OBGYN: My patients' health and wellbeing will be endangered by NC House bill
Earlier this month, the North Carolina House of Representatives passed House Bill 519, also known as the 'Parents' Medical Bill of Rights.' As a board certified OBGYN who treats minors, I am deeply concerned about the implications of this bill. This legislation, which aims to revise the laws regarding minors' consent to medical treatment and parental access to medical records, poses significant risks to the health and wellbeing of patients across the state.
HB 519 will impede the trust young patients have in their medical providers and therefore undermine the confidentiality of their care. Currently, North Carolina law allows minors to consent to treatment for sexually transmitted infections (STIs), pregnancy, substance abuse, and mental health issues without parental involvement. This provision is crucial for ensuring that young patients feel safe seeking medical help without fear of judgment or repercussions from their parents.
By mandating parental consent for these sensitive treatments, the bill risks deterring minors from seeking necessary medical care. This could lead to untreated STIs (which can lead to future infertility), unaddressed mental health issues, and unintended pregnancies, all of which have serious long-term consequences for our young North Carolinians' health and wellbeing.
The trust between patients and healthcare providers is foundational to effective medical care. Confidentiality is a cornerstone of this trust, particularly for minors who may be navigating complex and sensitive health issues. HB 519 threatens to erode this trust by introducing parental oversight into the patient-provider relationship. Healthcare providers may find themselves in difficult positions, having to balance the legal requirements of HB 519 with our ethical duty to protect patient confidentiality.
Advocates for HB 519 argue that the exclusion of parental consent in our current laws leaves children to navigate serious medical situations alone. This perspective completely ignores the role that healthcare providers like myself play in the navigation of these issues. We do not leave our young patients 'alone' to navigate their medical decisions, but instead provide thoughtful guidance, including often suggesting the involvement of their parent(s) in their medical care. Unfortunately, for some of my young patients, their medical team members are the only trusted adults in their lives, and if they are required to obtain parental consent to seek treatment, they simply will not do so.
House Bill 519, while ostensibly aimed at empowering parents, poses significant risks to the health and wellbeing of minors in North Carolina. By undermining confidentiality, creating barriers to mental health and reproductive care, and hindering substance abuse treatment, the bill jeopardizes the autonomy and safety of young patients. As a physician who treats young patients, I urge the lawmakers to reconsider the implications of HB 519 and prioritize the health and rights of minors in our state.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
01-08-2025
- Chicago Tribune
Afternoon Briefing: Illinois schools to offer mental health screenings
Good afternoon, Chicago. Another Chicago hospital has ended gender-affirming pediatric surgery amid threats to its federal funding. But Illinois and 15 other states are fighting back in a federal lawsuit against the Trump administration for 'intimidating providers' into denying such care. UI Health became the latest hospital today to suspend gender-affirming surgical procedures for adolescents effective immediately, according to an announcement posted on the hospital's website. Here's what else is happening today. And remember, for the latest breaking news in Chicago, visit and sign up to get our alerts on all your devices. Subscribe to more newsletters | Asking Eric | Horoscopes | Puzzles & Games | Today in History The bill, SB 1560, requires all Illinois public schools to offer third through 12th grade students a free, optional mental health screening. The bill passed the Illinois House of Representatives on May 21, and the Senate a month earlier. Read more here. More top news stories: Craving a late night slider? Forget the 'Harold & Kumar' road trip quest and let a robot deliver White Castle to your door. Read more here. More top business stories: The Friendly Confines will host the Midsummer Classic for the first time since 1990, marking the fourth time in the ballpark's history. Read more here. More top sports stories: For singer-songwriter Tucker Pillsbury, who performs as Role Model, playing Lollapalooza isn't new. His performance yesterday marked his third appearance at the festival, with the first two taking place in 2022 and 2019 when he was known for his alternative bedroom pop music. Read more here. More top Eat. Watch. Do. stories: The agency responsible for carrying out President Donald Trump's mass deportations agenda says it has made tentative job offers to more than 1,000 people as it ramps up hiring following the passage of legislation earlier this month giving the agency a massive infusion of cash. Read more here. More top stories from around the world:
Axios
31-07-2025
- Axios
A majority of North Carolinians oppose cutting federal funding for research, poll finds
Nearly 60% of North Carolinians oppose large-scale federal funding cuts to medical research, a new survey has found. Why it matters: The Trump administration has proposed sweeping cuts to federal research funding, including $20 billion from the National Institutes of Health. That could have significant ramifications in North Carolina, where Duke University and UNC-Chapel Hill are among the largest recipients of research funding from the NIH. Already, the Trump administration has tried to change how the federal government covers indirect costs for research, which could lead to large funding decreases in the Triangle. However, that decision has been stopped in the courts. Between the lines: The poll was commissioned by United for Cures, a group backed by UsAgainstAlzheimer's, which opposes the Trump administration's cuts to the NIH. The poll was conducted by the firm Public Opinion Strategies, which surveyed 500 registered voters in North Carolina between June 23-26. Zoom in: Of the survey respondents who said they oppose cutting medical research, 48% said they strongly opposed it, according to Public Opinion Strategies. A large majority of those opposed to the cuts say they are worried about research being cut for cancer treatments and prevention. Many of the respondents said the cuts could affect how they vote, with 56% saying they would be less likely to vote for a member of Congress who voted for the cuts. Among self-described moderate voters, that share reaches 63%. On the other side, 33% of respondents said they favored cutting funding for medical research, and 25% said they would be more likely to vote for a member of Congress who voted for the cuts.
