Chair announced to lead Finucane inquiry
Sir Gary Hickinbottom has been appointed by the government to chair the inquiry into the murder of Belfast solicitor Pat Finucane.
Last September, it was announced that an independent public inquiry into the circumstances of Mr Finucane's death would be set up.
The 39-year-old was shot at his home in Belfast by loyalist paramilitaries in front of his wife and children.
Several examinations of the case have found evidence of state collusion in the killing.
The Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn said that the "exceptional reason" of outstanding and unfulfilled commitments by previous UK governments to establish a public inquiry meant it should proceed.
The inquiry will be established under the 2005 Inquiries Act, with full powers, including the power to compel the production of documents and to summon witnesses to give evidence on oath.
Sir Gary is a former Court of Appeals judge who also chaired the Post Office Overturned Convictions Independent Pecuniary Losses Assessment Panel and the Horizon Convictions Redress Panel.
The government has also confirmed the appointment of former Police Ombudsman Baroness Nuala O'Loan, and international human rights lawyer Francesca Del Mese, as assessors to the inquiry.
Confirming the announcement via a written statement to parliament, Benn said: "The murder of Mr Finucane was a barbarous and heinous crime and one which continues to highlight the legacy of the Troubles in Northern Ireland.
"I commend and support the tireless campaign of Mrs Finucane and her family in seeking answers to the brutal murder of their loved one and I am confident that this Inquiry will provide answers to the family who have suffered so terribly."
Benn said he was delighted that the chair had accepted the position.
"I am confident that, together, their valuable knowledge, experience and professionalism will be of great benefit to the work of the Inquiry," he said.
Sir Gary said he was "privileged" to take on responsibility for leading the public inquiry.
"At the heart of this case lies a family who lost their husband and father in horrific circumstances, and I look forward to meeting the Finucane family in Belfast as soon as possible," he added.
The government said it will undertake a consultation exercise with the chair on the proposed terms of reference for the inquiry, which will be agreed and published in due course.
Pat Finucane was a well-known defence solicitor who frequently acted for high profile IRA members.
He also represented loyalists in his work.
In February 1989 he was shot 14 times by two gunmen.
His wife, Geraldine, was also wounded.
One of his sons is the Sinn Féin MP John Finucane.
At an inquest into his death police refuted claims that Mr Finucane was in the IRA.
In 2012, Sir Desmond de Silva's report into the murder found there was agent involvement and that police took no action on threat intelligence regarding Mr Finucane.
Q&A: The murder of Pat Finucane
As it happened: Public inquiry ordered into Pat Finucane's murder
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
6 hours ago
- Politico
PhRMA bolsters its lobbying lineup
Presented by Recycled Materials Association With Daniel Lippman PhRMA HIRES RUBIN TURNBULL: Florida transplants Rubin Turnbull & Associates have registered to lobby for the brand name drug lobby PhRMA. The trade group retained Rubin Turnbull in March to lobby on a range of issues related to the drug industry, according to a newly filed disclosure. — It's the third new outside lobbying hire for PhRMA this year, after the organization hired DLA Piper and GOP lobbyist Doug Schwartz of HillNorth at the beginning of January. — PhRMA's latest hire came about a month into vocal industry skeptic Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s tenure atop the Health and Human Services Departmen. He has heaped criticism on vaccines and blamed drug industry lobbying for contributing to chronic disease among children in a report last month. — The industry already has no shortage of lobbying prowess, of course, with more than 40 other outside firms on retainer and lobbying outlays of $12.9 million just in Q1 of 2025 — a quarterly record. MORE IRA TAX CREDIT LOBBYING: Energizer Holdings has brought on Washington Council Ernst & Young for help salvaging an Inflation Reduction Act incentive for advanced manufacturing of products like batteries and battery components. — Tommy Brown, who worked in Treasury's legislative affairs office during the Biden administration, will work on the account along with Bob Schellhas, Evan Giesemann and Ryan Abraham, who was the Democratic tax counsel on the Senate Finance Committee during negotiations on the 2017 GOP tax bill, according to a disclosure filing. — The battery behemoth previously had just one other outside lobbying firm — Holland & Knight — on its roster. — Meanwhile, the Residential Solar