National Dialogue: ANC talking to an empty room, but it must listen
You don't have to be an expert to know that a wounded animal, when cornered, will fight tooth and nail for its survival.
Such a scene is playing out before our eyes with the ANC and its hijacking of the National Dialogue. The dialogue, packaged as a forum for citizens, activists, civil society, business, and political parties to discuss issues facing the country, kicks off today in Pretoria.
A true family meeting is needed. Not the one-sided announcements fed to us by the president under the Covid-19 lockdown, but a proper, clear-the-air discussion to unite us behind a strategy to take the country forward.
SA really is sitting on a watershed moment.
A coalition government demands more political consensus and unified policy than has been needed since 1994.
Black economic empowerment (BEE), the Expropriation Act, and SA's foreign policy are just three of many sticking points in the ruling government of national unity (GNU) that need to be discussed and a national stance adopted.
We can no longer drink from a tin that says national unity but tastes and smells just like ANC policy.
Social collapse
Socially, we sit on a tsunami of crises that threaten to overwhelm communities and citizens.
Whether it is powering streetlights or fixing potholes, businesses and citizen groups have had to step in where the government has failed. They deserve a place and a voice at the discussion table.
Services that should be offered by the government to its citizens are now being privatised, leaving those who want them to pay for everything from water and electricity to schooling, security, waste collection, and medical care. This further divides the chasm between the haves and have-nots in the most unequal country in the world.
Those who live on both ends of the chasm deserve to have a voice at the National Dialogue.
They should speak about how the government's failure to provide sufficient basic services and jobs has led to a scarcity and frustration that has become a fertile ground for Operation Dudula to thrive. Whenever the vigilante group questions the nationality of those working at stores or in line at clinics, hospitals, and schools, they are adding to the hysteria that 'foreigners are stealing our jobs, rights, and privileges'.
All citizens will talk about how we blindly deal with water shortages, power outages, corruption, racism, gender-based violence, and crime on a daily basis.
SA is among the most crime-ridden countries in the world. Private security companies and police are on the front line each day, dealing with everything from potential terrorism threats and illegal mining to extortion, kidnapping and muggings in the CBD that 'nobody saw'. They should be heard at a national discussion.
ALSO READ: A VIEW OF THE WEEK: When will the ground fall beneath us?
National dialogue: another ANC rally?
But none of these crucial players, whether meaningful political opposition to the ANC or John from down the road, will be there on Friday.
Several political parties have pulled out, as have key foundations and civil society organisations.
Their fears that this will be a costly talkshop for ANC cadres and their supporters to hijack may become a reality, with echo chambers of party policy passed as national consensus.
The party should have learnt from losing power in a bruising 2024 election and realised it needs to be a fair player.
Like an apologetic but insincere ex, ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula loves to go on about how the party has learnt its lessons from its past failures and has listened to the people of SA. It is a lie parroted by his boss, President Cyril Ramaphosa, when addressing the national government's failures.
But what lessons have they learnt, and who exactly have they been listening to?
Government community imbizos are a powerful and progressive step, but complaints fall on deaf ears, and no changes are implemented when the blue-light brigades leave town.
Both the ANC and the government that it controlled for 30 years need to understand the reality of the people they claim to serve, but refuse to hear it and would rather talk to an empty room.
Perhaps if they stopped talking, stopped fighting, the silence of those who chose not to be part of their charade will tell them how they got there in the first place.
NOW READ: A VIEW OF THE WEEK: Ramaphosa risks losing control of Cabinet
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
41 minutes ago
- Eyewitness News
Cosatu supports National Dialogue, but warns talk must lead to action
The National Dialogue has sparked mixed reactions, with critics questioning whether it can deliver concrete improvements to jobs, services, and the economy. RELATED: National Convention kicks off amid tensions over legitimacy, citizen representation While acknowledging public frustration, Cosatu maintains that a properly structured and monitored process could lay the groundwork for a renewed social contract, only if implementation follows. Phetoe says the labour federation initially raised concerns, but agreed to support the process after engagements with the dialogue team appointed by President Cyril Ramaphosa. He emphasises that any outcomes must be government-led to ensure implementation.
