EXCLUSIVE: Council in Dundee aware of Raac issues nearly 50 years ago
Dundee's former local council was aware of structural issues caused by Raac nearly 50 years ago, The Courier can reveal.
Documents from the local authority archives reveal that concerns were first raised about Siporex, a brand of Raac, as far back as 1977.
The issue was discovered in 34 homes.
In 1977, the depute chief architect of City of Dundee District Council – as it was called then – wrote a report called 'Craigie Drive 3rd Development – Defective Ceilings'.
The architect stated that the moisture content of Siporex 'was higher than normally would be expected' in units built nine years previously in 1968/69.
The architect, Ian M. Dunsire, speaks of the concrete 'blistering'.
He reports: 'These blisters are sufficiently loose to be easily removed and leave a small crater on the underside of the ceiling.'
Siporex problems were identified in three estates, known then as Craigie Drive 3rd development, and Kirk Street 1st and 2nd developments.
The Courier understands they are now called Southampton Place, Kirk Street and Yeamans Lane.
All three streets have been found to contain Raac since 2023 through testing by Dundee City Council.
In 1978, the director of technical services at the City of Dundee District Council submitted a report detailing the probable costs for 'the repair of Siporex ceilings' at the three developments.
£70,000 was set aside in 1978 to address the issue.
The Right to Buy scheme, through which many Raac properties were purchased from the council, did not begin until 1980.
Nearly 800 homes in Dundee are now known to contain Raac, the highest number of affected residential properties in Scotland.
Dundee City Council has repeatedly told homeowners they must pay for their own repairs.
A statement on the local authority's website states: 'The council has no ongoing maintenance responsibilities and no liability towards owners who bought their former council properties under the 'Right to Buy' scheme, or any subsequent owners.'
As part of our Trapped by Raac campaign, The Courier is asking people to sign this petition to help homeowners affected by the crisis.
The Courier asked Dundee City Council if it accepts that Raac was known to be in homes, and that there were issues with the product, before the properties were sold to private homeowners through the Right to Buy Scheme.
In response, a spokesperson for Dundee City Council said: 'These are historic records which relate to consideration of work at 34 properties.
'There was no suggestion of wider remedial work being identified across the rest of the development, or in other developments where Siporex might have been used, indicating that this was being treated as a localised issue.
'Defects can happen in properties of all construction types and there was no prior equivalent industry-wide concern about Raac until the issues came to light in schools in England from 2019 onwards.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Courier
3 hours ago
- The Courier
Dundee golfers could launch bid to reopen Caird Park courses
A group of Dundee golfers could launch a bid to reopen the Caird Park golf courses under a community ownership model. Friends of Cairdy and the Golf Course, made up of players and campaigners who want to see the courses reopened, is exploring the idea of taking the facilities over from the council. If the proposals went through and were financially viable, the courses could then be run as a not-for-profit set-up. The courses were shut down in April in a cost-cutting move by Leisure and Culture Dundee (LCD), ratified by Dundee City Council. The move was designed to save more than £400,000 a year from the LCD budget. The Courier revealed in December how a golf firm had drawn up 'exciting' plans to save the courses. However, these proposals have gone quiet, and the courses are currently being left to overgrow. Paul Johnson is a member of the campaign group and one of those pushing for golf's return to Caird Park. He told The Courier: 'We are confident we can sustain it because there were at least 1,000 season ticket holders when the courses closed. 'We would have at least 20 volunteers, and we would employ greenkeepers who were made unemployed. 'I believe there is still machinery there which can be used. 'Season ticket holders will sustain it, and once we get people playing golf on it again, it will generate money.' However, the group says it needs a breakdown of the finances associated with running the courses to assess whether a community takeover would be viable. Paul said: 'We put a Freedom of Information request into the council at least six months ago asking for the figures, but we've been told they can't give the information and they're holding us up. 'We need the council to give us that information.' Paul says the group wants to bring golf back to Caird Park by April next year. A meeting is being held among members on Thursday afternoon to discuss the proposals. They are also considering whether they could apply for any grants or funding that would help kick-start the takeover. Paul added: 'We just want it to be affordable because it's disgusting how they've treated working-class people. 'Closing the course has caused so much grief. 'I don't want it to become another Camperdown fiasco. 'It should remain a green belt for playing golf on.' In December last year, council leader Mark Flynn told The Courier he would be willing to listen to any proposals to keep golf at Caird Park. He said: 'If anyone is interested in doing something with the council and working with Caird Park to see what can be done in the future, my door is always open.' A Dundee City Council spokesperson said: 'Submissions from interested parties are currently being appraised regarding alternative leisure development of areas within the park and any recommendations would be considered at a future committee.'
