All-Ireland football group stage draw proves format is a failure – it's unnecessary distraction for provincial finalists
THE only good thing about the draw for the All-Ireland SFC group stages being made this week was it served as a reminder that this is the final edition of this failure of a format.
While there are logistical reasons for having the Championship mapped out this far in advance, the draw is an unnecessary distraction for the provincial finalists.
1
Graham Geraghty slammed the current All-Ireland SFC format
Credit: Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile
A revamped system will be in place in 2026, yet the method of separating the Sam Maguire counties from their Tailteann Cup counterparts is to remain the same.
And the flaws of linking it to the provincial competitions have been exposed again this year.
This should not be interpreted as any form of criticism of Clare, for they merely capitalised on the opportunity presented to them like any other team would be happy to do.
But the fact that a win against Tipperary, a Division 4 outfit, was all the Banner needed to secure their place in the All-Ireland series is a joke.
Read More on GAA
Antrim got the better of Clare when the teams met in Division 3 of the National League earlier this season.
But for Andy McEntee's side to compete in the Sam Maguire, victories over Tyrone and All-Ireland champions Armagh would have been required, as well as beating Cavan.
To reach the same destination, Antrim were tasked with surviving shark-infested waters but Clare barely got their feet wet crossing a stream.
As long as they persist with a two-tier Championship, the GAA have to find a way of levelling the playing field for teams with ambitions of being in with the big boys
Most read in Sport
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
39 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Indo GAA podcast: Football – Micko, jerseys and foreign trips Galway should be mad to tear into Armagh
Today at 08:37 Pat Spillane and Dick Clerkin join Michael Verney this week, and before we preview the last week of the All-Ireland group stages, Dick's old jerseys sends us down memory lane - Pat especially with all the ways Mick O'Dwyer used to raise funds for the Kerry team holidays. On the field, Dessie Farrell and Pádraic Joyce are under serious pressure as the group stages will claim their victims from this year's championship. Our GAA Podcast coverage is with thanks to AIB. We'd love to get your thoughts on your overall listening experience, it only takes a minute, and your feedback helps us keep improving what we do. Plus, when you take part, you'll be in with a chance to win a €500 One4All Voucher. Just head to and enter GAA.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Katie McCabe left out of Irish squad for United States friendlies
As she hinted she would last week, Carla Ward has left captain Katie McCabe out of her Ireland squad for two friendlies against the United States in Denver and Cincinnati later this month. Aoife Mannion will also miss the trip, but there are recalls for Wexford's Ellen Molloy and Crystal Palace's Hayley Nolan, neither having featured in a Ward squad before. Heather Payne, Leanne Kiernan, Tara O'Hanlon, Jamie Finn, Lily Agg and Jess Ziu are all still recovering from varying degrees of injury, so were not considered, while Shelbourne's Aoibheann Clancy is absent due to a family bereavement. Ward had described McCabe as being 'on the verge of burnout' after a gruelling season with Arsenal, which ran all the way to the end of May with their Champions League victory over Barcelona. She is, then, excused from duty this time around, as is Manchester United's Mannion whose injury record means her workload has to be carefully managed. Nolan won all three of her caps during Vera Pauw's time in charge but after being included in Eileen Gleeson's first three squads she has been overlooked since . She missed the first half of Palace's season, which ended in relegation from the WSL, with a shoulder injury she picked up in pre-season, but was an ever-present for them in defence on her return. READ MORE Molloy also made her senior debut under Pauw, as a 16-year-old back in 2020, but an ACL injury interrupted her progress. She had a brief spell with Sheffield United in the English Championship before returning to Wexford in January, her form since outstanding. Ellen Molloy scoring for Sheffield United against Birmingham City back in October. Photograph:Izzy Atkinson has also been included, a day after she was released by Palace. She is one of three 'unattached' players in the squad, along with goalkeeper Grace Moloney and defender Megan Campbell. Even with a full squad, these games would have been formidable enough prospects, the States top of the world rankings. The nations last met in an April 2023 double-header in Austin and St Louis, when Pauw was Irish manager, Ireland losing 2-0 and 1-0. US head coach Emma Hayes is a close friend of Ward who likened the former Chelsea manager to 'a big sister' who has offered her support and guidance throughout her coaching career. After Ward left the Aston Villa job a year ago, Hayes added her to the States' backroom team for the Olympic Games, where they won gold, Ward working for her as a scout analysing opponents. 'These games are an opportunity for us to work together on a number of things – both on and off the pitch – as we build towards the Nations League play-off against Belgium in October,' said Ward. 'We will be coming up against the best team in women's football, so we will have a plan for those games but it's also important that we make the most out of this camp as a whole.' 'When these games were first proposed to us we knew that we would be without certain players, but that opens the door for others to step up. We are building, camp by camp, so we are looking forward to getting together again and putting in some extra work that will stand to us moving forward.' These are Ireland's last scheduled fixtures before they take on Belgium in September, Ward's side having finished runners-up to Slovenia in their group. Ireland squad : Courtney Brosnan (Everton), Grace Moloney (unattached), Sophie Whitehouse (Charlton Athletic); Jessie Stapleton (West Ham), Anna Patten (Aston Villa), Caitlin Hayes (Brighton), Hayley Nolan (Crystal Palace), Chloe Mustaki (Bristol City), Megan Campbell (unattached); Denise O'Sullivan (North Carolina Courage), Megan Connolly (Lazio), Tyler Toland (Blackburn Rovers), Ruesha Littlejohn (Shamrock Rovers), Marissa Sheva (Sunderland), Ellen Molloy (Wexford); Kyra Carusa (San Diego Wave), Abbie Larkin (Crystal Palace), Amber Barrett (Standard Liege), Lucy Quinn (Birmingham City), Emily Murphy (Newcastle United), Saoirse Noonan (Celtic), Erin Healy (Adelaide United), Izzy Atkinson (unattached). Ireland fixtures Thursday, June 26th USA v Ireland Commerce City, Colorado, 2am Irish time (RTÉ Player) Sunday, June 29th USA v Ireland, Cincinnati, 8pm Irish time (RTÉ2/RTÉ Player)
The Journal
2 hours ago
- The Journal
Have you ever played hurling or camogie?
AFTER A WEEKEND spent at Croke Park where The 42FM's Sinéad O'Carroll watched her beloved Kildare hurlers win the Joe McDonagh cup, herself and Gavin Cooney discussed the GAA's failure to grow hurling across the country on this week's podcast. As they dissected Kildare's rise to compete among Leinster's elite in the Liam McCarthy Cup next year, they asked why hurling is a minority sport and how the GAA is attempting to make it right. So today we're asking you: Have you ever played hurling or camogie? Poll Results: Yes (275) No (207) Only in school (68) Yes No Only in school Vote
