Dozens of former UK diplomats urge Starmer to recognise Palestinian state
Their letter to the prime minister came as the archbishop of York condemned the dehumanisation of people in Gaza as 'depraved' and 'barbaric'. It was 'a stain on the conscience of the international community', and Israel's 'war of aggression' was a 'grave sin', said Stephen Cottrell, currently the de facto leader of the Church of England.
The strength of the language used by Cottrell is a reflection of rapidly shifting opinion as images of starving children and accounts of civilians being killed as they try to secure food for their families emerge from Gaza.
In Starmer's cabinet, there has been a growing sense of horror and despair in recent weeks over Israel's actions and scenes in Gaza. This week, Wes Streeting, the health secretary, publicly called for recognition while there was 'still a state of Palestine left to recognise' and condemned Israeli actions that went 'well beyond legitimate self-defence'.
On Wednesday, Sadiq Khan, the mayor of London, urged the UK government to recognise a Palestinian state immediately, saying the scenes in Gaza were 'absolutely harrowing'.
In a statement on X, he wrote: 'The international community – including our own government – must do far more to pressure the Israeli government to stop this horrific, senseless killing and let vital, life-saving aid in. Nothing justifies the actions of the Israeli government.'
The letter to Starmer, which was signed by more than 30 former UK ambassadors and 20 former senior British diplomats at the United Nations, said the status quo in Gaza could be broken by recognising the state of Palestine.
'The risks of inaction have profound, historic and catastrophic implications,' it said. The state of Israel 'cannot be secure from threats in the future if the question of Palestine is not taken forward to a political settlement'.
It added: 'In the face of the current horror and impunity, words are not enough … A partial suspension of arms sales, delays on trade talks and limited sanctions are far from the full extent of the pressure the UK can bring to bear on Israel.'
Recognising a Palestinian state would be a 'foundational first step towards breaking the deadly status quo', the letter said.
Signatories included the former UK ambassadors to Afghanistan, Bahrain, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Morocco, Pakistan, Qatar, Syria and Turkey.
The letter reflects deep concern among former diplomats that Starmer appears reluctant to engage with the Middle East crisis, or understand that ineffective action will do little to assuage British reputation in the region.
One of the signatories said the letter reflected a strong current of opinion inside the Foreign Office over the recognition issue, but such a claim is hard to test.
Cottrell's statement, issued on Wednesday, said: 'With each passing day in Gaza, the violence, starvation and dehumanisation being inflicted on the civilian population by the government of Israel becomes more depraved and unconscionable.
Sign up to Headlines UK
Get the day's headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning
after newsletter promotion
'In the name of God, I cry out against this barbaric assault on human life and dignity. It is a stain on the conscience of the international community, and a flagrant breach of international humanitarian law.'
He added: 'I have condemned many times the horrific Hamas attacks on 7 October, and I continue to call for the release of those still cruelly held hostage. We deplore every assault on the innocent. But … this war is now one of aggression – it is a grave sin and it must stop.'
Cottrell called for an immediate and permanent ceasefire, the release of all hostages and captives and for the rebuilding of Gaza. Any policy 'that would amount to the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian population from Gaza' must be rejected, he said.
Earlier on Wednesday, 111 aid organisations said 'mass starvation' was spreading in Gaza as a result of continued Israeli restrictions on how aid arrived and was distributed in the territory.
The organisations, including Doctors Without Borders (MSF), Save the Children and Oxfam, said: 'Our colleagues and those we serve are wasting away.' Israel claims aid is being allowed to enter Gaza but it is being stolen by Hamas.
There have been repeated incidents of civilians being shot while trying to access food from the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, an organisation backed by Israel that replaced the UN aid infrastructure in May. The UN says Israeli forces have since killed more than 1,000 Palestinians trying to get food.
The UK foreign secretary, David Lammy, who said he felt 'appalled, sickened' by the scenes of starving Palestinians being shot as they sought food, said Britain would 'play its part' in reaching a two-state solution.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
New Israeli settlement to split East Jerusalem from occupied West Bank
Israel 's far-right Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich has approved plans for a new settlement intended to separate East Jerusalem from the occupied West Bank. Mr Smotrich's office said the plan aims to "bury the idea of a Palestinian state", a move previously frozen since 2012 due to international objections. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has reiterated his call for the "voluntary migration" of Palestinians from Gaza, a concept critics equate to ethnic cleansing. Despite efforts to revive ceasefire talks, Mr Netanyahu's office confirmed Israel has no plans to send a negotiating team to Cairo. Meanwhile, Israeli gunfire has killed at least 25 people seeking aid in Gaza, according to health officials and witnesses.