Association retained a team of lobbyists at Becker & Poliakoff that includes a former chief of staff to Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.) to help save the IRA's residential clean energy credit and the clean electricity investment credit, according to a disclosure filing. TGIF and welcome to PI. Send K Street tips and gossip. You can add me on Signal, email me at coprysko@ and be sure to follow me on X: @caitlinoprysko. NEW BUSINESS: Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck has signed more than a dozen new clients, including chrome and nickel mining giant Corex Holdings, insulin management software company Glytec, and the philanthropy Daniels Fund. — Florida-based grocery chain Publix, meanwhile, has hired Ballard Partners to lobby on labor issues, compliance with environmental regulations and PBM reforms, according to a disclosure. — And Moody's Corp., the parent company of the credit rating service that downgraded the creditworthiness of the U.S. last month — eliciting brushback from the White House — has hired Republican firm CGCN Group. CGCN's Sam Geduldig, Ja'Ron Smith and Scott Riplinger began working on April 30 to provide 'education on economic trends impacting the global economy,' according to a disclosure filing. MORE TRUMP FALLOUT IN BIG LAW: 'Seven partners at Willkie Farr & Gallagher, a prominent law firm that cut a deal with President Trump to head off a potentially crippling executive order, announced on Friday that they were departing to join a firm that helped successfully challenge one of Mr. Trump's orders in court,' The New York Times' Mike Schmidt and Maggie Haberman report. — 'The decision by the partners, who are leaving Willkie Farr to join the law firm Cooley, is the latest of several high-profile departures of lawyers from firms that cut deals with the president. Cooley represented Jenner & Block in that firm's legal efforts to challenge an executive order rather than settle with the president. Last month, a federal judge struck down the executive order against Jenner, saying it was 'doubly violative of the Constitution.'' — 'Two of the partners leaving Willkie led its San Francisco office: Benedict Y. Hur and Simona Agnolucci, who served as a member of the firm's executive committee. Both are litigators and have told others they were extremely disappointed that the firm capitulated to Mr. Trump, according to two people briefed on the matter.' — Those departures are the 'latest reshuffling amid the fallout from the executive orders. In just the past month, six top partners at the law firm Paul Weiss, the first firm to cut a deal with Mr. Trump, decided to leave. Four of them started their own law firm, while another joined one of the other firms that has successfully fought Mr. Trump in court.' CVS TROUBLE ON THE BAYOU: 'Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill announced Thursday she is investigating whether pharmaceutical giant CVS improperly used customers' personal information to send out text messages lobbying against a proposed state law' that would have prohibited companies like CVS from owning both PBMs and drug stores, per the Associated Press' Sara Cline and Jack Brook. — 'Murrill also said she plans to issue a cease-and-desist letter to the company to stop the messages. As lawmakers debated a now-failed bill on Wednesday they held up screenshots of text messages sent by CVS.' — 'Last minute legislation in Louisiana threatens to close your CVS Pharmacy — your medication cost may go up and your pharmacist may lose their job,' one text obtained by The AP read. The company's texts 'to Louisiana residents included a link to a draft letter urging lawmakers to oppose the legislation that someone could sign with their email address and send to legislators.' ANNALS OF CAMPAIGN FINANCE: 'The House Ethics Committee is launching a subpanel to review its guidance on campaign activities,' POLITICO's Hailey Fuchs writes. A new working group led by Texas Reps. Nathaniel Moran, a Republican, and Sylvia Garcia, a Democrat, will 'review and make recommendations to improve, clarify, and modernize the Committee's guidance regarding campaign activity by House Members, officers, and employees,' according to the panel. — 'It's unclear what prompted the committee to create a new body tasked with improving resources around campaign activity rules. A spokesperson for the Ethics Committee did not respond to a series of questions about the working group.' — 'However, a number of lawmakers have been dogged by allegations in recent years that they violated rules around campaigning — including, for example, accepting a campaign donation in connection to some kind of official action as a lawmaker.' FOR YOUR RADAR: 'As the Trump administration considers approving a proposed merger between two of the world's largest advertising agencies, Omnicom Group and Interpublic Group, regulators may