Bulk bill incentive could miss thousands of GP clinics
Labor's $7.9 billion plan to expand the Bulk Billing Incentive Program to include non-concession patients projected the number of fully bulk-billing GP clinics to rise to 4800.
But healthcare directory operator Cleanbill estimates the number of entirely bulk-billing clinics will rise by just 740 to 2081 because incentive payments will not cover consultation costs for certain clinics.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler slammed the report as inaccurate and fundamentally flawed.
"This is a headline-grabbing phone poll conducted by a private company whose own website says their data is not 'reliable, accurate, complete or suitable'," Mr Butler said in a statement.
"For the first time, Labor will expand bulk-billing incentives to all Australians and create an additional new incentive payment for practices that bulk bill every patient."
From November 1, clinics that bulk bill every patient will receive a 12.5 per cent payment for each consultation, along with a conditional, variable payment depending on the clinic's remoteness.
The report found it would only make sense for clinics to accept the Bulk Billing Incentive if their out-of-pocket costs were lower than the national average, or if they were more remote and attracted a higher incentive contribution.
"The vast majority (72 per cent) of GP clinics are located in metro areas, where the New Total Medicare Payment is still $16 below the current average total cost of a non-bulk-billed standard consultation," the Cleanbill report said.
It estimated the economic effect of the Bulk Billing Incentive expansion would need to be between 20 per cent and 30 per cent greater than the actual amount of the incentive payment for 4800 clinics to become fully bulk-billing as a result of the change.
Patients whose clinics did not switch to fully bulk billing would face higher out-of-pocket costs in future, Cleanbill said.
The federal health department said the report was based on a false assumption that if a GP did not bulk bill every patient, they bulk billed none.
A plan to boost the number of fully bulk-billing general practice clinics is likely to fall dramatically short of forecasts, a healthcare directory operator warns.
Labor's $7.9 billion plan to expand the Bulk Billing Incentive Program to include non-concession patients projected the number of fully bulk-billing GP clinics to rise to 4800.
But healthcare directory operator Cleanbill estimates the number of entirely bulk-billing clinics will rise by just 740 to 2081 because incentive payments will not cover consultation costs for certain clinics.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler slammed the report as inaccurate and fundamentally flawed.
"This is a headline-grabbing phone poll conducted by a private company whose own website says their data is not 'reliable, accurate, complete or suitable'," Mr Butler said in a statement.
"For the first time, Labor will expand bulk-billing incentives to all Australians and create an additional new incentive payment for practices that bulk bill every patient."
From November 1, clinics that bulk bill every patient will receive a 12.5 per cent payment for each consultation, along with a conditional, variable payment depending on the clinic's remoteness.
The report found it would only make sense for clinics to accept the Bulk Billing Incentive if their out-of-pocket costs were lower than the national average, or if they were more remote and attracted a higher incentive contribution.
"The vast majority (72 per cent) of GP clinics are located in metro areas, where the New Total Medicare Payment is still $16 below the current average total cost of a non-bulk-billed standard consultation," the Cleanbill report said.
It estimated the economic effect of the Bulk Billing Incentive expansion would need to be between 20 per cent and 30 per cent greater than the actual amount of the incentive payment for 4800 clinics to become fully bulk-billing as a result of the change.
Patients whose clinics did not switch to fully bulk billing would face higher out-of-pocket costs in future, Cleanbill said.
The federal health department said the report was based on a false assumption that if a GP did not bulk bill every patient, they bulk billed none.
A plan to boost the number of fully bulk-billing general practice clinics is likely to fall dramatically short of forecasts, a healthcare directory operator warns.
Labor's $7.9 billion plan to expand the Bulk Billing Incentive Program to include non-concession patients projected the number of fully bulk-billing GP clinics to rise to 4800.
But healthcare directory operator Cleanbill estimates the number of entirely bulk-billing clinics will rise by just 740 to 2081 because incentive payments will not cover consultation costs for certain clinics.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler slammed the report as inaccurate and fundamentally flawed.