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
Phillipson: Teachers cannot insist on gender-neutral Mx title
Teachers can ask to be addressed as Mx instead of Mr or Mrs but they cannot insist on people using the gender-neutral title, the Education Secretary has said. Bridget Phillipson said schools have a responsibility to make sure teachers are treated with respect, but also that people 'with a range of viewpoints' on transgender issues are also treated with respect. Ms Phillipson was pressed further on Thursday on comments she made earlier this week about the right of teachers to make such a request. The Telegraph reported recently that a primary school in the south-east of England had listed a new teacher, who the newspaper said was male according to their biological sex, as Mx in a list of staff members. Mx is described as a gender-neutral title for those who do not identify as being of a particular gender or do not wish to be identified by gender. Speaking on Times Radio, Ms Phillipson said: 'A teacher can, of course, make that request, but you can't insist that it's followed.' Asked whether she would call someone Mx, Ms Phillipson said: 'I think that's a hypothetical situation. I've never been asked to do that. 'As a matter of principle, on a wider point, I would usually seek to respond to someone in a way that they would prefer, but there is no obligation for people to do that.' Asked by Nick Ferrari on LBC whether the issue will cause confusion, she said: ' Schools, as employers, have responsibilities for managing this, in that they have a responsibility to ensure that staff are treated with respect, but also that people with a range of viewpoints are also able to express their views and are treated with respect as well.' Ms Phillipson also said she 'can't put a timescale' on when long-awaited guidance for schools on gender-questioning children will be published. The Government has previously said it will not be hurried into publishing guidance for schools, amid calls which came after the Supreme Court ruling on the legal definition of a woman in April. Draft guidance for schools and colleges on how best to support pupils has been on hold since Labour entered Government. It was published by the Conservative government in December 2023, and a consultation ended in March last year. On Thursday Ms Phillipson, who has previously said guidance would be issued later this year, said the priority is getting the guidance right. She told LBC: 'I think it's more important that we get it right than we rush it, because these are serious and quite sensitive issues about children and young people and their wellbeing. 'I do know that schools are asking for guidance. 'We want to make sure they've got that guidance, but what matters most is that the guidance they get is workable and they find it practical and helpful in responding to what can be quite challenging issues for schools, when they're supporting young people who might be experiencing questions around distress or their wellbeing.'
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
Starmer welcomes Zelensky to Downing Street ahead of Putin-Trump meeting
Sir Keir Starmer has welcomed Volodymyr Zelensky to Downing Street as Europe braces for Donald Trump's face-to-face discussions with Vladimir Putin on Friday. The Ukrainian president and Prime Minister embraced and posed for the cameras in front of Number 10 with a handshake as he arrived in Westminster on Thursday morning while gathered media in Downing Street shouted questions. A red carpet had been rolled out for his arrival. The Prime Minister's meeting with Mr Zelensky comes after he said Britain stands ready to 'increase pressure' on Russia if necessary. During a call with the US president and European allies on Wednesday, Sir Keir praised Mr Trump for his work to bring forward a 'viable' chance of an end to the war ahead of his scheduled meeting with the Russian leader. Concerns have been raised over Mr Zelensky's exclusion from the discussions between Mr Trump and Mr Putin, which are set to take place in Alaska on Friday. Speaking on Wednesday, Sir Keir said: 'This meeting on Friday that President Trump is attending is hugely important. 'As I've said personally to President Trump for the three-and-a-bit years this conflict has been going on, we haven't got anywhere near a prospect of actually a viable solution, a viable way of bringing it to a ceasefire. 'And now we do have that chance, because of the work of that the president has put in.' Further sanctions could be imposed on Russia should the Kremlin fail to engage and the UK is already working on its next package of measures targeting Moscow, he said. 'We're ready to support this, including from the plans we've already drawn up to deploy a reassurance force once hostilities have ceased,' he told allies. 'It is important to remind colleagues that we do stand ready also to increase pressure on Russia, particularly the economy, with sanctions and wider measures as may be necessary.' Sir Keir and European leaders have repeatedly said discussions about Ukraine should not happen without it amid concerns the country is being sidelined in negotiations about its own future.
