South Africa's push to amend BEE laws for Musk's Starlink triggers public backlash
The South African government is facing intense political backlash after changes to its Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) laws, potentially allowing Elon Musk's Starlink to operate in the country with exemptions from existing Black ownership requirements.
The South African government is facing criticism for proposed changes to Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) laws.
The new laws may allow foreign companies, such as Starlink, to bypass Black ownership requirements through alternative contributions.
Critics claim this move undermines South Africa's existing empowerment policies aiming to correct historical injustices.
As reported by the Financial Times, South Africa's Minister of Communications, Solly Malatsi revealed plans to allow telecom companies like Starlink to sidestep the 30% Black ownership law through ' equity equivalence ' initiatives, such as local partnerships, job creation, or supporting small businesses, in lieu of equity stakes
The proposal follows public remarks by Musk that he has been locked out of South Africa's telecom market because he is " not Black."
However, the timing and framing of the legislation has sparked intense criticism from opposition parties and civil society, who accuse the government of tailoring laws to benefit a powerful foreign billionaire.
Criticism spreads over SA's BEE amendment
Build One South Africa (BOSA), a prominent opposition party, has criticized the government's decision as a " backdoor deal" with Musk, arguing it unfairly favors the billionaire's interests over those of local businesses bound by BEE laws.
According to BOSA deputy leader Nobuntu Hlazo-Webster " The message being sent is that if you are a powerful foreign billionaire, you can sidestep South Africa's laws, while our local businesses are forced to jump through hoops,"
BOSA spokesperson Roger Solomons also warned that the proposed exemption would allow Starlink to enter the market" under conditions favourable to them, not the country,"
He called the move " impulsive and reckless."
Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) leader Julius Malema echoed this sentiment, promising to oppose Starlink's entry in Parliament.
' We will not be dictated to by business,' Malema said, accusing the government of prioritizing corporate interests over national policy.
Defense grows amid criticism
Meanwhile, the ruling African National Congress (ANC) has defended BEE as essential to reversing the effects of apartheid, while the Democratic Alliance (DA), the second-largest party and a key coalition partner, is suing the government over existing BEE laws.
DA MP James Lorimer called the proposed rules ' a death knell for foreign investment'
"These ownership demands will crush what little appetite remains for investment in South African mining," He said.
" The bill doubles down on failed transformation policies at a time when our economy needs growth." He added.
The country's President Cyril Ramaphosa has stood firm against dismantling BEE, attributing South Africa's economic stagnation to concentrated ownership rather than empowerment policies.
He said: "It is the partial and exclusive ownership of the means of production in our country that is holding this economy from growing,"
The controversy is consequent of a major political shift: the ANC, weakened by poor 2024 election results driven by public frustration over crime, unemployment, and inflation, has entered into a 10-party coalition, the first time since the end of apartheid that it has lost its wide majority.
As Parliament debates the bill in the coming week, the government faces a balancing act; modernize economic policy to attract foreign innovation and investment or risk undermining the very affirmative action framework that has defined its post-apartheid vision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tulsa mayor unveils plan for $100M trust to 'repair' effect of 1921 Race Massacre
Tulsa Mayor Monroe Nichols is proposing a $100 million private trust as part of a reparations plan for descendants of the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre. Nichols, the city's first Black mayor, told the Associated Press that the proposal wouldn't require city council approval, but the council would need to authorize the transfer of any city property to the trust. Dig deeper Tulsa Mayor Monroe Nichols said the private trust would offer descendants of the Tulsa Race Massacre scholarships and housing help. This plan would not give direct cash payments to descendants or the last two centenarian survivors of the attack that killed as many as 300 Black people. RELATED:Reparations lawsuit for 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre dismissed by judge Nichols told reporters he does not use the term reparations, which he calls politically charged, characterizing his plan instead as a "road to repair." The Associated Press reported that the trust would be created with a goal to secure $105 million in assets, with most of the funding either secured or committed by June 1, 2026. The plan calls for the bulk of the funding, $60 million, to go toward improving buildings and revitalizing Tulsa's north side. Nichols made the announcement about the plan at the Greenwood Cultural Center, located in the district of North Tulsa that was destroyed by a white mob during the massacre. There are only two living survivors of the Race Massacre in Tulsa, both of whom are 110 years old: Leslie Benningfield Randle and Viola Fletcher. The women, both of whom were in attendance on Sunday for the event. The backstory TheTulsa Race Massacre occurred between May 31 and June 1, 1921 in the Greenwood community, a Black-owned business district and residential neighborhood in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Sparked by allegations that a 19-year-old Black man had assaulted a 17-year-old white girl in an elevator, the Greenwood community, known as Black Wall Street because of the number of Black-owned businesses, was destroyed in a two-day attack by a white mob. RELATED:Tulsa Race Massacre survivor Hughes Van Ellis dies at 102 Tulsa's police department appointed white mobs and provided them with guns. Some reports describe white men with badges setting fires and shooting Black people as part of the Greenwood invasion. In the aftermath of the attack, roughly 300 Black people were killed. Over a thousand homes were burned and others looted, leaving 10,000 residents displaced and homeless and the Black business district destroyed. As residents worked to rebuild the Greenwood community, thousands of residents during the winter of 1921-22 were forced to live in tents, according to the Oklahoma Historical Society. Dig deeper Tulsa is not the first U.S. city to explore reparations. The Chicago suburb of Evanston, Illinois, was the first U.S. city to make reparations available to its Black residents for past discrimination, offering qualifying households $25,000 for home repairs, down payments on property, and interest or late penalties on property in the city. The funding for the program came from taxes on the sale of recreational marijuana. According to the Associated Press, other places and organizations that have considered providing reparations range from the state of California to cities including Amherst, Massachusetts; Providence, Rhode Island; Asheville, North Carolina; and Iowa City, Iowa; religious denominations like the Episcopal Church; and prominent colleges like Georgetown University in Washington. The Source Information for this story was provided by the Associated Press and the Oklahoma Historical Society, which provides background on the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre. This story was reported from Washington, D.C.
