Auckland Pastor Convicted, Church Fined For Unsafe Building
The Samoan Congregational Christian Church of New Zealand Māngere Trust and its pastor, Sean Palala, were sentenced at the Auckland District Court, for 15 charges of breaches to the Building Act and Resource Management Act.
The church and community centre, on McKenzie Road, Māngere, continued to be used for gatherings, even after being slapped with a dangerous building notice.
The church was fined $82,000 for a breach of abatement, breach of notice to fix, multiple breaches of enforcement orders and dangerous building notices, and ordered to pay a reparation to Auckland Council for costs.
Palala was convicted on all charges and sentenced to 400 hours community work and fined $7000 for his offending.
In a written statement, Auckland Council said the Court found the Trust had continued using the church building, in direct contravention of the interim enforcement order prohibiting its use from 2 May, 2023.
Gatherings continued on multiple occasions, despite a dangerous building notice also restricting access to the building.
At sentencing, council's head of prosecutions, John Kang, told the court the breaches of enforcement orders were "highly deliberate", committed while the defendants were awaiting sentence for the earlier offending.
Kang said that despite being personally warned by the Chief Environment Court Judge and served with the enforcement order on two separate occasions, Palala went on to breach the interim enforcement order on at least four occasions.
"Furthermore, a copy of the dangerous building notice remained affixed to the front window by the main entrance to the church building throughout the entire duration of the offending," Kang said.
In delivering his decision, Judge David Kirkpatrick found the prosecution's case had been proven beyond reasonable doubt.
"I find the Samoan Congregational Christian Church of New Zealand Māngere Trust and Sean Palala both guilty of the charges they face."
Judge Kirkpatrick emphasised the repetition of offending by the defendants was a "seriously aggravating factor", with no evidence that any steps had been taken either to fix or demolish the building.
Council's licensing and compliance field operations manager David Pawson said the court's verdict sent a strong message that ignoring enforcement orders and continuing to use unsafe buildings would not be tolerated.
"Compliance with building and resource consent laws is essential for the safety of our communities," he said.
He said council was committed to upholding the law and ensuring all structures met necessary safety and planning regulations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
6 days ago
- RNZ News
Auckland Council warns irresponsible dog owners to expect consequences
The council says too many dog owners are failing to take responsibility for their pets. (File photo) Photo: Irresponsible dog owners should expect to face consequences, Auckland Council has warned. The council said it had prosecuted 611 dog owners over the past five years for bites, maulings and other attacks. A New Lynn dog owner was most recently sentenced to 70 hours of community service and ordered to pay $500 in reparation after their rottweiler seriously injured a pedestrian in October 2023. The passerby was left with a 15 centimetre wound that required surgery. "Too many dog owners are failing to take responsibility. We are seeing a rise in serious attacks, and its clear many owners don't care, or don't believe they'll be held responsible," Auckland Council's general manager of compliance Robert Irvine said. "Let us be clear: they will. Owning a dog comes with a duty to ensure the safety of the community. If you can't meet that duty, you shouldn't own a dog." The renewed warning comes as dog attacks surge. In 2020, the council logged just under 2000 dog attacks. But between June of 2024 and June of 2025, almost 3000 dog attacks and 15,000 roaming dogs were reported to council. A roaming dog seen in South Auckland earlier this year. (File photo) Photo: Nick Monro The council attributed the rise in attacks to a decline in desexing and a boom of dog ownership following the Covid-19 lockdowns. "Some of these injuries are gruesome. They leave physical and psychological scars," head of prosecutions John Kang said. "What's worse is that many of these incidents are entirely preventable - they often happen when owners fail to control their dogs or turn a blind eye to aggressive behaviour. "We will continue to prosecute where criminal action is justified under the Solicitor-General's Prosecution Guidelines." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
7 days ago
- RNZ News
Trial date set for former funeral director accused of improper handling of human remains
Waikumete Cemetery. Photo: J E McGowan / CC BY 2.0 / Flickr A trial date has been set for a second former Auckland funeral director, whose name is suppressed. The name suppression and other matters will be argued at a pre-trial hearing on 25 November 2025. The former funeral director , who appeared in court on Tuesday, had earlier pleaded not guilty to charges related to the improper handling of human remains at Waikumete Cemetery, the largest in New Zealand and one of 53 run by Auckland Council. The court has ordered that any pre-trial applications must be filed by 3 November, with responses due by 17 November. A five-day jury trial is scheduled to begin on 8 June 2026. Bail for the defendant and name suppression for the complainants will continue until the November hearing. Waikumete Cemetery was also the site of previous offences involving former funeral director Fiona Bakulich , who was arrested in October 2024 during Operation Lola. She was sentenced in April 2025 . LDR is local body journalism funded by RNZ and NZ on Air.
