED UR SUPPORT , AND PRAYERS IN THIS DIFFICULT TIMES' . In it, they alleged they were victims of a financial betrayal by someone they considered close—claiming they lost their life savings, had to mortgage their home, and were left emotionally and financially devastated. Watch it here: Payment transfer confirmation to Puja on 2nd June before Rescue Payment confirmation sent to Kunal Verma with date and subsequent threats. 'I am not saying that the money they demanded was compensation for the abduction. Yes, we had professional transactions. But no business loss, no due payment can justify this kind of madness. Abduction or kidnapping can never be a fair or lawful way to settle anything. There is no excuse for what happened,' - Shyam Sunder Dey. Acceptance of Rs 13 lacs payment in Kolkata by Puja Banerjee's assistant, Munmum.
Indian Express
6 hours ago
- Indian Express
Visitors at China zoo pull tiger hair for ‘good luck', spark outrage
A group of visitors at a zoo in Liaoning province, northeastern China, has drawn criticism after a video showed them pulling out hair from a resting tiger through a metal fence, reported South China Morning Post (SCMP). The incident occurred on June 8 in a special viewing area where big cats typically lie atop a steel tunnel. The video, which has since gone viral, captures a woman urging others to 'pull more' because tiger hair is believed to 'keep evil away and protect the home.' Several others followed suit, with some tying the tufts of tiger fur to their handbags. One man posed proudly with the hair, calling it the 'best souvenir — and free.' In traditional Chinese culture, tiger hair is thought to ward off evil spirits and bring good luck. However, many social media users were quick to condemn the act. The video has received over 700,000 views online, with commenters calling the tourists 'selfish and ignorant.' According to mainland outlet Dianshi News (via SCMP), zoo staff said they have repeatedly tried to stop visitors from touching the animals but haven't been successful. An animal keeper noted that touching or provoking animals is strictly prohibited and can cause distress. Experts have warned that such behavior is dangerous. Pulling a tiger's hair can not only cause pain to the tiger but also provoke aggression, putting both the animal and humans at risk. So far, it's unclear if the individuals involved will face any punishment. Zhu Wei, a law expert at the China University of Political Science and Law, told SCMP that zoo visitors can face civil penalties for harming animals, including fines, warnings, or even detention under Chinese law. Online, many called for stronger physical barriers and stricter enforcement to prevent similar incidents. One social media user commented: 'Animals and tourists should be equals in a zoo. It is the zoo's duty to keep the animals safe.' Others echoed similar sentiments. This is not an isolated incident. In May, a photographer at a scenic spot in Xinjiang was filmed throwing stones at a swan to keep it awake for better photos. (With inputs from South China Morning Post)
NDTV
7 hours ago
- NDTV
Japanese Woman Returns Home From Work, Finds Underwear-Clad Boss In Her Bed
The Japanese police have arrested a man after he was found lying in his employee's bed, only wearing his underwear. The unidentified woman in her 20s, from Japan's western Fukuoka Prefecture, had returned to home during lunch break to pick up some belongings when she discovered her boss on the bed in a compromising position. The woman calmly left the apartment, shut the door behind and immediately alerted the police. Authorities later arrested the man in the vicinity of her residence, according to a report in the South China Morning Post. The unidentified 47-year-old boss told the police during interrogation that he liked the woman and wanted to know more about her. However, it wasn't the first time he had sneaked into her room. The police are now investigating how he managed to get access and whether he may have installed any illegal surveillance devices. The woman had been completely unaware of any prior break-ins. The incident went viral on Japanese social media, with users demanding that authorities take strict action against the boss. 'I hope he did not go back to work like nothing had happened, and I hope the woman does not end up quitting her job,' said one user. Another added: "I think it was fortunate that she happened to go home to pick stuff up; otherwise she might have remained ignorant about the previous break-ins by her pervert boss and his behaviour would have become more dangerous," another said. Workplace harassment in Japan has become a much-discussed subject in recent times. In February, Japanese women started sharing their workplace harassment stories in the wake of Masahiro Nakai settling his sexual assault case. Nakai, a former member of the hugely popular boy band SMAP, allegedly sexually assaulted a woman at a private dinner that was arranged by a senior member of staff at Fuji TV, one of Japan's biggest broadcasters. The network came under scrutiny from workers who claimed that female employees were routinely pressured to "entertain" famous male celebrities. A Japanese equivalent of #MeToo called watashi ga taishoku shita hontou no riyuu (The real reason I quit my job) started trending on X (formerly Twitter) with women documenting their horrifying stories.