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
‘Sinners' Shows Clarksdale's Past. What's Next for the Birthplace of the Blues?
CLARKSDALE, MISS. – Tyler Yarbrough makes it clear. Sinners and the cultural fest that followed may have thrust Clarksdale into the national spotlight, but this moment represents the culmination of years of hard-fought progress. In as little as three weeks, community members, more than a dozen sponsors, and partners planned and executed Clarksdale Culture Capital's Sinners fest on May 29-31. It wouldn't have happened if residents weren't already recharged and already rebuilding. A diverse and intergenerational mix of people lined up on East Second Street hours before the doors opened to enjoy screenings and fellowship at the Clarksdale Civic Auditorium. Despite an overcast sky, thousands packed the Civic Auditorium to see two free screenings and hear directly from the cast and crew — and the mood was electric. The auditorium erupted with applause when Yarbrough walked to the front of the room. A wave of pride, joy, and celebration washed over him as he peered back into the crowd. At the moment, he saw what he always believed: Clarksdale has the power to work together to achieve greatness. High school students volunteered as ushers. Youth worked at the concession stand. The Iota Omicron chapter of Omega Psi Phi helped clean in between screenings. Restaurants like the Matchbox and Levon's had Sinners-inspired drinks on their menu. Community members like Yasmine Malone stopped by the screening with her nephew, then moderated the panel discussion 'Coffee with Kinfolk: Our Vision For The Future.' Natives like Jaleesa Collins — one of the organizers who first sparked the idea of a screening — drove from Florida during a rainstorm to ensure the event was a success. The excitement continued over the next two days, as people packed out Meraki Roasting Co., the Crossroads Cultural Art Center, and the Delta Blues Museum to participate in important conversations. They talked about the legacy of Black farmers, the steps to building a blues economy that benefits Black creators, how Mississippi can build infrastructure to attract blockbuster films, and the Choctaw and Chinese Americans' rich cultural diversity within the region. On Friday morning, folks gathered over coffee and pastries prior to a panel discussion at Meraki, which teaches youth entrepreneurial skills and career readiness. Attendees hugged and caught up on local happenings. Others discussed the film and the future of Clarksdale, which perfectly aligned with the 'Coffee with Kinfolk' panel. During the panel, Yarbrough shared the sacrifices he and others continue to make to do the work to make Clarksdale better. He mentioned the yearlong effort to revitalize J's Grocery, the only Black supermarket in the town, and its reopening last month. Collins, who was also a panelist, is helping to host the first-ever Clarksdale Day over Labor Day weekend to celebrate local culture through activities such as a parade, car show, award ceremony, and barbecue competition. There's also Griot Arts, a youth nonprofit that is rebuilding the historic Paramount Theater in downtown Clarksdale, and Higher Purpose Hub, which received a $2.2 million grant to build a regional hub to improve 'intergenerational economic opportunity' across the Delta. In addition to the collaboration showcased last weekend, the conversation also explored how it is often a challenge for organizations — and even local people — to believe in and support those who are doing the work on the ground. Often, international tourists appreciate the beauty of Clarksdale's culture, art, and architecture, while locals may not fully embrace it, said Edna Nicole Luckett, known as Edna Nicole, a local artist and musician. Now is the time for Clarksdale to champion its city, and for Black people to take ownership of a culture that they have created while allowing the art to heal and preserve our history, she said. 'Clarksdale has always been a big deal, not just when it comes to music — when it comes to sports, when it comes to culture, when it comes to agriculture,' she said. 'But we don't sell it to our own people, and we don't believe that anymore. … The blues is more than the four streets that make up downtown. It's the neighborhoods, it's the rural areas, and we need those areas to come out and support because we want to represent our people the right way.' Read More: Clarksdale Pushed for a Screening of 'Sinners'. They're Getting One This Week. Part of the onus is on the community to shift the narrative and create change, said Tim Lampkin, founder and executive director of Higher Purpose Hub. 'We have to take a different type of stance in talking about the place that we love, and that goes for the folks that are not believing in our own local leaders. How can you expect it to be changed when you're the main one talking negative about the work that's happening?' Lampkin said. He added: 'We have to get beyond this moment and stop pointing the finger at each other and come together and work to build the unthinkable. There are too many people outside of the culture that already don't believe in this. So, how do we change that? It starts with us, individually, collectively, building every single day.' Lampkin's remarks were met with laughter from the audience, as he noted he's not a preacher, so he's going to leave the preaching to them. These recent events and the momentum from Sinners have inspired Clarksdale residents and natives to continue rebuilding their city. Like many pivotal movements in U.S. history, this historic moment in Clarksdale has been shaped by young people driving change. They're reclaiming it as their Southern renaissance. On the last day of the festival, changemakers from Clarksdale; Jackson, the state's capital; and neighboring Memphis, Tennessee, shared their perspectives on the importance of youth involvement in making lasting change happen. As people poured into the Crossroads Cultural Art Center, many shared laughs, conversations, and vibed over music prior to the main discussion. Jasmine Williams of 'Sipp Talk Media, who moderated the conversation, described what this moment of renaissance meant for her. 