Senators return impeachment case against Sara Duterte to the Philippine House
In this photo provided by the Senate Social Media Unit, Philippine Senate president Francis Escudero leads Philippine senators as they take oath as jurors in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte at the Philippine Senate in Pasay city, Philippines on Tuesday June 10, 2025. - Senate Social Media Unit, Voltaire Fernandez Domingo via AP
MANILA: Philippine senators set themselves as an impeachment court Tuesday (June 10) for the trial of Vice President Sara Duterte over corruption and other criminal allegations, but voted to send the raft of complaints back to the lower House of Representatives due to legal questions.
Dozens of activists protesting outside the Senate condemned Senate President Chiz Escudero and 17 other senators for voting to send back the impeachment complaint to the House instead of immediately bringing Duterte to trial. Five senators rejected the move.
The Senate action will delay the start of Duterte's impeachment trial but it's unclear what other impact it would have on her case.
"There is no `remand' or `return' in the constitution,' said Senator Risa Hontiveros, who has demanded an immediate trial of the vice president. "Our obligation is to try and decide.'
Escudero said the move did not mean that the impeachment complaint was being dismissed and underscored that point by issuing summons for Duterte to appear before the impeachment court when the trial proceeds.
Duterte was impeached by the House in February on a range of accusations that include plotting to assassinate President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and large-scale corruption.
Many legislators who backed Duterte's impeachment were political allies of Marcos and her impeachment deepened a bitter political rift between the two highest leaders of one of Asia's most rambunctious democracies.
The vice president's supporters have said the legislators violated the constitution and congressional rules to force her impeachment and prevent her from running in presidential elections in 2028, when Marcos' six-year term ends.
Duterte, 47, is the daughter of former President Rodrigo Duterte who was arrested in March and flown to The Netherlands to face charges of crimes against humanity at the International Criminal Court.
The Hague-based court had ordered the former president's arrest through Interpol, the global police organisation, after accusing him of committing a crime against humanity over deadly anti-drug crackdowns he oversaw while in office. - AP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
5 hours ago
- New Straits Times
#NSTviral: Fresh road markings spotted at Gerik crash site
KUALA LUMPUR: The site of the tragic crash that claimed the lives of 15 Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI) students along the East–West Highway is believed to have recently received new road markings, according to a video that has since gone viral. Posted by user @update11111 on social media platform X, the 60-second clip shows a man driving on the opposite lane of the accident site, pointing out newly painted road markings. "Line baru ada" ("There are new lines"), he remarks, suggesting the lines were freshly painted following the incident. The crash, which occurred at Km53 of the highway on Monday, involved a tour bus carrying 42 students and a Perodua Alza. Thirteen students were killed at the scene, while two others died later in hospital. In a separate post yesterday, actor and road safety advocate Azlan Sani Zawawi, popularly known as Lando Zawawi, commented that the lane where the bus overturned appeared to lack adequate road markings at the time of the incident. Other users, including one identified as Ahmad Syah, also raised concerns over the road's condition. "There are uneven surfaces, cracks, and signs of patchwork. The colour and texture of the tarmac are inconsistent, which suggests recent but uneven resurfacing," he said. The fatal incident has sparked widespread debate over maintenance and enforcement standards on high-risk roads. Meanwhile, investigations continue into the bus operator's practices. The company's owner was questioned by police earlier today. The firm had its operating permits revoked yesterday after it was found to have committed multiple violations, including leasing its permit to a third party and failing to activate the bus's GPS tracking system. Transport Minister Anthony Loke confirmed that the permit holder, based in Kedah, had subleased the operating licence to a Kelantan-based party for RM500 a month — a direct breach of regulations. Authorities have yet to determine whether road conditions or driver negligence caused the crash. Technical inspections, including a brake system analysis, are ongoing.
