All-Ireland football group stage draw proves format is a failure – it's unnecessary distraction for provincial finalists
THE only good thing about the draw for the All-Ireland SFC group stages being made this week was it served as a reminder that this is the final edition of this failure of a format.
While there are logistical reasons for having the Championship mapped out this far in advance, the draw is an unnecessary distraction for the provincial finalists.
1
Graham Geraghty slammed the current All-Ireland SFC format
Credit: Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile
A revamped system will be in place in 2026, yet the method of separating the Sam Maguire counties from their Tailteann Cup counterparts is to remain the same.
And the flaws of linking it to the provincial competitions have been exposed again this year.
This should not be interpreted as any form of criticism of Clare, for they merely capitalised on the opportunity presented to them like any other team would be happy to do.
But the fact that a win against Tipperary, a Division 4 outfit, was all the Banner needed to secure their place in the All-Ireland series is a joke.
Read More on GAA
Antrim got the better of Clare when the teams met in Division 3 of the National League earlier this season.
But for Andy McEntee's side to compete in the Sam Maguire, victories over Tyrone and All-Ireland champions Armagh would have been required, as well as beating Cavan.
To reach the same destination, Antrim were tasked with surviving shark-infested waters but Clare barely got their feet wet crossing a stream.
As long as they persist with a two-tier Championship, the GAA have to find a way of levelling the playing field for teams with ambitions of being in with the big boys
Most read in Sport
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
40 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Luxembourg v Ireland: Killian Phillips makes first start for Boys In Green
Live | Ireland take on Luxembourg in an international friendly with kick off at 7.45pm. Ben Blake brings you all the action. 5 minutes ago Happy hunting ground The last time Ireland played at the Stade de Luxembourg, back in November 2021, they enjoyed a 3-0 win under Stephen Kenny thanks to goals from Shane Duffy, Chiedozie Ogbene and Callum Robinson. Ireland had gone down 1-0 when the sides met in Dublin earlier that year. 7 minutes ago Five players could make their senior debuts The late call-up for Stoke City midfielder Bosun Lawal means he joins Max O'Leary, Josh Keeley, John Joe Patrick Finn and Josh Honohan as the uncapped Irish players in tonight's squad. While 28-year-old O'Leary starts to make his international bow, the other four have been named on the bench. 14 minutes ago Daniel McDonnell looks ahead to this evening's game 'What Ireland are trying to do is establish their own identity and, while the Icelander does not want basketball matches in the autumn, it's clear he wants big men in his side that might be comfortable on a court,' writes Dan. Ireland v Luxembourg preview: Heimir Hallgrimsson wants his big men to stand up and be counted For all the talk of an Irish upturn, watching Portugal claim Nations League glory on Sunday served as a reminder of the heights Heimir Hallgrimsson's side will need to reach if they are to participate in the World Cup qualification discussion. 15 minutes ago Good evening and welcome along. Heimir Hallgrimsson's men are at the Stade de Luxembourg for the second international friendly of this summer window. Having been denied a confidence-boosting win against one of Africa's top sides Senegal, albeit their second string, by Ismaila Sarr's late equaliser at the Aviva Stadium on Friday night, the Boys in Green take on a nation sitting 31 places below them in the Fifa rankings. A condensed campaign of World Cup qualifiers is set to begin in September, when Hungary and recently-crowned Nations League champions Portugal will undoubtedly provide much stiffer tests. However, Icelander Hallgrimsson – who celebrates his 58th birthday today – will be hoping to continue the small signs of progress with a victory and performance to match it here. Scheduled to kick off at 7.45pm, the game is being shown live on RTÉ 2 and we will be following events closely on the Irish Independent. Live Blog Software
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Leaving Cert student diary: ‘Biology isn't my strongest subject - but that was a lovely paper'
Do as much as possible in as little time as I can: that's been my motto for the past few weeks. I really pulled the socks up to get these exams over the line. So far, the exams have been good. I enjoyed the first English paper, though the second was trickier. Same with maths: a good paper one followed by a more difficult paper two. Irish was good, and I liked the essay titles which were broad and easy to expand on, although I found the listening comprehension more challenging than previous years. And biology, not my strongest subject, was such a lovely paper today, and definitely the most accessible in years. READ MORE I hope to study athletic and rehabilitation at TUS (Technological University of the Shannon), and this degree would allow me to move into a masters in physiotherapy. I've considered studying abroad, as the Netherlands offers a similar course and it would be delivered through English. But I think I'd prefer to stay here – I'm from the area, TUS is a good university, and I could keep up my part-time job in the local Dunnes Stores. I love sports and I play for the Garrycastle GAA club, so I could keep that up if I stay local. Of course, the cost of living away from home is huge, and accommodation is so hard to find, so being at home would be so much more affordable. I'm doing all higher-level subjects, except for maths. I'm already at a disadvantage. At the start of fifth year, I did higher-level maths because I wanted the chance to get those 25 bonus points. But I quickly realised that I would have to neglect my other subjects, especially the ones that I'm strong in. It wasn't an easy decision to automatically drop to ordinary level and be 25 points down – just because I have strengths other than maths. I ultimately decided it made more sense to focus on the subjects I actually liked, but I know that so many do higher-level maths, struggle with it and fall behind in their other subjects. I just don't understand who this system serves. Still to come: Spanish, agricultural science and construction studies. For those last two, I've already done a significant chunk through project work. Nearly there. I'm aiming for as high as I can get – then it's time to put the feet up, relax and go on our Leaving Cert Albufeira trip. – Killian Keegan is a Leaving Cert student at Athlone Community College
The 42
an hour ago
- The 42
August All-Ireland senior finals could make a return in 2027