'We all are the products of multiple movements. One thing I really care about showing people is that Mississippi — the South, Memphis — we never stopped, even though people stopped looking,' Williams said. 'We can deem this a renaissance because we are in this moment, and we know what we're doing, and we're building on the work of people who did it for generations.' Read More: 'Sinners' Honored Juke Joints. Today, They're Fighting to Stay Open. Jermeria Skillom, coordinator of Mississippi Delta Programs for Partnership for a Healthier America, said organizers and creators have sparked a sense of purpose, and for folks to know they can 'live, thrive, and create a sense of belonging' in the place that raised them. 'The next generation [should] never feel like leaving Mississippi is an option. You may have an opportunity to leave, but it's not an option,' Skillom said. 'That Mississippi pride is the Southern pride. It's nothing to be ashamed of, and that freed me.' For progress to continue, Clarksdale resident, preacher, and event organizer Mark Webb says, healing must take place. 'The Scripture tells us to reach the least of these. When the least of these begins to rise, guess what? The community will begin to soar. I want to be a part of healing to bring our community together,' he said. 'One of the things that I really am inspired by … is that despite the obstacles, those who are willing, we can lock arms and we can get some things done.' The post 'Sinners' Shows Clarksdale's Past. What's Next for the Birthplace of the Blues? appeared first on Capital B News.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Huge change for mobile users as new Space X service gives boost to regional Aussies, campers
Select Australians living rurally and in regional areas will soon have access to better mobile coverage, with Telstra launching the country's first satellite-to-mobile text service, allowing users to send and receive messages even outside of 4G and 5G covered zones. In the Aussie outback, on remote roads, and in places like isolated hiking trails, sending messages can be near-impossible with regular service. But now, Telstra, in collaboration with Elon Musk's SpaceX, aims to fix the problem. While the program is still in its early days, the telco said on Tuesday it stands to be of enormous benefit to farmers and those working in ultra-remote areas of the country, in particular. It's been branded a "just-in-case" connectivity layer that allows a person to make contact with a loved one to make contact in the event of an emergency. The messaging service relies on Low Earth Orbit satellites and direct-to-device technology to send signals straight from space to compatible mobile phones. Currently, only the Samsung Galaxy S25 can send texts this way. Any phone, however, can receive them. Broader compatibility is expected to be rolled out in the future. When users are outside Telstra's mobile coverage in mainland Australia or Tasmania, their phone will automatically switch to the Starlink satellite. Rural Australians have long relied on LEO satellite services like Starlink, Sky Muster, Intelsat, and Inmarsat for internet, calls, emails, and texts — and this new messaging service builds on that. A user simply needs to compose a text as normal and keep their phone in clear view of the sky. Depending on the location, device, and satellite availability, it may take a few minutes or more to send or receive messages. Telstra's executive for technology engagement, Channa Seneviratne, said the service can't yet connect directly to emergency services, meaning users would need to message someone else to call triple-0 if needed. "It's important to remember that this is not an emergency service," he said. "Australia is a very big country, and there are places where a mobile network does not provide coverage. So if you are somebody who lives ... outside of that network coverage, Telstra satellite messaging will be perfect for you. Sad sight on remote Aussie road highlights dangerous problem Air crew makes exciting 'once-in-a-lifetime' discovery in outback Remote outback family shares their 'very special' tradition "This is a really exciting advancement in technology." He said Telstra is working to make the technology compatible with more devices, including Apple products, with voice calls over the LEOsat network also in development, but not expected until 2027. The satellite tech will be built into contracts at no added price, and Telstra said customers can expect further announcements in the coming months. "Following launch, we will continue to test and refine the service so we can continue to offer the best product we can for customers," it said in a statement this morning. In the future, satellite-to-mobile tech is expected to go beyond just texting, with plans to support data use and voice calls as the network evolves. Do you have a story tip? Email: newsroomau@ You can also follow us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Twitter and YouTube.
