Ford files $100-million suit over alleged 'Lemon Law' scheme by L.A. lawyers
Ford Motor Co. has filed suit against multiple prominent Southern California law firms and attorneys, alleging that they engaged in a vast and sophisticated fraud scheme to collect at least $100 million in "phantom legal fees' under the state's Lemon Law.
In a complaint filed early Wednesday in Los Angeles federal court, the Dearborn, Mich.-based car manufacturer claimed the lawyers violated the Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act by working together to carry out the alleged fraud for years.
Describing the invoices it received from California lawyers as a 'magical mystery tour of fictitious billings,' Ford claimed that attorneys named in the lawsuit took advantage of a statute designed to protect consumers from faulty products, including cars.
Under the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, commonly known as California's Lemon Law, automakers are required to pay for legal work, court fees and related expenses associated with defective vehicles.
That requirement, Ford alleged, has created an opportunity for lawyers to pad their bottom line by claiming more hours than they actually worked or reporting having been in more than one place at the same time.
The complaint alleged that Steve B. Mikhov was the 'ringleader of the criminal enterprise' and that he and Knight Law Group, the Los Angeles-based firm where he was a founding partner, 'orchestrated' the scheme.
Emails and phone messages seeking comment from Knight Law Group were not immediately returned Wednesday, nor were requests for comment made via email addresses and cellphone numbers for Mikhov listed in online databases.
Ford, which is being represented by New York-based Kasowitz Benson Torres LLP, claimed in the complaint that an investigation uncovered payments of legal fees that reflected work that never could have happened.
For instance, the auto giant alleged that Knight partner Amy Morse 'billed more than 20 hours per day on at least 66 occasions, 34 of which exceeded 24 hours, including an ostensibly heroic but physically impossible 57.5-hour workday in November 2016." Morse did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment Wednesday.
Edward McNally, a former federal prosecutor and lawyer for Ford at Kasowitz Benson Torres, described how the alleged scheme worked in an emailed statement.
'When you look at any single legal bill for a single case it might show only one or two hours for a given lawyer on a given day—nothing to draw suspicion," he said. "However, when Ford searched across public filings, as alleged in the complaint, the conduct in this case was carried out through a sophisticated and unlawful enterprise of attorneys and law firms that spread their fraudulent and inflated bills across thousands of cases and against many auto makers.'
The other defendants who benefited from the alleged conspiracy, Ford claimed, include Knight partner Roger Kirnos and former Knight paralegal Dorothy Becerra; L.A.-based Altman Law Group and its founder and former member attorney, Bryan C. Altman; and San Diego-based Wirtz Law APC and Richard Wirtz, its founder and managing partner.
Emails and phone messages seeking comment from Kirnos, Altman Group, Wirtz Law, Altman and Wirtz were not immediately returned Wednesday. Contact information for Becerra could not be located immediately Wednesday.
Daniel J. Fetterman, a former federal prosecutor and partner at Kasowitz Benson Torres, said the firm's automaker client has been in contact with federal authorities.
'Ford reported this conduct to the United States Attorney's Office and has been cooperating with a grand jury subpoena served on it in the fall of 2021," Fetterman said. Ciaran McEvoy, a spokesman for the U.S. Attorney's Office in L.A., declined to comment Wednesday.
Sherman 'Tiger" Joyce, president of the American Tort Reform Assn., said via email that the alleged fraudulent scheme "is an affront to the civil justice system and these lawyers who have harmed consumers by needlessly dragging out and driving up costs of litigation should be held accountable."
Ford claimed in its filing that the scheme 'has an informal governing structure that at certain times operates as a command hierarchy," meaning it had a chain of command. The arrangement, Ford alleged, violated the RICO Act, which has played a central role in cases against high-profile organizations including Italian crime families, Mexican drug cartels and the Hells Angels motorcycle gang. Ford argues it is owed civil damages under the federal racketeering law.
The automaker's lawsuit said the attorneys involved "associated with one another in the Enterprise for the common purposes of preparing and filing fraudulent fee applications and billing records, negotiating fraudulent settlements, splitting inflated fees, and funneling fraud proceeds into attorney distributions and extravagant purchases.'
