Putin's ‘digital gulag': Inside the Kremlin's attempt to construct a spy app to snoop on Russians
The app, launched in March by Russian tech company VK, will be installed on every new device sold in Russia from September this year. But there are fears it will work as a 'spy programme', allowing Russia's FSB security service to establish a rigid surveillance programme.
The app will provide not only a space for messaging and video calls, but will be a broader information system with access to government services and mobile payments, analysts told The Independent. With servers based in Russia, Max will be subject to Russian law, which grants the FSB to have access to certain materials.
WhatsApp - the global messenger app used by more than 70 per cent of Russians - is 'highly likely' to be banned as Moscow looks to push people towards using Max, Mark Galeotti, a veteran observer of Russian security and politics and director of Mayak Intelligence, told The Independent.
Russian opposition journalist Andrey Okun said Max would be central to the Kremlin's dream of constructing a 'digital gulag'. Writing for the Republic website, he said in comments reported by The Times: 'This will be a sterile space in which the authorities have complete control over the leisure time, motives and thoughts of citizens.'
But experts on Russian technology and surveillance say that the introduction of the app, which is said to have been developed on Vladimir Putin's orders, is only the latest step in repeated measures to ramp up its ability to monitor the entire Russian online sphere.
'This is a normalisation of Russia's surveillance of its internet use… it's part of a long, long process,' Keir Giles, author of Russia's War on Everybody, told The Independent. ' The perceived threat from Western communications technology is not something that's new. It's something that has always been a focus for the Russian security services.'
Moscow's security industry has for decades been frustrated by Russian citizens using foreign software such as Google, Skype and Hotmail, all of which made it much more difficult to read their messages, Mr Giles explained.
Western communications technologies have always been perceived as a threat by Russian security services. After years of trying to clamp down on services such as WhatsApp, the latest move to push Russians towards Max is 'really just tidying up at this point', he added.
Popular apps such as WhatsApp - a messenger owned by Meta, which is designated as an extremist organisation by Russia - are now facing a potential ban.
Mr Giles said the messenger app has been an 'anomaly' in avoiding the Russian crackdown so far, likely due to its widespread use across the country. Figures show it is used by more than 70 per cent of people in Russia.
'It would be disruptive and unpopular to [ban it] without having a replacement available,' Mr Giles added.
Prof Galeotti said: 'The Russian state looks keen to be using sticks rather than carrots by either banning or putting restrictions on WhatsApp and possibly also [messaging service] Telegram in the future, just to kind of drive people towards Max.
'Whether it's a complete ban or whether it's just simply sort of slowdowns and restrictions, I think WhatsApp is going to find itself under real pressure in Russia.'
Pushing users towards Max is unlikely to have a significant impact on Russian opposition and activism against the government, Prof Galeotti explained, because they tend to avoid WhatsApp in favour of 'more seriously secure' apps such as Proton Mail and Signal.
But it may prompt a significant change in 'casual dissent', he added. 'That's where it might have a freezing effect: people who might be under other circumstances willing to send messages with slightly scurrilous content about the Kremlin might think twice.'
Russia previously attempted to block the Telegram messaging app in 2018. But the attempt failed, and did not practically affect the availability of Telegram in Russia, leading it to be officially unblocked two years later.
But Mikhail Klimarev, the head of Russia's Internet Protection Society, told The Times that he expected Moscow to renew attempts to ban it by the end of the year.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Five dead as Ukraine and Russia launch drone and missile attacks
Five people were killed and several others injured in Ukraine and Russia following a wave of overnight drone and missile attacks by both countries. Russia launched 235 drones and 27 missiles at Ukraine, with 10 missiles and 25 drones hitting targets in the Dnipro, Sumy, and Kharkiv regions, causing damage to buildings and infrastructure. Ukraine retaliated with drone attacks on Russian territory, with Russia's Defence Ministry claiming to have intercepted 54 drones over regions including Rostov, Bryansk, and Stavropol. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky vowed that Russia would face consequences for its strikes, stating that Ukrainian long-range drones would ensure this. Russia's Defence Ministry claimed its strikes targeted Ukrainian military sites, while a Russian official stated that peace talks were never truly on the West's agenda.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
I've seen the real face of China and it's sadistic and cruel beneath the 'Botox' façade
Former detainee Cheng Lei has warned the Albanese government to look deeper than China's public façade as she describes distressing surveillance that happens daily in Australia. Ms Cheng was imprisoned for more than three years in China, with the first six months in solitary confinement where she was forced to sit still for 13 hours per day and write 'self–bashing essays'. After almost two years free and now based in Melbourne, she has warned the Albanese government against drinking the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) 'Kool-Aid'. 'There is China's public face, and it's a great face, and it's getting better all the time, with a lot of Botox,' the mother-of-two said. 'But the surface is not how it is at the core and it spends trillions of dollars – its entire stability maintenance budget – to keep up that façade. 'We are just conveniently forgetting China is a state that prioritises the CCP's rule above all else, and individuals don't matter in that system. 'I'm lucky enough to have seen both sides and I just want to remind people at all times what it can, and does do, when it thinks nobody's looking.' Ms Cheng, who is a Chinese-born Australian journalist, described how 'cruelty is the policy' of China, inside and outside its prisons. 'The people who look at the fancy buildings and infrastructure, and think, "Oh, wow, how wonderful is this!" I want them to pause and think, "Do I want to be in that system?" 'Do I want my kids to grow up with that sort of cruelty and the back-breaking work and not having enough rights and not being able to criticise? 