Isle of man school meals report branded 'meaningless' by MHK
A report on school meals on the Isle of Man that saw redactions on more than 80% of its pages has been branded "completely meaningless" by an MHK The document, published in March, looks at areas such as the operating model and costs saw large sections of the text and in some cases full pages blacked out.Joney Faragher MHK said the review had a "significant level of both political and public interest" but "no one can get any information" out of what has been released.Education Minister Daphne Caine said while the report had not been produced "in a way that could made public", the details were "informing policy" on the issue.
The 2023 School Meals Review, originally drafted for internal use by the Department of Education, Sport and Culture (Desc), confirmed £2,522,000 was spent on the service in the academic year 2022-2023. But the publicly available version of the document has removed a list of 24 recommended improvements to the service, considerations of a new model and the details of potential alternatives, and a suggested five-year plan.Information on more than 120 pages of the 147-page report can not be viewed.
'In development'
In Tuesday's sitting of the House of Keys, Lawrie Hooper MHK said: "The fact the department has decided to redact everything related to the development and formulation of policy is somewhat absurd."He asked how Tynwald members were expected to engage with the review all politicians could see was "pages upon pages of blacked out text".Tim Glover MHK said the "excessive redactions" undermined public scrutiny and called for the minister to explain what steps were being taken "by the secret squirrel department" to improve transparency on the publication of official reports.Caine told members the report had originally been produced to "inform department policy" and as such "prior to its publication it was treated as a Freedom of Information (FOI) request".In line with FOI exemptions on formulation of policy, conduct of public business, personal information and commercial interests, aspects of the report has been removed, she said.The minister told members school meals policy was "very much in development" and therefore it would be "inappropriate and a bit irresponsible to put that in the public domain" before the details had been confirmed.However, she said key areas of focus for Desc would be a reduction in the use of ultra-processed food, using more local produce, reducing food waste and conducting parental and student surveys on meal choices, which had been outlined in the annual departmental plan.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
5 hours ago
- Wales Online
Violence erupts for third night in UK town as rioters set leisure centre on fire
Violence erupts for third night in UK town as rioters set leisure centre on fire Homes have been evacuated and a leisure centre housing migrants has been set alight A third night of civil unrest has unfolded in Ballymena, NI (Image: Getty Images ) A third night of violence has ensued in a UK town in what has been described as "anti-immigration riots." Videos circulating online show a number of projectiles being launched at police in Ballymena, Northern Ireland, including petrol bombs and fireworks in another night of rioting which has seen violence, arrests and a number of people injured. The riots began on Monday after two teenage boys appeared in court accused of attempted rape. They had confirmed their names and ages through a Romanian interpreter and denied the charges against them. By Monday afternoon, a social media post advertising a planned protest at 7.30pm that evening had been widely circulated and despite it being planned as peaceful, violent attacks were launched on places known to house migrants. Since then there have been three nights of violence and vandalism with people reportedly afraid to leave their homes, multiple arrests and dozens of police officers injured. On Wednesday masked youths attacked Larne Leisure Centre by smashing windows and setting fires. They are believed to have targeted the building after social media posts had suggested that those moved out of Ballymena homes were being housed there. Article continues below It is understood that there was no one inside the Leisure Centre during the attack. Emergency services created blockades with vehicles and a water cannon was also used in an effort to disperse the crowds that gathered close to Clonavon Terrace. Police used water jets to disperse the crowds (Image: Getty Images ) DUP politician Gordon Lyons posted a message to Facebook on Wednesday: "A number of individuals were temporarily moved to Larne Lesiure Centre... following disturbances in Ballymena. "It has now been confirmed to us by the PSNI and Council that all these individuals are in the care of the Housing Executive and have been moved out of Larne. "Protesting is of course a legitimate right but violence is not and I would encourage everyone to remain peaceful." The Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has condemned the 'mindless attacks which has been described by senior police officers as "racist thuggery." Article continues below Some Ballymena residents have put British and Irish flags in their windows so that their homes are not targeted. Many locals have said they are too afraid to leave their homes.
