College football preseason poll ranking errors include Tennessee, Oklahoma, Clemson
The Longhorns possess the coach, the roster and the quarterback to pursue a national championship.
After the No. 1 spot, though, the two polls featured several discrepancies. Oklahoma became subject to the biggest disagreement. The Sooners went unranked by the coaches, but landed No. 18 in the AP poll.
Here's a look at the eight biggest discrepancies between the polls, with my ruling on which poll got it right:
Clemson
Coaches: No. 6
AP: No. 4
Who got it right?: AP
Clemson finished with four losses last season, but never mind that fading object in the rearview mirror, because Dabo Swinney retained a talented roster that's now more experienced. He even added some polish with a few transfers. Clemson touts the nation's best defensive line, along with arguably the nation's top quarterback, Cade Klubnik. The Tigers aren't just contenders inside the ACC. They're national championship contenders.
Florida
Coaches: No. 17
AP: No. 15
Who got it right?: Coaches
Both poll services overrated the Gators, but the coaches came closer to the mark. Florida ended last season playing well. DJ Lagway is one of the nation's most promising quarterbacks, but he rehabbed injuries throughout the offseason, and after an underwhelming transfer haul, I question whether Lagway enjoys enough support on either side of the ball to justify these rankings in the face of a daunting schedule.
Texas A&M
Coaches: No. 21
AP: No. 19
Who got it right?: Coaches
Texas A&M being overrated is an August tradition. The Aggies were ranked in the preseason polls in each of the past six years. They finished the season ranked only twice during that span, and only once did they finish higher than their preseason ranking. That doesn't mean these Aggies will stink. They're equipped with a solid offensive line and a strong backfield. But, combine how they buckled at the end of last season with their history of failing to meet projections, and the AP awarded too much respect.
Kansas State
Coaches: No. 20
AP: No. 17
Who got it right?: AP
Kansas State unraveled last November but still finished 9-4, and the Wildcats returned a bulk of their production, including quarterback Avery Johnson. That helps explain why the Wildcats are an oddsmaker front-runner to win the Big 12. Kansas State's run game and rushing defense each should rank near the top of its conference. The coaches underrated the Wildcats, and the media corrected that.
Brigham Young
Coaches: No. 23
AP: Unranked
Who got it right?: AP
The coaches' ranking is out of touch with the reality that the Cougars' planned starting quarterback, Jake Retzlaff, transferred to Tulane this summer, rather than face an honor code suspension at BYU. Given that late roster twist, a different Big 12 team, Baylor, would be a better choice in the rankings than BYU. The Bears went unranked in both polls. BYU's coaches poll ranking honors its 2024 performance rather than its 2025 reality.
WHO PREVAILS?: A scavenger hunt to locate the next national champion
Mississippi
Coaches: No. 15
AP: No. 21
Who got it right?: Coaches
Lane Kiffin plays transfer roulette as well as anyone, and he assembled another impressive haul to replace the significant loss of talent from last season's 10-win team. Whether you think the AP or coaches ranking is more appropriate depends on whether you're a believer in quarterback Austin Simmons, a first-year starter. I'm a believer, after watching Simmons thrive in a relief appearance against Georgia. He'll enjoy a sufficient supporting cast.
Tennessee
Coaches: No. 18
AP: No. 24
Who got it right?: AP
Ideally, split the difference between these two rankings, but, forced to choose one, I'd say the AP rankings are closer to the mark after Tennessee endured significant losses from its playoff team, including the April departure of quarterback Nico Iamaleava. Coach Josh Heupel's track record indicates a high floor, but combine the Vols' meek transfer haul with the quarterback uncertainty, and the coaches' ranking seems too bullish. At least the schedule is accommodating, by SEC standards.
Oklahoma
Coaches: Unranked
AP: No. 18
Who got it right?: AP
Embattled coach Brent Venables used the offseason to seed a revival, after the 2024 season went bust. Sweeping roster changes include the additions of star quarterback John Mateer, a transfer from Washington State, and Jadyn Ott, a former All-America running back for California. The AP ranking might be a smidge lofty for a team facing Oklahoma's brutal schedule, but it's closer to the mark than the Sooners being omitted from the coaches poll, where they received the most points among unranked teams.
Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com and follow him on X @btoppmeyer.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: College football preseason poll rankings errors for eight teams
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Rays rally late to beat Giants 2-1, spoil Verlander's strong start
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Yandy Díaz and Brandon Lowe hit consecutive two-out RBI singles in the eighth inning, and the Tampa Bay Rays rallied for the second straight day to beat the San Francisco Giants 2-1 on Saturday night. The Rays' offense had been on mute much of the day against three-time Cy Young winner Justin Verlander, but broke out when Verlander left after seven scoreless innings. After No. 9 hitter Nick Fortes was hit by a pitch with two outs, Chandler Simpson singled before Díaz singled in Tampa Bay's first run off José Buttó (3-3). Lowe followed with his second hit of the game to drive in a run and hand the Giants their seventh consecutive loss. Edwin Uceta (9-2) retired four batters. Pete Fairbanks pitched the ninth for his 22nd save. Tampa Bay's win spoiled a solid start by the 42-year-old Verlander, who allowed two hits and had eight strikeouts, moving him within four of tying Walter Johnson (3,515) for ninth place on the career list. The Giants scored in the sixth when Willy Adames singled, stole second and came home when Christian Koss hit a single past diving third baseman Junior Caminero. Rays starter Adrian Houser matched his season-high of six strikeouts and allowed four hits over five scoreless innings making his third start since being acquired from the Chicago White Sox. Rays manager Kevin Cash was ejected in the eighth inning for arguing a strike call. Key moment With two on and two out in the sixth, Rays right fielder Jake Mangum chased down Jung Hoo Lee's deep drive and made a sliding catch on the warning track. Key stat Verlander needed 17 pitches to retire the side in the sixth and seventh. Up next Giants ace RHP Logan Webb (10-9, 3.34 ERA) faces Rays RHP Ryan Pepiot (8-9, 3.86) in the series finale on Sunday. ___ AP MLB:
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Austin Dillon Finds Redemption at Richmond, Wins His Way into the Playoffs Without Crashing Others
Last year, Austin Dillon wrecked Joey Logano and Denny Hamlin for the win at Richmond Raceway, hoping to secure his spot in the playoffs with a win. Dillon was in a must-win position, too far below the cut line with two races remaining. In the end, NASCAR let Dillon keep the win but took away his playoff berth. This year, outside the points again with two races remaining, Dillon returned to Richmond hoping to right last year's mistake. Dillon did so in dominant fashion as he was the clear fastest driver in the final stage of the 400-lap race. Dillon was the first driver to make their final pit stop on the main strategy, going to pit with 58 laps remaining after a multi-lap battle with Ryan Blaney for the lead. Dillon went to the pits as soon as Blaney secured his pass. Blaney asked a lap later if he could follow, and the No. 12 team had him stay out for three laps to build a tire gap between the two. Blaney pitted with 55 laps to go and came out 11 seconds behind Dillon, as the rest of the leaders also cycled through the pits, the duo returned to 1-2. Blaney was as close as 3.7 seconds with 35 laps remaining, but his tires were falling off majorly over the final run, and Dillon was able to pull away on older tires. "All of a sudden, I didn't have a right rear," Blaney said after the race, where he fell back to third. "I thought I was really trying to be disciplined and save a tire." Blaney's third-place finish is his first top-five at Richmond Raceway. Alex Bowman, who, with Dillon's win, falls to the final spot above the cutline, was running third behind Blaney as the Penske driver's tires started to fall out. Bowman, with fresher tires, made the pass for second and started to eat into Dillon's lead. Ultimately, traffic and lack of remaining laps stopped Bowman from making a run up to Dillon to challenge for a win. Bowman radioed in the closing laps that Dillon's teammate was blocking for him. "I complained about it on the radio, but that's just what we do," Dillon said. "Vented a little bit, but we had a really good Ally No. 48 during that last run." Bowman now enters Daytona, the final race before the playoffs, in the most stressful situation, with a Superspeedway being the easiest place for a new winner to appear this late in the season, just as Harrison Burton secured his spot in the playoffs last year. Blaney was followed by his teammates Joey Logano, who ran up to fourth after starting in 38th, and Austin Cindric in fifth. Kyle Larson found his way to a top ten finish after problems throughout qualifying and the race, finishing sixth ahead of Daniel Suarez, who tied his second-best finish of the season with seventh at Richmond. Josh Berry, Brad Keselowski, and Denny Hamlin completed the top ten. Suarez, Keselowski, and Hamlin were all involved in the lap-199 crash that ended the night for Chase Elliott and Justin Haley. The stages were swept by 23XI Racing drivers Tyler Reddick and Bubba Wallace, but both of them found trouble before the end of the night. First, Reddick was spun after being wrapped up in contact between ty Gibbs and Daniel Suarez. A stage later, Wallace went to pit from second in the sequence when his car was released too soon, and his left front wheel was not fully secure, leading to the No. 19 team of Chase Briscoe to finish the pit stop for him. Reddick ultimately finished 15th, putting his playoff berth on the line, if Bowman can make up the needed points at Daytona, and we see a new winner next Saturday. You Might Also Like You Need a Torque Wrench in Your Toolbox Tested: Best Car Interior Cleaners The Man Who Signs Every Car
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Rafael Navarro has 2 goals, 1 assist for Rapids in 3-1 win over Atlanta
COMMERCE CITY, Colo. (AP) — Rafael Navarro had two goals and an assist, Darren Yapi scored a goal for the second consecutive game and the Colorado Rapids beat Atlanta United 3-1 on Saturday night to extend its unbeaten streak to 10 games. Colorado (10-11-6) snapped a three-game winless streak. Navarro drew a foul in the penalty area, conceded by Juan Berrocal, and then converted from the spot in the 64th to give the Rapids a 2-1 lead. Navarro, who has 11 goals and two multi-goal games this season, capped the scoring in the 71st with a first-touch finish from the edge of the area. Atlanta (4-12-10) is winless since a 3-2 victory against Orlando on May 28. Zack Steffen had a save for Colorado. Yapi, who scored two second-half goals in Colorado's 2-1 win over Minnesota on Sunday, opened the scoring in the 18th minute. Yapi skipped a volley, off a centering header played by Navarro, into the net from near the penalty spot. Alexey Miranchuk bent a shot from outside the penalty arc inside the left post to make it 1-1 in the 20th. Atlanta had 56% possession and outshot the Rapids 13-8. ___ AP soccer: The Associated Press