Ford said the nine-figure damage total it is seeking would recoup what it lost in allegedly bogus payouts, along with thousands of hours investigating the alleged scheme and what the company described as the harm to its reputation it sustained as a result of representations the lawyers allegedly made in court and online about the amounts they recovered from the automaker.
Kyla Christoffersen Powell, president and chief executive of the Civil Justice Assn. of California, said in an emailed statement that the alleged fraud scheme highlighted longstanding problems with the state's Lemon Law.
"The shocking attorney conduct outlined in today's filing by Ford underscores the need for the Legislature to consider additional reforms to the lemon law that remove perverse incentives for attorneys," she wrote.
Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week.
This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Delta warns new tariffs could force it to stop buying foreign-made airplanes
WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Delta Air Lines warned new tariffs on imported airplanes and parts could force the airline to stop buying foreign-made planes impacting millions of customers. The Atlanta-based carrier told the U.S. Commerce Department in comments seen by Reuters Thursday that in 2023 and 2024 it took delivery of 47 Airbus aircraft produced in Canada, Germany and France. If the carrier had not been able to take delivery of those planes because of tariffs it would have forced flight cancellations impacting 10 million customers. Delta said a "similar impact could be expected going forward" if the Trump administration imposes new tariffs.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Dr. Martens' Stock Soars as CEO Implements New Strategic Plan Following ‘Year of Stabilization'
Shares for Dr. Martens Plc surged nearly 24 percent on Thursday following the release of a new strategic turnaround plan in efforts to return to profit growth in fiscal 2026. According to chief executive officer Ije Nwokorie, who took the helm earlier this year, the company's 'single focus' in fiscal 2025 was to bring stability back to Dr. Martens. More from WWD Journeys Helps Genesco Deliver Q1 Sales Above Expectations Dr. Martens Looks to Adidas For New Chief Brand Officer Name Game: Shoe Carnival Is Converting More Stores to Shoe Station Banner 'We have achieved this by returning our direct-to-consumer channel in the Americas back to growth, resetting our marketing approach to focus relentlessly on our products, delivering cost savings, and significantly strengthening our balance sheet,' Nwokorie said in a statement. In fiscal 2025, the UK-based footwear company reported that net revenue fell 10 percent to 787.6 million pounds from 877.1 million in fiscal 2024. Dr. Martens noted that the results were in-line with guidance, however, and came up against a challenging macroeconomic and consumer backdrop in several of its core markets. Net debt for the year was 249.5 million pounds, down from 359.8 million pounds in fiscal 2024. Net profit stood at 4.5 million pounds in the year to the end of March, down from 69.2 million pounds the year prior. By category, overall, pairs were down 9 percent, with DTC pairs flat and wholesale pairs down 15 percent as expected, as the company's wholesale partners normalized their inventory levels. 'We saw a very strong performance in shoes, with DTC pairs up 15 percent with particular success in our bestselling Adrian loafer, as well as in new shoe families, the Lowell and Buzz,' the company said in its latest earnings statement. 'Sandals also saw a good performance, with DTC pairs up 7 percent, and we continue to see a strong performance in our mules range, led by the Zebzag. Boots remained challenging, with DTC pairs down 9 percent, with our continuity boots weaker, as expected. This was partially offset by success in product newness, both as extensions of the core icons, for example through the Ambassador soft leather boot and through new product lines such as the Anistone biker boot.' As a proportion of fiscal year 2025 Group revenue, boots accounted for 57 percent, shoes 26 percent, sandals 12 percent and bags & other 5 percent. By channel, direct-to-consumer revenue was down 4.2 percent to 510.7 million pounds in fiscal 2025, while wholesale fell 19.5 percent to 276.9 million pounds, as expected. Within DTC, retail revenue was down 5.6 percent to 242.4 million pounds and e-commerce was down 2.9 percent to 268.3 million pounds. By region, EMEA revenue was down 11.0 percent to 384.2 million pounds for the year, which was driven by the UK. In the Americas, revenue was down 11.4 percent to 288.5 million pounds, and in APAC, revenue dipped 3.8 percent to 114.9 million pounds, with a good performance in Japan and China, the company noted. Looking closer at the Americas, Dr. Martens stated that the region delivered DTC growth in the second half of fiscal 2025 as the company pivoted its marketing to 'relentlessly focus' on product. 