Jason Bourne's Virtues
In the first movie, Jason Bourne rejects vice and orients himself toward the good. In the second, he faces and does what he can to remedy the evil he has done. In the third movie, he is particularly marked by magnanimity, putting his skills and sorrows at the service of others. As a whole, these movies offer hope in virtue's ability to help conquer the greatest of odds.
Prudence and 'The Bourne Identity'
The queen of the cardinal virtues is prudence, because it's the virtue by which human beings can know, in a practical way, how to do good. While it's as common to associate prudence with evil masterminds and cowards as with good and wise people, prudence really has nothing to do with evil. Evil is self-destructive; smart evil people just destroy themselves cleverly. Socrates and Plato say that the only real evil does is to the doer's soul. The Bible states: 'The wicked fall into their own nets.'
In 'The Bourne Identity,' a practical man becomes truly prudent by seeking good and avoiding evil. It begins with the title character floating unconscious in the Mediterranean Sea. Upon being rescued, he has no memory of who he is. He's pursued by the police as he attempts to retrieve his identity. He ultimately discovers that he was a black ops agent, who has assassinated dozens of targets while working for a CIA program called Treadstone.
Jason Bourne (Matt Damon) has no idea who he is, in "The Bourne Identity."
Universal Pictures
This discovery creates a crisis: If amnesia doesn't change a person's moral character, Bourne will probably return to his old life. However, his final revelation proves the most critical: He had a change of heart before he lost his memory. A rejection of evil, though not remembered, has set Bourne on a new trajectory.
Bourne exemplifies prudence because his actions are ordered toward the good, whether the lower good of self-preservation and self-defense early in the movie, or the higher goods he comes to embrace, such as preserving and defending the lives of the innocent. While bloody, the final confrontation at the movie's end illustrates his pursuit of higher goods, most importantly his intention to relinquish his former life as an assassin. To do this, given his inability to remember his past, he needs more knowledge, and the only way to get it is to meet his evil former employer under very dangerous circumstances.
All of his actions require not only the intention to do good, but also the know-how to accomplish it. Classical and Christian authors, from Aristotle to Thomas Aquinas, have written many lists of what these 'sub-virtues' or parts of prudence are. Bourne exemplifies many, such as his quick thinking when he's called upon to defend a family against a sniper with a much better gun, perfect lines of sight, and a stronger position.
Related Stories
2/4/2025
10/22/2024
Movie poster for "The Bourne Identity."
Universal Pictures
'Circumspection,' the awareness of dangers and how to address them, is the unassuming name of the virtue that inspires the action sequence near the beginning of the movie: Bourne, about to be arrested in a U.S. Embassy, incapacitates his would-be captors, then calmly and deliberately escapes from a group of soldiers.
Justice and 'The Bourne Supremacy'
'The Bourne Supremacy' opens with a debate about prudence and resolves itself by means of the next cardinal virtue, justice. Justice is a virtue that is about relationships with other human beings. It can be summed up in Aristotle's 'giving to others their due.'
At the beginning of 'The Bourne Supremacy,' Bourne and his girlfriend Marie are attempting to escape from an assassin. They begin to argue while fleeing. Bourne maintains that their future is predetermined: They must continually fly from and fight against the organization that is pursuing them. 'We don't have a choice,' he says. Marie counters: 'Yes, you do.' Immediately after this, Marie is shot. Bourne and the viewers never learn what she was going to suggest.
Nevertheless, the rest of the movie is about Bourne making good choices. Since they are choices having to do with others, the film is fundamentally concerned with justice.
Jason Bourne (Matt Damon) is being tracked by nefarious agencies, in "The Bourne Supremacy."
Universal Pictures
Moreover, the plot is initialized by the injustices perpetrated by CIA director Ward Abbot, who orders the assassination attempt on Bourne to cover up his own corrupt activities. The two strands of Bourne's pursuit of justice and Abbot's of injustice weave around each other through the whole movie. As Bourne learns more about his past life, he finally remembers his first kill for Treadstone, and the two strands are resolved. On one hand, Bourne's pursuit of justice occurs on multiple levels. On the other, Abbot gets his just desserts.
