It may take weeks to confirm if Muhammad Sinwar was killed in air strike on Khan Younis hospital
It may take days, or even weeks, before the death of Muhammad Sinwar can be confirmed, but Israeli defence officials believe that everyone who was present in what they say was an underground compound targeted in Tuesday night's air strikes beneath the Khan Younis European Hospital is dead. 'If Sinwar was there he was killed,' said an Israeli source.
The air strikes were approved by prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu, defence minister Yisrael Katz and Israel Defense Forces chief-of staff Lieut Gen Eyal Zamir in 'real time' in response to an 'immediate opportunity that had emerged', once it was established that there were no hostages in the vicinity, defence officials said. The urgency of the strike left no time to inform the United States in advance despite the 'sensitivity' stemming from President Donald Trump's visit to
Saudi Arabia
.
Muhammad Sinwar, the 49-year-old younger brother of Yahya Sinwar – the Hamas leader killed by Israel in October – is considered one of the architects of the October 7th, 2023, attack on southern Israel. He is the senior figure in Hamas's military wing and had, in the months following his brother's assassination, in effect taken over Hamas's leadership, Israeli security officials believe.
In the past he served as the commander of Hamas's Khan Younis brigade and masterminded the kidnapping of Gilad Shalit, an Israeli soldier seized on the Gaza border in 2006, who was subsequently released for more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners held by Israel, including Yahya Sinwar.
READ MORE
Muhammad Sinwar is considered a charismatic leader but also has a reputation for brutality and ruthlessness, and was widely feared across Gaza. He has survived numerous Israeli attempts on his life, and Israel offered a $300,000 reward for information leading to his whereabouts. He is rarely seen in public in recent years, even avoiding his father's funeral in 2022.
If Sinwar's death is confirmed it means that only a handful of senior officials in Hamas's military wing in Gaza remain alive. However, Hamas still exists as an organisation, and its radical Islamist ideology, based on the teachings of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, has deep roots among the Gazan population.
Israel considers Muhammad Sinwar the chief obstacle to a new ceasefire and hostage-release deal, taking as he did a more hardline position than the Hamas leadership in exile and his subordinates in Gaza.
There was much speculation on Wednesday that Sinwar's possible death might makes it easier for Hamas negotiators to show increased flexibility, facilitating a new ceasefire deal, as proximity negotiations resumed in Doha after months of deadlock, with Trump making it clear his patience is running out. Significant progress in the talks, combined with US pressure on Israel, could also lead to a delay or cancelling of Israel's planned military escalation aimed at conquering the entire Gaza Strip.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Israeli fire kills 60 in Gaza and many were near aid site, medics say
Israeli gunfire and airstrikes killed at least 60 Palestinians in Gaza, most of them near an aid site operated by the US- and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) in the centre of the enclave, local health officials said. Medical officials at Shifa and Al-Quds hospitals said at least 25 people were killed and dozens wounded as the approached a food distribution centre near the former Jewish settlement of Netzarim before dawn. Israel's military, which has been at war with Hamas militants since October 2023, said its forces fired warning shots overnight towards a group of suspects as they posed a threat to troops in the area of the Netzarim Corridor. "This is despite warnings that the area is an active combat zone. The IDF is aware of reports regarding individuals injured; the details are under review," it said. Later yesterday, health officials at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis in the southern Gaza said at least 14 people had been killed by Israeli gunfire as they approached another GHF site in Rafah. Gaza Humanitarian Foundation says five members killed in Hamas attack The US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation accused militant group Hamas of attacking a bus carrying its staffers to an aid distribution center, saying at least five people were killed and multiple others injured. The group said in a statement that around 10pm local time "a bus carrying more than two dozen members of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation team... were brutally attacked by Hamas." "We are still gathering facts, but what we know is devastating: there are at least five fatalities, multiple injuries, and fear that some of our team members may have been taken hostage," the statement read. In an email to AFP the group said all the passengers on the bus were Palestinian and all were aid workers. They were en route to GHF's distribution centre in the area west of Khan Younis. "We condemn this heinous and deliberate attack in the strongest possible terms," the group said in its statement. "These were aid workers. Humanitarians. Fathers, brothers, sons and friends, who were risking their lives every day to help others." An officially private effort with opaque funding and backed by Israel, GHF began operations on 26 May after Israel completely cut off supplies into Gaza for more than two months, sparking warnings of mass famine. The Israeli military faces allegations of shooting into crowds of civilians rushing to pick up aid packages near GHF sites. Israeli authorities and the GHF - which uses contracted US security - denied any such incident took place. The United Nations and major aid groups have refused to cooperate with the foundation over concerns it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives. The GHF earlier said it was unaware of incidents involving civilians but added that it was working closely with Israeli authorities to ensure safe passage routes are maintained, and that it was essential for Palestinians to closely follow instructions. "Ultimately, the solution is more aid, which will create more certainty and less urgency among the population," it said by email in response to Reuters questions. "There is not yet enough food to feed everyone in need in Gaza. Our current focus is to feed as many people as is safely possible within the constraints of a highly volatile environment." GHF said it distributed 2.5 million meals, the largest single-day delivery since it began operations, bringing to more than 16 million the number of meals provided since its operations started in late May. Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry says that since then, 163 Palestinians had been killed and over 1,000 wounded trying to obtain the food boxes. The United Nations has condemned the killings and has refused to supply aid via the foundation, which uses private contractors with Israeli military backup in what they say is a breach of humanitarian standards. Elsewhere in Gaza, its health ministry said at least 11 other people were killed by separate Israeli gunfire and strikes across the coastal enclave. The war erupted 20 months ago after Hamas-led militants took 251 hostages and killed 1,200 people, most of them civilians, on 7 October 2023, Israel's single deadliest day. Israel's military campaign has since killed nearly 55,000 Palestinians, most of them civilians, according to health authorities in Gaza, and flattened much of the densely populated strip, which is home to more than two million people. Most of the population is displaced and malnutrition is widespread. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Tuesday there had been "significant progress" in efforts to secure the release of the remaining hostages in Gaza, but that it was "too soon" to raise hopes that a deal would be reached.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the US/Iran talks: difficult compromises lie ahead
Many actors are in play and a great deal is at stake in the latest round of talks between the United States and Iran on that country's nuclear enrichment programme. Israel is threatening to attack Iranian nuclear plants if the US fails to act, European powers accuse Iran of breaching agreed inspections, while Gulf powers exert a powerful influence on President Donald Trump to avoid a dangerous war by compromises that would open up large economic opportunities for the US. These bilateral talks, and the parallel nuclear negotiations in Vienna, which could open up a new round of United Nations sanctions, hinge largely on whether Iran can continue its nuclear enrichment programme or must close it down. Iran flatly refuses to stop enrichment, a demand spearheaded by Israel and supported by a strong lobby within Trump's entourage. He has recently shifted his position towards no enrichment, but if that remains unacceptable to the Iranians he faces a fateful choice between finding a compromise and opening a path towards possible war. Trump's first overseas state visit to Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar last month exposed him to their immense wealth and newfound regional power, both of which he values. Their desire for more stable relations with Iran cuts right across Israeli leader Binyamin Netanyahu's push for military action against Iran's enrichment. That feeds into the intense debates around Trump's administration on whether such a war would derail his presidency. There is scope for diplomatic progress if the political will is there. One suggestion from the US negotiator Steve Witkoff is that Iran's enrichment for energy and other peaceful uses be tied into a wider regional programme that would create security and economic incentives all round. Iran's refusal of that option could shift if it sees UN sanctions as a real possibility and chooses to avoid that. France, Germany and the UK should channel such pressure towards finding such a path to regional security as part of their wider critique of Netanyahu's war in Gaza. READ MORE
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Palestinian lives being weighed against bond markets,' Dáil hears in debate over Israeli bonds
Taoiseach Micheál Martin has been accused of 'speaking the truth in order to bury it' by acknowledging genocide in Gaza but failing to prevent the Central Bank's role in the sale of Israeli war bonds. In a Dáil debate calling for an end for the bank's involvement in the sale of the bonds, Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon said the Israeli bonds prospectus advertisement says ''stand with Israel. Israel is at war.' These bonds bankroll the bombs, the starvation, the extermination,' he said. He said that while the Government states that genocide is happening, 'Ireland must do nothing that might affect our GDP, that might affect our relationship with the US. This is what it comes down to - Palestinian lives being weighed against bond markets and bilateral trade flows'. What is happening 'by virtue of the fact that we're refusing to meet our obligations for the prevention of genocide is collusion. And what the Taoiseach is doing is speaking the truth only in order to bury it'. READ MORE Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe insisted the Government 'is working relentlessly with partners and with others to affect the type of change that Israel may not be able to ignore'. He said 'our efforts are making a difference, but I accept that they need to deliver more'. Ireland's approach to the unfolding tragedy is one of 'principled conviction, but also a recognition of the realities that we face, that we have to build up a diplomatic coalition to achieve more. 'We also have to be conscious of laws that are already in place,' he said as he introduced a countermotion. He said that, similar to the Sinn Féin motion, the Social Democrats proposal 'would be unworkable, will contravene EU law and would not achieve its intended objective'. The Social Democrats introduced the motion two weeks after Sinn Féin introduced legislation which was voted down , to stop the Central Bank's involvement in the sale of Israeli bonds. Party deputy leader Cian O'Callaghan said 'men, women, and children are being starved to death'. 'Mothers have been forced to try and boil grass to feed their children and starvation is being used as a weapon of war against innocent people. 'The Governor of the Central Bank says that the Central Bank cannot act on this, that it's beyond their competency to decide whether or not genocide is taking place.' But he said in January 2024 'the International Court of Justice confirmed the plausibility of the charges of genocide taken against Israel by South Africa'. The Government recognised that 'what's happening in Gaza is genocide' but 'it is not simply enough to say that what is happening is genocide'. The Government 'must do everything you can to stop and prevent genocide in Gaza.' The Israeli government 'is selling these bonds to help finance the genocide. And the Irish Central Bank is facilitating the sale of those bonds in Europe. That is a direct link between these bonds and the genocide that is taking place and this has to stop.' Sinn Féin finance spokesman Pearse Doherty described the Government's response as 'shameful' and that they would be 'on the wrong side of history' as 'genocide is staring us in the face'. People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy asked 'is your argument seriously that a regulation on financial prospectuses should override the UN Convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide'. Minister of State Robert Troy said measures have to be negotiated and agreed internationally 'at EU and UN level for them to have real impact and credibility'. He added that 'any attempt to act unilaterally could undermine the unified approach that we're beginning to see form at EU level. We cannot seek to uphold international law by breaking EU law.'
