New ruling revives effort to cut Nashville's Metro Council in half
Why it matters: The 2-1 decision released Tuesday reverses a lower court ruling and hands the state a significant victory in its ongoing legal battle with Metro.
If the appeals ruling stands, the council would be reduced to 20 members following an upcoming election.
The big picture: Republican lawmakers approved a law to shrink the council in 2023 amid a pitched battle between state and local leaders.
The law would have shrunk the size of the council after the August 2023 election. Courts initially delayed the law and then ruled that it violated the Tennessee Constitution because it was an attempt to single out Nashville.
The latest: The divided appeals court disagreed, saying the law was constitutionally sound because it could apply in Nashville and to future metropolitan councils.
"There is simply 'nothing in the language of the constitution to prevent' the Tennessee General Assembly from imposing its own limit on the voting membership of a metropolitan council," the ruling states.
What's next: The city could seek a review from the Tennessee Supreme Court.
What they're saying:"We are understandably disappointed and concerned about this ruling's implications for local sovereignty," Metro associate law director Allison L. Bussell said in a statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
8 minutes ago
- Politico
Another megabill? Senate Republicans have their doubts.
And Senate Finance Committee Chair Mike Crapo (R-Idaho) said he's open to considering as many as 200 tax proposals from his members that were ultimately not included in the first megabill. But most senators have questions about what could go into another reconciliation package — and they're casting doubts on whether it's even politically possible to do this all over again. 'You have to have a reason to do it,' said Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.). 'It's not easy to do, so you have to have a purpose for doing it in the first place.' That unifying purpose for Republicans the first time around was a desire to deliver Trump a major legislative victory early in his second term and prevent a tax hike that they feared would weaken the economy. Republican leaders' decision to throw in a debt limit extension through 2026 as Treasury warned the nation would soon exceed its borrowing authority added a do-or-die incentive. 'Without the pressure, I don't see how you get it done,' said one Republican senator, granted anonymity to speak freely, about prospects for passing a second reconciliation bill without an existential impetus for action. 'I don't think I see what the pressure is here.' At the same time, despite the White House's enthusiasm for another reconciliation bill, administration officials have not yet told lawmakers what policies they want considered, according to three people speaking on condition of anonymity. Sens. Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) and Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) — chairs of the committees on Armed Services and Budget, respectively — also said before leaving for recess they have not received guidance from the White House. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, said he still hadn't heard from the administration about its broader set of legislative priorities heading into the fall. At this point, the loudest reconciliation push in the Senate is coming from deficit hawks like Sen. Ron Johnson, who wants to use another bill to cut spending further than what conservatives were able to achieve in the first package.
Politico
15 minutes ago
- Politico
The mysteries of megabill 2.0
IN TODAY'S EDITION:— A Senate buzzkill for megabill 2.0— California Dems prep new congressional map— Murphy looks to revive doctor pay revamp Republicans are going through the motions on the road to megabill 2.0. But a growing number of GOP lawmakers are skeptical about what's to come. Despite Speaker Mike Johnson's push for second and third budget reconciliation bills, it's becoming clear that Senate Republicans aren't so sure what the party can deliver after a grueling battle over the 'big, beautiful' tax and spending plan that became law last month. Mia, Jordain Carney and Cassandra Dumay are out this morning with a look at the big reasons why GOP skepticism abounds. No direction — A White House official tells Mia that President Donald Trump really does want Congress to craft another domestic policy bill using the party-line budget reconciliation process. But Republicans say they're still waiting for the administration to provide specific instructions about what they should consider. Among those in the dark are committee leaders including Budget Chair Lindsey Graham and Armed Services Chair Roger Wicker. Commerce Chair Ted Cruz says he doesn't even know what the administration's broader legislative priorities are heading into the fall. 'You have to have a reason to do it,' Sen. Mike Rounds says. 'It's not easy to do, so you have to have a purpose for doing it in the first place.' Some Senate Republicans are working to fill in the gaps. Sen. Ron Johnson, a deficit hawk, is looking to cut spending. Senate Finance Chair Mike Crapo says he'll sort through roughly 200 tax proposals that were left out of the first reconciliation bill. No deadlines — Even if the White House floats some policy asks, it's not likely Republicans will feel as much pressure to advance a bill. With megabill 1.0, they had to avert a year-end expiration of Trump's 2017 tax cuts and head off a debt ceiling crisis. 