
Tampa City Council blocks Rodeph Sholom condo proposal a third time
A third attempt to build a condominium on the site of the Rodeph Sholom synagogue on Bayshore Blvd was shot down by Tampa City Council Tuesday night after hours of public comments and a heated back and forth between council members.
For nearly three years, The Related Group has tried and failed to rezone a portion of the synagogue's land to build a high-rise condo tower.
Two earlier iterations of the plan presented in May 2023 and February this year were rejected by the city council for being too tall and out of place in the neighborhood. The first proposal called for 29 stories and the second called for 26.
The third time around, the developer and synagogue took a different approach.
Last year, Related and Rodeph Sholom filed a request for relief under Florida's land use laws. They claimed the synagogue's property value was diminished by the city's attempts to block rezoning.
All three parties entered mediation in June. They agreed that the synagogue and developer should present an amended proposal and let council decide whether to accept or reject the plan as a form of settlement.
That's what Tuesday's meeting was about. Council members Charlie Miranda, Bill Carlson, Lynn Hurtak and Guido Maniscalco voted to reject the settlement while Alan Clendenin, Gwendolyn Henderson and Luis Viera voted in favor of it.
The updated plan called for a 16-story tower with 38-condo units. It also included additional sidewalks, an enhanced crosswalk and more trees than prior proposals.
Members of the neighboring Tampa Garden Club and several nearby condo owners who turned out to oppose the measure said this wasn't an adequate compromise.
'If you start with a project that is absurdly incompatible, that doesn't make it compatible, it just makes it less absurdly incompatible,' said Richard Harrison, an attorney representing the Garden Club. He compared the plan to putting 'lipstick on a pig.'
Rodeph Sholom congregation members and other supporters said the land deal would make it possible for them to pay for necessary building upgrades and remain on Bayshore, which has been their home for more than 100 years.
They pointed to nearby buildings like the 24-story Altura Bayshore condo and the 15-story Presbyterian apartments to show the prevalence of high-rise development in the area.
'This is bigger than one building,' Lloyd Stern, president of Rodeph Sholom said. 'This is about Tampa's future. Will we be a city that embraces responsible sustainable growth, or one that caves to a small vocal opposition at the expense of progress?'
Though the proposal is stalled for now, the fight may not be over. The developer and synagogue already laid the groundwork for a potential lawsuit when they filed a petition in court last year.
In an interview ahead of Tuesday's meeting, Nicole MacInnes from Stearns Miller Weaver, the law firm representing Rodeph Sholom and Related, told the Tampa Bay Times that they would 'certainly be looking at all legal opportunities that they have to continue with this site.'
Council members Viera and Clendenin, who voted in favor of the settlement, questioned whether this was a battle worth waging considering the potential legal implications and the possibility that a future council may vote to approve an even bigger development on the site.
Hurtak, who opposed the measure, argued that voting in favor of the plan just to avoid litigation would set a dangerous precedent.
'This is exactly what developers are going to do,' she said. 'If they can get on this they are going to start high and they're going to end a little bit higher than they are allowed. We are opening the floodgates to this.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
Nuventive and the APCU Launch Sustainability Ecosystem to Accelerate Success Through Innovation
Digital Community is Now Open to Higher Education Associations Interested in Sharing Effective Practices PITTSBURGH, June 10, 2025 /PRNewswire/ -- Nuventive, the data-informed improvement company™, has launched a new Sustainability Improvement Ecosystem in partnership with the Association of Presbyterian Colleges and Universities (APCU). This digital community enables organizations to benchmark and share effective practices in support of sustainability goals. The new ecosystem is built on the Nuventive Improvement Platform, which has helped institutions of all sizes achieve improvement goals and strategic alignment for more than two decades. Through this partnership, the APCU institutions are pioneering a new way to access real-world strategies and demonstrate measurable progress on sustainability initiatives. The APCU's participation was funded by a grant from the Council of Independent Colleges. "We're thrilled to launch this Sustainability Ecosystem with the APCU, a visionary partner committed to addressing one of the most pressing challenges of our time," said Dr. David Raney, CEO of Nuventive. "This community enables participants to learn from one another, identify what's working, and use data to take informed action." The Sustainability Ecosystem allows participants to: Discover and explore sustainability initiatives from peer organizations Access a growing, searchable library of effective practices, lessons learned, and strategies Align initiatives with institutional strategic plans and broader outcome sets Benchmark internal efforts against others and track progress over time Use interactive dashboards to visualize activity and impact Share insights, documents, and data across a trusted network "Nuventive's platform is a powerful tool that enables our members to share stories about their commitment to sustainability in tangible, trackable ways," said Jeffrey Arnold, Executive Director of the APCU. "It also allows our schools to reinforce environmental stewardship – a Presbyterian value that transcends religion and applies to all organizations working to leave the world better than they found it." While the initial rollout centers on APCU member institutions, other higher education associations with a common interest in sustainability, a willingness to share their work, and a desire to improve may apply to join. Contact sustainability@ to learn more. More information about the APCU's sustainability efforts is available at: About NuventiveNuventive, the