Indonesia's costly bet on French Rafale jets under scrutiny after India-Pakistan aerial clash
Indonesia's high-stakes bet on French-made Rafale jets is facing scrutiny after Pakistan claimed to have shot down three of the same aircraft used by India, raising questions in Jakarta about the cost, capability and strategic logic behind the deal, which came with a price tag of more than US$8 billion.
The controversy erupted on May 7, when the Pakistan Army announced it had downed five Indian warplanes – including three Rafales – during an aerial clash, using its Chinese-made J-10C fighters equipped with advanced PL-15 air-to-air missiles.
While New Delhi has not verified the claims, Indian Air Force Air Marshal AK Bharti told reporters on Sunday that 'losses are a part of combat', without offering further details.
Hours after the air skirmish, CNN quoted an unnamed senior French intelligence official as confirming that one Indian Rafale had been shot down, which, the broadcaster noted, 'would mark the first time that one of the sophisticated French-made warplanes has been lost in combat'.
After India and Pakistan trade blows over Kashmir, will their ceasefire hold?
After India and Pakistan trade blows over Kashmir, will their ceasefire hold?
The development has triggered alarm in Indonesia, which last year concluded an order for 42 Rafale warplanes from their manufacturer, French aviation giant Dassault. In 2022, when Indonesia first initiated the order, a spokesman with France's defence ministry told reporters that the deal was worth US$8.1 billion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Trump's tariffs to squeeze Vietnam even if it lifts all duties on US goods: Lutnick
Washington will not reciprocate even if Hanoi removes all tariffs on American goods, according to US Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick, as he said Vietnam re-exports a significant volume of Chinese products to the US. Advertisement 'Absolutely not, absolutely not. That would be the silliest thing we could do,' Lutnick said when Republican Senator John Kennedy asked him whether the US will respond in kind if Vietnam decided to eliminate all tariffs and trade barriers against American imports, calling a potential agreement like that 'a terrible deal'. Lutnick added that Vietnam exported US$125 billion in goods to the US while only importing US$12.5 million worth of American products, without specifying a period. 'They buy US$90 billion from China, then they mark it up and send it to us. So it's just a pathway of China to us,' Lutnick said, though he suggested there might be some room for negotiations if Vietnam decides to stop re-exporting Chinese goods to the US. 05:19 How are Chinese citizens feeling the effects of the US-China tariff war? How are Chinese citizens feeling the effects of the US-China tariff war? A number of US brands, including Apple Inc. and Nike Inc., have manufacturing partners in Vietnam. Often these suppliers import materials and parts from China and conduct the final assembly in Vietnam. These American companies could be affected if US President Donald Trump eventually decides to slap stiff tariffs on the Asian nation.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
It will pay Hong Kong's workers to check their savings after MPF shake-up
Hong Kong's retirement savings scheme has had its fair share of criticism over the years. The meagre compulsory monthly contributions and relatively high administration fees charged by private service providers mean many retirees are struggling to make ends meet. Thankfully, a revamp is under way. It is welcome news that fees charged under the Mandatory Provident Fund (MPF) have fallen by 36 per cent since the launch of a centralised electronic platform last year, one of the scheme's most significant reforms since its introduction in 2000. The fee currently set at 37 basis points (0.37 per cent), which is 36 per cent lower than the average of 58 basis points (0.58 per cent) charged by trustees before switching to the e-platform, is expected to decrease gradually. The cumulative savings from lower fees are estimated to reach HK$30 billion to HK$40 billion (US$3.8 billion to US$5.1 billion) over a 10-year period, representing a decrease of 41 to 55 per cent in fees, according to the MPF authority. The massive savings speak volumes for the inadequacies of the previous arrangements. The eMPF was launched last June to provide a centralised online platform that would replace the separate systems used by 12 different operators, allowing all service providers, 367,000 employers and 4.75 million members to manage fund assets worth HK$1.338 trillion on a single platform on their mobile phones or computers. A quarter of the small and medium-tier accounts would have migrated to the platform by August. The top four players that manage 70 per cent of the MPF's assets are slated to move over between September and December – a process described as very challenging.
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
How Malaysia's wealth of produce inspires Japanese chef at K kaiseki in Kuala Lumpur
Almost five years after the 2020 closure of two-Michelin-star Tenku RyuGin in Tsim Sha Tsui, Hong Kong, former chef de cuisine Hidemichi Seki has embarked on his next culinary adventure. Advertisement He was on hiatus in his homeland, Japan, when the team from Malaysian hospitality group Ilham Dining Concepts (IDC) came knocking in 2022, inviting him to start his own restaurant in Kuala Lumpur. Seki launched his first restaurant, K, in February 2025. On the 37th floor of the Foster and Partners-designed Ilham Tower, the kaiseki restaurant offers a generous 15-course tasting menu. Despite receiving offers from restaurants in Japan, Seki chose to move to Malaysia's capital, wanting to see more of the world while still living close to nature. K kaiseki restaurant opened on the 37th floor of the Ilham Tower in Kuala Lumpur in March 2025. Photo: K Kuala Lumpur 'I've always wanted to gain more diverse experiences overseas and immerse myself in different cultures,' he says. Advertisement