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
Six key details you need to know about major house funding change
Chancellor Rachel Reeves has announced £39billion of investment in a new 10-year Affordable Homes Programme - here's everything you need to know about the scheme Rachel Reeves has announced a bombshell £39billion cash injection for affordable and social homes. Delivering her Spending Review in the Commons, the Chancellor said she wanted to ensure people had the "security of a proper home". She said it was a plan to meet the "scale of the housing crisis". Ms Reeves announced a new 10-year Affordable Homes Programme, which will see £39bn of investment over the next decade. She said it was the biggest increase in half a century. She made the commitment in the Spending Review, which sets government departments' budgets for future years, as she promised to "invest in Britain's renewal". It comes as Keir Starmer pushes to meet Labour's manifesto pledge to build 1.5 million homes by the next election. When the plan was first unveiled last night, campaigners said the plan was 'transformational' and could help reverse decades of neglect. Here's a take a look at what the plans could mean for you. READ MORE: Rachel Reeves Spending Review LIVE - Affordable housing change and NHS bombshell What has been announced? In her Spending Review, Rachel Reeves announced substantial increases in capital investment. Capital spending relates to long-term projects such as infrastructure and roads. Among the headline figures, the Government is providing £39billion for a new 10-year Affordable Homes Programme. It means hundreds of thousands of new affordable homes will be built over the next decade. Ms Reeves told the Commons: "Led by (Housing Secretary Angela Rayner), we are taking action. I am proud to announce the biggest cash injection into social and affordable housing in 50 years. A new Affordable Homes Programme - in which I am investing £39billion over the next decade." Why is it necessary? England is facing a huge housing emergency, with millions of people unable to access vital housing. There are 1.3 million households stuck on social housing waiting lists in England, a rise of 10% in the last two years. Some 20,560 social homes were lost in 2023/24, primarily through Right to Buy sales and demolitions, while 19,910 were delivered - meaning a loss of 650 social homes. In the Commons, Ms Reeves said social housing had been "neglected for too many decades, but not by this Labour Government". What is the Affordable Homes Programme? The current Affordable Homes Programme (AHP) has been running from 2021 and had been due to end next year. The scheme allocates grant funding to Local Authorities and Housing Associations to help support the capital costs of developing affordable housing for rent or sale. The new AHP will run for a decade - so double the length of the current one. Plus, the funding announced by Rachel Reeves for the new scheme far exceeds the amount previously committed by the Tories. The Treasury said Labour's plan would see annual investment in affordable housing rise to £4billion by 2029/30, almost double the average of £2.3billion between 2021 and 2026. Who will benefit? Delivery of the current AHP programme is delegated to the scheme's delivery partners Homes England (HE) and the Greater London Authority (GLA). Councils can bid for grant funding to support the delivery for affordable homes. Funding is given on a case-by-case basis. AHP funding supports rental accommodation, homes for ownership and homes in rural settlements and supported housing for older, disabled or vulnerable people. Ms Reeves told the Commons some areas already have plans to put in bids for affordable homes to be built in their region. She said: "Direct Government funding that will support housebuilding especially for social rent and I am pleased to report that towns and cities including Blackpool, Preston, Sheffield and Swindon already have plans to bring forward bids to build new houses." Is there more help for the housing crisis? Alongside the affordable homes announcement, the Government will also address high home energy costs by improving energy efficiency through the Warm Homes Plan. The plan will help to cut bills for families by upgrading homes through insulation, heating and solar panels. A ten-year social rent settlement will set a rent policy for social housing from 2026 that enables providers to borrow and invest in new and existing homes, while also