Hilale Slams UN Security Council Report for Biased Western Sahara Paragraph
Doha – Morocco's Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Omar Hilale, has formally challenged the UN Security Council over a biased paragraph concerning Morocco's Western Sahara in its latest report to the General Assembly.
In a strongly-worded letter addressed to the Security Council's president and members, Hilale expressed Morocco's 'profound surprise and firm rejection' of the singling out of 'two parties' in the paragraph about the Sahara. The missive was sent following the Council's adoption of its 2024 informative report to the General Assembly on May 30.
The Moroccan diplomat pointed out that the introduction to the Security Council's report specifies in its final paragraph that the section's purpose 'is not to provide an exhaustive list of meetings, developments or Council responses,' but rather 'a succinct and useful overview of the main developments throughout the year.'
Hilale blasted the contested paragraph for 'flagrantly deviating' from this directive, which has guided the drafting of previous annual reports.
He charged that instead of faithfully reporting the Security Council's position and sincere efforts toward a political, just, and sustainable solution to this regional dispute, it presents 'a partisan and unbalanced reading' of positions expressed within the Council.
'This paragraph reflects only, in a selective and non-contextualized manner, the national position of the introduction's writer and that of a non-permanent Security Council member,' Hilale declared, noting it 'silences the contributions and positions expressed by other members,' thus 'moving away from the consensus within this body.'
The ambassador firmly asserted that contrary to the paragraph's claim, the Security Council has established four parties to the political process: Morocco, Algeria, Mauritania, and the separatist Polisario Front, citing them five times in all its resolutions since 2018.
Morocco's representative stressed that no report from the Secretary-General nor any General Assembly resolution singles out two parties at the expense of the four stakeholders in the political process.
A futile attempt to derail the growing international momentum
He added that the writer's biased approach is contradicted by the current international momentum, marked by widespread support for resolving this regional dispute solely on the basis of Morocco's Autonomy Plan, respecting the country's sovereignty and territorial integrity.
The Moroccan envoy continued that this serious and credible initiative enjoys strong and open support from 116 countries.
This includes two permanent Security Council members, with the United Kingdom joining just yesterday, as well as three non-permanent members who sat on the Council in 2024, and six among the current non-permanent members.
Hilale condemned how this approach 'discredits the Security Council's work vis-à-vis the General Assembly' by departing from the established practice of factuality and neutrality that traditionally characterizes Security Council reports to the General Assembly.
He warned it also 'raises questions about the General Assembly's confidence in the integrity of reports transmitted to it by the Security Council.'
'Instead of attempting to mislead the General Assembly by referring to his national position and that of a non-permanent Council member who is also a main party to this dispute, the writer of this section should have demonstrated neutrality and objectivity,' the diplomat thundered.
He further insisted that the writer should have informed the General Assembly about the constants and foundations of the political process established by the Security Council.
The Moroccan representative lambasted the writer for opposing the restoration of factuality in this section by invoking a supposed 'procedural integrity,' which 'cannot take precedence when such a flagrant inaccuracy is reported at any stage.'
Hilale went on to say that the report's objectivity and factuality are 'a political prerequisite to the Security Council's mission as guarantor of the political process' for resolving the Sahara question.
For all these reasons, Morocco firmly denounces this failure to maintain the rigor, impartiality, and integrity of this section of the report.
The country also rejects the politically motivated distortion of this paragraph, which 'can only be perceived as a vain attempt to undermine the international momentum in favor of the political process undertaken under the exclusive auspices of the United Nations.'
The letter has also been transmitted to the General Assembly president and the secretary-general, and will be published as an official document of both the Security Council and the General Assembly.
Read also: Hilale: 'Sahara Occupation Ended with Provinces' Return to Morocco' Tags: Ambassador Omar HilaleUN Security CouncilWestern sahara
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Ya Biladi
27 minutes ago
- Ya Biladi
Sahara : Moroccan army drone strikes Algerian truck near Bir Lahlou
A Royal Armed Forces (FAR) drone strike on Wednesday, June 4, destroyed an Algerian-registered truck east of the Sand Wall near Bir Lahlou, killing all three occupants on board. The truck, which was returning from Mauritania, had entered the region from southern Algeria. It remains unclear why the vehicle entered this active conflict zone or what it was carrying. In response, Algerian President Abdelmadjid Tebboune convened a meeting of the High Security Council, as briefly noted in a statement from the Algerian presidency. However, Algerian media did not report the drone strike or mention Morocco's involvement. This incident is not unprecedented. Moroccan drones have previously targeted Algerian trucks in the area, prompting verbal warnings from the Algerian government, though these threats have not led to concrete action. Since the Polisario Front resumed hostilities on November 13, 2020, the FAR has effectively enforced a no-go zone east of the Sand Wall, significantly limiting movement in the area and forcing the Polisario to retreat from what it had declared «liberated territories». Bir Lahlou, where the strike occurred, was once regarded as the «capital» of the self-proclaimed Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic.