The Star
6 hours ago
- The Star
Charter experts urge Philippines Senate to proceed with Duterte impeachment trial
MANILA: The Philippines's oldest and most authoritative voice on constitutional law has urged the Senate to proceed with the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, reminding senators that the accountability of public officials should not be thwarted by procedural inventions or partisan manoeuvring. 'At stake is not merely the fate of one official, but the integrity of the Constitution itself. Impeachment is the people's mechanism to enforce Accountability of Public Officials. It must not be thwarted by procedural invention or partisan manoeuvre,' the Philippine Constitution Association (Philconsa), led by its chairman, retired Chief Justice Reynato Puno, said in a statement. Philconsa issued the statement after the Senate convened as an impeachment court but opted to remand the Articles of Impeachment to the House of Representatives, citing alleged 'constitutional infirmities' that needed to be addressed. The supposed 'constitutional infirmities' were raised by the Duterte bloc, staunch allies of Vice President Duterte and her father, former President Rodrigo Duterte. Among the issues cited was the lack of certification, which Philconsa argued is neither required by the Constitution nor supported by established impeachment practice. Four key constitutional concerns were raised by the Senate's remand: > Grave abuse of discretion: Whether the Senate unlawfully suspended its jurisdiction, already validly acquired as an impeachment court. > Encroachment on the House's exclusive power: Whether requiring the House to certify compliance with the one-year ban infringes upon the House's sole prerogative under Article XI, Section 3 of the Constitution. > Circumlocutory delay: Whether imposing novel requirements not found in the Constitution or Senate rules constitutes a circumlocutory device designed to delay or defeat the trial. > Due process and impartiality: Whether raising possible defences on behalf of the respondent compromises the impartiality of the Senate as an impeachment court. Philconsa reminded the Senate that once convened as an impeachment court, its jurisdiction 'cannot be lost or suspended by mere procedural acts.' Citing the 1997 case of Republic vs. Sandiganbayan, Philconsa said, 'jurisdiction, once validly acquired, is not lost by subsequent happenings. It continues until the case is finally resolved or dismissed.' It also pointed out that the principle of continuing jurisdiction has been an established practice, including during the impeachment trial of former US President Bill Clinton. The House of Representatives has since adopted a resolution certifying that the impeachment complaint against Duterte complies with constitutional requirements. However, it deferred acceptance of the articles of impeachment until the Senate responds to clarificatory questions submitted by the House prosecution panel regarding the remand order. Vice President Duterte, who faces allegations including corruption and plotting to assassinate President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., has denied all wrongdoing and dismissed the impeachment efforts as politically motivated. If the trial proceeds and results in her conviction, she could be removed from office and face a lifetime ban from holding public office. The Senate's decision has sparked public outcry, with protests erupting outside the Senate complex and various groups decrying the move as a betrayal of the Constitution. Malacanang has distanced itself from the controversy, stating that the President is not involved in the Senate's deliberations, but emphasised the importance of adhering to legal procedures. - Philippine Daily Inquirer/ANN
New Straits Times
9 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Kulim tour bus company declines comment on Gerik crash that killed 15 UPSI students
KULIM: A tour bus company based in Kulim, whose operating permit had been leased to another operator involved in Monday's fatal crash in Gerik, Perak which claimed the lives of 15 Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI) students, has declined to comment on the incident. A representative from the company said it would refrain from making any statements while authorities conduct a full investigation. "We do not wish to comment at this time. Let the authorities carry out a thorough investigation as we do not want to complicate matters. "Furthermore, the incident involved numerous casualties. We wish to respect the families who are grieving the loss of their loved ones. "That is all we have to say for now," the representative told the New Straits Times, declining to elaborate further when contacted today. The Transport Ministry announced that the company's permits were revoked due to multiple breaches of permit conditions. The Transport Ministry announced yesterday that all of the company's permits were revoked due to multiple breaches of permit conditions. Its Minister Anthony Loke had said that the company had committed two serious violations: leasing its permit to a third party and failing to activate the vehicle's GPS tracking system. He revealed that the Kedah-based permit holder had leased the permit to an operator in Kelantan for RM500 per month. In the early hours of Monday, a tour bus carrying 42 UPSI students from Jerteh, Terengganu, to Tanjung Malim, Perak, collided with a Perodua Alza multi-purpose vehicle (MPV) along the East-West Highway (JRTB) near Tasik Banding, Gerik. Fifteen students tragically lost their lives in the crash, with 33 others injured. Meanwhile, checks at the company's registered premises, a double-storey shoplot along Jalan Kilang Lama, revealed that the office remains closed. A worker at a neighbouring unit said the office had been shut for over a year. "The office has been quiet since the Covid-19 pandemic in 2021. "I noticed it was fully closed more than a year ago," said the woman, who requested anonymity. The company's signboard states that it offers bus and van rental services for holidays, worker transportation, tour packages, and hotel bookings. A review of the company's Facebook page showed that it was last updated in September 2024. It is understood that the company currently operates bus services for transporting workers, with two of its buses found parked in a locked open-air lot not far from the premises.
