Demonstrators demand overpass at dangerous Carberry intersection
CARBERRY — More than 150 people stood near the Trans-Canada Highway and Highway 5 to denounce the preferred option for a redesign of the intersection in response to a collision two years ago that killed 17 people.
They carried signs that read 'safety not shortcuts,' and 'how many more accidents before they listen.' The group opposes a U-turn option, which is called an RCUT.
Jordan Dickson, 31, one of the organizers, said the RCUT model isn't safe for the farmers and truckers who live in the area.
More than 150 people gathered to protest proposed changes for the Trans-Canada Highway and Highway 5, where 17 people died in a crash in June 2023.
'There's hundreds, if not thousands of trucks … plus all the other everyday passenger traffic coming through here,' she said.
The RCUT model, or restricted crossing U-turn, doesn't exist in Manitoba but is commonly found in the United States. The Carberry RCUT would include U-turns both east and west of the current intersection.
At an open house in late March, a consultant hired by the provincial government said three design options were under consideration, but his presentation focused on the RCUT design because, he said, it is unfamiliar to Manitobans.
Dickson, who lives 30 seconds away from the intersection, said the McCain potato plant southeast of Carberry is the source of a lot of traffic throughout the year, and big vehicles would have a hard time matching the speed on the Trans-Canada before slowing down for a U-turn.
'For all those vehicles to have to merge onto the (Trans-Canada), merge over three lanes, do a U-turn, merge back over — it's a recipe for a disaster,' said Dickson, standing near crosses that have been erected to honour the 17 victims of the June 2023 crash.
They died after their minibus crossed into the eastbound lanes of Highway 1 and was hit by a semi-trailer.
Attendees at the rally said they want an overpass — a much more expensive option — to be built.
The province has said it isn't feasible, but Dickson said cost shouldn't matter.
'How many more lives have to be lost before the province finally realizes that the cost is worth it?' she said.
Kirsten Duguay said her daughter is supposed to start working at the hospital in Neepawa soon and will have to cross the intersection to get to work. She said she's worried about her safety if an RCUT is implemented.
'It makes me nervous that she has to navigate that intersection, possibly after a 12-hour shift where she's tired,' said the 55-year-old Duguay, who is a nurse in Carberry.
A truck driver who said he uses the intersection at least three times a day said he's worried about the RCUT intersection.
'I can tell you right now, your accident rate is going to skyrocket,' said 50-year-old Byron Vanrooyen. 'A truck can't pick up speed fast enough, and the guys with the cars come down here driving at 110, 120 (km/h) — you can't push a truck in there faster.'
Vanrooyen said some tractors can't go faster than 30 km/h when pulling equipment, and they'll be in the way of other traffic.
TIM SMITH / THE BRANDON SUN
Protesters carried signs that read 'safety not shortcuts,' and 'how many more accidents before they listen.' The group opposes a U-turn option, called an RCUT.
'You're going to create more problems, with people having more accidents and more deaths,' he said.
Rally-goers, equipped with a megaphone, said the province surveyed traffic volumes in July, which is among the least busy times of the year. They said the survey should have been conducted in the busy spring or fall seasons.
'The consultants aren't listening. They roll their eyes, they brush us off,' Dickson told the crowd via the megaphone.
Carberry Mayor Ray Muirhead, who wasn't at the rally, said he's 'still on the fence' about which route the province should select.
He said because the province said it won't build an overpass, he prefers the RCUT, as the design is safer than other interchanges. But he also acknowledged that farming equipment, which travels a lot slower than the 100 km/h speed limit, could pose a danger on the busy Trans-Canada.
Muirhead said the province should put the overpass option back on the table, and said the NDP government saying it's too expensive is a way of 'passing the buck off to another government.'
Weekday Mornings
A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day.
He said the rally will draw attention to the issue but he doesn't think it will affect the government's decision.
Transportation and Infrastructure Minister Lisa Naylor, in a statement Thursday, didn't provide an update on which design is favoured.
'The province has conducted extensive community consultations, and no final decision has been made,' said a spokesperson from Naylor's office. 'Work continues on the functional design process and the project remains on schedule.'
Construction is set to begin in early 2026, and should be open to traffic in the fall of 2026.