Daily Record
17 hours ago
- Daily Record
Public to decide what will be in proposed play facility in one area of Cleland
A consultation has been published by Cleland Community Council asking locals for their opinions on a proposed new play area in Parkside. The public can decide what they would like to see in a proposed play facility in one area of Cleland. A consultation has been published by Cleland Community Council asking locals for their opinions on a proposed new play area in Parkside. Options include a new bike track of Multi Use Games Area (MUGA). In a statement on their Facebook page, Cleland Community Council said: 'We are working closely with North Lanarkshire Council's Community Partnership Team to develop a new proposal for a possible facility for children and young people in Parkside. 'We want to hear from you on your preference of which of these two possible facilities children and young people would want to see and would use more regularly. 'We are working to access funding through the council's Local Development Programme fund to hopefully secure the budget to create a proposal plan leading to this project.' There are also in-person consultations to be held. These will be on Tuesday, June 17, from 6.30pm to 8.30pm in Cleland Community Centre and on Wednesday, June 18, from 10am to 11.30am in Cleland Library. The issue of better play equipment for Parkside kids has been an issue for residents for several years. Back in 2022, over 700 people signed a petition demanding an upgrade to play facilities. Speaking at that time, concerned resident Lizann Carroll said: 'We have been promised facilities since even before Covid, but we are hoping the council can look at this again and bring the proposals forward. 'The kids have got nothing up here and that's just not good enough.' Progressive Change Murdostoun councillor Cameron McManus is encouraging locals to complete the survey. He said: 'This is welcome news as many have been campaigning for better play facilities in Parkside long before Covid. 'It is important people express their views. Whether it's a bike track of a Multi Use Games Area (MUGA), people have to have their say. 'The more people that complete the survey then we will have a much better idea of exactly what local people are looking for.' Labour's Murdostoun councillor Louise Roarty added: 'I'm delighted this consultation has been developed to give the people of Parkside a voice to express what they consider to be the best options for the children and the community.' You can fill in the online survey by logging onto the Cleland Community Council Facebook page. The survey will close on June 23.
Wales Online
19 hours ago
- Wales Online
Rachel Reeves pledges millions to help make Wales' coal tips safe
Rachel Reeves pledges millions to help make Wales' coal tips safe The total cost of repairing coal tips in Wales is currently estimated to be more than £500m The site of the Tylorstown landslide in February 2020 (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne ) The UK Government has said it will give more money to help make Wales' coal tips safe. After months of requests from Welsh Government, an additional £118m of money to help with repairing the legacy of coal tips in Wales has been pledged. There had already been a pledge for £25m in the autumn by chancellor Rachel Reeves, but today she announced £118m over the three years of this spending review period. The total cost of repairing coal tips in Wales is currently estimated to be more than £500m. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here In an answer to the Freedom of Information request about coal tips in January this year, the Welsh Government said the previously quoted sum of £500-600m to deliver all the repairs needed was being reassessed. The explanation given was: "It is important to note that the range of £500-£600m was a provisional estimate based on the limited information available at the time, following the impact of Storm Dennis. "Since the initial estimated figure was produced, Welsh Government has done a considerable amount of work mapping recorded coal tips. The categorisation of these tips has also evolved in this timeframe as intelligence has been gained through the ongoing tip inspection and maintenance regime. Article continues below "With an improved information base now available an up-to-date figure for the total cost of managing Wales' coal tips is currently being worked through. Welsh Government will publicise the updated figure in due course, once it has been calculated." A spokesperson confirmed today that no revised figure is yet available. The UK Government has now committed £25m in the autumn budget and £118m over this three-year spending review period. The Welsh Government has given £44.4 million in capital funding for coal tip maintenance between 2022 and 2024. and £34m to 10 impacted councils and Natural Resources Wales. Adding together the UK and Welsh Government money, the total is currently £221m. Wales' First Minister Eluned Morgan however explained that the amount pledged by the UK Government was the maximum they had asked for from their UK Labour counterparts. "That is particularly good because we got every penny we asked for in relation to coal tips. You've got to be able to absorb this money in the time frame, have people to do the work, and they've really come up with the goods," she said. Article continues below Mrs Morgan said they had assessed the expertise and resources available which would avoid overcommitting and potentially having to return money. Earlier in the day, representatives from three Welsh councils said there will more than likely never be enough funding for the risk posed by disused coal tips in Wales to be taken away. They told the Commons' Welsh affairs committee that funding will only "scratch the surface" of the problem.