The principles behind Bourne's choices are nothing if not of prudence and justice. One notable example occurs when Bourne has CIA officer Pamela Landy in his crosshairs, ready to retaliate for Marie's murder. However, before he shoots, he realizes that he might be mistaken about whether Landy was involved. He quickly pivots to a different plan that involves gathering more information. Whether it's right or not to take justice into one's own hands, it's surely unjust to take an innocent life while trying to do so.
Jason Bourne (Matt Damon) has second thoughts about sniping someone, in "The Bourne Supremacy."
Universal Pictures
As the movie continues, justice comes more
into the foreground. In a beautiful and surprising scene near the end of the movie, classical virtue, embraced by ancient philosophers like Aristotle and Cicero, merge with the Judeo-Christian virtue of repentance. When he's finally able to remember another set of assassinations he performed in his old life, he risks his life to travel to Moscow. He finds the daughter of the victims and apologizes. Bourne has met the challenge of Marie's final words; whatever outside pressures may be, there is always a choice, and Bourne repeatedly choses justice, however difficult.
Fortitude and 'The Bourne Ultimatum'
The 'Bourne' films confirm one thing: the heroic and admirable nature of fortitude, which is the willingness to encounter danger as long as it is right to do so. 'The Bourne Ultimatum' particularly revels in this virtue. The word 'fortitude' comes from a Latin word meaning both 'bravery' and 'strength.'
Picking up in Moscow right where the second film ended, 'Ultimatum' starts with Bourne's next task, which is to recover the memory of how he was recruited and trained for Treadstone. He must also expose the remaining corrupt CIA officials who managed the program. Avoiding capture, fighting off other black ops agents, and saving a
girl along the way, Bourne succeeds in both goals.
In one of the bloodiest fight scenes in the Bourne trilogy, Jason Bourne fights against evil enemies, in "The Bourne Ultimatum."
Universal Pictures
The movie features a fight scene in Tangier. It's the longest and one of the most brutal in the series, and therefore, in addition to Bourne's incredible physical abilities, it requires incredible perseverance and patience.
The scene helps viewers consider the interconnectedness of the cardinal virtues. Prudence, justice, and fortitude are connected hierarchically. Prudence dictates the aims both of justice and fortitude, and taking risks, the arena of fortitude, is only virtuous if the goals are just. Bourne pursues and fights only for the sake of a prudent and just motive: saving his friend's life.
Justice isn't always meted out in an official capacity; there are far more informal opportunities to do right.
Shutterstock
Finally, the movie ends with Bourne showing magnanimity, the crowning part of fortitude. His aim turns out to be not only learning more about his past, but also performing a great deed for the public good: exposing the illegal and immoral activities of a corrupt government organization. While doing so, he refuses to kill an assassin who had tried to kill him.
Similar to the end of the second film, classical and Christian virtues come together in an act of mercy. First, it's something like justice: Bourne, as a former assassin, recognizes that he isn't the one to judge this man. It's also an example of the virtue of forgiveness.
Virtue Strengthens, Evil Weakens
While Bourne's material disadvantages are overcome and play an important part in the viewers' delight, it's more important to realize how much the movies make of Bourne's one advantage: his virtues. The Bourne movies set up virtue in a high-pressure laboratory experiment: one man against a well-connected, wealthy, all-seeing organization with almost endless advantages. All the advantages, that is, except virtue.
While the protagonist possesses an incredible array of skills and abilities as an assassin, it's undeniable that he becomes more powerful as he begins to renounce this life. Once merely an instrument, a mere 'asset' of the CIA sub-organization Treadstone, he triumphs over the CIA and all its resources because he decides to live virtuously. In spite of his former employers' repeated assumptions, his decisions and actions can't be predicted because they are the actions of a free moral agent.
Nothing is more predictable than evil. That's the way that Bourne is almost always a step ahead of his enemies. He knows the kind of treachery they will attempt. He's familiar with their reliance on manpower, technology, and procedures over prudence and reason.
