YouTube misinformation tools are inconsistent in Europe: report says
When users watch a YouTube video on a topic that is often embroiled in misinformation, such as COVID-19 vaccines or climate change, a label should pop up to direct them to third-party sources with more information on the issue, for example Wikipedia.
The information panel is also meant to appear in users' search results in their operating language.
However AI Forensics, a Europe-based nonprofit that investigates major tech companies, found that this is often not the case.
The researchers built a web crawler to test the panels, and found that across the 83 languages on the video platform, the information panels are applied inconsistently to 12 topics on Wikipedia's list of conspiracy theories as well as four types of publisher labels.
All of the panels are available in English. In German, videos on all but one topic – the Armenian genocide – have these labels. Meanwhile, very few panels are available in Icelandic or Lithuanian.
AI Forensics said the tests show YouTube pays 'disproportionate attention towards Western languages' and 'neglects' regional languages like Basque, Catalan, and Galician.
YouTube's content disclaimers go beyond misinformation-prone topics. It also includes labels for news sources and fact-checkers that explain whether they are partially or fully funded by government sources, as a way to 'help you better understand the sources of news content,' the company says.
But public funding was flagged in some countries and not others, the AI Forensics report found.
Euronews, for example, receives some funding from the European Union. YouTube flagged this in some countries, but not in Denmark, Greece, Norway, Iceland, Finland, or Portugal.
'We are scared … there might be some group of people that have differential access to safety' measures to fight misinformation on the platform, Salvatore Romano, head of research at AI Forensics, told Euronews Next.
'Instead of increasing [the] trust of users on the platform, it is undermining [it],' Romano added.
Unclear whether YouTube will address discrepancies
YouTube's website notes that 'information panels may not be available in all countries/regions and languages,' and that the company is working to expand their reach.
The AI Forensics team said they have met with YouTube to present their research. During those meetings, YouTube allegedly indicated that the discrepancies between languages were not supposed to happen, and that it didn't have a way to systematically check how the panels are deployed across Europe.
AI Forensics said YouTube agreed to address these discrepancies but did not go into detail.
YouTube did not respond to a Euronews Next request for clarity on the alleged meetings or the measures it plans to take.
YouTube, under parent company Google, is a signatory to the European Commission's Code of Practice on Disinformation, a voluntary agreement that sets standards for tech companies to fight disinformation.
In March, YouTube said that as part of its commitment, it will 'assess and update the topics prone to misinformation that receive additional context from information panels'.
But Romano believes the haphazard content labeling could be even more extensive than the AI Forensics researchers found, given the report says it shows only a 'partial view' with a small sample of panels.
Commission could put 'pressure on YouTube' over inconsistencies: AI Forensics
Romano said he's hoping YouTube will correct the discrepancies. If it doesn't, he said he will call on the European Commission, the EU's executive body, to investigate a potential breach of the Digital Services Act (DSA).
The Commission could, for example, request more information from YouTube about how it administers its panels, which is the first step of any DSA investigation, he said.
'The EU Commission could put pressure on YouTube to show them that this type of inconsistency is unacceptable across platforms and across products,' he said, noting that it creates 'second-rate markets' throughout Europe where standards meant to protect against misinformation are not being met.
Euronews Next reached out to the Commission to confirm whether it would be asking for more information from YouTube but did not receive an immediate reply.
Romano, at least, will be watching. He said his team built a tool to track how regularly YouTube's information labels come up in various languages.