impose unusual conditions,' per NYT's Lauren Hirsch, Benjamin Mullin, Kate Conger and Tiffany Hsu. — 'A proposed consent decree would prevent the merged company from boycotting platforms because of their political content by refusing to place their clients' advertisements on them, according to two people briefed on the matter.' — 'The restrictions being discussed by the Federal Trade Commission as part of its merger review are part of an effort by the Trump administration to use federal agencies to root out what it considers political bias in corporate America against conservative voices and causes.' — Omnicom has faced scrutiny from Republicans in Washington for its participation in the advertising coalition Global Alliance for Responsible Media, which launched in 2019 in an effort to persuade social media companies to tighten up their content moderation policies. — The group came into the spotlight more recently for recommending a pause for advertising on X following Elon Musk's takeover of the company, triggering an antitrust lawsuit from Musk and prompting the alliance to shut down not long after, though the alliance maintained it had done nothing wrong. Jobs report — Patrick McGill is now director of client services at StackAdapt. He previously was lead associate account director at Trade Desk. — Joe Grogan and John Czwartacki have launched Public Policy Solutions. Grogan is a Trump OMB and Domestic Policy Council alum. Czwartacki is a Trump OMB and CFPB alum. — Jesse Binnall and former Rep. John Sweeney (R-N.Y.) have launched King Street Solutions, a boutique government affairs firm. Binnall currently is a partner at Binnall Law Group. — NCTA announced two major retirements: Rick Chessen, senior vice president of legal and regulatory affairs and chief legal officer, and Mark Bell, senior vice president of creative services. Chessen will be succeeded by Russ Hanser, who joined NCTA in 2024 by way of the Commerce Department. Kristin Buch, who joined NCTA in 2012 and currently serves as NCTA's veep of creative services, will ascend to Bell's role. — Anthony DiGrado is joining ClearPath as a senior manager. He was previously the director of public affairs at the Plastics Industry Association. — Liya Rechtman has joined Evergreen Action as senior transportation policy lead. She previously worked as an environmental protection specialist at DOT. New Joint Fundraisers Frontline Organizing for Representation, Change & Equity (FORCE) PAC (Reps. Emilia Sykes, Steven Horsford, Jahana Hayes, Don Davis, Janelle Bynum) New PACs CITIZENS FOR A HEALTHY NEW MEXICO (Hybrid PAC) Nezarus (PAC) Rising Dems (Hybrid PAC) New Lobbying REGISTRATIONS Agios Pharmaceuticals: Agios Pharmaceuticals Asha Strategies LLC: Nigerian Physician Advocacy Group Ballard Spahr LLP: Wallenius Wilhelmsen Ocean As Barker Leavitt, Pllc (Ska Mr. James C. Barker): Advantage Capital Boundary Stone Partners: The Ray Breakaway: Arnall Golden Gregory (On Behalf Of The Local Housing Administrators Coalition) Breakaway: National Rental Home Council Breakaway: Pretium Breakaway: U.S. Mortgage Insurers Capitol Hill Consulting Group: Acadiana Regional Airport Capitol Hill Consulting Group: United Network For Organ Sharing Cgcn Group, LLC: Moody's Corporation Crossroads Strategies, LLC: The Law Offices Of Christopher E. Chang On Behalf Of Mr. Jerry Wang Ernst & Young LLP (Washington Council Ernst & Young): Energizer Holdings Inc. Fierce Government Relations: Haas Automation, Inc. Invariant LLC: American Automotive Leasing Association Invariant LLC: Mysten Labs, Inc. John Watts: California Natural Resources Agency K&L Gates, LLP: Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority Lot Sixteen LLC: American Physical Society Mike Williams Capitol Strategies LLC (F/K/A Mw Capitol Strategies LLC): Andronaco Industries Mike Williams Capitol Strategies LLC (F/K/A Mw Capitol Strategies LLC): Waterfleet LLC Oculus Strategies, LLC: The Livingston Group, LLC Obob Health Supply LLC O'Neill And Associates: Cora Systems US Inc Rubin, Turnbull & Associates: Phrma Rubin, Turnbull & Associates: Universal Technical Institute Rubin, Turnbull & Associates: USantibotics Strategics Consulting, LLC: Town Of Stanley The Friedlander Group: Logista Advisors LLC The Roosevelt Group: Thermoanalytics New Lobbying Terminations Invariant LLC: Nextdoor Law Offices Of Frederick H. Graefe, Pllc: National Medical Funding Services Richard Sawaya: Halliburton Energy Services
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
Benn defends collaboration with Irish Government over legacy issues
Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn has said he will make no apology for working with the Irish Government on legacy issues after the leader of the DUP launched a stinging attack on his approach. Mr Benn was responding after Gavin Robinson branded the UK Government minister as 'foolish and hapless' in relation to his handling of efforts to deal with the legacy of the Troubles. Mr Robinson claimed Mr Benn's actions amounted to a 'disgraceful' attempt to 'satisfy the Irish Government'. The Northern Ireland Secretary was asked about the remarks as he attended a meeting of the British Irish Council in Newcastle, Co Down on Friday. 'I make no apology at all for trying to work with the Irish Government, because the lesson, indeed exemplified by the Good Friday Agreement, is we make most progress when we work together,' he said. 'And that is what I'm determined to do in the interests of truth and reconciliation and, finally, giving answers to families who have suffered so much.' Mr Robinson's hard-hitting statement on Friday morning came amid mounting expectation that the two governments will soon set out an agreed framework for addressing legacy issues related to the Northern Ireland conflict. Also responding to the DUP leader's criticism, Irish premier Micheal Martin and deputy premier Simon Harris both moved to defend Mr Benn as they praised his efforts to work with their Government to try to resolve outstanding issues around unsolved murder cases and families who continue to seek truth and justice for lost loved ones. They also rejected Mr Robinson's assertion that the Dublin government has adopted a 'scandalous approach to legacy' in failing to rigorously investigate and provide answers on atrocities with a cross-border dimension. The DUP leader made his statement after Mr Benn announced the appointment of a chair to lead a public inquiry into the 1989 loyalist murder of Belfast solicitor Pat Finucane. Mr Robinson believes the Finucane case is indicative of a government approach that sees the 'distasteful elevation' of some high-profile cases while countless other victims still await answers with no prospect of public inquiries. The DUP leader claimed 'Hapless Hilary' was pursing this stance while continuing to keep private any details on what he was negotiating with the Irish Government. 'The Irish Government have knowledge of and influence upon UK legacy plans, yet Northern Ireland victims, veterans and Parliamentarians are kept in the dark by the Secretary of State without so much as a blush on his face,' he said. 'Not for the first time, he advances a one-sided, partisan approach to the politics of Northern Ireland.' Since taking office last year, the Labour Government has pledged to repeal and replace some of the provisions of the contentious Legacy Act that was introduced by the last Conservative government, and bring forward a revised framework for dealing with cases linked to the Troubles. The Irish Government has been involved in the process, and political leaders in Dublin have said intensive engagement is ongoing to see if a 'landing zone' can be arrived at. The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 halted scores of civil cases and inquests into Troubles deaths and also offered conditional immunity to perpetrators of conflict-related crimes in exchange for their co-operation with a new investigatory and truth recovery body. The Act was opposed by all the main political parties in Northern Ireland, the Irish government and many victims' representative groups. In 2023, the Irish government initiated an interstate legal case against the UK in the European Court of Human Rights, claiming the Legacy Act breached the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). The case remains active, with ministers in Dublin wanting to see how Labour resolves its concerns over the legislation before any decision is taken to withdraw the action. Mr Benn told reporters in Newcastle that it was incumbent on all political leaders to finally secure agreement on legacy. 'Legacy is the unfinished business of the Good Friday Agreement,' he said. 'It was the issue which the Good Friday Agreement, which achieved so much, was unable to take forward. 'And I would simply say we, all of us, as politicians, as leaders, have a responsibility to try and find a way forward so that we can bring truth and justice for everyone, in particular for the families who, after decades, are still waiting for answers as to what happened to their loved ones when they were murdered.' At the press conference after the BIC, Mr Martin made a point of backing Mr Benn's stance. 'I firstly want to pay tribute to the Secretary of State for his honesty, his determination in the way he has pursued this issue of legacy, and indeed many other issues since he became Secretary of State,' he said. 