data-informed improvement company™, enables higher education institutions to turn their priorities into progress through the better use of information. Its cloud-based platform combines business processes and information to support any improvement initiative, including overall strategy, accreditation, student success, learning outcomes, general education, administrative outcomes, program review, and sustainability. Nuventive is headquartered in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. For more information, please visit or follow Nuventive on LinkedIn. About the Association of Presbyterian Colleges and UniversitiesThe Association of Presbyterian Colleges and Universities is an independent, not-for-profit organization dedicated to the support and advancement of colleges and universities founded by the Presbyterian Church (USA). The 49 member institutions have found 49 distinct ways to build on their Presbyterian heritage as they seek to impact their students and the world in remarkable ways. The result is a broad set of academic, social, and spiritual opportunities available across a diverse array of geographic settings that stretch across the continental U.S. and around the world. Nuventive, the Nuventive logo, and the marks relating to other Nuventive products and services referenced herein are either trademarks or registered trademarks of Nuventive LLC. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Media Contact: Learnmore@ View original content to download multimedia: SOURCE Nuventive Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
A Tampa cemetery is on sale again, reigniting debate over lost graves
Three years after the Tampa City Council unanimously rejected a land-use change for Showmen's Rest, a Tampa Heights cemetery, that would have allowed developers to build out the land, the parcel is up for sale again. This time, the cemetery isn't looking to change its zoning. But the City Council and nearby residents are still torn over a central question: Are there unknown bodies buried beneath the land? Owners of Showmen's Rest have said the portion of land up for sale has not been used for burials. But the Tampa City Council passed a motion Thursday to have city staff contact the property owner and ask if they could use ground-penetrating radar to address concerns about lost graves. 'Should there be graves there, individuals there, then we can look at steps forward,' said council member Guido Maniscalco, who made the motion. Maniscalco also requested a written report from city staff to update the council, which is due June 26. Although he did not mention the name of the property during the motion, Maniscalco confirmed with the Tampa Bay Times after the meeting that the report is about Showmen's Rest. Listed on Zillow for $750,000, the parcel of land at 3541 N. Blvd. is adjacent to the city-owned Woodlawn Cemetery. Showmen's Rest Cemetery hired a firm during the initial controversy more than three years ago that conducted two seismic studies that didn't find any lost graves. The Zillow listing states the seller will do another survey. 'The people that are going up against us keep insisting that there are bodies buried on this vacant parcel of land that we've never developed,' Showmen's Rest President John Perzia said. The cemetery has presented its seismic studies to the City Council, 'but nobody wanted to pay attention to it.' Perzia said the cemetery wants to sell this parcel, which was purchased from the city in 1971, to put it in a trust to keep up maintenance. They don't care who buys it, Perzia said, but they want to ensure their cemetery is preserved. 'I'm almost 70,' he said. 'When I pass away, who's going to take care of this place?' He said the city is welcome to buy the property, but city spokesperson Adam Smith said the administration is not looking to purchase. Perzia said neither he or his real estate broker had heard from the city on Monday afternoon. Maniscalco's motion on Thursday came after a previous council discussion of the cemetery on May 22. At that meeting, council member Bill Carlson also introduced the idea of setting aside city funds for ground-penetrating radar and addressing lost graves. 'What role can the city play? Because not everyone can pay for ground-penetrating radar and not everyone can afford just to give up their land,' Carlson said last month. The Tampa Bay Times reported in 2021 that there were 1,200 missing graves in the city, mostly those of influential Black residents, and the city is attempting to acknowledge and correct its role in erasing Black history. This year, the city erected a historical marker at Zion Cemetery, which was a Black burial ground before it was developed over. The city can't go onto privately owned land without the owner's permission to look for graves. If it does, the surveys are expensive. 'I was happy to hear the City Council is considering creating a fund for ground-penetrating radar,' said Rachael Kangas, director of the west central and central regions of the Florida Public Archaeology Network. 'That's usually the biggest issue we run into.' Kangas reviewed documents sent to her by Aileen Henderson, founder of The Cemetery Society, regarding the cemetery and its history, as well as research files her organization has on Woodlawn Cemetery and Showmen's Rest. 'According to the records I see, that entire block, including this parcel, were part of the original footprint of Woodlawn Cemetery and there is documentation from the newspaper that burials when the cemetery was first established were haphazard,' Kangas wrote in an email to Henderson that was shared with the Times. Additionally, Kangas wrote, the northwest corner of Woodlawn Cemetery was originally set aside for African American graves. She said documentation she read doesn't have details on the size of that area or where exactly the burials were. 'There is no reason to think this parcel of land is not part of a cemetery or that it doesn't contain unmarked burials,' Kangas wrote. Henderson said she also thinks Showmen's Rest could have lost graves and said she was excited to see the City Council take steps toward addressing the citywide issue. 'I don't blame the owner for doing what he has the right to do,' Henderson said. 'The reality is we have the supporting documentation that that is a cemetery.'