NZ Herald
06-08-2025
- NZ Herald
Rupa's Cafe in Freemans Bay gets ticking off from Auckland Council for trading without licence
However, officials from Auckland Council launched an investigation this week after it emerged the cafe had reopened and begun trading without a valid food licence. On Friday last week, a Herald worker spotted an 'Open' sign outside the cafe and freshly baked food in the cabinet, with at least six customers in the shop. Fresh food was displayed in a cabinet when a Herald worker visited Rupa's Cafe on Friday. An open sign was displayed outside the cafe's door on Friday last week. A council food inspector was dispatched to the business on Tuesday but it appeared to be shut. 'Since the food registration for Rupa's Cafe at 103 Wellington St, Freemans Bay was cancelled in June 2025, the council has received no subsequent application for a new food registration for a cafe or other food business at that address,' the council's team leader for Environmental Health Response, Alan Ahmu, said. 'We were unaware of the alleged reopening of a cafe at the address.' Following Tuesday's visit, the council said an inspector would make another visit in the next two days. Rupa's Cafe owner, Dilip Rupa. Photo / Dean Purcell In a statement yesterday afternoon, Ahmu said a food safety officer had now made contact with the cafe. The operator 'now has an awareness of the registration requirement, has ceased trading and advises they will not trade again unless they are registered', Ahmu told the Herald. Selling food without a licence can still carry penalties, the council confirmed. The maximum penalty upon conviction for an individual is a fine not exceeding $50,000, and for a body corporate is a fine not exceeding $200,000. The cafe appears to be closed today, with calls to business going unanswered this morning. Cafe and owner have colourful backstory Rupa, a controversial figure in Auckland's hospitality scene, has had run-ins with Auckland Council and WorkSafe over unpaid property taxes and compliance violations. Rupa was the first person to be prosecuted by WorkSafe for failing to display Covid-19 QR codes during the pandemic. 'My main objection to the QR code is no one knows what the coding is … there's no security and there's no knowledge of where this QR coding is going," Rupa told the Herald at the time. He was ultimately fined $1500 after a 2022 trial was held in his absence, with Judge Stephen Bonnar, KC, ruling Rupa 'held strong views' about the legality of the provisions and made an intentional choice not to comply. Rupa's Cafe started out as a general store, 72 years ago. Photo / Michael Craig The Rupa family also defied paying the rates on their Freemans Bay cafe and two Grey Lynn private homes over several years in a bitter stand-off with the council. With the combined unpaid rates bill on their properties growing to $350,000 by 2021, the council began court proceedings to try to recoup the missed payments. In September last year, the Herald revealed the outstanding rates and associated penalties had ballooned to a record $876,623.65 - $662,179.06 for the cafe and $214,444.59 for the family home – leading the council to pursue a forced sale of the Rupa family's properties. The council struck a last-minute deal with the Rupa family over the bill in April, although the details of it remain protected under confidentiality obligations. Opened 72 years ago by Rupa's parents as a general store, Rupa's Cafe built a loyal base of customers over the years as a Freemans Bay institution. The neighbourhood cafe was known for its coffee and chai, serving up a mix of Indian dishes – including what Cuisine's Ginny Grant called 'some of the best samosas in Auckland'.
