logo
Harvard Is Hoping Court Rules Trump Administration's $2.6b Research Cuts Were Illegal

Harvard Is Hoping Court Rules Trump Administration's $2.6b Research Cuts Were Illegal

Al Arabiya5 days ago
Harvard University will appear in federal court Monday to make the case that the Trump administration illegally cut $2.6 billion from the storied college – a pivotal moment in its battle against the federal government. If US District Judge Allison Burroughs decides in the university's favor, the ruling would reverse a series of funding freezes that later became outright cuts as the Trump administration escalated its fight with the nation's oldest and wealthiest university. Such a ruling, if it stands, would revive Harvard's sprawling scientific and medical research operation and hundreds of projects that lost federal money.
'This case involves the Government's efforts to use the withholding of federal funding as leverage to gain control of academic decision-making at Harvard,' the university said in its complaint. 'All told, the tradeoff put to Harvard and other universities is clear: Allow the Government to micromanage your academic institution or jeopardize the institution's ability to pursue medical breakthroughs, scientific discoveries, and innovative solutions.'
A second lawsuit over the cuts, filed by the American Association of University Professors and its Harvard faculty chapter, has been consolidated with the university's. Harvard's lawsuit accuses President Donald Trump's administration of waging a retaliation campaign against the university after it rejected a series of demands in an April 11 letter from a federal antisemitism task force. The letter demanded sweeping changes related to campus protests, academics, and admissions. For example, the letter told Harvard to audit the viewpoints of students and faculty and admit more students or hire new professors if the campus was found to lack diverse points of view. The letter was meant to address government accusations that the university had become a hotbed of liberalism and tolerated anti-Jewish harassment on campus.
Harvard President Alan Garber pledged to fight antisemitism but said no government should dictate what private universities can teach, whom they can admit and hire, and which areas of study and inquiry they can pursue. The same day Harvard rejected the demands, Trump officials moved to freeze $2.2 billion in research grants. Education Secretary Linda McMahon declared in May that Harvard would no longer be eligible for new grants, and weeks later, the administration began canceling contracts with Harvard. As Harvard fought the funding freeze in court, individual agencies began sending letters announcing that the frozen research grants were being terminated. They cited a clause that allows grants to be scrapped if they no longer align with government policies. Harvard, which has the nation's largest endowment at $53 billion, has moved to self-fund some of its research but warned it can't absorb the full cost of the federal cuts.
In court filings, the school said the government fails to explain how the termination of funding for research to treat cancer, support veterans, and improve national security addresses antisemitism. The Trump administration denies the cuts were made in retaliation, saying the grants were under review even before the April demand letter was sent. It argues the government has wide discretion to cancel contracts for policy reasons. 'It is the policy of the United States under the Trump Administration not to fund institutions that fail to adequately address antisemitism in their programs,' it said in court documents.
The research funding is only one front in Harvard's fight with the federal government. The Trump administration also has sought to prevent the school from hosting foreign students, and Trump has threatened to revoke Harvard's tax-exempt status. Finally, last month, the Trump administration formally issued a finding that the school tolerated antisemitism – a step that eventually could jeopardize all of Harvard's federal funding, including federal student loans or grants. The penalty is typically referred to as a 'death sentence.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Gaza Talks at Crossroads: US Pulls Negotiators as Mediators Report Progress
Gaza Talks at Crossroads: US Pulls Negotiators as Mediators Report Progress