'And we have welcomed his very open and determined approach. I would never question his bona fides in doing the very best for the people of Northern Ireland, and in terms of ensuring a very strong relationship between British and Irish Governments.' Mr Harris, who also attended the BIC summit, said the Governments were 'close to a way forward on legacy'. The Tanaiste added: 'And what I would say to Gavin, respectfully, and I said this to him when I met him, the country that I represent will play our part as well in relation to legacy, and we've shown that already on a number of occasions, and we will absolutely in any legacy framework want to make sure that all victims, all families, regardless of where on the island of Ireland an atrocity occurs, can get answers, can get truth, and can, of course, get justice where possible.' DUP deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly echoed the sentiments expressed by her party leader as she answered questions on the controversy following the BIC. 'I think there's a lot to be critical about in terms of the approach to legacy by the Secretary of State,' she said. Ms Little-Pengelly said many of the issues Mr Benn was considering related to matters that were devolved to Stormont. She added: 'For our part, we are absolutely clear that all victims should get access to justice. All victims should feel very clearly in our system that their loved ones mattered equally. 'Unfortunately, we've had a number of announcements on part of legacy, but not on the rest, and that leaves many victims and survivors concerned about what's happening in relation to that.'
Associated Press
14 hours ago
- Associated Press
Marcus Taylor should have been freed years ago. Mississippi courts refuse to release him
Marcus Taylor has been incarcerated for 10 years, serving a sentence that should have ended five years ago. In 2015, a judge sentenced the husband and father to 15 years in prison for conspiring to sell an opioid combination pain-relief medication – a schedule III controlled substance. But he spent eight years in jail before anyone realized the maximum sentence for his crime by law was five years. In May, the Mississippi Court of Appeals recognized that Taylor was serving a sentence 10 years longer than the legal maximum, but refused to order his release despite making note of the mistake, arguing that the issue was raised too late. Taylor, now 43, was indicted in 2014 on two counts of conspiracy to sell controlled substances, and one count of business burglary for breaking and entering a drugstore to steal them. In February 2015, he took what he thought was an advantageous deal: he pleaded guilty to the first count, and the two others were dismissed. But the plea petition was riddled with mistakes. It erroneously said the maximum sentence for conspiracy to sell schedule III controlled substances was 20 years – not five years. And no one in the court, including his lawyer, realized his sentence was 10 years longer than the legal maximum. It's only after he challenged his sentence in 2023, demanding eligibility for parole, that the problem surfaced. The Choctaw County Circuit Court denied Taylor's motion for post-conviction relief, because he filed it past the three-year deadline of his conviction. After investigating the issue for over a year, the appellate court ruled on May 6 this year that Taylor was indeed serving a sentence 10 years longer than authorized by law – meaning he should have been released in 2020. Yet, in a five-five decision, the court of appeals decided Taylor should still serve the rest of his wrongful sentence – because he didn't file his request in time. The court invoked a 2023 ruling by the Mississippi Supreme Court in Howell v. State of Mississippi, which put an end to the fundamental rights exception – an exemption to the three-year time limit to file a post-conviction relief claim, made to ensure individuals don't stay unconstitutionally incarcerated. The Mississippi Court of Appeals is obligated to follow the Supreme Court precedent, said Matthew Steffey, professor at the Mississippi College School of Law. 'This is the expected outcome of Howell, that there are going to be meritorious claims that are shut down for these technical limits,' he said. 'That's why many people, including dissenters on the Court of Appeals, believe it's wrong.' Indeed, despite this Supreme Court ruling, half the judges were ready to grant Taylor relief. 'All Mississippians have the right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment, and to incarcerate Taylor beyond the time authorized by law infringes upon that fundamental right,' Judge David Neil McCarty wrote in a dissenting opinion. But if the result is tied in a Court of Appeals, common practice calls for the court to confirm the original decision, Steffey said. On June 2, Taylor filed a motion for rehearing, asking the Court of Appeals to reconsider its application of Howell, saying his incarceration is a deprivation of his constitutional rights. But the Court of Appeals could still refuse to rehear the case. In case of an unfavorable ruling, Taylor's lawyer, Damon Stevenson, said they were ready to take the case to the Mississippi Supreme Court. If it agrees to examine Taylor's case, the Supreme Court could clarify how the law should be applied in cases like Taylor's. 