
Breakingviews - Couche-Tard should have gone hostile on Seven & i
Couche-Tard's bid for the 7-Eleven owner was compelling at a 47% premium to the undisturbed share price nearly a year ago, but the soft approach allowed its reluctant target to drag its feet. In Tokyo, it was no secret that the company did not want to be bought; its founding family even tried its own white knight buyout before abandoning it. So it is unsurprising that Alain Bouchard, Couche-Tard's founder and executive chair concluded "there has been no sincere or constructive engagement" after the suitor raised its offer and signed a non-disclosure agreement.
Seven & i calls these barbs "mischaracterizations", but the saga evokes Japan's past bad M&A, like Toshiba's long-drawn-out sale, which activists effectively kicked off in 2017. It also confirms that subsequently introduced guidelines for fair M&A and corporate takeovers aren't worth much. These were designed to revive the $4 trillion economy after decades of deflation. Companies are not on board, however.
They make a show of acting in good faith but clutch to poison pill defences, opens new tab. Even Japan's largest publicly traded firm, Toyota Motor (7203.T), opens new tab, in June emerged as a leader of a highly controversial $33 billion deal that, as the Asian Corporate Governance Association puts it, opens new tab, "exposes the persistent frailties of Japan's corporate governance regime and the enduring power of entrenched interests".
Couche-Tard's decision not to go hostile no doubt stemmed from worrying doing otherwise would scare off the Japanese management team. It also faced antitrust hurdles in the United States and clamouring about the national interest in Japan. Yet there is a growing contingent of bankers and lawyers in the Asian country who view cultural issues as outdated hurdles to transformative inbound deals; they are advising their clients to take a firmer and, if necessary, hostile approach from the beginning.
True, Couche-Tard succeeded in forcing Seven & i to replace its CEO with a foreigner, Stephen Dacus, and revise its standalone value creation plan. But without a suitor applying pressure, some commitments could fade over time. One of these is a 2 trillion yen ($13.5 billion) buyback over the next five years funded in part by the agreed 815 billion yen sale of the group's supermarket business to Bain Capital; another is a future stock market listing of its North American convenience store unit that targets an equity value of at least 1 trillion yen.
Shareholders have concluded that Seven & i was better off with a buyer too. The stock only fell 6% on Thursday, putting it 18% above its pre-deal level. But it is languishing one-fifth below Couche-Tard's offer. The Canadians did not get what they wanted, and arguably nor did Tokyo. Neither tried hard enough.
Follow Una Galani on Linkedin, opens new tab and X, opens new tab.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

South Wales Argus
29 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Next hikes outlook after sales boosted by weather and M&S woes
The womenswear and homewares chain posted a 10.5% rise in full-price sales for the second quarter to July 26, with growth of 10.9% for the half-year as a whole. In the UK, sales jumped by 7.8% in the second quarter as the group said it was boosted by 'better than expected weather and trading disruption at a major competitor'. M&S had to suspend online trading for nearly two months from mid-April after it was hit by a major hack. Next said the recent performance and forecasts for better-than-forecast second half trading means it now expects full-year sales to rise by 7.5% and for profits to increase by 9.3% to £1.11 billion. It had previously pencilled in sales growth of 6% and for profits to lift by 6.8%. The upgrade marks the group's third in just five months. But Next said it 'remains cautious for the second half', stressing that the improved outlook is for its international arm over the next six months. It said: 'In the UK, we believe we exceeded expectations in the second quarter as a result of better summer weather and trading disruption at a major competitor. 'We do not expect either of these factors to have a material effect in the second half, and so we are not increasing our guidance for UK sales in the second half.' It believes sales growth in the UK will slow sharply to 1.9% as the jobs market starts to falter following the Government's move to hike National Insurance contributions for employers, at the same time as rising the minimum wage. Next said: 'We expect UK employment opportunities to continue to diminish as we enter the second half, with the effects of April's National Insurance changes continuing to filter through into the economy as the year progresses. 'We believe that this will increasingly dampen consumer spending as the year progresses.' But an online marketing push for its international arm is bearing fruit, helping drive sales 28.1% higher in the first half and with growth of 19.4% now expected in the final six months. The results come after Next announced late on Wednesday that it had bought Seraphine – the maternity fashion firm, whose clothes were worn by the Princess of Wales during her pregnancies – after it recently collapsed into administration. Next paid £600,000 for the brand and announced it was bringing back Seraphine's founder Cecile Reinaud as an adviser to help relaunch the fashion label.