"This is a headline-grabbing phone poll conducted by a private company whose own website says their data is not 'reliable, accurate, complete or suitable'," Mr Butler said in a statement.
"For the first time, Labor will expand bulk-billing incentives to all Australians and create an additional new incentive payment for practices that bulk bill every patient."
From November 1, clinics that bulk bill every patient will receive a 12.5 per cent payment for each consultation, along with a conditional, variable payment depending on the clinic's remoteness.
The report found it would only make sense for clinics to accept the Bulk Billing Incentive if their out-of-pocket costs were lower than the national average, or if they were more remote and attracted a higher incentive contribution.
"The vast majority (72 per cent) of GP clinics are located in metro areas, where the New Total Medicare Payment is still $16 below the current average total cost of a non-bulk-billed standard consultation," the Cleanbill report said.
It estimated the economic effect of the Bulk Billing Incentive expansion would need to be between 20 per cent and 30 per cent greater than the actual amount of the incentive payment for 4800 clinics to become fully bulk-billing as a result of the change.
Patients whose clinics did not switch to fully bulk billing would face higher out-of-pocket costs in future, Cleanbill said.
The federal health department said the report was based on a false assumption that if a GP did not bulk bill every patient, they bulk billed none.
A plan to boost the number of fully bulk-billing general practice clinics is likely to fall dramatically short of forecasts, a healthcare directory operator warns.
Labor's $7.9 billion plan to expand the Bulk Billing Incentive Program to include non-concession patients projected the number of fully bulk-billing GP clinics to rise to 4800.
But healthcare directory operator Cleanbill estimates the number of entirely bulk-billing clinics will rise by just 740 to 2081 because incentive payments will not cover consultation costs for certain clinics.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler slammed the report as inaccurate and fundamentally flawed.
"This is a headline-grabbing phone poll conducted by a private company whose own website says their data is not 'reliable, accurate, complete or suitable'," Mr Butler said in a statement.
"For the first time, Labor will expand bulk-billing incentives to all Australians and create an additional new incentive payment for practices that bulk bill every patient."
From November 1, clinics that bulk bill every patient will receive a 12.5 per cent payment for each consultation, along with a conditional, variable payment depending on the clinic's remoteness.
The report found it would only make sense for clinics to accept the Bulk Billing Incentive if their out-of-pocket costs were lower than the national average, or if they were more remote and attracted a higher incentive contribution.
"The vast majority (72 per cent) of GP clinics are located in metro areas, where the New Total Medicare Payment is still $16 below the current average total cost of a non-bulk-billed standard consultation," the Cleanbill report said.
It estimated the economic effect of the Bulk Billing Incentive expansion would need to be between 20 per cent and 30 per cent greater than the actual amount of the incentive payment for 4800 clinics to become fully bulk-billing as a result of the change.
Patients whose clinics did not switch to fully bulk billing would face higher out-of-pocket costs in future, Cleanbill said.