'Without the pressure, I don't see how you get it done,' says one Republican senator granted anonymity. 'I don't think I see what the pressure is here.' GOOD MONDAY MORNING. Mia's out for the week. Email us: crazor@ and bguggenheim@ THE LEADERSHIP SUITE The latest on redistricting Democratic state lawmakers in California are expected to unveil a new congressional map this week. One draft that's circulating would give Democrats five new seats, potentially offsetting a GOP redistricting effort underway in Texas. Gov. Gavin Newsom wants to put the redistricting effort on the ballot in November. 'We discovered that we indeed could, consistent with the Voting Rights Act, put five Republican seats in play,' Rep. Zoe Lofgren, chair of the California Democratic congressional delegation, told CNN Sunday. 'We're unanimous in wanting to move forward.' As the White House ramps up pressure on red states to pursue redistricting, Vice President JD Vance said in a Fox News interview that he told Indiana state officials last week 'we want a unified Republican team.' Vance also said a new census sought by Trump could add 10 GOP seats and lead to 9 fewer Democratic seats. POLICY RUNDOWN COURT AFFIRMS CONGRESS' POWER OF THE PURSE — The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals is giving the Trump administration until Friday to put back online a public database that tracks federal spending, Kyle Cheney and Josh Gerstein report. The three-judge panel's unanimous decision over the weekend comes after the administration decided in March to shut the database down, claiming it threatened Trump's ability to manage federal spending. The judges declared that action was an affront to Congress' authority over government spending. MURPHY PREPS DOC PAY REVAMP — Rep. Greg Murphy, a House Ways and Means member and co-chair of the GOP Doctors Caucus, is looking to revive legislation aimed at shielding doctors from recurring cuts to their Medicare payments. It's a potential menu item for a year-end health care deal that lawmakers are beginning to sketch out. Doctors have seen declines in their Medicare payments for decades even as the cost of health care has steadily increased. The tax law that Trump enacted last month included a 2.5 percent bump for 2026, after Senate Republicans scrapped a House-backed provision that would have permanently tied the doctor fee scale to an index that tracks rising medical costs. Murphy wants a second shot. 'I cannot overemphasize how much damage these persistent cuts to the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule have done,' Murphy tells Benjamin. Best of POLITICO Pro and E&E: THE BEST OF THE REST Affairs, fraud and attack ads: The dirty fight for the Texas Senate, from Benedict Smith at The Telegraph Bernie Sanders thinks Democrats have turned on their base. Now it's time to fight back, from Veronica Stracqualursi at CNN THE CARRYOUT Welcome back to your Inside Congress hosts' favorite recess activity: sharing lawmakers' Capitol Hill food recommendations. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen said her go-to is a ham and swiss sandwich on rye from Capitol Hill Supermarket. What's your regular order in the neighborhood? Email crazor@ CAMPAIGN STOP CHIP ROY FOR AG? — Rep. Chip Roy is eyeing a bid for Texas attorney general as current AG Ken Paxton campaigns to oust Sen. John Cornyn, reports Mychael Schnell in The Hill. IOWA WATCH — Arizona Sen. Ruben Gallego attended the Iowa State Fair over the weekend. Asked by a reporter about a potential 2028 bid for president, the Arizona Democrat said he's 'focused on 2026' for now. TUNNEL TALK NEW EATERIES ON CAMPUS — The renovated Rayburn Cafeteria is scheduled to open this morning. It features the new CHA Street Food, which is available today, and Java House, which is expected to open Tuesday. Also opening today is the Starbucks Kiosk and Longworth Convenience Store, as well as the Common Grounds coffee shop in the Cannon basement. The Longworth and Ford cafeterias are closed for renovations. HAPPY BIRTHDAY Former Rep. Dan Kildee … former Sen. Tim Hutchinson … Billy Long (7-0) … NYT's David Brooks and Lyndsey Layton … Charles Blow … POLITICO's Toby Eckert, Michael Roberts and Danielle Bello … Lauren Maddox of Holland & Knight … Jesse Barba of Cengage Group … Kedrin Simms Brachman … former USTR Charlene Barshefsky … Marissa Secreto … Colin Cunliff … Thad Huguley … Greg Michaelidis … Ilana Drimmer … Sam Myers Jr. … National Journal's Emily Akhtarzandi TRIVIA FRIDAY'S ANSWER: Jim Wholey correctly answered that Theodore Roosevelt was the first president to receive the Nobel Peace Prize. TODAY'S QUESTION, from Calen: Name the current senators who have cast more than 10,000 votes. The first person to correctly guess gets a mention in the next edition of Inside Congress. Send your answers to insidecongress@
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Minnesota hasn't elected a GOP governor in almost 20 years. Can Republicans finally break the streak?