Bourne, on the contrary, repeatedly risks his life for the right to live according to prudence and reason. In doing, so he fully accords with Aristotle in his great work on the virtues, the 'Nichomachean Ethics.' Aristotle indicates that no happiness is possible without living according to reason, and that living according to reason isn't possible without the virtues.
The cover page of Aristotle's "Nichomachean Ethics."
PD-US
The Bourne movies are excellent vehicles for thinking about and learning about human virtue. Of course, they have been praised for their acting, plots, cinematography, and fight choreography. Their realism has also been highly touted. Perhaps their realism exists because they are informed by a deeper reality: the principles that perfect human beings.
What arts and culture topics would you like us to cover? Please email ideas or feedback to
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UPI
16 hours ago
- UPI
'Breakfast Club' returning to theaters for 40th anniversary
Left to right, Matthew Broderick, Macaulay Culkin, Ally Sheedy, Molly Ringwald, Judd Nelson, Jon Cryer and Anthony Michael Hall appear backstage at the Academy Awards in Hollywood in 2010. The actors, all of whom starred in "Brat Pack" movies, participated in a tribute to director John Hughes. File Photo by Jim Ruymen/UPI | License Photo Aug. 16 (UPI) -- The classic, high-school detention comedy, The Breakfast Club, is returning to theaters in time for the film's 40th anniversary. Starring Molly Ringwald, Emilio Estevez, Anthony Michael Hall, Ally Sheedy and Judd Nelson, the coming of age dramedy from writer-director John Hughes will be back in cinemas nationwide on Sept. 7 and 10. "Over the course of one day, Claire the princess (Molly Ringwald), Andrew the athlete (Emilio Estevez), Brian the brain (Anthony Michael Hall), Allison the basket case (Ally Sheedy) and John the criminal (Judd Nelson) break through their social barriers and reveal the private struggles beneath their public identities," a synopsis from Universal Pictures said. "Under the wary eye of Vice Principal Vernon (Paul Gleason) -- and the side-eye observations of custodian Carl (John Kapelos) -- they begin as strangers and leave with a deeper understanding of themselves and each other."
New York Times
a day ago
- New York Times
‘War Is Too Serious to Take Seriously All the Time,' So He Wrote a Comic Novel
'We go to war because of stories,' said the novelist Elliot Ackerman, who tells stories because he went to war. He was thinking of Vladimir Putin redrafting history to justify Russia's actions in Ukraine. But also of Iraq and Afghanistan, where he served five tours of duty as a Marine and C.I.A. paramilitary officer, awarded a Bronze Star, a Purple Heart and a Silver Star with a citation for 'heroic actions' during the second battle for Falluja in 2004. In his 2019 memoir 'Places and Names,' Ackerman offered eviscerating details underlying that commendation, mindful of the men he had lost, the abandoned allies and missions gone wrong. He chose not to deploy a sixth time. 'You have to declare for yourself a separate peace,' he said recently. The writer that the wars made of him has now taken an unexpectedly comic turn with his new novel, 'Sheepdogs,' published by Knopf on Aug. 5. In two memoirs and seven novels he has been reflective, elegiac, often ruefully nostalgic, at times quietly angry, always sternly principled, and analytical to the point of prophetic about what he considers pernicious developments at home and abroad. Many of his fictional subjects, like the orphaned Afghan boys in 'Green on Blue,' his 2015 debut, have tended to be caught in the roil of warfare and the fallout of ethnic, religious and cultural clashes. 'Sheepdogs' is a gear shift into deceptively rip-roaring caper mode. 'When I get together with guys I served with,' Ackerman said, 'we tell funny stories, even about serious stuff. War is too serious to take seriously all the time, and absurd because it flips norms — like 'Thou shalt not kill' — on their heads. Because I love heist books and buddy comedies, I wanted to tell a story in that register, about the economy that exists around war after it ends.' Ackerman keeps his medals in a bedroom drawer in the Fifth Avenue apartment he shares with his second wife, the novelist and screenwriter Lea Carpenter. (He spends half his time in Washington, D.C., with his daughter and son from his first marriage.) On a sizzling day in July he was sitting in the velvety cool of his Manhattan living room, one large wall covered with a mural-size lithograph of the 1792 storming of the Tuileries Palace, created by Ashley Hicks, a family friend. The French Revolution is one sly subtext to Ackerman's twisty who-stole-it. Disney's 'Robin Hood,' and 'great two-handers' like 'Lethal Weapon,' he said, are two others. (Still, he doesn't want it forgotten that Mel Gibson's Los Angeles police detective in the movie franchise is 'also a