The federal health department said the report was based on a false assumption that if a GP did not bulk bill every patient, they bulk billed none.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
Organ donation: Teddy Forster died before he got a new heart. A simple reform may have helped him
Teddy Forster died last year at age 20 months after waiting for a heart transplant. While Noah's cardiomyopathy is less serious than Teddy's – Noah is not currently on the waiting list for a heart transplant – he was nonetheless transferred from Perth to Melbourne after a series of back-to-back viruses that could have attacked his already fragile heart. Noah may also need a heart transplant one day. Sinead and Alex decided to share their family's story given Australia's heart transplant waiting list is at a five-year-high. The Allan government has still not overhauled how Victorians sign up to the organ donation register, more than a year after a parliamentary inquiry recommended linking registrations to driver's licence renewals. 'You never think the unthinkable will happen to you,' Sinead says. 'You don't want to plan for the worst day of your life. But families need to have those conversations. They need to be prepared so that if it happens, you don't need to think about it.' Loading Australia operates an opt-in system for organ donation, like the United States and Canada, and families are also asked for their consent. Jurisdictions such as Wales, Iceland and the Netherlands have adopted opt-out systems where people have to tell authorities about any religious or cultural objections. Research has shown as many as four out of five Australians support organ and tissue donation, but only one in three are registered on the Australian Organ Donor Register. South Australia leads the nation, with 74 per cent of eligible individuals signed up as organ donors, more than twice the national average. The South Australian government says this is because it was the first state in Australia to allow people to become a registered donor through their driver's licences. Only 23 per cent of Victorians are on the register, according to the recent inquiry, a figure well below the national average. Services Australia data shows that registrations are as low as 10 and 15 per cent in pockets of Melbourne's north and western suburbs. Beechworth, Yackandandah, Chiltern and Rutherglen, all in the state's north-east, have the highest level of registrations, at 42 per cent of the population. Dr Rohit D'Costa, the medical director of DonateLife Victoria, said older people shouldn't assume they wouldn't be suitable candidates for organ donation. 'People rule themselves out of being a donor, saying 'nobody would want my organs', but we've had donors well into their 80s. That liver tissue can last for many years after the donation,' D'Costa says. He says an older donor's kidneys and lungs could function for a decade or more in a recipient, and one organ donor can save as many as seven lives. Loading 'Adult donors can help little children. It's possible to do what's called a split liver, where part of the liver goes to an adult and the smaller lobe goes to a child. One adult can help multiple people with their generosity.' D'Costa hopes Victoria will soon shift to the model where people are prompted to register to be a donor whenever they renew their driver's licences. Opposition health spokeswoman Georgie Crozier says she will back such a proposal, which would retain Victoria's opt-in system. 'I don't think enough is being done by government to increase awareness,' Crozier says. An Allan government spokesperson says Labor will respond to the recent parliamentary inquiry later this year. 'We'll have more to say soon,' the spokesperson says. Meanwhile, 105-or-so Australians are waiting for a heart transplant, up from 64 this time last year. Noah Forster isn't one of them. For now. 'He's getting stronger every day,' mum Sinead says, wiping away tears. Start the day with a summary of the day's most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
Sky News AU
7 hours ago
- Sky News AU
'Not up for negotiation': Aussies expected to save $200m a year from major cap on PBS-listed scripts despite tariff threats to industry
Millions of Australians are expected to save $200m in vital medication fees as a landmark bill caps the price of Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) prescriptions at just $25, down from $31.60. The bill is set to take effect from January 1, as the Labor government takes the first steps to legislate the bill and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese vows to keep his election pledge on cost of living relief. The changes mean the cost of medicines on the PBS could be significantly reduced by over 20 per cent. Minister for Health, Mark Butler said five million Australians will feel the relief in their pockets. The cost of medicine for pension and concession card holders will remain frozen at $7.70 until the end of 2029. The bill which was announced by Labor during the May election campaign is expected to cost the budget $690m over four years. Mr Albanese said it built on a pledge for cost of living relief. 'This is another example of cost of living relief that helps every Australian,' he said. 'The size of your bank balance shouldn't determine the quality of your healthcare. My government will continue to deliver cost of living relief for all Australians.' Mr Butler added general patients' medicines haven't been this cheap since 2004. 'The Albanese Government has been focused on delivering cheaper medicines for Australians," he said. 'Cheaper medicines are good for the hip pocket and good for your health." The Assistant Health Minister, Emma McBride said the bill was set to pass despite US President Donald Trump's 200 per cent tariff threat on pharmaceutical imports. The US is Australia's biggest pharmaceutical export market and if the tariff is implemented it could cost the Australian economy up to $2.8 billion and force pharmas' to hike up their prices. However, Ms McBride said the PBS is not up for negotiation and "it is not a bargaining chip". "Labor introduced the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme to make sure that essential medicines were available to all Australians, and with this introduction of legislation to enact our election commitment, it will mean a cap on $25, which will save Australians about $200 million a year, 5.1 million Australians estimated to benefit," she said.
Sky News AU
8 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Labor's move to reduce PBS prescription cost will save Australians $200 million a year
The Albanese government is set to reduce PBS prescription prices to $25. Health Minister Mark Butler said the move will save five million Australian patients $200 million a year.