Through the publicly available tracker, people can see which topics have content labels in their language. It will also allow researchers to identify any changes to the information panels, Romano said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fashion Network
an hour ago
- Fashion Network
Indian exporters weigh options to deal with US levy that's ‘worse than Covid'
While escalating tariffs pose an existential threat to small enterprises like Twenty Second Miles, the larger ones are considering coping tactics including relocating production lines to countries with a lower tariff barrier, tapping buyers in other geographies and exploring acquisitions in the US. Gokaldas Exports Ltd., one of India's largest apparel exporters that earns about 70% of its revenue from the US, plans to ramp up production in its factories in Kenya and Ethiopia which face just a 10% US levy. 'Africa is looking like a good source at the moment,' Gokaldas' Managing Director Sivaramakrishnan Ganapathi said in an interview. 'We are seeing a huge amount of inquiries for production from that region from American customers.' The mitigating strategies will be a gut punch for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's flagship 'Make in India' initiative and puncture any prospects to position India as an alternative manufacturing hotspot to China. Economists forecast that Trump tariffs could clip India's gross domestic product by as much as 1%. Trump has peppered his tariff onslaught with jibes about how the South Asian nation's trade barriers were 'obnoxious' and its economy 'dead' — remarks that have drawn counter from India's central bank. But businesses are hoping for more than just retorts. Businesses thought 'there would be more predictability,' according to Rohit Kumar, founding partner at public policy consultancy The Quantum Hub. 'In the short term, this threatens our China+1 strategy that India was positioning itself to benefit from. In the longer term, even this rerouting may not work for longer as policies could change,' Kumar said, referring to companies trying to recast supply chains. Analysts Chetna Kumar and Adam Farrar weighed in: 'The additional 25% oil penalty tariff would take the hit to US–bound exports to 60%, dragging GDP by 0.9%. This drop would be concentrated on the key items impacted by these tariffs such as gems and jewellery, textiles, footwear, carpets and agricultural goods — all labour-intensive industries.' The revised US levy announced as a penalty for India's purchases of Russian oil are set to take effect within 21 days, providing time for hectic parlays between New Delhi and Washington DC. In the meantime, companies are working on hedging strategies. Tata Group's Titan Ltd., which sells jewellery, is considering shifting some manufacturing to the Middle East which has lower duties on shipments into the US, Reuters reported Tuesday. Welspun Living Ltd., which sells home fabrics in the US, told analysts last week that it is looking at the UK, European Union, Middle East, Australia, New Zealand and Japan to reduce reliance on the American market. SNQS International, based in the textile hub of Tiruppur in southern India, gets about 20% of its business from the US but is now looking to double down on European nations, according to its founder V. Elangovan. Larger textile manufacturers are also grabbing smaller, low-value orders to keep their factories running and avoid shutdowns, Thukral of Twenty Second Miles said. This risks crowding out the smaller firms. Indian trade bodies across affected industries, including apparel, gems and jewellery, and shrimps, are ramping up calls of support from the Modi government. The Confederation of Indian Textile Industry wants the government to 'fast track' measures to limit the hardship faced by local apparel exporters while an industry body for shrimp exporters is seeking export incentive programs. The Gems and Jewellery Export Promotion Council wants duty drawbacks, pre-shipment loans and deferring interest on working capital facilities, Chairman Kirit Bhansali said in a statement.
Euronews
an hour ago
- Euronews
Here's why OpenAI's ChatGPT-5 drop matters
OpenAI is dropping the long-awaited GPT-5, the latest model of its popular artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot ChatGPT, on Thursday. The new model has advanced writing capabilities, invents answers less often when it doesn't have the right information to a query, and responds better to health-related questions by flagging potential medical concerns, according to the company. GPT-5 has 'agentic' capabilities that it will use when developing code, meaning that it will be able to perform some tasks and make decisions without human intervention. The updated model can make websites, apps, and games, and can be integrated with users' Google tools, like Gmail and Google Calendar, OpenAI said. People using a research preview version of ChatGPT will also be able to select between four 'personalities' for the chatbot. AI enthusiasts saw that the drop was coming after a since-deleted description for the upgrade on crowdsource coding platform Github was published in the early hours of Thursday morning. The launch of GPT-5 follows OpenAI's introduction of the open-source gpt‑oss series earlier this week. It's the first model where the company has also released the source code since 2019's GPT-2, so it can be fine-tuned by users to meet their specific needs. Why does this launch matter? The launch is the latest development in the road to agentic AI, where agents can take multi-step actions and use tools to browse the web without human prompts. That could look like an AI agent at a customer service centre having the ability to automatically ask questions, look up information in internal documents, respond with a solution, or refer the customer to a human if necessary, according to one example given by Amazon. Earlier this year, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman predicted that the first AI agents will soon be 'joining the workforce' and will 'materially change the output of companies'. In a June blog post, Altman used the example of an AI agent in a software engineering role, saying the agent will 'eventually be capable of doing most things a software engineer at a top company with a few years of experience could do, for tasks up to a couple of days long'. 'It will not have the biggest new ideas, it will require lots of human supervision and direction, and it will be great at some things and bad at others,' he wrote. Agents could also be considered 'real-but-relatively-junior' virtual coworkers that could be scaled to 'every field of knowledge work,' he continued. The OpenAI launch of agentic agents would not be the first from an AI company. Microsoft and Google have already launched AI agents that can be customised based on what services a company needs to provide or what tasks it wants to automate.