suicidal Vietnam vet.') In 'Sheepdogs,' two down-on-their-luck ex-military pals (think Robin Hood and Little John) accept a lucrative assignment from an online source known only as Sheep Dog: to repossess a private jet with a mysterious cargo held hostage on an airstrip in swampy Uganda. Cheese (as in 'Big Cheese Aziz') is a former flying ace with the Afghan Air Force, reduced to working nights at a Texas gas station. His American counterpart, discharged for conduct unbecoming of a member of a C.I.A. division so clandestine it's known only as the Office, goes by Skwerl, because, like a squirrel, he 'could get you anything you needed' and 'because Marines can't spell for [expletive].' Apart from the G.I. Joes and model fighter planes Ackerman single-mindedly collected as a boy, landing in the military scarcely seemed in the cards. He was raised in Los Angeles, Washington D.C. and London, a son of the Wall Street investor Peter Ackerman, a co-founder of FreshDirect and a prominent proponent of international nonviolent conflict resolution. His mother, the novelist Joanne Leedom-Ackerman, has long been active in PEN International. Aimless as a teenager, Ackerman said he found his first sense of meritocratic community and competitive drive among the 'skater rats' of the as-yet-ungentrified South Bank in London. He 'joined R.O.T.C. in college, graduated summa cum laude from Tufts University in 2003, was first in his class at Quantico and, at 24, was among the youngest commissioned officers in charge of a platoon in Iraq. A few years later he traded his Marine Corps body armor for Pashtun mountain garb, working covertly as a paramilitary adviser to Afghan troops battling the Taliban. He remains bitter over 'the catastrophic withdrawal from Afghanistan' in 2021, when, as chronicled in his second memoir, 'The Fifth Act,' he participated long-distance in an effort to evacuate as many Afghan allies as possible from Kabul. Ackerman said he has never been required to vet his writing with the Marine Corps or the C.I.A. This leaves open to conjecture what Langley would make, in 'Sheepdogs,' of Knotty Pleasures, a rope-manufacturing business run by Skwerl's dominatrix girlfriend that is markedly more solvent than his security company; of her excommunicated Amish client's unforeseen skills; or of the White Russian, a female mastermind from the South Bronx with ultimate authority over 'America's off-the-books armies.' The book is being developed as a streaming series by Tom Hanks's production company, and Ackerman is at work on a sequel. Despite its zany elements, 'Sheepdogs' turns somber in its apparent allusions to a disastrous 2008 U.S. military raid on the village of Azizabad that left some 90 civilians dead, including about 60 children. (The Pentagon disputed this figure.) Ackerman, who was the Marine Special Operations Officer in charge of ground operations for the strike, has not spoken publicly about it. Asked about how the attack reverberates in the novel, which locates it in a place called Now Zad, and its psychic toll on Skwerl, he said, 'My fiction is my way of writing about war in its totality, and the degrees of complexity around it, whether in Falluja, Haditha, Helmand Province or Azizabad. 'Now Zad is not a stand-in for Azizabad, no more than Sperkai is in 'Green on Blue,'' he added. 'My job was raids for years, and I saw a lot, some of it good and some of it horrible. All the books I've written engage with that.' He is proud to have served in 2005 as commander of a Marine infantry battalion aiding in relief operations in post-Hurricane Katrina New Orleans. But he feels just as strongly, in view of the ongoing Marine and National Guard presence in cities like Los Angeles and Washington, D.C., that 'sending Federal troops on what increasingly feels like a politically motivated deployment is toxic to our society and to our military.' Ackerman credits his military and intelligence-gathering experiences for his ability to hone his characters psychologically. 'Living inside your characters' heads is like leading a platoon or, in special ops, figuring out what makes your adversaries tick,' he said. He now co-teaches a course at Yale, 'Field Operations in Global Affairs,' with Matt Trevithick, the C.E.O. of Blank Slate Technologies, which works with the defense, aviation and security industries. They became friends at the start of Ackerman's writing career, while Trevithick was a consultant to humanitarian and development organizations in the volatile borderlands of southern Turkey, Syria, Iraq and Iran. 'Sheepdogs' leans more into 'the eccentric and absurdist' than other Ackerman books, Trevithick said, but it's not a complete change of direction. 'Both of us agreed a long time ago that the truest way to write about our complicated experiences was through fiction, which can capture what's true even if the stories aren't,' he added. Or, as Ackerman sees it, 'Times of great upheaval are vital for fiction.'