— Brandon Sun
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
30-05-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Generating goodwill at the parking meter
Opinion Recent reports from the City of Winnipeg about plans to remove all the downtown parking meters left our household upset. We're among the 20 per cent who use the meters. We dig out change or use a credit card. On nice days, we can walk downtown, but when transporting kids or in bad weather, we rely on the meters. Based on anecdotal evidence, the meters sometimes failed. Apparently, so did the phone app that replaces it. The city's efforts to boost downtown visitor numbers should target that 20 per cent — the occasional visitors who haven't downloaded an app but rely on meters instead. This news story made me remember a better parking experience. BROOK JONES/FREE PRESS There are better ways for the City of Winnipeg to handle getting rid of its parking pay stations, which will be removed between July 2 and Aug. 31. A pay station is pictured along Broadway Avenue on May 21. Our family was on summer vacation in Western New York. We took a highway exit to Jamestown. Parking on a hilltop, in the middle of downtown, we put our coins in the old-fashioned crank parking meter and walked, admiring the landscape, to a nice restaurant for lunch. The food was good. When we decided to have dessert, my husband sorted out more change for the meter. We had extra time to stroll downtown, see lake views, window shop and see a comedy centre, inspired by Lucille Ball, who was from Jamestown. We remembered this positive break from the road fondly. In comparison, we encountered numerous 'E-Z-Pass' incidents which left us frazzled. Many highways require tolls but no longer have a payment system without a physical device in the car. We tried to get around Chicago while I scrambled to figure out how to pay for our tolls online. I still don't know if we covered those tolls, though we honestly tried. If Winnipeg wants people to feel comfortable coming downtown, the city should provide alternatives to a reliance on a phone app. Ernie Nuytten suggests in a letter to the editor on May 24 that these parking booklets should be available wherever Winnipeg Transit tickets are sold. Ursula Delfing writes that parking near the downtown 'Parking Store' be free, to avoid getting tickets while trying to obtain a parking booklet. Like our troubles taking toll roads on vacation when we lacked the local 'passes,' Edwin Buettner suggests how difficult these systems would be for those who live outside the city but must come in on occasion for appointments downtown. City employees calculated the savings of removing the meters, but what are the costs of failing to provide access to downtown parking for those without cellphones, tourists, and out-of-town Manitobans who need medical care? The city must calculate costs to provide parking booklet sales elsewhere in the city, especially at hotels and convenience stores. When we discussed these parking issues, other solutions came up. Our household lives in a city neighbourhood. We must have parking permits for street parking. Yearly, we take photos of our driver's licences, car registration, and submit a form. Eventually someone calls us back and takes payment over the phone. What if, after the first registration, we received a 'renewal' email that said, 'According to city records, you live at the same address and have the same two cars as last year. Care to renew your permit? If so, click here. Pay online.' This would reduce costs and save time for the city and those who need street parking. A bigger revenue generator could follow. When tradespeople visit a city neighbourhood like ours with permit parking, they risk tickets if they park for too long. High school students parking on streets near private schools also risk tickets daily. Those who go downtown but fail to make the app or the meter work also hazard parking tickets. Imagine a 'super pass.' The city could set a flat fee, payable once a year, so that electricians, plumbers, realtors, students and theatre-goers could park legally in metered or permit areas without using an app or risking a ticket. The super pass would be available online, or at convenience stores and other locations where people might get parking booklets. Winnipeggers and tourists could choose options: download the app, buy single tickets for one trip to a downtown doctor's office or buy a whole year's pass and stop worrying about parking. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. Of course, the yearly fee concept must be worked out, but $500 or more might result in more visitor traffic downtown and many fewer parking tickets. Reducing system inefficiencies, like creating an easy online renewal system that links up with our addresses and car registrations, would also reduce costs. This might boost interest in coming downtown to the Exchange, to theatre venues or festivals. Offering multiple options for parking payment might boost the city's coffers. Better yet, it could reduce citizens' anger over the difficulties in downtown parking and the parking tickets that follow. Jamestown, N.Y. is a long way away. Even so, I'd go right back to crank my change in the old-fashioned meters, check out the scenery, eat a good lunch, and wander its historic downtown. City officials should think about how coming downtown can generate goodwill as well as income. Ripping out the current parking meters may be necessary, but it's what follows that matters. Obstacles to parking will build or destroy Winnipeggers' interest in visiting downtown. Offering multiple approaches to future downtown parking creates a better, more inclusive outcome for all of us. Joanne Seiff, a Winnipeg author, has been contributing opinions and analysis to the Free Press since 2009.
