Swinney apology to Gypsy Travellers ‘significant milestone', campaigner says
Roseanna McPhee welcomed the apology, which she said was the result of years of campaigning.
John Swinney made the formal apology at Holyrood on Thursday over 'unfair and unjust policies' that caused 'trauma' in what was known as the 'tinker experiment'.
Between 1940 and 1980, the so-called experiment – supported by councils and the UK Government – attempted to strip away the nomadic lifestyle of Gypsy Travellers, providing rudimentary and often cramped huts for people to live in.
First Minister Scotland John Swinney issued a formal apology over 'unacceptable' policies against Gypsy Travellers (Jane Barlow/PA)
A report published by the Scottish Government stated that 'the context within which the TE (tinker experiment) occurred is best understood as cultural genocide'.
Ms McPhee, whose family was among those settled in Pitlochry on the former Bobbin Mill site, had grown up in a prefabricated Second World War-style Nissen hut which had no electricity and used candles for light.
She welcomed the First Minister's apology, but said more needed to be done to stop the discrimination that her community continues to face.
First Minister @JohnSwinney has apologised in @ScotParl for historical policies affecting Gypsy/Traveller communities, acknowledging they were unacceptable and caused enduring harm.
More information here: https://t.co/hG5NqF1Br8 pic.twitter.com/B84NTjpmPn
— Scot Gov Fairer (@ScotGovFairer) June 25, 2025
She told the PA news agency: 'It's a milestone that we have reached in our long, long campaign, with no resources and just two or three generals and few food soldiers, really, because most people want to hide.
'I think the fact we managed to achieve that apology from the Government is a significant milestone.
'We're hopeful that discussions shall move forward, and perhaps something may be done about the general level of racism which we suffer, particularly in relation to public bodies.'
Gypsy Traveller campaigner Roseanna McPhee welcomed the First Minister's apology (Craig Meighan/PA)
Ms McPhee said the apology could have been 'more robust' and expressed disappointment that Mr Swinney did not label the Tinker Experiment as 'cultural genocide', the description used in the report published by the Government.
'Cultural genocide is a crime against humanity,' she said. 'They did not name the offence. They did not say they took full responsibility of the offence.
'However, it's a positive step on the road towards the discussion around restitution and just satisfaction.'
Asked if she believed the Scottish Government should offer redress to affected families, she said: 'I absolutely believe it.
'If you'd been kept in degrading conditions as long as I have, with 16 health conditions and prevented from working with a joint-honours degrees and two post-graduates I think you might see some reason to have redress too.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
39 minutes ago
- Daily Record
The 38 nuclear bunkers in Scotland you need to know about as WW3 fears surge
Many Scottish bunkers were built in World War Two and were upgraded during the Cold War Scotland holds a crucial place in Britain's vast network of underground bunkers, developed over decades to protect the nation in times of conflict. This network, made up of anti-aircraft operation rooms, regional war rooms, underground Observer Corps posts, command bunkers, emergency centres, and radar stations, includes 38 nuclear bunkers scattered across the country. Many of these Scottish sites date back to the Second World War and were later converted to withstand nuclear threats during the Cold War. Others were newly built to defend against potential Soviet attacks. While peaceful relations with Russia have since been established and many bunkers across Britain have fallen into disuse or been sold off, a significant number remain operational in Scotland, ready to be used if nuclear conflict arises with Russia or other hostile states. Research from Subterranea Britannica reveals a total of 284 fallout shelters across the UK, Express reports, with eight new discoveries adding to their records in recent months. Of these, 38 are in Scotland, highlighting the country's vital strategic role. One of Scotland's most remarkable bunkers is Pitreavie Castle Combined HQ. Originally a fortified house built in the early 17th century, the castle was sold to the Air Ministry in 1938. An underground bunker was built beneath it, which during the Second World War coordinated operations for both RAF Coastal Command and the Royal Navy. Following the war, Pitreavie Castle served as a UK and NATO maritime headquarters until its closure in 1996. Subterranea Britannica notes that it housed the No. 18 Group headquarters, responsible for maritime air operations north of Flamborough Head in Yorkshire, covering northern and western Scottish waters. Naval operations from Flamborough Head to Wick in Caithness were commanded from Rosyth by the Navy's Commander-in-Chief. Full list of Scotland's nuclear bunkers: Aberdeen Civil Defence Control Aberdeen Tertowie House Grampian Regional Council Emergency Centre Aird Uig Rotor Radar Station Anstruther Rotor Radar Station and Scotland North Zone HQ Ayr ROC Group HQ Barnton Quarry Rotor SOC and Regional Seat of Government Buchan R7 Remote Type 7 Radar Buchan Rotor Radar Station Burntisland Railway Control Centre Cragiehall AAOR Craigiebarns Dundee ROC Group HQ Crosslaw Rotor Radar Station Cultybraggan RGHQ East Kilbride Western Zone Regional War Room Edinburgh City Control Elgin Pinefields Area Control Falkirk Civil Defence Headquarters Faraid Head Rotor Radar Station Gairloch AAOR Inverbervie Rotor Radar Station Inverkip AAOR Inverness Raigmore Highland Emergency Centre Inverness ROC HQ Inverurie Gordon District Council Emergency Centre Kilchiaran Rotor Radar Station Kirknewton Regional War Room and Scottish Eastern Zone HQ Northfield Aberdeen ROC Group HQ Oban ROC Group HQ Pitreavie Castle Combined HQ Portree bunker Saxa Vord Rotor Radar Station Schoolhill ROC Sector Control Stonehaven Kincardine and Deeside District Council Emergency Centre Tayside Regional Council Emergency Centre Torrance House AAOR Turnhouse Edinburgh ROC Group HQ Uddingston BT Repeater Wick Rotor Radar Station Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Beyond government bunkers, Scotland is also seeing growth in private underground shelters. As fears of war and unrest rise, demand for secure safe rooms has surged by up to 400 per cent in recent years, with companies like Subterranean Spaces and The Panic Room Company reporting skyrocketing interest. Basic backyard bunkers can cost around £10,000, while luxury shelters fitted with cinemas, gyms, and independent power supplies can top £3million. Wealthy clients across the UK, especially in Scotland, London, and Wales, are investing in these bunkers not only as protection but as lifestyle features, doubling as wine cellars or entertainment spaces.