'With new products such as Ambassador, Anistone, Buzz and Dunnet Flower performing very strongly for us and our partners; we delivered 25 million pounds of annualized cost savings, at the top end of our target, with the full benefit in fiscal 2026; and we strengthened our balance sheet through a significant reduction in inventory and net debt, as well as the successful refinancing of the Group,' the company said. As for tariffs, the company noted that the entirety of its spring/summer 2025 stock is already in the market, and by the start of July, the majority of autumn/winter 2025 will be either in the market or in transit. 'We generate strong product gross margins, which is helpful given that tariffs are charged on cost, not retail price,' the company stated. 'We will continue to assess the situation carefully, but can confirm that for SS25 and AW25 we will be keeping average prices unchanged in the market. More broadly, we continue to manage all costs tightly, working closely with our wholesale and supplier partners.' The company also released a new strategic plan on Thursday. Dubbed 'Levers For Growth,' Dr. Martens said that the plan builds on the work undertaken in fiscal 2025 to stabilize the business. The new plan focuses on four 'levers' including engaging more consumers, driving more product purchase occasions, curating market-right distribution, and simplifying the operating model. Dr. Martens said that the new strategy capitalizes on the strengths of its business, including its 'iconic global brand, high quality products, world-class supply chain, modern technology systems, committed wholesale and distributor partners and passionate and talented team,' and taps into the significant new markets and profit pools that are available to the company. Over the medium-term, Dr. Martens said it expects to deliver sustainable, profitable revenue growth above the rate of the relevant footwear market, with operating leverage driving a mid to high-teens EBIT margin and underpinned by strong cash generation. 'Levers For Growth will increase our opportunities by shifting the business from a channel-first to a consumer-first mindset,' Nwokorie said. 'We will give more people more reasons to buy more of our products, whether that's our iconic boots and shoes, newer product families such as Zebzag and Buzz, or adjacent categories such as sandals, bags and leather goods. And we will tailor distribution to each market, blending DTC and B2B, optimizing brand reach and ensuring a better use of capital.' The CEO added that he is 'laser focused' on day-to-day execution, managing costs and maintaining the company's operational discipline while it navigates the current macroeconomic uncertainties. Best of WWD All the Retailers That Nike Left and Then Went Back Mikey Madison's Elegant Red Carpet Shoe Style [PHOTOS] Julia Fox's Sleekest and Boldest Shoe Looks Over the Years [Photos] Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
29 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Watch: Shannon Smith samples chicken restaurants across the Triad
PIEDMONT TRIAD, N.C. (WGHP) — Chicken chains are flocking to the Piedmont Triad. Four new fast-casual franchises opened this spring in Guilford County alone, and more are under construction. People have packed Dave's Hot Chicken on Battleground Avenue in Greensboro. The Los Angeles-based chain serves huge tenders and sliders. Customers can choose their heat level, starting at no spice and running all the way up to reaper, which comes with a disclaimer. Just across the street on Lawndale Drive, A Hangry Joe's Hot Chicken is under construction, and one is already open on North Main Street in High Point. Their menu is inspired by Nashville's Famous Hot Chicken. Again, you can customize your spice levels. The hottest one requires you to sign a waiver to try it. Also in High Point, off NC 68/Eastchester Drive, Slim Chickens opened, serving a variety of all-natural fresh chicken tenders and wings with a selection of sauces and seasonings. Finally, a chicken restaurant with international flair. Pollo Compero is a chain started Guatemalan in 1971. They specialize in fried chicken, empanadas and other Latin-inspired side dishes. FOX8 FOODIE Shannon Smith took a tasting tour of the four new franchises and shares her thoughts. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