'I do think one has to reinterpret Mississippi Supreme Court precedent to give Mr. Taylor relief, and that's more a job for the Supreme Court than the court of appeals,' Steffey said. Many hope Taylor's case and potential release could set a precedent and protect others in the same situation. Mississippi courts have refused to grant relief to incarcerated people serving expired sentences in the past, even before Howell. 'We could get a clear law in the state of Mississippi that says there are certain rights that are not abridged by time: at any point that injustice is recognized, the court can step in and right it,' Stevenson said. The escalation of the case has led the Capital Post-Conviction Counsel to step in. On June 4, it filed an amicus brief – additional information and legal arguments given to the court to assist them in their decision, in support of Taylor's motion for rehearing. Although the state office normally assists individuals sentenced to death in Mississippi, it has expertise in helping people file post-conviction petitions, just like Taylor. The attorney general's office, which represents the state of Mississippi in the case, rapidly opposed the counsel's intervention, demanding that the Court reject its brief. The AG's office argued that the Capital Post-Conviction Counsel's involvement was 'neither necessary nor appropriate,' and that it had filed the brief too late. To Stevenson, the attorney general's office's immediate opposition shows a broader pattern of combativeness against defendants, at the expense of fairness and justice. 'At this point, it's our position that Mr. Taylor has actually moved from being a defendant to a victim,' Stevenson said. 'The attorney general's office has to take an honest look at this case and say, 'Do we really want to be on the side of fighting for people to stay incarcerated who legally do not belong in a prison cell?'' Defendants' rights are often overlooked although they are an essential part of a fair judicial process, because severity sells electorally, and ultimately, judges are elected public officials, Steffey said. 'Judges campaign promising to be fair, or to be tough and fair, or to be tough, all of which sends a signal that they are part of the crime fighting community,' Steffey said. 'You hear a lot about justice for victims, very little about justice for the accused.' While the Court of Appeals still hasn't decided whether to rehear Taylor's case or not, his children are growing up without him. And his wife, Kimberly Brown Taylor, is raising them alone. When she started dating Taylor in 2008, Brown Taylor already had a baby, Joshua, who is 19 now. Taylor treated him like his own, she said. They still write each other letters. With Taylor, she had another son, Blakeland, who is 13 and has not seen his father since he got incarcerated when he was just a baby. 'It has been kind of hard on me as a single parent,' Brown Taylor said. ' I haven't slept at night at all since he's been gone.' When Taylor was incarcerated, Brown Taylor found herself having to assume the financial and personal charge of raising two kids. She went back to college and studied accounting. She worked two jobs until she became an accountant. Just like everyone else, she had no idea his sentence was above the legal maximum. She's angry about the time lost and worried about Taylor's mental health. 'For someone to sit in there past that time, I guess the extra five years, that can mess with someone mentally,' she said. 'He could have been there, being that father to my son, giving me relief, giving my son the loving that he needed.' Brown Taylor says she keeps Blakeland and Joshua informed about their dad's case everyday, but they still don't understand why he can't come home. Blakeland feels like a part of his childhood was stripped away. He said he wishes his father could watch his basketball games and participate in school father-son events with him. 'I just feel like my dad should be at home. It's eating me alive,' Blakeland said. Taylor might very well serve the five remaining years of his original sentence, if the Court of Appeals or the Mississippi Supreme Court don't rule in his favor. His lawyer argues he has far served his time, and should be brought back into the community. 'When people make mistakes, it is totally acceptable to ask them to pay their debt to society,' Stevenson said. 'However, their debt should not be greater than what is allowed by law.' Time passes and incomprehension grows in the Taylor family. It gets a little harder everyday to understand why Taylor remains incarcerated. 'God gives all of us chances after chances after chances. So why can't they or whomever allow Marcus to have a chance?' Brown Taylor said. ___ This story was originally published by Mississippi Today and distributed through a partnership with The Associated Press.