South Wales Argus
41 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
New UK trade strategy 'important step forward' for Wales
The plan sets out a post-Brexit vision to position the UK as the world's most connected trading nation and create £5 billion worth of export opportunities for businesses. Jo Stevens, secretary of state for Wales, said: "Our Trade Strategy is an important step forward for businesses in Wales. "The UK Government has already secured better access for Welsh exporters to the European Union, United States and India in recent trade deals and this builds on the progress made. "We are focusing on targeted sector deals which will deliver results quickly that help Welsh businesses of all sizes reach new markets with greater confidence. "This approach ensures that innovation and economic growth reach all parts of Wales, delivering on our Plan for Change commitment to raise living standards throughout every part of the UK." The strategy includes expanding UK Export Finance (UKEF) capacity to £80 billion and introduces a Small Exports Builder to improve access to export protection insurance for smaller firms. It also pledges to strengthen the UK's trade defence toolkit and make the trade remedies system more agile and assertive. The strategy follows recent trade agreements with the EU, US, and India, all of which offer new opportunities for Welsh exporters. The EU deal is expected to benefit Wales' food and drink sector in particular, with improved access for Welsh sausages and lamb mince, and fewer barriers for pet owners travelling to the continent. The US agreement protects jobs in key industries across Wales, including aerospace manufacturing. The Indian deal is projected to add £4.8 billion to the UK economy and increase wages by £2.2 billion each year. The UK Government said it is working with industry to shape future steel trade measures that will protect UK producers after the current safeguard expires in June 2026. Meanwhile, up to £13 billion in direct lending will be made available to support exports from key industrial sectors. The strategy forms part of the UK Government's wider Plan for Change and aims to deliver stronger, more sustainable economic growth by boosting international trade.
South Wales Argus
41 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Welsh university collapse is a 'real danger', Senedd hears
Dan Beard, who chairs Unison Cymru's higher education forum, told the Senedd's education committee: 'Without change, we will see universities collapsing or contracting significantly.' Giving evidence to an inquiry on higher education, which was prompted by cuts at institutions across Wales, Unison called for urgent intervention from ministers. 'Nearly all universities are making cuts to some degree or another,' Mr Beard told the inquiry. Unison described the Welsh Government's February announcement of £18.5m for universities as 'nowhere near enough,' with Cardiff alone facing a £30m shortfall. 'Without a strategy and funding, Welsh universities will continue to contract, shedding staff and closing unprofitable courses,' the union said in its written evidence. Unison expressed frustration with the Welsh Government 'waiting to see' how UK ministers respond, cautioning: 'The gravity of the situation means we can't afford to wait.' The trade union said higher education institutions face a dire financial situation, with hundreds of redundancies proposed which could be devastating for Wales. 'There is a real danger a university in Wales could collapse next year,' Unison warned. Gareth Lloyd, Wales official at the University and College Union (UCU), said the union's members felt ambushed by Cardiff University's announcement of job cuts. Pinning a breakdown in trust at the university's door, he told the committee: 'The Cardiff UCU branch responded as they felt appropriate based on their membership.' Mr Lloyd said: 'On every level, discussion has to take place early on – you do not go to the press, make announcements and put people's jobs at risk.' He raised the upsetting impact of the cuts on students as well as UCU members, warning: 'If we're not careful, this could have a real detrimental effect on students who don't want to go there and that really, really worries me.' During the meeting on June 25, Mr Beard added: 'Privately, there were lots of senior leaders in other universities aghast about how Cardiff University went about it…. In the other seven institutions across Wales, they said that's the wrong way to do it.'