protecting social housing tenants. It will see rents rise at CPI inflation + 1% from 2026. Money for homelessness and rough sleeping has been protected in the Spending Review, while £100million, including from the Transformation Fund, for early interventions to prevent homelessness. What do experts say? Campaigners last night hailed the £39billion announcement. Kate Henderson, chief executive of the National Housing Federation, said: 'This is a transformation package for social housing and will deliver the right conditions for a decade of renewal and growth." Mairi MacRae, director of campaigns and policy at Shelter, said: 'This increased investment is a watershed moment in tackling the housing emergency. It's a huge opportunity to reverse decades of neglect and start a bold new chapter for housing in this country." While there was praise, it was warned that building social homes must be a priority within the new AHP. Currently, various types of housing fall under the 'affordable homes' umbrella, including shared ownership, affordable rent, social rent, first homes Research by Shelter, a homelessness charity found that the current AHP had delivered over 74,000 grant-funded affordable homes by March 2024. Only around 11,000 - just 15% - of these were genuinely affordable social rent homes. Housing campaigner Kwajo Tweneboa said: "This announcement has potential - but without clear social housing targets, it risks becoming another promise that won't deliver change for the children and families who need it most."
The Courier
a day ago
- The Courier
EXCLUSIVE: Council in Dundee aware of Raac issues nearly 50 years ago
Dundee's former local council was aware of structural issues caused by Raac nearly 50 years ago, The Courier can reveal. Documents from the local authority archives reveal that concerns were first raised about Siporex, a brand of Raac, as far back as 1977. The issue was discovered in 34 homes. In 1977, the depute chief architect of City of Dundee District Council – as it was called then – wrote a report called 'Craigie Drive 3rd Development – Defective Ceilings'. The architect stated that the moisture content of Siporex 'was higher than normally would be expected' in units built nine years previously in 1968/69. The architect, Ian M. Dunsire, speaks of the concrete 'blistering'. He reports: 'These blisters are sufficiently loose to be easily removed and leave a small crater on the underside of the ceiling.' Siporex problems were identified in three estates, known then as Craigie Drive 3rd development, and Kirk Street 1st and 2nd developments. The Courier understands they are now called Southampton Place, Kirk Street and Yeamans Lane. All three streets have been found to contain Raac since 2023 through testing by Dundee City Council. In 1978, the director of technical services at the City of Dundee District Council submitted a report detailing the probable costs for 'the repair of Siporex ceilings' at the three developments. £70,000 was set aside in 1978 to address the issue. The Right to Buy scheme, through which many Raac properties were purchased from the council, did not begin until 1980. Nearly 800 homes in Dundee are now known to contain Raac, the highest number of affected residential properties in Scotland. Dundee City Council has repeatedly told homeowners they must pay for their own repairs. A statement on the local authority's website states: 'The council has no ongoing maintenance responsibilities and no liability towards owners who bought their former council properties under the 'Right to Buy' scheme, or any subsequent owners.' As part of our Trapped by Raac campaign, The Courier is asking people to sign this petition to help homeowners affected by the crisis. The Courier asked Dundee City Council if it accepts that Raac was known to be in homes, and that there were issues with the product, before the properties were sold to private homeowners through the Right to Buy Scheme. In response, a spokesperson for Dundee City Council said: 'These are historic records which relate to consideration of work at 34 properties. 'There was no suggestion of wider remedial work being identified across the rest of the development, or in other developments where Siporex might have been used, indicating that this was being treated as a localised issue. 'Defects can happen in properties of all construction types and there was no prior equivalent industry-wide concern about Raac until the issues came to light in schools in England from 2019 onwards.'