The Hill
31-07-2025
- The Hill
Cooper's North Carolina Senate bid will put Medicaid front and center
Democrats are hoping health care will be a winning issue across the 2026 midterm elections and see North Carolina as the top potential pickup opportunity in their long-shot play to regain control of the Senate. They think Cooper's record as governor — working with and pressuring the GOP-dominated Legislature across two terms until he could expand Medicaid — makes him the perfect messenger. In his campaign launch video, Cooper previewed what will likely be a common line of attack. He accused Republicans of 'ripping away our health care' and threatening Medicare and Social Security 'just to give tax breaks to billionaires.' In his first television interview after announcing his candidacy, Cooper made it clear he wants to focus on Medicaid and affordability. 'We expanded health care to more than 670,000 North Carolinians. We were able to put a plan in place that helps address the high cost of living for North Carolinians by eliminating $4 billion in medical debt for 2 million North Carolinians,' Cooper told Rachel Maddow. 'We knew we had accomplished something, getting health insurance to people who had never had it before. Now, Washington Republicans are going to strip it away. I think that is such a contrast in this race,' he added. Health care looms over the race — likely between Cooper and Republican National Committee Chair Michael Whatley, who has President Trump's endorsement — in part because incumbent Sen. Thom Tillis (R) is not running. Tillis said he would retire rather than vote for Trump's massive tax cut and spending legislation. He called the legislation 'devastating' and was one of only three Republicans to vote against the bill after saying it would 'betray the very promise' Trump made about not touching Medicaid. The legislation is projected to push about 10 million low-income people off their health insurance over the next decade. Health policy research group KFF estimates 520,000 North Carolinians will lose their health insurance because of proposed changes to Medicaid and ObamaCare exchange health plans, and if enhanced subsidies expire at the end of 2025. Brad Woodhouse, a longtime Democratic strategist and president of the advocacy group Protect Our Care, said Cooper is going to spend the next year linking Whatley to the GOP Medicaid cuts. 'I don't know what positions Michael Whatley is going to take. He's a blank slate … but what he is tied to, it's Trump. And these cuts are Trump's, this health care disaster is Trump's. Michael Whatley can't separate himself from Trump,' Woodhouse said. When he first ran for governor in 2016, Cooper said he wanted expand Medicaid and help low-income residents afford health care. But he faced strong opposition from the GOP-controlled Legislature. Legislation finally passed in March 2023, spurred by a growing chorus of Republican support and the promise of more than $1.5 billion in additional federal money for the state. Health care resonates with voters across the political spectrum, and Cooper is likely to tout his ability to work across the aisle, which experts said is something that helped him consistently win in North Carolina even when Trump was on the ticket. 'Cooper is going to focus on where he knows best, and he's got the track record of six statewide elections under his belt to know how to best frame and message a campaign to North Carolinians,' said Michael Bitzer, a professor of politics and history at Catawba College. 'I think the argument that he will make is, 'We worked together across political aisles to get Medicaid expanded, and now Washington Republicans are cutting just about the same number as we expanded,'' Bitzer said. Yet in trying to tie Whatley to the 'big, beautiful' law, Cooper is going to face the same issue as Democrats nationwide: Most of the cuts in the law are back-loaded and won't take effect until well after the midterm elections. 'Clearly, he's going to bring up [Medicaid]. The problem is people aren't going to feel this until after the election takes place. So the trick for Cooper is going to be to remind people of how beneficial Medicaid expansion has been and get them to believe him about how bad it's going to be,' said Chris Cooper, a Western Carolina University politics professor. It's not clear Republicans will want to engage the former governor on Medicaid directly, and Bitzer said they have their own list of attacks. Federal campaigns often center on much more partisan issues than statewide elections, and Republicans have already started attacking Cooper as a radical liberal.