Forbes
a day ago
- Forbes
‘Nobody 2': What Happens During The End Credits?
The Bob Odenkirk crime comedy Nobody 2 has something going on during the end credits, but does it indicate whether the film will get a sequel? Nobody 2 is the sequel to Odenkirk's crime comedy hit Nobody. In the 2021 film, Odenkirk (Breaking Bad, Better Call Saul) stars as Hutch Mansell, a by-the-numbers working stiff who harbors a secret past as an off-the-books government assassin. After Hutch, his wife, Becca (Connie Nielsen) and kids (Gage Munroe and Paisley Cadorath) are held up in a home invasion, the seemingly mild-mannered office worker begins taking out the bad guys with his particular set of skills, leading him to a massive confrontation with a Russian mobster. Set four years after the events of the original film, Nobody 2 finds Hutch back at work as full-time assassin, mainly because a criminal organization bankrolled the $30 million Hutch needed to pay back the Russian mob after burning their gigantic stash of cash in the 2021 film. Knowing Becca is frustrated by him working all the time, Hutch takes his wife, kids and father (Christopher Lloyd) on a summer getaway to Plummerville, the location of an antiquated theme park where Hutch and his brother Harry (RZA) had their happiest childhood memories. However, when townies at the park mess with Hutch and his family, the undercover hitman snaps, which sets off a chain of events where he will eventually face off against Ladeena (Sharon Stone) — an evil mobster who uses Plummerville as a clearinghouse for her massive bootlegging operation. Note: The next section contains spoiler details from 'Nobody 2.' What Do 'Nobody 2's' End Credits Tell Us? Generally, end-credits and/or post-credits scenes either wrap up loose ends from a scene earlier in the movie or set up a sequel. Nobody 2 has something that occurs during the end credits, but it's not necessarily a scene, but a summation of what happens at Plummerville over the course of the movie. During the film, the Mansell family members share a disposable 35mm camera to take pictures of what they did on their very eventful vacation. At the end of the film, the Mansell family gathers in Hutch and Becca's house around a slide projector and instead of seeing the images from the camera on a screen on a wall, the photos show up alongside the end credits. The photos, however, don't have much to do with the murder and mayhem that happens when Hutch confronts Summerville's villains or Ladeena, but instead show the happy memories that Hutch was hoping for on the vacation. Only the last photo during the end credits pictures the fiery aftermath of Hutch's ultimate battle with Ladeena. There is no post-credits scene in Nobody 2. And while the photos that are shown during the end credits of the film give no indication of whether there will be another Nobody sequel, the odds are in favor of Bob Odenkirk and company if they decide to pursue it. To begin with, it won't take much for Nobody 2 to become profitable, since, according to Variety, it cost $25 million to make before prints and advertising costs, a number that is relatively low for a summer movie release. Perhaps the biggest requirement for any sequel potentially happening is whether what comes before it makes money. The next key is whether Odenkirk wants to do another Nobody movie, and if a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter is any indication, he's up for it. 'I'd do more [Nobody]. I'd love to do more of it, but I don't think I'm going to dig right in,' Odenkirk told THR. 'I have another action film called Normal that's coming out [at the Toronto International Film Festival 2025], so that's already in the can. But, right now, I think I want to do some comedy if they'll let me.' Also starring John Ortiz and Colin Hanks, Nobody 2 is new in theaters nationwide.