Fashion Network
an hour ago
- Fashion Network
Indian exporters weigh options to deal with US levy that's ‘worse than Covid'
While escalating tariffs pose an existential threat to small enterprises like Twenty Second Miles, the larger ones are considering coping tactics including relocating production lines to countries with a lower tariff barrier, tapping buyers in other geographies and exploring acquisitions in the US. Gokaldas Exports Ltd., one of India's largest apparel exporters that earns about 70% of its revenue from the US, plans to ramp up production in its factories in Kenya and Ethiopia which face just a 10% US levy. 'Africa is looking like a good source at the moment,' Gokaldas' Managing Director Sivaramakrishnan Ganapathi said in an interview. 'We are seeing a huge amount of inquiries for production from that region from American customers.' The mitigating strategies will be a gut punch for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's flagship 'Make in India' initiative and puncture any prospects to position India as an alternative manufacturing hotspot to China. Economists forecast that Trump tariffs could clip India's gross domestic product by as much as 1%. Trump has peppered his tariff onslaught with jibes about how the South Asian nation's trade barriers were 'obnoxious' and its economy 'dead' — remarks that have drawn counter from India's central bank. But businesses are hoping for more than just retorts. Businesses thought 'there would be more predictability,' according to Rohit Kumar, founding partner at public policy consultancy The Quantum Hub. 'In the short term, this threatens our China+1 strategy that India was positioning itself to benefit from. In the longer term, even this rerouting may not work for longer as policies could change,' Kumar said, referring to companies trying to recast supply chains. Analysts Chetna Kumar and Adam Farrar weighed in: 'The additional 25% oil penalty tariff would take the hit to US–bound exports to 60%, dragging GDP by 0.9%. This drop would be concentrated on the key items impacted by these tariffs such as gems and jewellery, textiles, footwear, carpets and agricultural goods — all labour-intensive industries.' The revised US levy announced as a penalty for India's purchases of Russian oil are set to take effect within 21 days, providing time for hectic parlays between New Delhi and Washington DC. In the meantime, companies are working on hedging strategies. Tata Group's Titan Ltd., which sells jewellery, is considering shifting some manufacturing to the Middle East which has lower duties on shipments into the US, Reuters reported Tuesday. Welspun Living Ltd., which sells home fabrics in the US, told analysts last week that it is looking at the UK, European Union, Middle East, Australia, New Zealand and Japan to reduce reliance on the American market. SNQS International, based in the textile hub of Tiruppur in southern India, gets about 20% of its business from the US but is now looking to double down on European nations, according to its founder V. Elangovan. Larger textile manufacturers are also grabbing smaller, low-value orders to keep their factories running and avoid shutdowns, Thukral of Twenty Second Miles said. This risks crowding out the smaller firms. Indian trade bodies across affected industries, including apparel, gems and jewellery, and shrimps, are ramping up calls of support from the Modi government. The Confederation of Indian Textile Industry wants the government to 'fast track' measures to limit the hardship faced by local apparel exporters while an industry body for shrimp exporters is seeking export incentive programs. The Gems and Jewellery Export Promotion Council wants duty drawbacks, pre-shipment loans and deferring interest on working capital facilities, Chairman Kirit Bhansali said in a statement.
