All-Ireland football group stage draw proves format is a failure – it's unnecessary distraction for provincial finalists
THE only good thing about the draw for the All-Ireland SFC group stages being made this week was it served as a reminder that this is the final edition of this failure of a format.
While there are logistical reasons for having the Championship mapped out this far in advance, the draw is an unnecessary distraction for the provincial finalists.
1
Graham Geraghty slammed the current All-Ireland SFC format
Credit: Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile
A revamped system will be in place in 2026, yet the method of separating the Sam Maguire counties from their Tailteann Cup counterparts is to remain the same.
And the flaws of linking it to the provincial competitions have been exposed again this year.
This should not be interpreted as any form of criticism of Clare, for they merely capitalised on the opportunity presented to them like any other team would be happy to do.
But the fact that a win against Tipperary, a Division 4 outfit, was all the Banner needed to secure their place in the All-Ireland series is a joke.
Read More on GAA
Antrim got the better of Clare when the teams met in Division 3 of the National League earlier this season.
But for Andy McEntee's side to compete in the Sam Maguire, victories over Tyrone and All-Ireland champions Armagh would have been required, as well as beating Cavan.
To reach the same destination, Antrim were tasked with surviving shark-infested waters but Clare barely got their feet wet crossing a stream.
As long as they persist with a two-tier Championship, the GAA have to find a way of levelling the playing field for teams with ambitions of being in with the big boys
Most read in Sport
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Leaving Cert Irish paper two: Sighs of relief as predicted topics make for approachable exam
Well-chosen questions and the appearance of predicted topics on the higher level Irish paper two made for an accessible exam, teachers have said. 'The paper would no doubt have been well-received by the students,' said Stephen Doyle, subject expert and an Irish teacher at Moyle Park College in Dublin. 'The two reading comprehensions were well chosen – the first text focused on Rory Gallagher and music while the second passage about sport in Ireland was very relevant and easy to relate to,' Mr Doyle said. 'Both were very manageable. The grammar threw up no surprises while the 6B questions were a bit more specific than in previous years.' READ MORE Danielle O'Connell, an Irish teacher with , said that 6B posed the biggest challenge in an otherwise mostly accessible, manageable and fair paper. 'Section 6A followed a familiar pattern, with the grammar components proving predictable and well within students' expectations,' she said. 'However, Section 6B presented a more complex challenge, echoing a trend seen in recent years. Candidates were asked to respond to the prompt: 'Tabhair dhá phointe eolais, i d'fIocail féin, as an sliocht a léiríonn fírinne an ráitis sin' (Give two points of information, in your own words, from the passage that show the truth of this statement), which may have required additional interpretation.' In the prose section, students were relieved to see the long-awaited Hurlamaboc appear. 'Students were expecting it last year but it didn't appear; thankfully this year it did,' said Mr Doyle. 'Students had an option between Hurlamaboc and Oisín I dTír na nÓg with the questions being very straightforward with no surprises.' Nuala Úi Cheallaigh, an Irish teacher at the Institute of Education, said that it was a 'lovely continuation of previous papers with broad questions that allowed students to adapt their material.' In the poetry section, Ms Úi Cheallaigh said that both 'Colscaradh' and 'An Scailpín Fánach' were both highly anticipated. 'The questions were in line with previous years, but students looking to optimise their marks in this section would need to be attuned to the effects of the techniques asked in the middle question,' she said. The litriocht bhreise section also offered broad and approachable questions, said Ms Úi Cheallaigh. 'Those who prepared An Triail will have ample choice of material in exploring the women's failure to understand Máire's circumstances, with at least three key characters jumping to mind. 'Those doing A Thig Ná Tit Orm would have needed to focus on the specific positive moments of the author's recollections but will also have several moments to explore the requisite joy and shenanigans,' said Ms Úi Cheallaigh. 'Overall, this paper allowed students to demonstrate their work and grasp of the material in a very fair and open way. 'The real challenge will be the exam discipline necessary to make the most effective use of the tight timing by selecting and editing what to cover and what to exclude,' said Ms Úi Cheallaigh. Ordinary level On the ordinary level paper, Mr Doyle said that it was student-friendly and covered the basics well. 'The reading comprehensions focused on the Olympics and the Phoenix Park (nature), topics that were accessible and relatable for students. The prose section offered a choice between 'Dís', 'Oisín I dTír na nÓg' and 'Hurlamaboc' which was expected and gave students good options,' he said. 'The poetry section included 'Mo Ghrá-sa','An tEarrach Thiar' and 'Colscaradh' with straightforward questions that tested students' understanding of the main themes and content. 'There were no surprise questions. Overall, this paper provided ordinary level students with plenty of opportunities to demonstrate their knowledge successfully.' Try this one at home: -Leaving Cert Irish paper 2, Q2(a) (a) Freagair an cheist thíos ar an ngiota as an úrscéal Hurlamaboc. 'Tugtar léiriú dúinn sa ghiota as an úrscéal Hurlamaboc ar Lisín, bean a bhfuil go leor cúiseanna ceiliúrtha aici agus nach mbíonn riamh díomhaoin.' Déan plé ar an ráiteas sin.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