Leaders

timean hour ago

  • Leaders

Gaza Talks at Crossroads: US Pulls Negotiators as Mediators Report Progress

The US and Israel pulled their negotiating teams from Qatar for consultation, hours after Hamas submitted its response to the latest Gaza ceasefire proposal. On the other hand, mediators Egypt and Qatar reported some progress in the talks and said they would resume, as international concern mounts over Gaza's worsening humanitarian situation and spreading hunger. Blaming Hamas The US President, Donald Trump, and the Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, on Friday accused Hamas of not wanting a deal in Gaza, signaling that they would give up on the ceasefire negotiations, reported Reuters. 'Hamas really didn't want to make a deal. I think they want to die. And it's very bad. And it got to be to a point where you're going to have to finish the job,' Trump told reporters. On Thursday, Trump's Special Envoy, Steve Witkoff, said that Hamas was not acting in good faith and its response to the truce proposal showed a lack of desire to reach a ceasefire in Gaza. Similarly, Netanyahu said that 'Hamas is the obstacle to a hostage release deal,' according to a statement by his office. Alternative Options Both the US and Israel suggested they would look for alternatives to release the remaining hostages, without elaborating. Witkoff said that the US would 'consider alternative options to bring the hostages home and try to create a more stable environment for the people of Gaza.' Meanwhile, the Israeli Prime Minister said that Tel Aviv and Washington were 'considering alternative options to bring our hostages home, end Hamas's terror rule, and secure lasting peace for Israel and our region.' With regards to this, the US State Department spokeswoman, Tammy Bruce, declined to reveal what options Trump and Witkoff were referring to. 'We've tried. The world has watched this. What the options are — clearly there are many tools in President Trump's tool chest, many options that Special Envoy Witkoff has,' she told CNN on Friday. 'So, they are very smart, adept individuals who know the players. And I expect that we'll have some success,' Bruce added. Constructive Gaza Talks In contrast, Hamas deemed the latest round of negotiations constructive, criticizing Witkoff's remarks as an attempt to pressure the Palestinian movement for the benefit of Israel in the next round of talks. 'What we have presented – with full awareness and understanding of the complexity of the situation – we believe could lead to a deal if the enemy had the will to reach one,' Hamas official Bassem Naim said in a statement on Facebook. He said that said the talks addressed several gaps, such as the ceasefire agenda, guarantees to continue negotiating to reach a permanent agreement and how humanitarian aid would be delivered. Mediators Optimism Mediators Egypt and Qatar echoed Naim's comments. In a joint statement, the two countries said that the latest round of talks had seen some progress and that they would resume, without setting a date. 'It is normal to suspend talks to hold consultations before the resumption of the dialogue once more,' they said. Moreover, Egypt and Qatar reiterated their commitment to continuing their efforts to reach a comprehensive ceasefire agreement in Gaza in collaboration with the US. Negotiations have been taking place for months to reach a ceasefire deal that would release Israeli hostages, increase aid flow into Gaza and halt the fighting for 60 days. However, some sticking points have obstructed progress, including the redeployment of Israeli troops in Gaza and what would happen after the 60-day truce if no permanent agreement was reached. Looming Famine Gaza is facing a worsening humanitarian catastrophe, as international aid organizations warn of mass hunger in the Strip amid the restricted flow of aid. In response to mounting pressures, the Israeli military said on Friday it would allow countries to airdrop aid supplies into Gaza. 'The Gaza Strip does not need flying aerobatics, it needs an open humanitarian corridor and a steady daily flow of aid trucks to save what remains of the lives of besieged, starving civilians,' the director of the Hamas-run Gaza government media office, Ismail Al-Thawabta, told Reuters. As deaths related to malnutrition increased this month, around 28 countries and more than 115 aid agencies called for an immediate end to the Gaza war, criticizing Israel's restriction on aid flow and the delivery mechanism to deployed under the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). Short link : Post Views: 27

US sanctions Venezuelan gang allegedly linked to President Nicolas Maduro
US sanctions Venezuelan gang allegedly linked to President Nicolas Maduro