GAA PRESIDENT JARLATH Burns has revealed August All-Ireland finals could be back in place for the 2027 season. The timing of the showpiece games in the inter-county championship has sparked heated debate with successive weekends in July currently used. Burns, speaking today at Offaly's GAA training centre 'The Faithful Fields' in Kilcormac, outlined how August All-Ireland finals may return in two years time. 'We have an amateur organisation that is also working alongside Croke Park, which is a commercial organisation. Croke Park operates with regard to its priorities and how it does its business, a year in advance. So, already, August 2026 is taken up. 'That puts August 2027 into the mix. I'm around the country all the time, in clubs and counties every single day of the week, and the thing that I get most debate on are the timings of the All-Ireland finals. 'And there is a school of thought that is saying that first and third weeks in August, leave everything as it is and just have a bigger space between the semi-finals and the finals, three weeks instead of two weeks. GAA President Jarlath Burns. Leah Scholes / INPHO Leah Scholes / INPHO / INPHO 'That means then that there's only the two teams that are being affected. The disadvantage of that is that you're into the bank holiday weekend, and that can create difficulty as well. 'You might have heard me saying that this isn't going to happen during my presidency. The decision might be made during my presidency, but it might not actually occur during my presidency. But I am certainly open to first and third weeks in August from 2027 on. 'At the end of the day, we are a games organisation. We also have to factor in replays. We have to factor in camogie and LGFA, and replays for those as well. So Croke Park could be very, very busy in that month of August. But that's great. The more games we can have in it, the better.' Advertisement Armagh's Aidan Forker and John Maher of Galway in action in last year's All-Ireland senior football final. Bryan Keane / INPHO Bryan Keane / INPHO / INPHO Clare's Diarmuid Ryan and Seamus Harnedy of Cork in action in last year's All-Ireland senior hurling final. Bryan Keane / INPHO Bryan Keane / INPHO / INPHO With concerts already likely to be booked in for August 2026, a shift in timing of the All-Ireland finals in 2027 would create a window earlier in the summer for the stadium to be used for such events. 'One of the jobs you get when you're President of the GAA, you're chair of the Croke Park board so you get to understand the cycle of touring acts and it would have been perfect for them to finish their tour in Ireland and then go on maybe to Australia or wherever for it going into the summer. 'Now it might be to start the tour in Ireland and that's doable. You know, everybody wants to play in Croke Park. That's one thing. All of the biggest acts in the world, they do want to play in Croke Park.' In the wake of last Saturday's dramatic Munster final, the debate has surfaced as to whether a replay would have been a fairer solution. Burns would be in favour of replays if there was sufficient room in the calendar. 'You don't have to talk to me above anybody else about replays and provincial finals. We've lost three now (and) two quarter-finals, on penalties. I would be very much in favour of replays where at all possible.' 'At the end of this championship, because it's a three-year phase, we're going to review all aspects of it. I agree with the split-season for all of the reasons that I've given before, but I definitely think that any review should consider the possibility of replays, particularly in provincial finals. Limerick's Cian Lynch and William O'Donoghue dejected after the game last Saturday. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO 'I just think that was such a game of drama, it was just a pity the way it ended. The Armagh-Donegal game could have gone the same way for the third year in a row, so I'm totally in favour of replays.' The GAA President admitted the preliminary hurling quarter-finals are a barrier to faciltating replays in the current schedule. 'We did bring a motion to Congress this year. Ironically, it was Munster GAA who stymied it. For good reason as well, because they know that they have it very tight with the preliminary quarter-finals. 'Those mean a lot to the counties that are in them. Every time CCCC have gone to Ard Chomhairle to try and end the preliminary quarter-finals, the counties themselves who would be in that position have always come back and said, 'No, this preliminary quarter-final means an awful lot to our team and our county, and we want to keep it.' 'If you do away with the preliminary quarter-finals, there are advantages to that because you could stretch out the Joe McDonagh Cup and you could make that a longer competition. 'But because they have to be ready for the preliminary quarter-finals, you end up then with all of those Joe McDonagh counties ending at the same date as the Leinster final. There are lots of considerations there but certainly I'd be open to doing whatever has to be done to get replays in for provincial finals.' Burns was also asked for his views on penalty shootouts being employed to deliver a winner in championship ties. Cork goalkeeper Patrick Collins saves a penalty during last Saturday's shootout. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO 'That's what's in rule and that's what we have at the moment. It's not too often that you have penalties in a hurling match for obvious reasons. There are many people who say it adds to the drama as well, and that it can assist in the narrative of the game, that there was a winner on the day, there was a cup presented. 'Whenever we used to have replays, people gave off to the GAA that we were just doing it for the financial gain. And remember, the 83 per cent goes back. We need every penny we can get for all those good reasons. And now we have stopped replays to allow for the club season. We're getting, not criticism, but debate over it. 'So there are all of these points that you have to consider. The GAA do not take these decisions lightly. They are all voted on. We're a very democratic organisation and if people want to change it, we'll be in favour of that.' No decision has yet been made on the International Rules returning laser this year with suggestions of games in Croke Park and SuperValu Páirc Uí Chaoimh. 'We haven't really made any decision on that,' stated Burns. 'We have a Management meeting on Friday night and that's on the agenda. We have to be mindful of lots of things because that's coming in the middle of a closed season, which we are very protective about and that's why we did away with the pre-season competitions last year because we wanted our county players to have a genuine closed season. If we are going to start now with International Rules at that time, we know that that would compromise that principle that we have brought in, giving our players that rest period. So it's something that we have to do a little bit deeper thinking on, to be honest, before we make an actual decision on it. Personally, I would love to see the International Rules back, the players would love to see it back, but we have to be very careful about the consequences of bringing it back.