GAA fans ‘loved seeing and hearing' the late Micheal O Muircheartaigh as he features in RTE documentary Hell for Leather
GAA documentary series 'Hell for Leather' premiered last night on RTE and featured huge GAA stars. The documentary, which can be streamed on the Advertisement 2 The GAA community has truly missed the Kerryman and his iconic commentary 2 There was delight throughout the country as Ó Muircheartaigh took to our screens again Credit: RTE ONE Fans were particularly delighted to see the great Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh who The legendary commentator shared his insight into the origins of the sport of Gaelic Football in the first episode of the documentary series. He explained what Caid was in the documentary which is believed to be the building blocks of Gaelic football. He said: "Kerry had a game of it's own going way back. This is hundreds of years ago. All you needed was a Caid, a pig's bladder. Advertisement Read more on GAA "There was no control of the numbers that would be involved. "Played on open territories. Parishes would meet in the centre, and then the game would start "It was a hard game, there was no real strict rules." Fans took to social media to praise the first episode of the documentary series. Advertisement Most read in GAA Football Exclusive One fan said: "Loved seeing and listening to Micheál Ó Muircheartaigh once more on this Hell For Leather documentary" Former Down and Kilcoo captain Darragh O'Hanlon simply put: "Hell for Leather what a show." Brendan Cummins defends time-keeping in Munster GAA hurling final between Cork and Limerick Sports journalist Daniel Hussey said: "Excellent first episode of Hell For Leather. Well worth a watch back on RTÉ Player." The documentary series took seven years to reach the screens as it began production as the natural successor to hurling series The Game in 2018. Advertisement The series was unfortunately delayed due to Covid, an All-Ireland final played during a lockdown and the consequences for sport, film-making and life in general during that time. The project was part funded by Coimisiún na Meán, the Department of Finance, the Gaelic Athletic Association and sponsors Collen. The series featured stars such as Brian Fenton, Colm Cooper, David Clifford and Cora Staunton. But fans were most excited to hear legend of the game Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh. The Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh Cup was unveiled Advertisement The Cup is to be given to the winners of the Allianz Football League Division 1 Final. It was unveiled in the build up to the Fittingly, Kerry were crowned champions and captain Gavin White was the first to lift the Mícheál Ó Muircheartaigh Cup at Croke Park.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ireland get together in Luxembourg for one last job
You'd imagine that, at this stage of the year, Heimir Hallgrímsson's men are dreaming of lying on a beach somewhere and resting their weary bones after an interminable club and international season. Before they get to do that, though, they have a friendly away to Luxembourg to contend with, Gavin Cummiskey previewing this evening's game. And he hears from Irish captain Nathan Collins who is likely to have a new gaffer when he returns to Brentford , Thomas Frank on the verge of taking over from Ange Postecoglou at Spurs. James McDermott traces the development of football in Luxembourg , optimism rising there over their chances of qualifying for their first ever major tournament. In Luc Holtz, they have the second-longest-serving national coach in Europe, but he's been embroiled in no end of controversy after naming Gerson Rodrigues in his squad - Rodrigues is currently serving an 18-month suspended sentence after being found guilty of assaulting his former girlfriend. In Gaelic games, that penalty shoot-out in the Munster hurling final brought back some memories for Conor McManus , not least of the one that decided Monaghan's All Ireland quarter-final against Armagh two years ago. Happy memories, too - McManus scored twice. Our GAA crew pick out five things they learned from the weekend , Denis Walsh writing about how the character of the Munster final 'changed noticeably' when referee James Owens took over from Thomas Walsh after the latter suffered from cramp. Gordon Manning addresses the same matter, and asks what exactly we want from our officials ? Let the game flow, or clamp down on every infringement? READ MORE In rugby, Gerry Thornley looks ahead to the URC final between Leinster and the Bulls , Leinster badly in need of a win to wrap up a frustrating season. While Sam Prendergast 'might have left his kicking boots at home last weekend against Glasgow', Johnny Watterson hears Tyler Bleyendaal salute the young outhalf who, he says, has become 'one of the game drivers' in the Leinster squad. Owen Doyle, meanwhile, was left 'perplexed' by URC chief executive Martin Anayi's response to Jaden Hendrikse's 'cramp and wink' carry-on against Munster. ' Incredibly, he did not condemn the gamesmanship ,' instead insisting that the game needs 'characters'. If this behaviour catches on, says Owen, we will see it 'spread like slurry' in the game. In golf, Philip Reid is over at Oakmont Country Club for the build-up to the US Open, Dustin Johnson the last winner of the tournament when it was staged at the Pennsylvania course. Much has changed in the world of golf since then , Johnson among those who 'jumped ship for a bottomless pit of greenbacks' on the LIV tour. And in racing, Brian O'Connor brings news that Ireland's champion jockey Colin Keane has secured one of racing's most prized jobs after he was appointed as the number one in Europe to Juddmonte. 'It opens the way for the Meath jockey to take his career to the next level on the world stage.' TV Watch: RTÉ 2 has live coverage this evening of the Republic of Ireland's friendly away to Luxembourg (7.45), and at the same time on ITV, England play Senegal, who drew in Dublin last Friday.
