Church abuse victim stages quiet protest at General Synod
It is 07:30 BST on a grey, humid July morning in York.The city is hosting General Synod - the Church of England's parliament - which is about to approve the landmark compensation legislation.Ms Read, who travelled from her north-east of England home because she "had to be here", has already set up outside.She says, as a child, she was "sadistically" abused over a number of years at her local church by her own father, and also by a male curate and a female church warden.In adulthood, she and her sisters, who also say they were abused as children by the same people, reported the allegations to the Church of England three times, but it never launched a formal investigation.
Ms Read is at General Synod to protest. But she is not blocking traffic, nor is she chanting or shouting into a megaphone. She is sitting peacefully in a camping chair opposite Central Hall, where the event is being held, drinking a cup of tea and eating a biscuit.She is quiet, but she no longer feels silenced and her presence is powerful.Behind her stands a banner she has made. In big red, black and green letters it reads: "Three sisters sadistically abused at a NE church still waiting for justice."
Ms Read's appearance in the shadow of the chamber housing the most powerful figures in the Church of England is striking.Throughout the day members of the public, bishops, clergymen and clergywomen approach her to ask what her story is. Some take over food and drinks.Ms Read says she is here to tell Church leaders that there is an "urgent need" to treat people who report abuse allegations with kindness because "that hasn't been our experience".Her fight for answers has been re-traumatising, she says, but she has waived her right to anonymity in order to share her story.Time may have passed but the mental anguish caused by the abuse and the alleged "fobbing off" from Church leaders has not, she says.In a face-to-face meeting with her in May, Archbishop of York Stephen Cottrell, the interim leader of the Church, offered an "unequivocal apology" for the abuse she had experienced and "recognised that it will have affected her life in many ways".Last month, following a BBC investigation which revealed the Read sisters' story, the Church of England also said it was "truly sorry" for the response they received when they made their initial reports.
'Survivor focused' compensation
The Church has put aside £150m for what it is calling the Redress Scheme, to which any victim of Church-related abuse can apply. It was agreed by General Synod, but still needs to be officially signed off by the government.The Church says the scheme is "survivor focused" and "offers more than money".As well as financial compensation, which can range from £5,000 to £660,000, survivors and victims can also receive "a formal apology, acknowledgment, therapeutic support, and other forms of bespoke redress", it says.Applications can be made via a designated website and "independently assessed by trained assessors" who will consider the type of abuse, aggravating factors and the impact on the victim, it says.They will then decide the level of compensation and support given."This is about the Church facing its past failures with honesty and humility," it says.
The Right Reverend Philip Mounstephen, who chairs the Church's Redress Board, says it is "a matter of great shame" that the scheme is needed. He has previously said it was unclear how many people would apply."I am confident the scheme will provide much needed redress to survivors," he says, adding it will be "bespoke" for each applicant.The scheme has already been delayed by several years and, for Ms Read, it is too late.She has already "spent so many hours and months" in therapy and does not want to "spend any more of my remaining years trekking to therapists", she says."Even if I got the highest award possible, that doesn't compensate for my trauma."Ms Read has been diagnosed with depression and post-traumatic stress disorder linked to her childhood abuse which has, at times, plagued her adult life.Her relationships have been affected and she has only ever been able to work part time.She has panic attacks in religious buildings which make her feel "terrorised" to the point she "has to scream" and get out. Episodes of feeling suicidal mean she "has struggled to survive" on occasions.
"Redress sounds good but, from past experience, I can't quite believe it," Ms Read says."It's really urgent to highlight the need for the Church to get safeguarding right, not just on paper but in actions."Her silent protest brought some closure and, after decades of her feeling dismissed, people have eventually listened, she says."I feel like my voice has finally been heard. I can now move on with the rest of my life."
Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
2 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Bank of England poised to cut interest rates on Thursday
The Bank of England is poised to cut interest rates on Thursday despite a growing divide between its policymakers over the dangers to the economy from high inflation and rising unemployment. In a development that will ease pressure on households and businesses, City forecasters expect the central bank to announce a quarter-point cut, its fifth rate reduction in a year. Financial markets predict an almost 100% chance of a quarter-point cut from 4.25%, the same as the last reduction in May. The chancellor, Rachel Reeves, will welcome the cut as Labour comes under pressure over its economic management and growing questions about potential tax rises at her autumn budget. Ministers have sought to claim credit for the Bank reducing its base rate four times since August last year, arguing that it had been able to do so only after Labour had worked to 'restore stability to the economy'. Publishing research before the rate decision at midday on Thursday, the party said a family buying a typical home was now paying almost £1,000 a year less on their mortgage than in July 2024, when the Conservatives left office. Figures from the property website Rightmove showed that a typical first-time buyer's mortgage payment was now almost £100 a month less than a year earlier. However, a fifth rate cut will highlight the dangers facing the economy amid a worsening slowdown, as households and businesses grapple with tax rises, stubborn inflation, and global uncertainty created by Donald Trump's tariff war. Analysts expect the vote on rates from the Bank's nine-strong monetary policy committee to be split, exposing tensions at the heart of Threadneedle Street over the best course of action to keep fast-rising consumer prices in check while also safeguarding jobs and growth. City investors are predicting a three-way split, with the external economists Alan Taylor and Swati Dhingra favouring a bigger, half-point cut amid concern about rising job losses. Most of the MPC members, including the governor, Andrew Bailey, are expected to vote for a quarter-point reduction. Huw Pill, the Bank's chief economist, could split from his colleagues to join the external economist Catherine Mann in voting to keep rates unchanged owing to concerns that inflationary pressures are mounting. Analysts believe that divisions have become more entrenched since the Bank last produced economic forecasts in May. Threadneedle Street will update its outlook on Thursday. Michael Saunders, a former MPC member who is now at the consultancy Oxford Economics, said the committee's split was understandable. 'You have weak growth, rising unemployment and inflation well above target; those signals go in opposite directions [for a rate decision],' he said. 'Different people will put different weights on them. It is not sign that they are more argumentative than other committees [in the past], just that they face a greater disparity between growth, unemployment and inflation.' Sign up to Business Today Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning after newsletter promotion Interest rate cuts support economic growth by lowering borrowing costs for businesses and households. However, bolstering economic activity can stoke inflationary pressures. 'Monetary policy remains quite tight. Fiscal policy is tightening, and the budget may include further tax hikes later this year. Trade policy uncertainty remains high, deterring investment and hiring.' China diverting cheap exports from the US to the UK during Trump's tariff war could also reinforce downward pressure on inflation, he added. Labour has come under pressure from business leaders blaming Britain's recent economic weakness on Reeves raising employment taxes in her first autumn budget, which firms warned would force them to cut jobs and put up prices. Official figures show unemployment has crept higher in recent months, while the economy shrank in April and May. Inflation has risen by more than expected, reaching 3.6% in June – significantly above the Bank's 2% target. Business surveys this week have shown a slowdown in the service sector and a collapse in construction output. Labour said cheaper mortgage rates available today – with the average two-year fixed rate falling to 4.52% – had saved borrowers £81.69 on average each month. The Treasury minister James Murray said: 'Labour's urgent task when we took office was to restore stability to the economy after 14 years of Tory failure. Since we came into office, rates have been cut four times, and that's putting more pounds in the pocket of homeowners through cheaper mortgages.'
BBC News
2 minutes ago
- BBC News
Waste worker faces threats to 'smash face in' amid rise in abuse
A worker at a recycling centre has told of how people have threatened to "wait for him at the end of the day" and "smash his face in" after a rise in reports of abuse at the sites. Waste operator Suez has recorded a 42% increase in reports of abuse at its household waste sites nationally in 2025 compared to the previous company has seen 64 incidents reported in Greater Manchester, with employees facing threats of violence for refusing to accept trade waste and enforcing site rules. Michael Peers, who works at the centre in Bredbury, said: "You could have 1,000 people coming on site, and 999 are great and follow requests, but it's that one person." Suez operates 20 household waste recycling centres across Greater Manchester, and said the sites receive 400,000 visitors a operator has called for members of the public to respect its staff as it released the abuse figures. Stuart Taylor, who is a supervisor for five of the sites in the county, said he "constantly" worries about staff at the five sites he is responsible said one person was hit on site and had their jaw broken."It's not something you come to work for, to have that environment," he Peers, who works as a chargehand, said he had received threats of violence while doing his job."Members of the public suggesting they're going to come back and wait for us at the end of the day, smash my face in," he said "no one's going to ask to be abused" while doing their job and "everyone should have respect for one another in their profession".