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
ANC to debate two centres of power in Limpopo
Both Ramathuba and Mpe have confirmed they will stand for the position of ANC provincial chair in Limpopo. The ANC's two centres of power are set to dominate discussions when Premier Phophi Ramathuba and Polokwane Mayor Makoro 'Putin' John Mpe are set to contest for the position of ANC provincial chair at the upcoming provincial elective conference. Two in the race for ANC provincial chair Both Ramathuba and Mpe have confirmed they will stand for the position, only if nominated by branches at the right time. The two centres of power policy was introduced during the 2007 Polokwane ANC national elective conference where former president Jacob Zuma toppled then-president Thabo Mbeki to become ANC president. Limpopo is currently run by a premier, Ramathuba, who is not the party's provincial chair. Now, Makoro 'Putin' John Mpe is being touted by some to be elected ANC provincial chairperson. This after he won his 'third term' bid in May at the Peter Mokaba regional elective conference. ALSO READ: Leadership battle heats up in Limpopo Asked about the province's view on the two centres of power, ANC provincial spokesperson Mathole Jimmy Machaka said: 'The view of the ANC is that the centre is one and the centre is Frans Mohlala (ANC Limpopo headquarters). It is the ANC-led government and not the other way round,' he said. Month before he died, ANC veteran Tshwenuwani Farisani said the debate on the so-called two centres of power has caused long-standing tension between the party's leadership and its governmental structures. This tension, Farisani said, has played out in the South African political landscape, with the ANC often facing challenges of whether the chairperson of the party should become the premier of the province. He said the debate often arises when the ANC's internal political dynamics clash with government policies or decisions. 'This can lead to confusion, policy inconsistencies, and challenges for effective governance,' he said. ANC Women's League to support Ramathuba On Friday, the ANC Women's League in Limpopo said it will throw its support behind Ramathuba. 'It is the position of the ANCWL in Limpopo to support any woman who stands for the position of provincial chairperson, provided she possesses the necessary skills, experience, and capacity. The ANCWL is committed to ensuring that women occupy all corridors of power,' said league provincial secretary, Tebogo Mamorobela. ALSO READ: Mbalula launches probe into Limpopo ANC election irregularities The ANC Youth League in the province has not yet decided who it will support. ANCYL provincial chair Faith Sebopela, however, said it will support the PEC's call for an early conference. 'On who should lead the province as chair is a subject for another day,' she said. Allegations of corruption Mpe's road to the ANC Limpopo headquarters as party provincial chair, and his alleged desire to then become premier, has been marred by allegations of corruption. For the past month, the mayor – who is also ANC Peter Mokaba regional chair and the South African Local Government Association (Salga) Limpopo chair – and his city manager Thuso Nemugumoni have been accused of corruption. They have also been accused of awarding municipal tenders to foreign nationals, the latest of which was last month when the municipality appointed a foreign national as director of water and sanitation. Mpe claims the accusations were orchestrated by ANC members who are 'bitter' after losing regional elections. 'These are bitter comrades who are scared of losing the provincial conference because, despite playing all the tricks in the book, they still lost the Peter Mokaba regional elective conference in May, where I was re-elected unopposed for a third term. 'Those who have proof of any corruption element against me must hand over their proof to law-enforcement agencies such as the Hawks, the Special Investigating Unit (SIU), the Public Protector, and or the police,' he said. The term of office for the 10th Limpopo ANC provincial executive committee (PEC) ends in June 2026. It remains to be seen who will become the new Limpopo ANC provincial chairperson to replace the sitting chair, Stan Mathabatha. READ NEXT: Tensions erupt in Limpopo ANC after vandalism of spokesperson's bakkie
The Herald
an hour ago
- The Herald
We are here to start the dialogue, says Ramaphosa
President Cyril Ramaphosa has emphasised his standing amid the wrangling over the national dialogue. Taking to the podium to address the national convention meant to kick off the dialogue, the president maintained he is well within his rights to oversee the process as its convener. 'I have called this first national convention in my capacity as your president, as the head of state. I have done so in line with section 83 of our constitution, which requires the president, as the head of state and head of the national executive, to promote the unity of the nation and that which will advance the republic. 'This is what brings me here. This is why I invited all of you here, to be here and be part of this dialogue,' said Ramaphosa. Despite the dramatic 11th-hour withdrawal from the dialogue by legacy foundations, Ramaphosa insisted there was a need to forge ahead as planned. Thanking them for their work preparing for the dialogue, Ramaphosa said any hesitation or postponement could erode trust in the process by civil society organisations and NGOs invited to share their views. 'For more than a year, various formations of civil society have been working to conceptualise and champion the national dialogue. Central to this effort have been a number of legacy foundations established by and named for stalwarts of our liberation struggle. We express our gratitude and appreciation for the work of these foundations in giving life to the national dialogue.' He said this would open up a space where South Africans confront their realities openly, respectfully and constructively. ' This is not a partisan platform. This is a national platform. Here, no voice is too small and no perspective is too inconvenient to be heard. We are gathered to listen to each other, to understand one another and to chart a common path forward for our country. 'We meet at a time of profound challenges: economic hardship, unemployment, inequality, growing poverty and a crisis of confidence in our institutions. We also meet at a time when the world is rapidly changing and our ability to adapt and renew ourselves will define the next generation. But history teaches us that nations are not defined solely by their difficulties; they are defined by how they respond to challenges they face.' Ramaphosa said the South African struggle was one for freedom from the nightmare of apartheid, one that proved there was unity in diversity. 'It is a powerful force for transformation. Gathered in this hall are people from all across our land, people from all walks of life, people of all races, all classes, all languages and cultures.' Despite the diversity of those participating in forums like the dialogue, one thing that held South Africans together was that they were all 'sons and daughters of the same soil'. 'We share a common past. We share the same inheritance of division, of inequality and of injustice. We share the same pride at ending the crime of apartheid and establishing a constitutional democracy. We also share a common future. And that is why we have chosen to gather here today. Because each one of us, regardless of our differences, is committed to work together to build the future of which we all dream. 'We have chosen to be here because we believe in the power of dialogue and united action. We believe that if we share our concerns and fears, we can conquer them. If we understand the challenges we face, we can overcome them. 'If we know what hurts us, we can heal. If we know what divides us, we can unite.' He said across the length and breadth of South Africa, people would, and should, meet to talk about what worried them, what gave them hope and how they thought their lives and the country could be better.
