
Book dealer cleared of selling rare stolen Heaney books
A book dealer who claimed he bought two missing and "extraordinarily rare" Seamus Heaney first editions worth €2,000 at a bric-a-brac stall has walked free from court.
Seventy-year-old Alan Ladak of Fahy Gardens, Loughrea, Co Galway, admitted he was reckless in buying the books for about €40 each, hoping to sell them for a profit.
However, he pleaded not guilty at Dublin District Court to possessing stolen property, two books by the Nobel Prize-winning Derry poet, The Tollund Man worth €1,250, and Shivers valued at €750 last year.
The books previously disappeared from Kenny's Bookshop in Galway.
However, they were located after Mr Ladak later went to sell them to the Temple Bar Bookshop in Dublin between 1 May and 30 June and on 6 October 2024.
Granting a dismissal, Judge Adrian Harris accepted legal submissions from defence counsel Aoife Mutch, which focused on the lack of evidence presented in court, as the two books, after being returned, were re-sold before the trial.
Garda Alan Cawley questioned Mr Ladak, originally from England, who brought Shivers to the Temple Bar Bookshop on 6 October and returned four days later to complete the sale.
During the interview, Mr Ladak maintained that he had previously sold WB Yeats and Samuel Beckett books three or four times to the shop.
His statement recorded that he was offered €200 for Shivers on 6 October.
In his interview, he recalled selling The Tollund Man for €250 from May to June, the court heard.
However, the pensioner maintained that he bought each edition for about €40 from an anonymous bric-a-brac stall in the centre of Galway city.
He denied knowing they were stolen, but he agreed he had been reckless and was not diligent in establishing where the books came from, the court heard.
Mr Ladak admitted in his interview, "I thought they were cheap at the time, and I hoped to make money," but explained that it was difficult to say what they were worth, and he hoped to make €200 for each edition.
Asked why he came to Dublin to sell them, he told the garda that he had free travel, and it was a day out, and there were more shops there.
He thought it had been about ten years since he had gone to Kenny's Bookshop, which had moved to a new location.
In cross-examination, Ms Mutch questioned the garda about whether he had made enquiries in Galway into the unnamed bric-a-brac stall mentioned by her client.
He replied that he did not because Mr Ladak did not have a receipt, and he did not think he could find the stall.
The stolen books had since been returned to Kenny's Bookshop and were sold.
The garda agreed he did not have the actual originals in court.
The second witness, Tomás Kenny, of Kenny's Bookshop, said the store was the country's biggest dealer of rare books.
He recalled being contacted by Temple Bar books about the edition Mr Ladak had brought into them.
Mr Kenny said only 125 copies were printed.
He described that edition as "extraordinarily rare", having been signed to poet Gerard Fanning, and he added that publisher Peter Fallon had autographed the other book.
They had previously gone missing from his bookstore.
In defence submission, the defence barrister highlighted the use of hearsay evidence in the running of the prosecution case, which, she argued, affected her client's right to a fair trial.
She stressed that the books had not been brought to the hearing and seemed to now be in other people's hands, and the photocopy images of the books, tendered as evidence, did not show the inscriptions described by Mr Kenny.
Judge Harris accepted the points raised by the barrister and acquitted Mr Ladak, who was not required to testify during the hearing.
He was also found not guilty of unlawful possession of a knife he had on the date of his arrest.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


RTÉ News
5 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Judge declares mistrial on Harvey Weinstein rape charge
The judge overseeing Harvey Weinstein's criminal case in Manhattan has declared a mistrial on a rape charge, one day after the former Hollywood movie mogul was convicted on a felony sex abuse charge. Justice Curtis Farber ended the nearly seven-week trial after the jury foreperson refused to continue deliberations, following multiple days of reported dissension among jurors that at times was aired in the courtroom. Prosecutors said they will try Weinstein a third time on the charge of third-degree rape, over his alleged mistreatment of the aspiring actress Jessica Mann in 2013. Justice Farber said the case will proceed to trial, over the objections of Weinstein's lawyer Arthur Aidala, and set a hearing for 2 July. 73-year-old Weinstein had pleaded not guilty and has denied assaulting anyone or having non-consensual sex. He faces up to 25 years in prison for his conviction on a charge of first-degree criminal sexual act, stemming from his alleged assault of former production assistant Miriam Haley in 2006. Weinstein was also acquitted of the same charge over his alleged assault in 2002 of Kaja Sokola, then a 16-year-old aspiring actress. He is separately appealing a 2022 rape conviction in California, for which he was sentenced to 16 years in prison. Weinstein's downfall began in 2017 and helped spark the #MeToo movement, which encouraged women to come forward with allegations of sexual misconduct by powerful men. A different jury in the Manhattan court had found Weinstein guilty in 2020 of raping Ms Mann and sexually assaulting Ms Haley, but New York state's highest court overturned that conviction last year. More than 100 women have accused him of misconduct. The mistrial came one day after the jury foreperson told Justice Farber that other jurors were shouting at and threatening him for refusing to change his vote on the rape count. The foreperson did not indicate publicly how he planned to vote, and Justice Farber sent jurors home to cool off. In closing arguments on 3 June, the prosecution told the 12 jurors that the evidence showed how Weinstein used his power and influence to trap and abuse women. The defence countered that the accusers lied on the witness stand out of spite after their consensual sexual encounters with the Oscar-winning producer failed to result in Hollywood stardom. Weinstein, who has had many health problems in recent years and attended the retrial in a wheelchair, co-founded the Miramax studio, whose hit movies included such Academy Award winners as "Shakespeare in Love" and "Pulp Fiction." Weinstein's own eponymous film studio filed for bankruptcy in March 2018, five months after sexual misconduct accusations against him became widely publicised.


