Barbara Kay: A disabled man's fight for life in an age of MAiD
How many disabled people choose MAiD because their will to live is sapped by the infantilizing strictures of institutional life or forced transfer to a care home far from loved ones, even though a cheaper and empowering alternative is available? It is to Foley's immense credit that he has bent his muscular will to insisting upon self-directed care, which is already a right in many western countries, such as the U.S., Australia, New Zealand, Ireland and Scotland.
Article content
It almost became a right in Canada too. In 2015, the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care introduced 'Patients First: A Roadmap to Strengthen Home and Community Care,' a plan which outlined the province's intent to introduce a self-directed care option to patients.
Article content
'Putting patients first means giving clients and caregivers greater say in choosing a provider and how that provider delivers services,' read the report. 'Over the next two years, we will begin to offer a self-directed care option, in which clients and their caregivers are given funds to hire their own provider or purchase services from a provider of their choice.' Unfortunately, it never really got off the ground and was 'paused' in 2016, according to a local health network briefing obtained by Foley, which he shared with me.
Article content
Article content
Since SDF would offer immeasurably better quality of life for Foley, free up a bed in the hospital and save LHSC a great deal of money, I'm hard-pressed to see the downside here. C.D. Howe Institute associate director of research Rosalie Wyonch provides additional support for my perspective. Patients like Foley, she told Postmedia earlier this week, 'take up more patient bed capacity than all the top 10 surgeries combined…. It's probably the single-biggest hospital capacity issue. If we were to fix it, we would essentially no longer be at risk of acute care bed shortages.'
Article content
Euthanasia, for those who want it, is considered a human right in Canada. Self-directed care for those disabled Canadians who do not want MAiD should also be considered a human right.
Article content
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Police ask court to find Winnipeg care home in contempt over failure to provide info on woman's fall, death
Police are asking a court to find a Winnipeg personal care home in contempt, because the home refused to hand over information from a critical incident report conducted after a 90-year-old woman died there following a fall out of bed last October. The Winnipeg Police Service filed a notice of application earlier this month in Manitoba's Court of King's Bench, asking the court to find Concordia Place guilty of common law contempt for failing to comply with a production order. The dispute began after the Winnipeg Police Service got the production order in February, asking Concordia Place to disclose a list of information, including reports related to the woman and communications, including emails, during the home's investigation into her injury and death. The care home — which is operated by Concordia Hospital under an agreement with the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority — responded the following month, providing some of the information police asked for. However, it said in a letter later submitted as a court exhibit that provincial legislation prevented it from sharing other documents investigators requested, including reports prepared for the critical incident committee, as well as communication during the care home's investigation into the woman's injury and death. Manitoba Health investigates all critical incidents, which it defines as "an unintended event that occurs when health services are provided to an individual and results in a consequence to him or her that is serious and undesired." Police asked the court in the contempt application to impose a penalty on the care home "which the court deems fit," including an order forcing it to comply with the production order. The update comes after Concordia Place filed a notice of application last month asking the court to quash the production order, arguing in part that the judge who granted it failed to impose adequate conditions to minimize the risk of disclosing the privileged information, and that the order was overly broad. It pointed to sections of the Manitoba Evidence Act and the Health System Governance and Accountability Act as reasons it was barred from disclosing the information. "Because of these statutory provisions against disclosure, Concordia Place staff are assured confidentiality in the critical incident process," the notice of application said. "They are told that this process is strictly confidential and based on provincial laws, critical incident documents are not compellable in court. This is designed to create a culture of safety, and to encourage reporting and participation in the investigation and review of critical incidents." The critical incident in question was reported at the care home on Oct. 9, 2024, when a woman with dementia fell out of bed and was lifted back in by a health-care aide, the care home's July filing said. The woman was said to have been experiencing an overall general decline in health in the year preceding the fall. The morning after the incident, skin changes and swelling were observed on the woman, and an X-ray confirmed she had a fractured leg, but due to her age and other existing medical conditions, she was not considered for surgery to repair the fracture, the court filing said. The application said the woman died a week after the fall, but there is no evidence the fall caused her death. The matter appeared in a Winnipeg courtroom last week and was adjourned without setting a next date.