Reuters
30 minutes ago
- Reuters
India PM Modi faces opposition fury after Trump's 25% tariff threat
NEW DELHI, July 31 (Reuters) - Indian opposition parties criticised the government on Thursday, describing U.S. President Donald Trump's threat of a 25% tariff as a diplomatic failure for New Delhi, while the rupee currency tumbled and equity indexes slid in response to the news. The 25% rate would single out India more harshly than other major trading partners, and threatens to unravel months of talks, undermining one of Washington's strategic partners in the region, viewed as a counterbalance to China. Trump said the tariff on goods imports from India would start from Friday, in addition to an unspecified penalty for Russian dealings and involvement in the BRICS grouping of nations, but added later that trade talks continued. In response, the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi said it was studying the implications of Trump's remarks and was dedicated to securing a fair trade deal. "This development reflects a broader collapse of foreign policy under the Modi government," a lawmaker of the main opposition Congress said in a notice asking for a discussion of the matter in the lower house. The debate would focus on the "government's economic and diplomatic failure in preventing the imposition of 25% U.S. tariffs plus penalties on Indian exports," it added. Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal is expected to brief the lower house later on Thursday, television news channels said. Economists warned the steep tariff could hurt India's manufacturing ambitions and trim up to 40 basis points from economic growth in the financial year to March 2026. India's benchmark equity indices, the Nifty 50 (.NSEI), opens new tab and BSE Sensex (.BSESN), opens new tab, fell about 0.6% each, while the rupee declined to 87.74, its lowest in more than five months, before paring losses. India has received a "raw deal", said Priyanka Kishore, an economist at Asia Decoded. "While further trade talks may bring the tariff rate down, it appears unlikely that India will secure a significantly better outcome than its eastern neighbours," she added. That would raise questions about India's relative appeal as a China plus one destination, she said, referring to a strategy of diversifying supply chains through manufacturing outside China to reduce geopolitical and operational risks. Trade talks continued, Trump said on social media, however, as nations face a Friday deadline to strike deals on reciprocal tariffs or have a U.S. tariff slapped on their exports. The U.S. levy on India exceeds those achieved by some other nations in deals with the Trump administration. For example, the tariff on Vietnam is set at 20% and on Indonesia at 19%, with levies of 15% on Japanese and European Union exports. On Wednesday, Trump said Washington had reached a trade deal with India's arch-rival Pakistan that Islamabad said would lead to lower tariffs on its exports, but neither side have yet revealed the agreed rate. Since India's short but deadly conflict with Pakistan in May, New Delhi has been unhappy about Trump's closeness with Islamabad and has protested, casting a shadow over trade talks. Despite former public displays of bonhomie between Trump and Modi, India has taken a slightly harder stance against the United States in recent weeks. Trump has repeatedly taken credit for the India-Pakistan ceasefire he announced on social media on May 10, but India disputes his claim that it resulted from his intervention and trade threats. "The country is now bearing the cost of Narendra Modi's friendship," Congress said. The United States, the world's largest economy, now has a trade deficit of $45.7 billion with India, the fifth largest. Russia remained India's top oil supplier during the first six months of 2025, accounting for 35% of overall supplies. "I don't care what India does with Russia," Trump said in a Truth Social post on Thursday, adding, "They can take their dead economies down together, for all I care."


Reuters
30 minutes ago
- Reuters
India's RBI unlikely to re-introduce fixed-rate liquidity operations, sources say
MUMBAI, July 31 (Reuters) - India's central bank is unlikely to re-introduce the policy of lending money daily to banks at a fixed rate, despite increased clamour for it from market participants, three sources said on Thursday. The policy, called fixed rate liquidity operations, will help banks manage their needs better, several bankers proposed to the RBI in meetings held over the last few months. Banks had asked for the quantum of infusion to be fixed on a percentage of their deposit base. "The RBI is clearly not in favour of hand-holding banks and wants to keep any liquidity operation on a variable rate," one source said. The sources requested anonymity as they are not authorised to speak to media. The RBI did not reply to a Reuters email seeking comment. In variable repo or reverse repo, through which RBI injects or absorbs cash, banks have to undergo a bidding process based on their funding needs. Last week, overnight inter-bank call money rates jumped above marginal standing facility rate, which is the policy corridor ceiling, after banks parked funds with RBI under reverse repos. They then faced a shortage after tax outflows. "On days like that, it helps if there is a repo window available," the second source said. Lenders also asked for relaxation of daily maintenance of the cash reserve ratio, which is the percentage of deposits that they need to park with the RBI. The RBI is also reviewing the liquidity management framework. The revised framework could be released alongside the monetary policy decision on August 6, some market participants said. The sources said that the RBI may shift to a seven-day operation as the main liquidity tool, instead of the current 14-day auctions adopted in 2020. The bank has skipped conducting the 14-day operation since the last six fortnights.