Telegraph
2 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Revealed: 200 asylum hotel residents charged with crimes this year
At least 200 people living in asylum seeker hotels have been charged with criminal offences this year, without police revealing their immigration status, The Telegraph can disclose. Court records show that 211 people living in the hotels, which are used by the Home Office to house asylum seekers, have been charged with a combined 425 offences. Of these, 109 were violent offences and 44 were sexual offences, including four counts of alleged rape. There were also 63 theft-related offences. The Telegraph analysed court records linked to 50 known asylum hotels. There are more than 200 such sites across the UK used to house those seeking asylum, with still more asylum seekers housed in private rentals. Not every defendant who lists one of these hotels as their place of residence is necessarily an asylum seeker. It has not been possible to establish how many of the alleged offenders identified by The Telegraph are currently applying for asylum in the UK. Nevertheless, The Telegraph's findings offer a sense of the numbers of asylum seekers who may be involved in crime. It came as migrants continued to arrive in the UK after crossing the English Channel on the day a ' one in, one out ' deal with France came into force. Under a pilot scheme that took effect on Wednesday, adults arriving on a small boat can be detained and returned to France for the first time in an effort to limit arrivals. This is in exchange for an approved asylum seeker in France to be brought to the UK under a safe route. On Wednesday, the Conservative Party also set out proposals under which asylum seekers who had been caught working illegally would have their claim automatically rejected and face immediate deportation, either to their country of origin or to a safe third country. All wages gained from the individual working illegally would be seized and used to cover the cost of any asylum support they received. Yvette Cooper, the Home Secretary, said this week that police should reveal more information about suspects, and that guidance to police was already being looked at. But she added it was an 'operational decision' for forces and the Crown Prosecution Service over what information to release. Police are under pressure to routinely disclose the nationality and migration status of suspects to protect community cohesion and to address a perception among some groups that asylum seekers are carrying out a disproportionate number of offences. On Tuesday, Ms Cooper told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that ministers wanted the public to have more detail about those charged, adding: 'We do think the guidance needs to change.' The Law Commission is expected to issue new guidance in the coming months that would allow nationality and asylum status to be disclosed if it is in the public interest to do so. While the majority of hotels had one or two residents charged with criminal offences, there were some with significantly more. Residents at the Holiday Inn, Empire Way, in Wembley were charged with 28 offences in the time period, while those at the Holiday Inn Express in Oxford and the Derby Midland Hotel had been charged with a combined 24 offences. In Epping, protests broke out last month after reports that an Ethiopian asylum seeker, Hadush Kebatu, had been charged with sexually assaulting a schoolgirl eight days after arriving in the UK. He has denied wrongdoing. Mr Kebatu is not the only Bell Hotel resident to face serious criminal charges. In April, another man appeared before Chelmsford magistrates' court charged with two counts of arson with intent to endanger life. The case was sent to Chelmsford Crown Court for a plea hearing on 5 May. In addition to Mr Kebatu, the review of court reports linked to 50 migrant hotels identified seven other individuals charged with a combined further 11 sex offences against children. These included the alleged rape of a girl aged 13 to 15; six counts of making child abuse material; two counts of attempting sexual communication with a child; an attempt to meet a girl under 16 after grooming; and one count of possessing child abuse material. In another case, a warrant was issued in June for a 24-year-old resident of a Liverpool migrant hotel accused of attempting to engage in sexual communication with a child. The man, who had failed to appear at Sefton magistrates' court on June 20 for his trial, allegedly sent numerous WhatsApp messages to a child under 16. According to court records, he arranged to meet the child, told her he loved her, and expressed desires to 'lay down with her and kiss and cuddle her'. He had previously pleaded not guilty to the charge. Sexual crimes against adults made up 32 of the offences reviewed by The Telegraph. The court records suggest that a significant proportion of these offences are alleged to have been perpetrated against other apparent asylum seekers. In some cases, bail conditions stipulate that the defendant cannot enter into another hotel used by the Home Office as this is where the alleged victim lives. In others, there is a marital relationship between the alleged perpetrator and victim. In one case, before a court in the north of England last month, a resident of a hotel housing asylum seekers was accused of strangling and suffocating his wife. A further 49 hotel residents were charged with 109 violent offences, including 40 counts of assault by beating, 19 of assaulting emergency workers, five of actual bodily harm, 10 of common assault and five of intentional strangulation. In one case, a 24-year-old man living in a Bournemouth hotel allegedly threatened another person with a snooker cue. He was granted unconditional bail and is due to appear at Poole magistrates' court on Aug 6 for a plea hearing. A Kurdish interpreter will attend. In another, heard on May 19, a 24-year-old asylum seeker was handed a suspended sentence at Chelmsford magistrates' court after admitting affray. Magistrates cited Sohaib Atem's 'strong personal mitigation' and 'realistic prospect of rehabilitation' in suspending an eight-month prison term for 12 months. A frequent complaint from residents living near asylum hotels is a rise in theft. Of the 63 theft offences residents in the 50 hotels were alleged to have committed, 14 were burglary offences and 37 were thefts from shops. Among them was Mamukr Kvaratskhelia, 39, who also appeared at Chelmsford magistrates' court in March charged with five counts of theft over a three-month period. He is accused of stealing designer sunglasses and fragrance worth more than £2,000, including £299 Ray-Bans from John Lewis and four pairs of glasses worth £1,165 from a local optician. Twelve hotel residents were charged with criminal damage. In one case, Akhmed Mohammad, formerly housed at Wethersfield asylum centre in Essex, was ordered to pay £380 for damaging a lavatory window in a car park. Mohammed was given until Sept 5 to pay the total amount, with magistrates citing his 'good previous character, low means and circumstances' in their decision. 'Police are in invidious position' Philip Seccombe, the Warwickshire police and crime commissioner, has pressed Ms Cooper for an urgent update on what information forces should give to the public after allegations that authorities tried to cover up alleged offences by asylum seekers. Mr Seccombe called for fresh national guidance to be issued after the charging of two men – reported to be Afghan asylum seekers – prompted accusations that the force withheld information about their immigration status. The pair are accused of raping of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. Mr Seccombe said: 'Currently, police forces are in an invidious position when deciding what can and should be disclosed in sensitive cases, given that the national guidance is silent on both the ethnicity and immigration status of suspects. 'It is very easy to criticise and suggest that the balance of disclosure hasn't been correct, but it is much harder to take these decisions on the ground.'