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
'Leave them alone': Expert shares how to stay safe after rabid bats found in Brantford, Centre Wellington
A rabid bat found at a Brantford daycare last week has renewed concerns about bat-related rabies exposure in southern Ontario. One child and one staff member came into contact with the infected bat, prompting a public health investigation and a temporary closure of the daycare. It reopened this week. In Centre Wellington, a person began precautionary treatment for potential exposure last week after a rabid bat was found there. Public health officials for Wellington-Dufferin-Guelph said bat-related incidents are on the rise this year. The number of investigations public health conducted last year related to bats was 47. So far for this year, that number is up to 61 bat-related investigations. While cases of human rabies are rare, experts warn that bats are a common carrier of the virus and that even small bites or scratches can pose a serious risk if not treated. To better understand how people can protect themselves and prevent bats from entering their homes, CBC Kitchener-Waterloo's Joe Pavia spoke to Brock Fenton, a biology professor emeritus at Western University. This interview has been edited for length and clarity. Joe Pavia: Should humans be afraid of bats? Brock Fenton: I would say instead of saying 'Don't be afraid of them' [just] leave them alone, don't handle them. So if you're somewhere out and a bat comes over, don't handle it. And if it's in your grandmother's bedroom, put on your ski glove before you grab it, something that the bat can't bite through. Rabies is spread by biting. Rabid animals, including bats, have the rabies virus in their bloodstream. If their blood gets into your bloodstream, that's bad news. Joe Pavia: How does a bat become rabid? Brock Fenton: We don't know for sure. I think that bats certainly spread it among themselves and that's probably where it comes from. Brantford, Ont., daycare closes temporarily after child finds rabid bat, hands it to worker Public health clears Brantford, Ont., daycare to reopen after investigation following rabid bat discovery Joe Pavia: How can people prevent bats from entering their home? Brock Fenton: If it's the occasional stray bat, there's probably not very much you can do about it. It's like trying to keep squirrels out of your garden, right? But if you've got bats living in your attic, you should take steps to get rid of them. That means getting in touch with somebody who does animal control. What they do is they block up the openings the bats would use. So if you've got a bedroom or bathroom and you have a fan, but there's no screen on it, that immediately allows the bat to get in because bats don't have the equipment to make openings. They have to use existing openings. Brock Fenton: Its pretty hard to tell what bats like as a place to live. I've put up lots of bat boxes but I've never had any move into them. I suspect they're much choosier about their real estate. Joe Pavia: Why are bats so important to the ecosystem? Brock Fenton: They occur pretty much everywhere in the world. They consume a lot of insects because most of them are insect eaters. All of the Canadian species are insect eaters. In the tropics, bats also pollinate plants, so they're also important in agriculture. My great love of bats just has to do with the fact that they're so lovely as a teaching animal. There's so much about them we don't know and people are usually intrigued by things they don't know. So that can keep you going for your whole career, and you're still learning new things about bats. There's all these things about bats that make them interesting and intriguing. Rabies is a sort of an unpleasant side effect.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Number of Mounties on long-term sick leave poses 'significant operational challenges': report
The proportion of Mounties on long-term, off-duty sick leave has reached an all-time high and become a critical issue for the national police force, according to a new outside report. The Management Advisory Board (MAB), an oversight body that advises the RCMP commissioner, is warning that the existing model of unlimited sick leave at full pay is unsustainable and in need of a rethink in order to get more officers back on patrol — recommendations that are already garnering vehement disagreement from the RCMP union. "The rapid increase over the past fifteen years in the number of RCMP employees on [leave] presents an area of well-being concern at the individual level and poses significant operational challenges at the organizational level," said the report from the board's well-being task force. "It also has the potential to impact public safety writ large," the report continued. "This increase also comes with significant associated financial costs." Long-term, off-duty sick status is used for absences due to illness, injury or disability that exceed 30 consecutive days. According to the task force's figures, the number of RCMP regular members on leave has increased by 184 per cent over a 14-year period. As of Dec. 31, 2024, about seven per cent of the regular members were on long-term, off-duty leave at an approximate cost of $58 million, the task force estimated in its report. It also raised concerns about the number of Mounties on extended leave for more than a year. As it stands, the task force — which said it talked to regular members, supervisors and senior leadership — found the model "offers no incentive to return to work." The task force said it recognizes Mounties put their lives on the line and many will face injury and trauma during their careers. "These injuries, whether mental, physical, or otherwise, need appropriate recovery time," said the report. However, it also recommends the RCMP rethink its unlimited sick leave regime at full pay, and consider incorporating a reduction in pay after a pre-established period on leave. "The task force heard repeatedly that the current unlimited sick leave at full pay model used by the RCMP is unsustainable in its current state, places undue pressure on the organization and has an adverse impact on the RCMP's human, financial and technical resources," it said. RCMP says it's reviewing recommendations The union representing thousands of RCMP officers vehemently disagrees with the report's findings. Brian Sauvé, president of the National Police Federation, said the issues don't lie with the sick leave pay model, but with how it's managed. He believes the report missed the union's warnings that the RCMP's disability management accommodation program is not properly funded. "They never looked at the fact that there's a shared responsibility here, and half that responsibility rests with management," Sauvé said in an interview. "Members fall through the cracks, are not contacted by their employer — sometimes for six months or longer — for return-to-work programs or disability management accommodation programs." The MAB report pointed to models used by other police forces to reduce pay for members on leave. For example, it said the Edmonton Police Service reduces pay to 90 per cent or 75 per cent, at the chief's discretion, after 85 days of sick leave. Sauvé countered that RCMP members are in a unique position as they fall outside of any provincial or territorial worker compensation scheme. He also said sick leave is something that must be decided through collective bargaining, and any proposal to modify it must be brought to the union. "So you can provide advice all you want to the RCMP commissioner. If they want to bring it to the bargaining table, they can." The RCMP said the board's report "is currently under comprehensive review," and it will deliver a more substantive response to the advisory body shortly. "The RCMP welcomes the MAB's engagement on this important issue, as the need to improve how the RCMP manages long term off-duty sick cases has been identified as a key area of concern by employees and by management at the RCMP," said spokesperson Camille Boily-Lavoie