Al Arabiya

time3 hours ago

  • Al Arabiya

US sanctions Venezuelan gang allegedly linked to President Nicolas Maduro

The United States Treasury on Friday announced sanctions against a Venezuelan group which it claims is led by President Nicolas Maduro, alleging it backs leading drug cartels. The Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) announced restrictions on the so-called 'Cartel of the Suns,' classing it as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist entity. The OFAC agency, which determines sanctions based on US foreign policy, says the group is 'headed by Nicolas Maduro' and 'other high-ranking Venezuelan individuals in the Maduro regime.' It also alleged the cartel 'provides material support' to the Tren de Aragua and the Sinaloa Cartel -- criminal gangs designated by President Donald Trump's administration as terrorist groups. 'Today's action further exposes the illegitimate Maduro regime's facilitation of narco-terrorism through terrorist groups like Cartel de los Soles,' Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said in a statement. Trump's first term administration indicted Maduro and several of his top aides for 'narco-terrorism' and offered a reward for their capture, claims that were slammed by the leftist Venezuelan leader. According to Trump's government, 'Cartel de los Soles' has an objective of 'using the flood of illegal narcotics as a weapon against the United States.' Trump has targeted several groups south of the US border that he says are funneling vast amounts of dangerous illicit drugs into the United States and are involved in extortion, migrant smuggling and other violent crime. Relations between Washington and Caracas have been deteriorating for years. In 2019, the United States contested Maduro's re-election, which was widely deemed as fraudulent by the international community. Trump this year announced a partial ban on travelers from Venezuela, among a dozen countries. On Thursday, Maduro announced that the United States was allowing petroleum giant Chevron to resume operations in the South American country after previously slapping sanctions. Washington has not confirmed the development.

Pakistan deputy PM says hopeful of finalizing US trade deal ‘in days'
Pakistan deputy PM says hopeful of finalizing US trade deal ‘in days'

Arab News

time6 hours ago

  • Arab News

Pakistan deputy PM says hopeful of finalizing US trade deal ‘in days'

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan deputy prime minister and foreign minister, Ishaq Dar, said on Friday that his country was hopeful of finalizing a trade deal with the United States 'in days.' Pakistan and the United States (US) have been engaged in talks after Washington announced a 29 percent 'reciprocal tariff' on Pakistani exports in April. Islamabad said the move, paused in June for a 90-day period, may undercut its fragile, export-led recovery. The US is Pakistan's top export destination, with shipments totaling $5.44 billion in fiscal year 2023-2024, according to official data. From July 2024 to February 2025, exports rose 10 percent from a year earlier. Speaking at the Atlantic Council think tank in Washington, the Pakistani deputy premier said both sides have recently held discussions relating to textiles, digital trade and agriculture. 'Pakistan seeks better market access in the US. On our part, we are working toward granting greater market access to the US products in the large Pakistani markets,' he said. 'We hope to conclude a mutually beneficial trade agreement at the earliest, hopefully in days not in weeks.' Under US President Donald Trump, Washington has attempted to renegotiate trade agreements with many countries that he threatened with tariffs over what he calls unfair trade relations. Many economists dispute Trump's characterization. Dar also met Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Friday. 'Met with Pakistani Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister @MIshaqDar50 today to discuss expanding bilateral trade and enhancing collaboration in the critical minerals sector,' Rubio said on X. 'I also thanked him for Pakistan's partnership in countering terrorism and preserving regional stability.' The Pakistani foreign ministry also said Dar 'appreciated the pivotal role' by Trump and Rubio 'in de-escalating tensions between Pakistan and India by facilitating a ceasefire.' The State Department statement did not mention India. Trump has repeatedly taken credit for the India-Pakistan ceasefire he announced on social media on May 10 after Washington held talks with both sides. India disputes Trump's claims that the ceasefire resulted from his intervention and trade threats. An April 22 militant attack in Indian-administered Kashmir killed 26 men and sparked heavy fighting between the nuclear-armed Asian neighbors in the latest escalation of a decades-old rivalry. India struck Pakistan on May 7 and the two nations exchanged hostilities, killing dozens across three days. The ceasefire was declared on May 10. New Delhi blamed the April attack on Pakistan, which denied responsibility and called for a neutral investigation. Washington condemned the attack but did not blame Islamabad.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store