'People get sucked into the Kool-Aid and the fancy façade and they don't ask why Chinese people want to get out of the country, if it's such a great country to live in.' Her comments follow Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's six-day diplomatic tour of China in which he was photographed at popular tourist spots. He also received glowing reviews from Chinese media, which praised the blossoming relations between the two countries. 'I just don't see anything specific coming out of all this lovey-doveyness,' Ms Cheng told Daily Mail Australia following the meeting. 'The Chinese love for you to feel comfortable and that you are friends as long as you play ball. '(Officials) have this preoccupation with "(saving) face" and once you have that friendly vibe, it's impossible to play hardball.' In an ideal world, Ms Cheng wants Canberra to be able to have both: 'Let's talk more on trade, but yes, let's write something specific about the treatment of Aussie prisoners.' Ms Cheng was imprisoned by Chinese authorities in 2020 after being accused of 'illegally supplying state secrets overseas', allegations that were unfounded. The case concerned her sharing a government briefing with another journalist, with officials claiming it was embargoed, despite there being no time of permitted release on the document until a year after the incident. In her new book, 'Cheng Lei: A Memoir of Freedom', she speaks freely and with brutal honesty about the cruelty she endured at the hands of the Chinese prison system. For the first six months, she was placed under 'Residential Surveillance at a Designated Location' (RSDL), which the UN describes as 'enforced disappearance and might amount to torture'. Since 2012, China's Criminal Procedure Law has been amended to give police the power to take people into custody without disclosing where they will be held. 'I had to remain in the same position for 13 hours a day,' she said, adding she was permitted a few 10-minute breaks to walk between guards, only after she was visited by the Australian embassy. 'All those years, I had been told you cannot say this, you cannot mention the word 'case' at the embassy visit. You cannot mention your name. 'I had to write these self–bashing essays in which I just basically was telling lies. I had to write these untruthful things (about myself) in order to get by.' 'I just can't see another country that is as sadistic, as organised and so in tune with f***ing up your psychology that they would design something like this,' she said. Almost two years since she was liberated and, now settled in Melbourne as a Sky News host, Ms Cheng still feels as though the CCP has not forgotten her. 'There are so many strange things, like on Amazon: there are two fake books with the same name as my book,' she said. 'And last year, when I did a stand-up with (dissident Vicky Xu), there were two spies in the audience videotaping us with their hood pulled up.' But her concern remains for others, acknowledging that by striking a public figure, she appears 'safer' than others. 'I hear about ordinary Australians, for example, organising a vigil for the Tiananmen Square Massacre and being followed by hooded individuals in Western Australia,' she said, referencing a tip she had been given last week. 'While I'm personally not scared, it is extremely distressing in our country people who are doing ordinary things that are totally within their rights, are having to do it in fear.' Ms Cheng asserted China has a 'serious fear of its own people', whether in mainland China or among overseas communities. 'That's why they try to control people,' she said. 'It's either coercion through the community associations and trying to woo people, and then for them to intimidate other overseas Chinese.' One example she gave was WeChat groups in Melbourne where Ms Cheng said members are prohibited from talking about the independence of Taiwan or Hong Kong. 'If you do, (they tell you) you can get out of the group,' she said. 'They are also using fear of what might happen to the business interests or their families.' Despite the attempted intimidation, threats from online trolls and a public attempt by Chinese officials to block her during a press conference by China's second–in–command Premier Li Qiang in June last year, Ms Cheng is revelling in her freedom. 'There's nothing so blissful as having my voice back and to make a difference,' she said. 'It's hard to explain how insanely good freedom feels. 'I've been skydiving. I just got my open water dive scuba licence with my daughter. I'm playing soccer three to four times a week, making new friends.' Where does that leave Ms Cheng now? 'I wish people would make informed judgements about China because right now we just have a lot of ignorant prejudice,' she said. 'People say, "Oh, well, China is all bad." Or they just conflate Chinese people and the CCP and China, the country. 'I want people to - and I wish more overseas Chinese people would - think about what it is to live here and how we should all protect the freedoms you can't experience in China.'
Sky News
2 hours ago
- Sky News
Five killed after Russia and Ukraine trade aerial bombardments
At least five people have been killed after Russia and Ukraine traded aerial bombardments overnight, officials have said. In Ukraine, the southern region of Dnipro and the northeastern region of Sumy were attacked by rockets and drones. The head of the Dnipro regional administration, Serhii Lysak, said at least three people had died and at least five were injured. In the city of Dnipro, a multi-storey building and businesses were damaged in the strike, and a fire engulfed a shopping centre in the region. The military administration in Sumy said three people were injured. Over three hours, Ukraine's second-largest city, Kharkiv, was hit by four guided aerial bombs, two ballistic missiles and 15 drones. In a Telegram post, its mayor, Ihor Terekhov, said high-rise residential buildings, local businesses, roads and the communication network were damaged. He said at least five people were injured, including three rescue workers hit in a double tap strike, where a second attack targets emergency workers trying to help those wounded in the initial attack. In total, Russia targeted Ukraine with 208 drones and 27 missiles overnight, according to the daily air force report. It said air defence and electronic warfare took down or intercepted 183 drones and 17 missiles, but hits from 10 missiles and 25 drones had been recorded in nine locations, according to preliminary data. Officials in Russia said Ukrainian drones targeted several regions overnight, with a drone attack on the border region of Rostov killing two people, according to acting governor Yuri Slyusar. In the neighbouring Stavropol region, drones hit an industrial facility, governor Vladimir Vladimirov said on Telegram. The attack sparked a brief fire, he added. Drones also targeted Moscow but were shot down, according to mayor Sergei Sobyanin. They also targeted an industrial facility in the Penza region southeast of the capital, governor Oleg Melnichenko said. Russia's Defence Ministry said its air defences shot down or intercepted a total of 54 Ukrainian drones.