Aug. 8—By Ryan Faircloth, Star Tribune (TNS) Minnesota Republicans think they could have their best shot in years to take back the governorship if Tim Walz attempts a risky third run for office next fall. But it's unclear if conservatives in the state will be ready to capitalize on the opportunity. The party, which hasn't won any statewide office since 2006, is low on cash and struggling to gain ground in the metro. Top leaders are still battling an activist base that has made it difficult for candidates with broad appeal to win the nomination. So far, few Republicans have stepped forward to run. "We need additional people to jump into the race," said Amy Koch, a Republican operative and former Minnesota Senate majority leader. "Folks have to get in, they have to be able to raise money." With 15 months until Election Day, the GOP field for governor is thin and largely familiar, a symptom of the party's broader challenges. Top-tier prospects such as U.S. Reps. Tom Emmer and Pete Stauber ruled out running for governor earlier this year, choosing to stay in their safe seats during a midterm election that could be difficult for their party. The most prominent Republicans in the race are Scott Jensen and Kendall Qualls. Jensen is a Chaska physician who lost to Walz by more than 7 percentage points in 2022. Qualls, a businessman, lost the GOP endorsement to Jensen that same year. Former U.S. Naval intelligence officer Phillip Parrish and retired mixed martial arts fighter Brad Kohler are also running. Other Republicans who could bring a fresh name to the top of the ticket are still mulling whether to run, including Minnesota House Speaker Lisa Demuth, state Reps. Kristin Robbins and Jim Nash, and Minneapolis attorney Chris Madel. "Republicans have a great opportunity," said Preya Samsundar, a GOP operative in Minnesota. "But ... you're going to need a candidate who's not dogged by past baggage." Walz will face intense scrutiny if he runs for a historic third consecutive term, with a long record for Republicans to attack. A June poll by the Minnesota Star Tribune found at least 6 in 10 registered voters outside Hennepin and Ramsey counties said they disapproved of Walz's performance, including those in outer-ring suburbs. Republicans think he's also more vulnerable after his failed bid for vice president last fall, which prompted more intense scrutiny of his record as governor and previous service in Congress. Another factor that could play into the race is President Donald Trump, who has attacked Walz as a "terrible governor" and could decide to throw his full support behind a challenger. "If I'm another candidate, I'm reaching out to Trump's people," Koch said. "They do seem to have beef." Republicans will have a good shot if they can find the right candidate and make the 2026 election a referendum on Walz, not Trump, said David Schultz, a political science professor at Hamline University. "If the Republicans can put up a strong viable candidate against Walz, I think he's in for a heck of a race," Schultz said. One issue Republicans have struggled with is their endorsement process, which carries a lot of weight with primary voters. Activists who decide who the party backs often prioritize conservative credentials, seeking candidates who will take hardline stances on issues such as abortion or — since Trump's takeover of the national party — election denialism, even if it hurts them in the general election. Jensen, who last won the GOP nomination, has previously said he felt pressured by party activists on the issue of abortion during the 2022 campaign. Democrats hammered Jensen that year for saying he would try to ban abortion if elected. In a recent interview, Jensen said his second bid for governor won't be "confined by partisan rhetoric." He said he now considers abortion to be "settled law" in Minnesota, and that he would not endorse a party platform that opposes gay marriage. Jensen's shift toward the middle has already put him at odds with right-wing activists, raising questions of whether he can win the endorsement again. Erik Mortensen, president of the right-wing group Action 4 Liberty, recently criticized Jensen on social media for his stances on abortion and background checks for gun purchases. "This is the problem with MN 'Republicans'. Their brand means absolutely nothing and is indistinguishable from the Democrat platform," Mortensen said. Robbins could face similar pushback from the party's right flank if she jumps into the governor's race. The Maple Grove Republican, who chairs the House Fraud Prevention and State Agency Oversight Committee, served as Minnesota chair of Nikki Haley's 2024 presidential campaign. "I think they might view her with some suspicion," Schultz said of GOP activists loyal to Trump. Qualls, who came just short of winning the endorsement in 2022, said he still has strong support among activists, including some who previously supported Jensen. "Many of them don't want to see that movie again," Qualls said, in a dig at Jensen's second campaign. He believes his background as a businessman and Army veteran will appeal to a broad swath of voters. If elected, he would be Minnesota's first Black governor. Qualls said he has twice as many campaign volunteers this time around and is exceeding previous fundraising numbers, though he wouldn't specify how much he's raised. His core message, he said, will center on lowering the cost of living, reducing crime and improving the education system. Qualls said he wants Minneapolis to feel safe again and would seek to hire and deploy more state-level law enforcement to the city. But name recognition will be a challenge for Qualls, who isn't well-known outside party circles. His fundraising ability is also a question mark. Republicans will face a prolific fundraiser in Walz if he runs for re-election. His campaign had $1 million in the bank at the end of last year. In an interview last month, Walz predicted he will win if he runs again and warned potential challengers they would face the "best fundraiser that ever sat in this office." The governor told reporters recently that he's likely to announce his re-election plans shortly after the Minnesota State Fair. Whoever emerges as the GOP frontrunner will need to be a strong fundraiser themselves, because they likely won't be able to depend on the state Republican Party for substantial support. The Republican Party of Minnesota had just over $59,000 in its federal bank account at the end of June, according to its most recent campaign finance report. The Minnesota DFL had more than $2.7 million. The DFL had another $2.2 million in its state campaign account at the end of last year. The Minnesota GOP ended last year with about $2,100 in its state account. Koch said the ideal GOP candidate for governor would have a little bit of everything: Good name recognition, minimal baggage, fundraising prowess and broad appeal. She believes Demuth, the state House speaker, could be the candidate who fits that bill. "I would think that Demuth would jump to the front of the field for the potential to win," Koch said.