Irish Examiner
5 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Weinstein case judge declares mistrial on remaining rape charge amid jury issues
The judge in Harvey Weinstein's sex assaults trial declared a mistrial on the remaining rape charge after the jury foreperson said he would not continue deliberating. Deliberations ended on Thursday, a day after the jury delivered a partial verdict in Weinstein's sex crimes retrial. The jury foreperson said he would not continue deliberating after claiming he was bullied by another juror (Elizabeth Williams via AP) The jury got stuck on a third charge – a rape accusation dating to 2013. The foreperson complained on Wednesday that he felt bullied by another juror and said on Thursday he would not go back into the jury room. The panel convicted the former studio boss of one charge but acquitted him of another. Both of those charges concerned accusations of forcing oral sex on women in 2006. Those verdicts still stand. The jury of seven women and five men unanimously reached those decisions last Friday, the foreperson later told the judge. The verdict was delivered on Wednesday only because Judge Curtis Farber asked whether there was agreement on any of the charges. The third charge was a rape accusation involving a woman who also said she had a consensual relationship with the Oscar-winning producer. Under New York law, the third-degree rape charge carries a lesser penalty than the other two counts. Weinstein denies all the charges. In an unusual exchange with the judge, Harvey Weinstein told him the judge was 'endangering' him, saying 'I can't be judged by a situation that's going on like this' (Elizabeth Williams via AP) In an unusual exchange with the judge during some legal arguments before the partial verdict was disclosed on Wednesday, Weinstein insisted it was unfair to continue the trial after two jurors came forward with concerns about the proceedings. 'I can't be judged by a situation that's going on like this,' said Weinstein, 73, claiming the judge was 'endangering' him. Jury-room strains started leaking into public view on Friday when a juror asked to be excused because he felt another was being treated unfairly. Then on Monday, the foreperson complained that other jurors were pushing people to change their minds and talking about information beyond the charges. The man raised concerns again on Wednesday. In a closed-door discussion with prosecutors, defence lawyers and the judge, the foreperson said another juror was yelling at him for sticking to his opinion and at one point vowed, 'You going to see me outside.' 'I feel afraid inside there,' the foreperson told the judge and lawyers, according to a transcript. Weinstein's initial conviction five years ago seemed to cement the downfall of one of Hollywood's most powerful men in a pivotal moment for the #MeToo movement against sexual misconduct. Harvey Weinstein was convicted of one charge, was acquitted of another and a mistrial ruled on the third (Jefferson Siegel /The New York Times via AP, Pool) But that conviction was overturned last year and the case was sent back for retrial in the same Manhattan courthouse. Weinstein's accusers said he exploited his Tinseltown influence to dangle career help, get them alone and then trap and force them into sexual encounters. His defence portrayed his accusers as Hollywood wannabes and hangers-on who willingly hooked up with him to court opportunity, then later said they were victimised to collect settlement funds and #MeToo approbation. Miriam Haley, the producer and production assistant whom Weinstein was convicted – twice, now – of sexually assaulting, said outside court on Wednesday that the new verdict 'gives me hope'. Accuser Kaja Sokola also called it 'a big win for everyone,' even though Weinstein was acquitted of forcibly performing oral sex on her when she was a 19-year-old fashion model. Her allegation was added to the case after the retrial was ordered. Weinstein also was convicted of raping another woman in California. He is appealing that conviction. The Associated Press generally does not name people who say they have been sexually assaulted, unless they agree to be identified. Ms Haley and Ms Sokola did so.


The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Irish jockey Michael O'Sullivan's cause of death confirmed as inquest hears rider died from ‘traumatic brain injury'
CHELTENHAM Festival-winning jockey Michael O'Sullivan died from a 'severe, traumatic brain injury' due to a horse riding accident, his inquest has heard. 4 Michael O'Sullivan fell from his horse while racing at Thurles earlier this year Credit: PA 4 He suffered a 'severe, traumatic brain injury' Credit: PA Dr Bolster carried out a Mr O'Sullivan, from Currabower, Lombardstown, Co Cork died at Cork University The jockey was airlifted to hospital following the serious last fence fall in Thurles, Co He was just days short of his 25th birthday when he passed away ten days later. READ MORE IN HORSE RACING Sergeant Aisling Murphy requested an adjournment of the inquest into the death of the champion jockey to facilitate 'preparatory work'. Cork City Coroner Philip Comyn said the inquest was being opened for the purpose of hearing medical evidence on the cause of death so that a death certificate could be issued to the Inspector Justin Walsh, from the Health and Safety Authority, confirmed that their Solicitor Denis Linehan, who represents the O'Sullivan family, was also in attendance at the inquest. Most read in The Irish Sun A full hearing of the case will take place at a later date. Michael is survived by his parents William and Bernie, his brother Alan, his partner Charlotte and his grandmother Mary. Michael O'Sullivan's girlfriend hugs jockey Seán Flanagan after Marine Nationale wins at Cheltenham Michael shot to public attention in 2023 when he won the Supreme Novices' Hurdle at In an incredible twist of fate, both horses also won at the Festival this year, just under a month after he was laid to rest. LIFELONG DREAM His father William told mourners that He said that he had his heart set on being a jockey from an early age. Meanwhile, Michael's brother Alan and his cousins, David O'Sullivan and Sonny McCartan, recently took part in the Cork City Marathon to raise funds for Bru Columbanus, a throughout the county. They decided to raise funds for the site in Wilton in Cork as it was a 'safe haven' for the O'Sullivan family when Michael was in intensive care. Over €94,000 has been raised for the charity so far. Donations can still be made online at 4 Huge crowds attended his funeral at St John the Baptist Church in Glantane, Co Cork on February 19 Credit: PA 4 Michael shot to public attention in 2023 when he won the Supreme Novices' Hurdle at Cheltenham Credit: PA