Ya Biladi
9 hours ago
- Ya Biladi
Moroccan groups join global march to end Gaza siege and genocide
Political and civic organizations within the Moroccan Front for Supporting Palestine and Against Normalization, along with the National Action Group for Palestine, have announced their participation in the global march calling for an end to the genocide and the lifting of the siege on the Gaza Strip. The march is scheduled to arrive in Cairo on June 12, with the return planned for June 20. At a press conference held on Wednesday, the National Action Group for Palestine stated that it had joined this international initiative, which brings together participants from 32 countries. The march will head to Egypt's El-Arish governorate in the Sinai Peninsula and then continue to Rafah, with the aim of «breaking the siege, ending the aggression» by the Israeli occupation, and «opening the crossings to deliver humanitarian aid to the grieving and resilient families» in Palestine. «History will remember with shame and dishonor the tragedy of the Palestinian people, who have been fighting for nearly a century for their freedom, independence, and the liberation of their land from invaders and occupiers», the Group's secretariat said in its statement. It also denounced that it has now been «more than 600 days» since the population of the Gaza Strip began enduring what it described as genocide, citing nearly «200,000 martyrs and injured» since October 7, 2023. The Group's participation, it explained, is intended to help mobilize Moroccan citizens who wish to join the march, while also coordinating the necessary administrative procedures. To this end, a letter was sent to the Egyptian embassy in Morocco requesting a meeting with the ambassador. However, the Group noted that this request has yet to receive a response. «We have also addressed a letter to the Moroccan Ministry of Foreign Affairs, urging it to intervene with the relevant Egyptian authorities to facilitate Moroccan participation in this global march», the Group added. During the press conference, organizers also detailed the planned itinerary: arrival at Cairo airport on June 12, departure for El-Arish on June 13, and the beginning of the march on foot to Rafah on the evening of June 13 or 14. Participants will spend three days in Rafah—on June 16, 17, and 18—before returning to Cairo on June 19. The final overnight stay in Cairo will be followed by departure on June 20.
Ya Biladi
9 hours ago
- Ya Biladi
Crown Prince Moulay El Hassan presides over military graduation at Kenitra's Royal College
Under the directives of King Mohammed VI, Supreme Commander and Chief of the General Staff of the Royal Armed Forces (FAR), Crown Prince Moulay El Hassan presided on Wednesday over the graduation ceremony for the Higher Defense Course and the Staff Course at the Royal College of Higher Military Education (CREMS) in Kenitra. Upon his arrival at CREMS, Crown Prince Moulay El Hassan was welcomed by the Army Corps General, Inspector General of the FAR and Commander of the Southern Zone, as well as the Colonel Major, Director of CREMS. He then reviewed a detachment of the Royal Air Forces presenting honors, according to a statement from the General Staff of the Royal Armed Forces. He was then greeted by the Army Corps General, Commander of the Royal Gendarmerie; senior officers from the FAR General Staff; the Wali of the Rabat-Salé-Kenitra region; the Governor of Kenitra Province; the Commanding Officer of the Kenitra Garrison; and members of the academic staff. Following a presentation on «The Role of the FAR in Border Security», Crown Prince Moulay El Hassan awarded certificates of higher military education, specialized master's degrees in national defense, and staff diplomas to both Moroccan and international officer trainees from the Higher Defense Course and the Staff Course. The Colonel Major, Director of CREMS, also presented him with a selection of the trainees' academic work, including research theses produced by graduates of the Higher Defense Course. The ceremony concluded with a commemorative photo of Crown Prince Moulay El Hassan with the two graduating classes. This year's graduates include 296 officers from the 25th class of the Higher Defense Course and the 59th class of the Staff Course, among them 77 officers representing 28 different countries.