Global News
29-05-2025
- Global News
Rural Manitoba roads earn dubious honours in CAA Worst Roads campaign
CAA Manitoba has announced the 'winner' of its annual Worst Roads campaign, and the dubious honour goes to Provincial Trunk Highway 34 in the Central Plains/Pembina Valley area. This year, the auto club said Thursday, marks the first time nine of the top 10 worst roads — as selected by Manitoba drivers — are outside Winnipeg's city limits, with Saskatchewan Avenue as the lone road in the provincial capital making the list at number 10. Drivers cited frustration with potholes as a major reason for PTH 34's nomination, with poor maintenance, poor signage, and unpaved sections adding to the overall experience. These frustrations, CAA said, aren't new — the highway has appeared on six of the annual Worst Roads lists, but 2025 marks its first time atop the leaderboard. A crumbling section of Provincial Trunk Highway 34 in Central Plains — the 'winner' of Manitoba's Worst Road for 2025. CAA Manitoba CAA's Ewald Friesen said the goal of the annual campaign is to raise awareness about the condition of some roads across the province and to hopefully spur government action when it comes to road repairs. Story continues below advertisement 'The CAA Worst Roads campaign provides a powerful snapshot to governments on where to prioritize budgets and move up road repairs by giving Manitobans an opportunity to have their say on the difficulties they are experiencing in getting around,' Friesen said. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'We saw the proof of this when last year's winner, 18th Street in Brandon, received a swift and co-ordinated response from governments on the same day the results were released, with shovels in the ground by fall.' Friesen said this year's campaign saw a large increase in the number of nominees, with more than 700 roads across 86 municipalities getting the nod. Joining PTH 34 in first place and Winnipeg's Saskatchewan Avenue at number 10 are two highways in the Interlake (PR 234 and 239), Richmond Avenue and 26th Street in Brandon, PR 307 in the Whiteshell, PR 349 in Westman, PTH 12 in the Eastman area, and PTH 26, also in Central Plains.
Winnipeg Free Press
29-05-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Highways to hell: province's worst roads
A Pembina Valley highway has earned the dubious distinction of being Manitoba's nastiest road in 2025. CAA's Worst Roads Campaign results revealed Highway 34, specifically the stretch between Holland and Gladstone, was Manitobans' No. 1 choice for its combination of jarring potholes, poor maintenance, bad signage and unpaved sections. It was the highway's sixth appearance as a finalist since CAA Manitoba began asking drivers, cyclists, transit users and pedestrians to serve as judges in the far-from-beauty contest in 2012. Ruth Bonneville / Free Press Potholes remain the worst culprits in why roadways rank poorly in the CAA surveys. This year's nomination period began March 18 and ended April 11. Ewald Friesen, CAA Manitoba's government relations manager, said the highway is one of nine rural roads that made the top — or bottom, really — 10 this year, a first. The lone Winnipeg street on the list was Saskatchewan Avenue, which made its seventh consecutive appearance. Winnipeg roads dominated last year's list, with six of the 10 finalists inside the Perimeter. But city drivers can usually find alternative routes. 'If you live in a rural part of this province, you depend on your road in a way that's a little bit more critical than any place else,' Friesen said. 'There are no other options if your road isn't passable.' A CAA Manitoba member-only survey in February found 96 per cent of 1,014 respondents were concerned about road conditions, he said. This year saw 723 different roads nominated, a 50 per cent spike compared to 2024's survey. Half of those that cracked the top 10 were first appearances. Friesen said past successes from surveys getting provincial and municipal governments to act on repairs have driven more people to vote. There were no available numbers on total voters, he said. Last year, Brandon's 18th Street was named the worst road in the province, getting a pledge from Premier Wab Kinew to get it repaired. Construction began last fall and is still under way. Wednesdays A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom. 'The government's co-ordinated and very swift response to the repair of 18th street has sort of empowered rural Manitobans,' said Friesen. Potholes were the leading sore spot for Manitobans when voting for the worst roads, he said. 'If your budget is already stretched and you're holding on to the car and you get vehicle damage as a result of bad roads, you're out the money,' he said. As the federal and provincial governments look to pull down inter-provincial trade barriers, Friesen said poor road conditions could also impact how effectively goods can be transported by truck. He's hopeful 2025's list will bring action from the province and municipalities to improve the situation.