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Meet the Harrisburg pastor bringing ‘church' to ‘state'
An ordained minister of the Presbyterian Church in America, Zeigler has worked in the Pennsylvania Capitol since March 2024 with the goal of providing religious and spiritual guidance through 'prayer, discipleship and evangelism.' (Capital-Star/Vincent DiFonzo) The Rev. Ron Zeigler has a proposition for Pennsylvania lawmakers: Take a minute from your busy day, sit with him and let him pray for you. Amid the busyness of the Pennsylvania Capitol as the legislature scrambles to pass the state budget on time, Zeigler frequents the East Wing cafeteria with a sign that invites all who pass by to sit down and talk with him. The reverend possesses a unique title — state Capitol minister — in which he provides pastoral services to Capitol denizens — lawmakers, civil servants, staff and just about anyone working in the building. By providing a 'political free zone' to talk with him, Zeigler says he's able to connect with state employees and lawmakers across the political spectrum. 'I tell folks if I'm a lobbyist of any kind, it's for Jesus Christ,' he said. 'What's most important to me is not the Republican or Democrat agenda, but the kingdom of Christ.' An ordained minister of the Presbyterian Church in America, Zeigler has worked full time in the Capitol since March 2024 with the goal of providing religious and spiritual guidance through 'prayer, discipleship and evangelism.' He works for Ministry to State, a Washington, D.C.-based Presbyterian ministry that reaches 10 state capitals and Washington, entirely funded by donations. Founder Chuck Garriott was inspired to create the organization after tragedy shook the nation. He was a pastor in Oklahoma City in 1995 when a powerful truck bomb detonated outside the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building, killing 167, including 19 children, and injuring more than 600 others. SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE The Oklahoma City bombing remains the deadliest domestic terrorist attack in American history. 'In the aftermath of this tragedy, Chuck and the elders at [their church] recognized a profound reality: Those serving in government face unique spiritual and personal challenges, and the church is uniquely positioned to offer them the care and support they need,' according to the organization's website. 'Motivated by this conviction, [they] began a ministry to the Oklahoma state capital, hosting a weekly luncheon Bible study that soon grew to more than 80 regular attendees,' the site says. In 2003, Garriott moved to Washington to establish Ministry to State, with the goal of replicating its Oklahoma City ministry in state capitals around the country. It maintains its position as a nonpartisan source of spiritual guidance for civil servants and elected officials. Steve Bostrom, the minister in Montana's Capitol, got involved after moving to Helena from North Carolina to start a church. Soon after, he began ministering to state legislators, leading to his full-time Ministry to State position. Bostrom sees precedent for Ministry to State's mission in the Bible, pointing to the missionary work of the apostle Paul, who, 'in his travels went to many capitals.' 'He was strategic, trying to reach leadership,' he said. Zeigler, a former public school teacher turned clergyman, said he was initially intimidated when Ministry to State's associate director for state capitols, Thomas Eddy, offered him the Harrisburg ministry 'I'm just a regular guy. I pastor small churches, and not that many people know me outside of my smaller circles,' Zeigler said. 'These are some significant people that work here in many ways. So I was a bit intimidated.' Zeigler initially told Eddy he didn't think he was the right fit, but '[Eddy] was really convinced that this ministry was for me,' he said. He told Eddy that 'the main gift God has given me is that I see people.' Eddy replied with a question: What is a group of people in American culture 'most people would rather not see and don't think well of?' Eddy's answer: civil government leaders. 'You're exactly the kind of person we need here,' Eddy told him. In his role, Zeigler makes himself available for discussion or prayer with 'anyone who could use someone,' with the goal of building personal, long-lasting connections. 'I'm here to see people not get eaten up by working here, it's a challenging place to be,' he said. 'I pray that they are able to stay faithful to their oath of office and just encourage them.' From 'long theological conversations' to simply listening to people talk about what troubles them, he said his conversations can vary wildly in topic. 'If there's anything I can do, I can pray, and I can just be available. And that's where this got started,' he said. During one particularly busy session day in the Capitol, Zeigler greeted a custodian in the hallway: 'I just said, 'Hello, how you doing?' She said, 'I'm feeling pretty sick, but today, it's all hands on deck.' He asked if he could pray with her. She agreed. 'I prayed that she'd be able to get through the day and that maybe once things settle down, that she might be able to get off early,' he said. 'When I was done, she was in tears, and she reached over and just gave me a big hug.' As an ordained minister, Zeigler holds his conversations in confidence, which he compared to the confidentiality of a priest or lawyer. 'The most rewarding parts of my ministry at the Capitol are talking with people about what it's important to them, and praying with them and for them,' Zeigler said. 'Simply caring for them as people is very rewarding.' Although Zeigler is Presbyterian, he works to connect with people of different religious beliefs. He says he is not present in Harrisburg to convert, but to minister, although he is not shy to preach when it's asked for. 'I'm here as a Christian minister, but I'm not pressing on anybody,' he said. 'I make sure it's clear that I'm here to talk about what's important to you. If you want to hear what I think about something I'm glad to tell you, and I'm glad to talk, but I will never press and say 'you got to believe what I believe.'' SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX